Having a Friendsgiving and I’ve been tasked with cooking the steaks. I was vegetarian for over 10 years but I did eat steaks before that. Not vegetarian anymore, but it’s still rare that I eat meat. It’s been so long since I’ve had steak and I’m excited to eat it again and really want to cook a good steak!
About 4-5 of the guests will want steaks and while I believe most of the guests will want it medium rare (myself included) one guest wants it medium.
I really know nothing about steaks so I’m trying to figure out what cut of meat I should get, how to season or marinate it and how I should cook it.
My mom used to get steak and tenderize it by stabbing it with a fork, putting Montreal steak seasoning on it and marinating it in a ziploc with Worcestershire sauce in the fridge for a day or two. But she would use London broil which I hear is not the most quality cut of steak.
If I get a nicer, fattier cut of meat, can I still marinate it like this and tenderize it with a fork? I also don’t have a grill. The tools available to me are a stovetop (pan), oven and air fryer.
What cut of meat should I get that is tasty and has some marbling but won’t break the bank? How should I cook it? How should I season or marinate it? Should I buy one large steak or 4-5 individual steaks for everyone who’s eating one?
Also, do I need to buy a meat thermometer or can I eyeball it?
Thanks in advance! It’s been a long time, but I’m really hoping I can make a killer steak!