r/StableDiffusion • u/Producing_It • 6h ago
Comparison H3 Image Edit vs Qwen Image 2.1 Edit
Just wanted to compare these two editing models since I consider them the best local options we have so far when it comes to edits. I used my 5090 to render these, and I also used a local LLM through a node in Comfy UI to enhance the prompts. The render times here don't include the prompt enhancer.
With H3 Image, besides the Sam Altman one, I rendered at 48 MP and downscaled it to 8 MP, and I just fully outputted at 8 MP with Qwen Image 2.1. I can include the workflows, but I have some vibecoded custom nodes that may not work the same for you.
1. Talking Ben replaces Sam Altman
Original prompt:
Replace the person in image 1 with the exact same CGI dog from image 2. Make the dog have the same pose, expression, and even clothing as the man in image 1. Transfer the facial expression as well. The background and setting, and everything else, should stay the same. Make the dog look like very good photorealistic CGI. Make sure the dog still keeps his body type and not a human's.
H3 Image Edit enhanced prompt:
The man seated in a wooden chair in <Picture 1>, wearing a brown crew-neck sweater and dark jeans with his hands resting on his lap, his head turned to his left and his mouth open mid-speech, surrounded by a warm home interior with illuminated bookshelves, a bookshelf of volumes, a dark mug on a small table to the left, a potted plant on a side table to the right, and a chair with a cushioned seat, is <Subject 1>. The light cream-and-tan furry CGI dog with a broad black nose, soft plush fur, and a stout canine body shown against a black background in <Picture 2> is <Subject 2>. The target image shows <Subject 2> occupying the seat in <Subject 1>'s place, rendered as highly photorealistic CGI that keeps the dog's own body type and fur while adopting <Subject 1>'s seated pose, open-mouthed talking expression, and full outfit, all within the unchanged home setting. <Subject 1> is partially preserved; his seated pose, head orientation, open-mouth expression, brown sweater, dark jeans, and the entire surrounding room with its bookshelves, mug, plant, side table, and lighting are retained, while his human head, hands, and body are replaced by the dog. <Subject 2> is partially preserved; its cream-tan plush fur, black nose, canine facial structure, and dog body proportions are retained, while its pose, expression, clothing, and background change to match <Subject 1>. The dog sits upright in the wooden chair exactly as the man did, its front paws resting on its lap in place of the man's hands, its lower body and hindquarters enclosed in the dark jeans and its torso and shoulders covered by the brown crew-neck sweater, the fabric draping realistically over the dog's furry form. Its head is turned to its left with the mouth open in the same mid-speech expression, the fur around the muzzle and cheeks showing fine photorealistic detail, soft studio-like highlights on the plush coat, and subtle contact shadows where the dog's body meets the chair and the sweater gathers over its paws, all lit by the same warm interior light that falls on the bookshelves and tables behind it so the dog reads as a believable CGI figure present in the room.
H3 Image Edit generation time: 52.17s with 20 MP internal render.
Qwen Image 2.1 enhanced prompt:
Replace the man sitting in the wooden chair in <image1> with the photorealistic CGI dog from <image2>, placing the dog in the exact same seated pose with its front paws clasped together in its lap, head turned to the same side with the same slight open-mouth expression and gaze direction. Dress the dog in the same brown/olive knit sweater and dark pants as the man wore, fitting the garment naturally over its furry dog body so the chest, paws, and legs remain clearly canine rather than human. Render the dog as highly photorealistic CGI matching the fur texture, color, and body proportions visible in <image2>. Keep the entire room setting from <image1> unchanged: the wooden chair, bookshelves, warm interior lighting, coffee mug on the side table, potted plant, floor, and camera framing all remain exactly as they were.
Qwen Image 2.1 generation time: 153.71s
2. Jensen Huang album cover
Original prompt:
Replace the girl in image 1 with the man from images 2 and 3. Put the man in image 2 in the same pose as the girl in image 1. But retain the clothes the man is currently wearing. Make sure he has the same facial expression and angle as the girl. Use image 3 as a reference for his facial features. Change the word "Britney Spears" to "Jensen Huang" in the same font, color, size, and position in the top right. Keep everything else the same, including the setting, colors, and background.
H3 Image Edit enhanced prompt:
The square composition, softly lit pink studio backdrop, and pink floor in <Picture 1> are <Subject 1>. The seated figure’s placement, folded-leg pose, head tilt, direct gaze, and broad toothy smile in <Picture 1> are <Subject 2>. The dark teal handwritten name 'Britney Spears' in the upper right of <Picture 1> is <Subject 3>. The small red subtitle '...baby one more time' beneath it is <Subject 4>. Jensen Huang in <Picture 2> and <Picture 3> is <Subject 5>. <Picture 2> supplies his black leather zip-front jacket, black shirt, black pants, and black shoes with white soles. The close-up in <Picture 3> supplies his facial features, swept silver hair, thin dark glasses, and natural skin texture. The target image shows <Subject 5> replacing the seated figure on the original album cover, with a new name in the upper right. <Subject 1> retains its framing, pink tones, and studio lighting, with contact shadows adjusted around the seated figure. <Subject 2> supplies the exact pose, facial expression, and head angle for <Subject 5>. <Subject 3> retains its handwritten style, dark teal color, size, and upper-right placement as the wording changes. <Subject 4> is fully preserved. <Subject 5> retains his recognizable features and the outfit from <Picture 2> as he moves from standing to the seated pose and smiles up at the camera. His knees sit close together in the foreground, his lower legs fold outward behind him, and both empty palms rest flat on the floor beside his hips with fingers spread. He leans forward with the top of his head tilted toward the upper left and his chin angled toward the lower right, looking up into the camera with lifted cheeks and visible teeth. The jacket and pants crease naturally around his bent arms and knees. The upper-right name reads 'Jensen Huang', with the same flowing strokes, letter height, and baseline as the original.
H3 Image Edit generation time: 115.06s
Qwen Image 2.1 enhanced prompt:
Replace the kneeling girl in <image1> with Jensen Huang, taking his facial features, gray hair, and glasses from <image3> and his black leather jacket, dark inner shirt, and black trousers from <image2>. Position him in the exact same pose as the girl in <image1>—kneeling on the floor with legs folded to one side and one hand planted behind him—and give him the same head angle and warm smiling expression she has, adapted to his face. Preserve his clothing exactly as shown in <image2> and <image3>, fitting it naturally to the kneeling pose. Keep the pink studio background, lighting, color palette, and framing of <image1> unchanged. In the top-right corner, replace the cursive "Britney Spears" wordmark with "Jensen Huang" in the same handwritten cursive font, same blue color, same size, and same position, leaving the smaller "...baby one more time" text below it intact.
Qwen Image 2.1 generation time: 138.58s
3. Trump at the stadium
Original prompt:
Replace the man in image 1 with the person from image 2, keeping the same clothes but swapping the head and skin to match the man from image 2. The facial expression, body pose, clothes, and lighting of the man from image 1 should be kept and transferred onto the man from image 2. Keep the lighting and the background the same.
H3 Image Edit enhanced prompt:
The man's body in <Picture 1>, wearing a red and blue plaid button-up shirt under a navy blue quilted puffer vest with both hands placed firmly on his hips in a wide-stanced standing pose, is <Subject 1>. The head of the person in <Picture 2>, featuring a full head of swept blond hair, a broad face with prominent cheekbones, and tanned skin, is <Subject 2>. The background scene in <Picture 1>, showing a crowded stadium with other spectators in casual clothing and a white 'ICC' logo in the upper right corner, is <Subject 3>. The stern, slightly furrowed-brow facial expression of the man in <Picture 1>, with narrowed eyes and a tight, unsmiling mouth, is <Subject 4>. The target image shows <Subject 2> seamlessly integrated onto <Subject 1>, with the head replacing the original while the body, pose, clothing, lighting, and <Subject 3> remain intact. <Subject 1> is fully preserved. <Subject 2> is partially preserved; his head structure, blond hair, and tanned skin tone remain, while his facial expression changes to match the stern look of <Subject 4>. <Subject 3> is fully preserved. <Subject 4> supplies the specific facial expression transferred onto <Subject 2>. The facial expression on <Subject 2> now mirrors the intensity of <Subject 4>: his eyes narrow, his brow furrows slightly, and his mouth tightens into the same unsmiling, serious set, all while his skin tone, hair volume, and facial bone structure remain those of the person in <Picture 2>. The lighting on the transplanted head matches the directional, slightly warm ambient stadium light, with soft shadows falling on the right side of the face consistent with the overall illumination of the scene, and the jawline blends naturally into the collar of the plaid shirt and the upper edge of the puffer vest.
H3 Image Edit generation time: 105.25s
Qwen Image 2.1 enhanced prompt:
Replace the head, hair, and skin of the man in <image1> with the face and head of Donald Trump from <image2>, grafting his blonde hair, facial features, and skin tone onto the existing body. Preserve the serious, neutral facial expression, the hands-on-hips body pose, the red-and-blue plaid shirt with navy puffer vest, the lighting, and the stadium-crowd background with the ICC logo exactly as shown in <image1>. Keep <image1> as the base image, matching the new head's scale, angle, and lighting to the original scene; use <image2> only as the source for the face, hair, and skin identity.
Qwen Image 2.1 generation time: 150.34s
4. Rivian replaces Cybertruck
Original prompt:
Replace the truck in image 1 with the truck in image 2. Put the truck from image 2 in the same pose, position, angle, and lighting as the truck in image 1. Make the truck from image 2 face the same direction as the truck from image 1.
H3 Image Edit enhanced prompt:
The cloudy sky, distant dark ridgeline, and wide framing in <Picture 1> are <Subject 1>. The uneven snow and ice beneath the Cybertruck in <Picture 1> are <Subject 2>. The Cybertruck’s parked stance, position in the frame, and low, nearly side-on camera view in <Picture 1> are <Subject 3>. The cool daylight, bright upper surfaces, and deep shadows beneath the Cybertruck in <Picture 1> are <Subject 4>. The metallic gray Rivian R1T in <Picture 2>, with its four-door cab, short bed, black wheels, vertical oval headlights, horizontal light bar, and small 'RIVIAN' door badge, is <Subject 5>. The target image shows <Subject 5> occupying the Cybertruck’s place in <Picture 1>. <Subject 1> is fully preserved. <Subject 2> retains its terrain and texture, with local changes where the replacement truck meets the ground and casts its shadow. <Subject 3> supplies the stance, placement, apparent scale, and viewing angle for <Subject 5>. <Subject 4> supplies the lighting for <Subject 5>. <Subject 5> retains its original body shape, proportions, paint, wheels, and trim as its orientation, perspective, and lighting change. The Rivian’s nose points toward the left edge and its bed extends to the right. The camera sees mostly the truck’s side and just a narrow slice of its front, with the nearer front wheel appearing larger and sitting on the raised snow at left. The rear wheel rests lower at right, matching the original stance across the uneven ground. Cool sky reflections follow the Rivian’s windows and curved body panels, and the tires cast close contact shadows that follow the contours of the snow. Any areas exposed by the different body shape continue the surrounding scene naturally.
H3 Image Edit generation time: 114.16s.
Qwen Image 2.1 enhanced prompt:
Replace the white Cybertruck in <image1> with the silver electric pickup truck shown in <image2>, placing it in the exact same position, three-quarter front-left angle, and facing direction (front toward the left) as the original truck in <image1>. Match the new truck to the snowy, overcast lighting of <image1>, with consistent shadows on the cracked ice and snow, and keep its size proportionate to the original. Preserve <image1> as the base scene: the snowy rocky ground, blue sky, clouds, and camera framing stay unchanged. Retain the truck from <image2>'s recognizable body shape, grille, headlights, wheels, and silver paint as its identity, adapted to the new pose and light.
Qwen Image 2.1 generation time: 189.20s.





