Tribute cost is the current mechanic for paying for a card in my game. It’s paid for by discarding other cards in your hand.
Some context first. The game is set in a primeval world where creatures and other living things are fighting for survival (I’ve got a ton of lore). Each card is modal, with a summon and an instinct both on one card.
A summon occupies the larger half of the card, has an ability, and is usually a creature or plant. Summons have a strength value denoted by the number in the paw symbol, a health value found below that in the blood droplet, and can engage in combat/blocking. An instinct is a cheaper, instant version of the ability that can be played at any point in the game regardless of whose turn it is. Usually the effect is weaker due to this flexibility.
Summons represent the beings who have chosen to participate in their ascendant’s quest for ascension. (Ascendants are basically your leaders/commanders.) Instincts are reflections of animalistic behaviors that align with whatever ability they represent. I’m still currently workshopping the card design & frames. Attached is the most updated designs (subject to changes), along with an example of an ascendant.
It’s a draft environment. The current working set has 152 unique cards, and a deck consists of 28 unique cards.
How tribute works now
Currently, as the game is set up, the tribute cost is found in the top left corner. The current way to pay a tribute 1 costed card is to discard any single card from your hand. If it were tribute 2, you would discard any 2 cards from your hand.
It’s scaled to how myself and playtesters feel the ability scales, i.e. a higher tribute cost for a higher tier/impactful effect. Since each card is modal, the summon and the instinct are weighted independently (a more permanent/passive effect on a creature vs instant ROI with instincts, albeit less impact in the long run).
The change I’m considering
Something I would love help balancing or implementing would be changing both the summon & the instinct to the same cost (and either scaling up or down the effect’s impact). And instead of having tribute be paid for by x amount of cards from hand, you would have to pay x amount of tribute equal to the tribute cost of cards in your hand.
For example, if a summon cost 7 tribute, you could still pay with 7 (tribute 1) costed cards, or a (tribute 3) + a (tribute 4) costed card. If an instinct cost 3 tribute, it could be paid for with either a single (tribute 3) card, or any card whose tribute value exceeds 3, with the overflow disappearing, for example paying for a tribute 2 costed card with a tribute 6 costed card.
This in my mind would allow for more cards played per turn, and more actions feel like more options and more fun.
Where I’m stuck
We’ve been playtesting both versions quite a bit, and at this point I think I’ve just got some analysis paralysis. Since I’m focused on making it work as a draft, I think that’s why I’m having difficulties getting good & balanced “ramp.” And since I have a fairly unique resource system, it’s proving a little too complicated to just theory craft and hope a couple games a day will show me the way.
Thoughts? Do you need more context? I really just need some outside perspectives because I almost feel like I'm too committed one way now.
Processing img dgsnaxy3172i1...
Processing img x4cbdh5j072i1...