r/secularism • • 1h ago

Failure of the Personal God

• Upvotes

Failure of the Personal God:

An innocent child lies in a hospital bed with cancer and sepsis. A young woman with a brain tumor is sent for palliative radiation.

As a physician for nearly four decades, these are not rare sights for me. I have stopped asking why innocent people suffer. I do not blame God, because I do not believe in God.

But families do believe. Parents pray with tears. Relatives pray with hope. Friends pray with desperation. Everyone begs God for mercy.

The doctors come. The nurses come. The medicines come. The machines come.

But God does not come in any visible, reliable, measurable way.

This is where the idea of a personal God begins to fail.

A personal God means a God who knows us, hears us, loves us, protects us, answers prayer, rewards goodness, punishes evil, performs miracles, and intervenes in human life.

This is the God most believers pray to: not an abstract force, but a listening, caring, protecting God who is supposed to act.

But the evidence does not match this belief.

Children get cancer. Innocent people die in disasters and accidents. Women are raped. Families starve. Good people suffer quietly while bad people often prosper.

If a loving, all-powerful God watches over the world, why does the world look so unwatched? And so unfair? So unjust?

If God truly provided justice, protection, and healing, we would not need hospitals, police, courts, laws, or rescue workers. But everyone knows we need them because there is no divine protection, and no evidence of any God.

Religions say, “God has a plan.” But what kind of plan requires a child’s cancer? What kind of wisdom needs a mother’s grief?

The world behaves as if biology, nature, chance, human choices, and social conditions shape life, not God.

That is the failure of the personal God.

What should these concerns mean for secular public institutions? How should governments assess claims about divine protection when funding health care, emergency services and public safety, while protecting freedom of belief and keeping religious authority separate from state decisions?


r/secularism • • 17h ago

Is secularism is self defeating? - [x-post /r/philosophyofreligion]

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/secularism • • 5h ago

What religious liberty is NOT.

0 Upvotes

Religious liberty does NOT mean automatic exemptions from generally applicable laws.

I think that the 1879 Supreme Court got this right (Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145 (1878)):

"Laws are made for the government of actions, and while they cannot interfere with mere religious belief and opinions, they may with practices. Suppose one believed that human sacrifices were a necessary part of religious worship; would it be seriously contended that the civil government under which he lived could not interfere to prevent a sacrifice? Or if a wife religiously believed it was her duty to burn herself upon the funeral pile of her dead husband; would it be beyond the power of the civil government to prevent her carrying her belief into practice?

So here, as a law of the organization of society under the exclusive dominion of the United States, it is provided that plural marriages shall not be allowed. Can a man excuse his practices to the contrary because of his religious belief?

To permit this would be to make the professed doctrines of religious belief superior to the law of the land, and, in effect, to permit every citizen to become a law unto himself. Government could exist only in name under such circumstances." (https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/98/145/#tab-opinion-1970077)

Should FLDS people should be allowed to commit bigamy if they claim a religious right to do so?

Should NeoAmericanChurch adherents should be legally allowed to manufacture distribute possess and consume LSD as one of their 'sacred sacraments'? (note carefully the Supreme Court decision allowing religious use of DMT - why should LSD be any different?) ( 546 U.S. 418 (2006) )

Should Muslim shops be able to legally engage in commercial discrimination against Jews?

Should Jewish groups be able to legally engage in boycotts against Muslims businesses?

Should any corporation or group be able to legally call for and engage in boycotts against Israeli businesses (BDS)?

Should Christian shops be able to legally engage in commercial discrimination against people perceived as gay?

Should Pastafarian shops be able to legally engage in commercial discrimination against people perceived as Christian?