Hello all, I would appreciate some gentle advice and appreciate you taking the time to read this. It’s very long so I apologize for the length but, I wanted to try and be transparent to ensure I receive proper advice. My (28M) girlfriend (23F) ended our relationship back in May for something I said in response to what I feel was an emotional affair with her police academy classmate/company leader (32M). I just would like some advice and maybe some insight to help me grow and appreciate anything to help me move onward in a positive way.
As a pretext, she was a friend of mine prior to our dating and we met through her mom, who ive known for 10 years of my life. We were friends for 7 years and mutually decided to start dating 3 years ago. About 1.5-2 yrs before we started dating, my ex was unfortunately assaulted in college by an unstable guy friend. He showed up to her dorm unannounced while going through his emotions and he took advantage of her kindness. There were warning signs that should have been obvious red flags but, they went unchecked and subsequent therapy suggested to her that she had social awareness and boundary issues.
Roughly 90% of her friends are guys. In the time we were together I assured her I was never jealous and trusted her deeply. Despite this, there were a couple incidents where some of her friends stepped forward and confessed they had feelings for her the whole time. One person was trying to ask her on a date for almost a week before she realized what he was doing and turned him down (this is very relevant because yes, she was that aloof). She confided in me the details of her past and I became a core component of her healing. When it came to intimacy, she had a phobia of pregnancy and deep anxiety surrounding sex so we only ever did what was comfortable for her but never full intercourse (this is very relevant). We had a very happy relationship until she 4 months into the police academy.
She met a guy there who I will call V (32M). V was in the military for 4 years and pipelined into the academy and was given the role of company leader for his cadet group. My ex who is a sheltered college girl with a scarred past was in that group. She told me he was everything she wanted to be as an officer and he was one of her first “friends” since college. She wanted to be his friend and at some point he started to get close to her. Id ask her about her days and she would always find a way to mention him. One instance I asked her about her day and she started talking about him instead. I told her I was uncomfortable with how much she spoke about him and expressed she could be friends with whoever she wanted but, I was concerned she was trying too hard to be this man’s friend when she should be focusing on studies.
At the start of the academy, we agreed to friday nights and Saturdays for us which left the rest of the time for her but, either me or her dad would offer to take her or I would order her an uber. V had offered to drive her one time but slowly that became her new preferred form of transport and he started driving her every day as was her wish. Over the course of April was when she started range training which was 4pm to midnight and an hour from the academy. V was her driving her completely at this time now which was definitely suspicious but, I never wanted to be “the jealous boyfriend” and let it go.
she also started acting weird around this time, mind you we had not had any issues up to this point. She started to say she was uncertain of our relationship and that she was afraid I would leave to which from My perspective was absolutely silly. I treated her as a wife. Wrote stories and poetry, providing therapy massages for training sores, gifts to cheer her up and motivate her, etc.. one day she said to me how lucky she was but then 5 minutes later said she didn’t know if we could continue the relationship and then went on a small rant about how cheating is common in law enforcement. That her instructors said she may lose her person on the outside and find someone new through the job even though academy had 0 tolerance policy for fraternizing and romance between classmates.
A week before our fight, she asked if it was okay if she didn’t love me as much as she used to and that she wanted to pause our intimacy. That hurt to hear but, I suggested it may be due to academy stress to which she agreed but asked if I was jealous of V. Again a red flag but I disregarded it. By this point, her entire social circle outside of the academy and her parents were telling her that her friendship with V was getting weird and it didn’t look good for her but she disregarded them saying he was just a friend. Her best friend also found out she told him everything about her past after just 2 weeks of talking when, she never told her parents at all. Ironically I was the last person to say he was bad.
A week later I wanted to surprise her with a gift but she said I might not want to give it to her and she didn’t know if she could tell me why. Through a multitude of questions she confessed to me that she had developed feelings for V. On his private car rides, he was saying how he never had time for relationships, that he never found “the one”, that most women were pretentious and that she was the only girl who ever understood him. She had also been having late night phone calls with him according to her mom and my ex herself said there were instances where she went to him for emotional support (which is something I thought was a boyfriend’s job.
I didn’t say anything at the time because I didn’t really understand how wrong that appeared and thought she was just getting support from who I thought was just friend). I asked how long it had been going for and she said 3 days (though her friends told me later she was implying feelings for him for almost a month which would explain her odd and distant behavior/comments.). She then told me that she wasn’t thinking it would go this far, that she wasn’t aware of what she was doing or even aware of the red flags V was giving her despite me consistently asking how I could help, support and be the best boyfriend for her I could be (even going as far as reading articles on how to date law enforcement and how to be supportive of them beyond traditional means). In the end, she was instead actively choosing to expend her time towards this guy who had been isolating her from her peers and friends/me. Seeking his rides instead of having me or her father drive her, having private conversations in his car, etc. .
again up to this point, her closest friends and family were telling her deliberately that what she was doing was wrong and from outside perspective, V was crossing severe relationship and morally social boundaries as was she I feel. This is when I said “you learned nothing from your past and didn’t grow as much as you thought. Your actions and decisions are why we’re in this mess”. This is the line I regret saying because it’s the line she attributed to ending the relationship.
This same night, I caught her texting V and telling him she thought we were breaking up. He wanted to meet her privately that same night. That was when I told her to tell him I knew everything. When she told him, he blew up on her and told her I wasn’t supposed to know. I was furious and was not very good at maintaining composure but I told her I wanted to try and fix things to which she reluctantly agreed. The next day I apologized for my behavior but was told it was to friendly and that she was experiencing emotional whiplash. I told her we didn’t have to hang out that weekend and could wait til the following weekend to hangout but that she needed to set a professional boundary on V.
That same day she texted me she needed me because V hurt her. When she set the boundary, he said what they could have had would have been great, that she led him on, gaslit him into believing they had a future and that she was nothing more than a manipulative attention seeking child. She said she was done with him and wanted to focus on repair. I sat her down on 2 separate occasions and apologized for my anger, told her how I felt about the choices made and that I wanted to forgive and move on together. Both times I also asked extensively if I did or said anything wrong. She emphasized that I didn’t.
A week later, she ended things with me. The day before, she went to a hang out with another police friend who we will call B (29M). B had been a police officer for one year and had a degree in psychiatry. My ex said she wanted to hang out with B before a date with me as a psych hang out to try and sort out the love triangle, which I would later her find out was something she could not fully disclose to him due to risk of expulsion. When she went to hang out with B, at first, she said it was just going to be a lunch which I had no problem with. Then as the time for our date started to grow closer I asked her where she was and she said she was going to a bunch of different shops and the arcade with B. To most people this is mundane hang out, but it was structured exactly like one of our first dates which upset me terribly, and I let her know that at the end of the day because it had only been a week since her confession and my trust was still hurt.
Again, I apologized for being hurt and that I wanted to keep trying. Before this hangout things were seemingly normal. After this hangout, she was distant, monotone and avoidant. When I asked her what advice she was given about V (again, she couldn’t talk about him to this person due to fear of expulsion), she said that he was “toxic, manipulative and that she needed to let go and move on”. I think she really got this advice about me and did so from a person who was not allowed to know about her actions (and didnt know) and someone she barely knew for 4 months. Its speculation but, I feel her desire for validation by this new crowd of police mates and the new relationship stress played a role here. It was a losing battle for me but I tried my best to be there for her.
The next day was when we broke up And that was when She said I had absolutely no right to bring up her past, that she promised she’d never let another man make her feel small and that I manipulated her into thinking V was bad when he was actually good for her. That my quoted statement was enough to warrant calling me a victim blaming monster but told her parents that she didn’t deserve me and was done with men. She then bracketed me in the same category as the man who assaulted her as “people who she thought were safe”. After the breakup, I offered support to her until the end of the academy to which she agreed. In this time was when I found out she went back to talking to V 3 days after the breakup despite her saying she was done with men, her own uncertainties around this man and her friends yelling at her that it was a bad idea on top of the emotional cheating being a month, not 3 days like she had told me. I called her out angrily and she broke down to her friends and told them I was right.
After that I apologized for my anger again, for canceling a planned meeting to talk when I found out the extra info and wanted to handle everything with patience and kindness moving forward. She would intermittently respond to small talk and at the end of those conversations, I would ask if she wanted my support still and she would continually say “yes” or “it would be nice”. Any future offers to talk in person she would say her friends were more important, that she would consider it or that she had an excuse that didn’t line up with the plans (i only asked two times and stopped when I heard obviously fake excuses). In this time, she was privately meeting with V and wasn’t telling her friends or family. I told her on her graduation day that if she wanted me around, she had to stop talking to V.
That prompted her to say we couldn’t be friends and that I crossed a line. That she could never consider another relationship with me again, never forgive herself, always felt like a project that I tried to fix or change (excuses that only came after the breakup and when I asked mutual friends if she explained why, her reaction was always that its just how she felt or that she didn’t want to talk about it. No real example. I genuinely wanted to know too because I absolutely don’t want to be that kind of person and wanted to make changes if necessary. These same friends told me that she never complained about me and even in some instances said how lucky and happy she was. And her own mother said to me I likely will be the best boyfriend she ever had.), and that she could never look at me the same way again. That was when I walked away and left her a message stacking the grievances on both sides with a major question that she couldn’t answer. “Why did you forgive this man when he actually insulted you but you condemn me for angrily stating something that you admitted to friends was true?”.
No contact started end of june but, within 1 week of no contact, her friends came to me in a panic and told me that my ex did something that they said was terrifying to them. I would later find out in an emergency update from those same friends that V had seemingly convinced my ex to give up her virginity with no protection or plan B and it resulted in a pregnancy scare that she electively hid from the both him and her parents (her dad is a retired officer so I understand why she did that). They grew so worried for her health that they gave her an intervention due to apparent signs of emotional abuse, manipulation and coercion that she repeatedly dismissed despite also openly acknowledging that this man was hurting her life. Despite all of this, his initial insults in response to relational boundary setting, clear lack of respect for her morals/boundaries and her own acknowledgment that she doesn’t even know what to call her situation with him (it’s so vastly different from how I treated her and so much more ambiguous that she can’t call it a true relationship), she has chosen to continue on with V through said seemingly ambiguous situationship. Her parents already had concerns about this man and she can’t really openly talk to him without backlash from friends as they have all of the screenshots, texts and her own accounts of V’s conduct. I have been trying my best to move on and take it day by day but I just wanted some insight.
Am I really the victim blaming monster who was manipulative and controlling? I definitely don’t want to go back to her as this has scarred me pretty badly and completely shifted my perspective of myself. Her vision of me calcified into her claims/accusations against me and the damage to my trust and respect I feel is not reparable. No contact was “mutually” agreed on and I have made it clear since the emergency intervention that I do not want updates anymore as her decisions after the breakup were completely different and “reckless” compared to the person I knew for 7 years.
My biggest issue now is grappling with the 2 phrases of my character from the one person whose word was my standard. One week from saying I did nothing wrong with her consistently expressing guilt, remorse and shame as well as me owning up to what I said in response to what was emotional cheating (at least thats what I am told) to being treated with hostility, being called a manipulative, victim blaming monster who was controlling and tried to fix this girl like a project was a painful turn I still struggle with. Being acknowledged enough to stay for 2 months as academy emotional support while being treated with ambiguous silence and awkward conversation I feel only made it worse. “Thankfully” that stopped end of june before the other developments were unceremoniously provided.
I know having a full insight in the relationship would be important so if I could give any details to help better understand I will happily do so and have no problems being honest. Thankyou for taking the time to read my story. This was both of our first and only relationships so the lines for me on what is truly infidelity (emotional or otherwise) are not very well established and I still struggle to understand if my reaction was justified or at least understandable.
Her decisions after the breakup were something she was free to do and she was free to end the relationship whenever she wanted but, I don’t feel the reasons are comparable to her actions and behavior. She made it very explicit early on that things ended because of what I said and what she believed I was to her but when I solidified no contact, she admitted the breakup was mostly her fault and by that time from my perspective, her decisions truly suggested she did know what she wanted with regards to a relationship/future, she just wanted them with her police academy group leader instead of me.