r/selfharm • u/Mental_Cat_16 • 18h ago
I asked about the Jewish perspective on sh and the response makes me cry every time I read it
TW religious discussion. if you dislike bringing religion into these matters, move along. This post is not intended to try to convert you (Jews don’t do that) or tell you you’re sinning. It’s actually the opposite. But if you don’t wish to read this, don’t. It’s that easy.
I just asked a rabbi about the Jewish perspective on self harm and if it was a sin, and the answer makes me cry every time I read it. Not because I’m sad or angry, but because it’s much nicer than I thought it would be. I don’t know if it will help someone but it’s also very interesting. And I think it’s a good thing to have out here for fellow monotheists. I can’t figure out how to post the screenshot lol so here is the text:
Thank you for reaching out and sharing this question so honestly. I want to acknowledge the emotional pain that lies beneath it. When someone turns to self-harm, it is rarely out of rebellion. It is often an attempt to cope with inner distress, numbness, or pain. When we are struggling, framing our pain through a lens of guilt or sin often adds an unbearable weight of shame to an already heavy burden. Shame only deepens the cycle of distress. Please know that you are met with compassion, not judgment.
In Jewish tradition, the primary framework for how we treat ourselves is built on loving preservation of life. The Torah commands us, "You shall greatly guard your lives/souls" (Deuteronomy 4:15). Our bodies and mind are sacred trusts given to us by Hashem to protect, nurture, and heal. Jewish law recognizes that emotional pain deeply affects a person's capacity. When someone is acting out of psychological distress rather than willful defiance, Jewish law views them through a lens of mercy and understanding, recognizing that they are hurting, not sinning.
You do not have to handle the urge to self-harm alone. Because self-harm is a coping mechanism for deeper pain, the goal isn't just stopping a behavior, it is getting compassionate, practical tools to help soothe your nervous system and address what is hurting underneath. If you ever feel overwhelmed and need someone to talk to right away, free, confidential support is available 24/7 by calling or texting 988.
You deserve relief and healing. Please treat yourself with the same kindness you would offer a dear friend who was hurting.
And then he signed his name, which I’m omitting for privacy purposes. I don’t know that any of this is news to anyone, but I found it really sweet. The rabbi was the director of a rehab or something and had a degree in psychology so he knows what he’s talking about. I hope this post isn’t breaking any rules. I’m truly sorry if it is, but I don’t think it is…