This omni is massive. I had lots of fun reading it. I love Alec’s journey throughout each arc. For me the weakest part might be the machines storyline near the end of the omni. Not that it was bad just felt like another war story when the first half of the book is dedicated to the rotworld storyline which in itself felt like a massive war.
It would be a disservice if I didn’t mention the art. The art is consistent throughout the omni and genuinely breathtaking at times. So many stunning 2 page spreads and swampy is depicted in so many cool ways whether he is an entire island or just a small plant.
I enjoyed Soule’s part more than Snyders. No hate to Scott Snyder just that Soule really fleshed out the green and introduced some really cool concepts like the parliament having its own agenda and how avatars can be replaced if the green feels their current avatar isn’t pleasing them. Snyder’s part felt like it was riding on rotworld being amazing and while it wasn’t awful by any means it definitely drags on a little especially When you realise that none of it mattered cos Animal man and swamp thing were able to just go back in time and make sure rotworld never happened
I also really liked how Anton Arcane was written by Soule, he genuinely believes that him spreading the rot is an act of love which is so twisted and cruel and it really stood out. He loves the rot and he believes spreading this gift is his duty which is such an interesting take imo. The seeder stuff was great as well, I loved that he helped Alec at the end against the machines.
Spoilers: It was very raw seeing how everytime Alec was getting close to Abby their circumstances makes the distance between them feel even bigger. Their ‘final’ meeting at the end of Snyder’s run was actually pretty sad imo