I've run a small bootstrapped consumer app since 2015. It moves music libraries between streaming services. I won't name or link it, because I want pushback on the decision, not traffic.
The old model
Free users could move 300 songs (600 if they joined our newsletter). Then a subscription. On paper it worked: the limit converted a lot of one-time users into paying users.
The catch: most of them cancelled right after their transfer. Moving your library is a one-time job. People paid once, got what they needed, and left. Our "subscription" business was really a one-time purchase business with extra steps.
A decade of stagnation
The market is small and crowded. Every year it was the same fight with the same competitors over the same one-time customers. Revenue stayed flat.
What we changed
We made basic transfers free, with a fair-use limit (up to 10,000 songs per account). The subscription now pays only for ongoing value: playlist tools and auto-sync between services. If you use two services at the same time, you need it every week, not once.
The bet: a free app spreads much further than a paid one (more installs, more ratings, more word of mouth), and recurring users convert to MRR that actually stays.
Where we are now
Revenue dropped significantly. We have enough savings to ride it for a long time, so this is not a survival post. But I underestimated how hard it is to watch the number drop every day and keep trusting the plan.
What I learned so far
- High conversion can hide a bad model. Our free limit converted well, and that made us blind to how fast people churned.
- State the free limit up front. Otherwise you get angry customers.
- With no revenue per transfer, growth has to come from somewhere else: a rating ask after a good transfer, share links, referrals and SEO.
My questions for you
- If you moved a core feature from paid to free in a mature product, how long until revenue came back, if it did?
- How do you decide when a drop is "the bet needs time" and when it is "the bet failed"? What metric did you watch?
- We also sell a lifetime plan next to monthly and yearly. Lifetime brings cash now but eats future MRR. Did anyone regret offering it?
My biggest question is, do we go back to freemium model if this does not grow our app? How long to wait to verify if it works or not?
We have other revenue streams, so it is not live or die situation for our company, but I have to say, it hurts to see less money coming in every day.