r/soapmaking • • Aug 11 '25

Soapmaking SUPPLIERS list

32 Upvotes

r/soapmaking • • Aug 11 '25

Soapmaking RESOURCES list

16 Upvotes

r/soapmaking • • 12h ago

CP Cold Process Soap ends

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/soapmaking • • 6h ago

M&P Melt & Pour Had to delete my main account but this is my second attempt!!

Post image
9 Upvotes

I wanted to mix the colors to be teal and dark sage green like an earthy vibe, but I was too impatient to let it cool so it all mixed into this, which I actually really like the color so I’m not too bummed. Already can’t wait to make a new batch! I’m hoping these will make good gifts!


r/soapmaking • • 8h ago

Questions about using goat milk in CP soap

3 Upvotes

As I’ve stated in my other posts, I am quite new to making soap. All the recipes I’ve currently been messing with are more tallow (beef) and olive oil dominate, and I also add a bit of coconut oil and castor oil depending on the recipe! Im pretty confident on the cleansing feel of a soap. I’m still working on a nice lather and also good longevity!
Anyways, my husband has been ranting and raving to people that I’m making soap for fun and his barber gifted him a handmade bar of soap from Oregon where they use goat milk! I finally gave the soap a try today and MY GOSH, the creamy lather was UNREAL… I loved it so much! I’m being led to believe that that’s from the goat milk correct? I’ve haven’t used it yet considering it’s still really unfamiliar to me but I wouldn’t be opposed to trying it!
I definitely babbled a little too long but I guess I’m more so asking soapers that used goats milk frequently in soap, why is it that you choose to use it and how? I’ve never used a milk in a soap!


r/soapmaking • • 12h ago

Insurance

3 Upvotes

Hello fellow soapmakers, I'm about to buy soapers insurance and was wondering if anyone has advice on this. Was looking at HSCG but resent the hidden fee of guild membership, so was going to go with ACT, which also includes guild membership fees but was at least upfront about this. Any thoughts? Much appreciated!!


r/soapmaking • • 1d ago

CP Cold Process I taught my husband and brother to make soap!

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

My husband did the drop swirl and my brother did the ITP swirl and they both came out so good! I’m so proud 🥰

Please excuse my raggedy countertop, she needs a good sanding and polishing.


r/soapmaking • • 1d ago

CP/HP + M&P Rainbow and fall soap

Thumbnail
gallery
211 Upvotes

I tried posting yesterday but for some reason it was removed, not sure why as no rules were broken. I'm really pleased with how these turned out. For the rainbow I used clover and aloe fragrance oil from bramble berry. The fall one is Lingon berry spice from bramble berry. Clover and aloe is one of my favorites. It's fresh, strong, and doesn't fade fast.


r/soapmaking • • 14h ago

What Went Wrong? Never seen this, what happened?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Made a double batch of lavender soap last night and when I cut it I noticed these opaque white patches throughout all the bars and significant soda ash. Also some small cracks on top. Makes me think it overheated, but what’s with the uneven inside and those white patches?

Recipe:
64oz total poured into 2 loaf molds

24oz Shea butter
24oz coconut oil
16 oz olive oil
20.4oz water
9oz sodium hydroxide
~4oz 40/20 lavender essential oil
Purple mica

I used the heat transfer method to melt my solid oils which I’ve done many times with no issues. (Used the hot lye solution to melt solid oils). Added olive oil, mixed well then stick blended. Everything looked beautiful!

I insulated both molds in a light towel. Then covered the top with an A frame type cardboard and another light towel.

Pics of finished bars, crack, soda ash and opaque patches inside and the freshly poured batter.


r/soapmaking • • 1d ago

CP Cold Process Oh how I love making soap

Thumbnail
gallery
121 Upvotes

Just 3 batches I made over the weekend, really hoping to get my skill level up to eventually start selling. They are so pretty and smell SO good!


r/soapmaking • • 1d ago

What Went Wrong? Can’t figure why soap went rancid

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hello everyone!
About three months ago we made three bars:

  1. eucalyptus EO
  2. lemongrass EO, wheatgrass infused EVOI
  3. Cedarwood EO, eucalyptus EO, red clay, calendula infused EVOI

They are all stored in cardboard boxes in a coat closet. It is kept dark in there. There are slight openings on top for air, but not big.

The red clay and cedar wood bar lost all its essential oil smell, and now smells rancid. The other two, stored the same way, and made around the same time, are perfectly fine.

Does anybody know why that could be? Also, any tips on storage are appreciated.

Recipe(2lb loaves) : 7.04 oz water, 4.11 oz NaOH, 13.44 oz extra virgin olive oil, 14.4 oz shea butter, 4.16 oz coconut oil.

In each case the essential oils and dry additives(like the red clay) were added at light trace. We soap at 90-95 degrees Fahrenheit, then put the molds in the freezer for the night.
Also a picture of the trouble soap when it was still pleasant🥲


r/soapmaking • • 2d ago

Ingredients Best Masculine Scent?

8 Upvotes

I’m purchasing from Brambleberry and want to know what kind of masculine scents you guys like. I’m not into musk, more of an Axe body spray type smell. Any suggestions?


r/soapmaking • • 3d ago

M&P Melt & Pour I made these soaps as party favors for my daughter's mermaid themed birthday

Thumbnail
gallery
145 Upvotes

I used SFIC Crystal Clear and White soap bases. They're scented with a blend of citrus, vanilla, and clove essential oils, and coloured with micas and eco glitter. I am so happy with how they turned out. I also made a mermaid tail pull apart cake with matching colours. It was a beautiful day full of beautiful things🩷🙏


r/soapmaking • • 2d ago

One batch more yellow than the other.

Post image
18 Upvotes

I invited my step mom to make soap with me (I make for fun and gifting, not selling). We made the same soap recipe, same measurements, same fresh ingredients and I walked her through each step, checked to make sure she reached a light trace. Very similar wooden molds. We used Lemongrass EO (I've used many times before) from Brambleberry. Why might her batch have come out more patchy yellow?

Could it be not mixing the fragrance as fully? Thats probably the only thing I didnt double check. The bars dont feel oily, and if It was DOS I would assume it would be both batches.

Her batch is the one in the back.


r/soapmaking • • 3d ago

HP Hot Process pine tar soap

Thumbnail
gallery
61 Upvotes

Awhile back someone posted some beautiful pics of pine tar soap they made ! it inspired me to make some too ! turned out great, except the strong smell of pine tar made my stomach sick. you really need to air out your place. I also messed up on the recipe, I ended up pouring too much pine tar out, and instead of adjusting and figuring out the exact amount, I just dumped it into the rest of the batter. luckily I used a hot process and it turned out great. I also ended up spilling a bunch of pine tar everywhere and it made a huge mess. I should've invested in a spout for the pine tar can. ugh !


r/soapmaking • • 3d ago

Technique Help Like a Glazed donut?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Is this just part of the soap batter that did not get tinted by the mica powder?
Or some other result of something I did or did not do in the method?

Upon molding, I see what looks like pure oil in a groove of the soap.
(First 3 pics)

4 days later, it looks exactly the same. (Last 2 pics/video)

Total oil weight 976 g. (75%Crisco, 25%Coconut)
Water 325.01 g. as % of oil weight (33.30%)
Super Fat/Discount (3.3%)
Lye Concentration 140.64 g. (30.204%)
Water : Lye Ratio (2.3109:1)
EO: 32.5 g,
Mica powders: 5 g
Method: stick blended melted oils for ten seconds and added lye-water when both lye-water and oils were about 145°F.
Blend to emulsify for about 3 minutes.
Add EO, blend 1 minute.
Separate batch in halves, blend in micas.
Pour batch into mold in wooden box, put wooden box top on, wrap in towel.
Stored In shady 72°F garage.
Unmolded and cut 26 hours later.
Curing in bedroom closet with much airflow, on parchment-paper upon wire rack.


r/soapmaking • • 3d ago

HP Hot Process What stage is this soap at?

Post image
6 Upvotes

I’m relatively new to making soap and i’m having trouble distinguishing between some of the stages. The photos online are not much help so I was wondering if anyone could tell me approximately what stage it’s at.


r/soapmaking • • 3d ago

Packaging, Labeling Dr Squatch labeling lawsuit

12 Upvotes

Very interesting to read the complaint which explains which ingredients plaintiffs allege are not natural and result in misleading advertising. Complaint linked in article https://www.classaction.org/news/9m-dr.-squatch-settlement-ends-lawsuit-over-alleged-synthetic-ingredients-in-natural-personal-care-products


r/soapmaking • • 4d ago

Other I'm Not the Only One Who's Done This Before, Right? RIGHT?!

Post image
16 Upvotes

See that black thing in my shea butter?

It's the spatula I was using to scoop out the butter.

I noticed it... after I resealed the bag.

*Sigh*


r/soapmaking • • 4d ago

Making soap

Post image
0 Upvotes

Making some soap 🧼


r/soapmaking • • 4d ago

Big soap makers, any tips for getting GMP/ISO 22716 certification?

3 Upvotes

We recently got a huge soap order of 50k units, but the buyer is looking for GMP/ISO 22716 certification.

We’re pretty compliant already with most of GMP and ISO SOPs, but it all sounds a bit intimidating at first glance.

Would love to hear stories about getting approved, denied, and what it all cost you.

Thanks 😊


r/soapmaking • • 5d ago

CP Cold Process A Little Update from My Workshop 🌿

Post image
53 Upvotes

It's been a while since my last post!

On the left: Kitchen Soap

After countless experiments and rounds of testing, I finally feel I've found a formula I'm happy with.

I've made a batch specifically for safety testing. I'll send it to the testing laboratory once it has completed the full six-week curing period. I'm excited to take this next step!

On the right: Five Syndet Shampoo Bars

I've developed five different formulas across four care categories:

- Daily Care: For oily and normal scalps

- Sensitive Care

- Hair Loss Care

- Clinic Care

I'm working on developing shampoo bars without petroleum-derived surfactants, preservatives, silicones, starches, or artificial colorants.

For the Hair Loss Care formula, I've included three ingredients listed in Korea's MFDS standards for functional cosmetics: menthol, D-panthenol, and salicylic acid.

There have been many failures and countless experiments along the way. I'm now about 90% satisfied with the results. The main formulas are in place, and I'm focusing on fine-tuning the details to get as close to 100% as possible.

I'm still researching, testing, and making small improvements along the way.

It's been a long journey of learning, experimenting, and refining. I'm happy to finally share a little of what I've been working on!


r/soapmaking • • 6d ago

CP Cold Process Show me your ugliest soap

Post image
39 Upvotes

I am new to cold process soap making but quickly became obsessed. I cranked out 14 batches with a variety of formulations in the last 2 months, and everything went beautifully…. Until today. I think it must have been the rose essential oil that I used for the first time and accelerated trace. My planned dusty pink bar with deeper reddish swirls turned to basically jello as soon as I added the essential oils and I had to press it into the mould. I am going to end up with bars that look like chunky raw meat.

Can everyone show me your worst batch ever to make me feel better?


r/soapmaking • • 5d ago

Recipe Advice Cold process soap color

2 Upvotes

Have those of you that use colloidal oatmeal notice that it affects your soap color? My bars keep coming out a creamy tan color despite my using titanium dioxide and I'm not sure if it's the colloidal oatmeal or the new lard I bought. The lard has a weird smell which I never noticed with other kinds of lard I've used previously.