r/telescopes • u/MimishoPopochas • 16h ago
Discussion Comparison of gathering light by aperture diameter in inches
CREDIT: ED TING
Edit: Here is a brief explanation for the naïveté:
This slide illustrates how a telescope's light-gathering power increases as its aperture (diameter) grows.
Because a telescope gathers light using a circular lens or mirror, its light-gathering capacity is proportional to its surface area (Area = pi * r^2), which scales with the square of the diameter. As a result, increasing a telescope's diameter yields diminishing percentage returns in light-gathering area as the scope gets larger.
Breakdown of the Ed Ting’s Slide
Bullet 4.5 to 6 = 100% Increase: Moving from a 4.5-inch to a 6-inch aperture substantially boosts the light-gathering surface, doubling the area (Ed Ting represented it here with an error, as a 100% increase).
Bullet 6 to 8 = 78% Increase: Upgrading from 6 inches to 8 inches increases the area by roughly 78% (8^2 / 6^2 = 64 / 36 \approx 1.78).
Bullet 8 to 10 = 56% Increase: Stepping up from an 8-inch to a 10-inch mirror yields a 56% increase in light-gathering area (10^2 / 8^2 = 100 / 64 = 1.56).
Bullet 10 to 12 = 44% Increase: Going from 10 inches to 12 inches provides a 44% increase in area (12^2 / 10^2 = 144 / 100 = 1.44).
Even though the linear size increase is similar or identical (adding 2 inches of diameter), the percentage boost in light-gathering power drops significantly at larger sizes. This explains why larger telescopes require exponentially larger increases in diameter to achieve significant jumps in performance.
Key Takeaways
1. Diminishing Returns on Linear Steps: Just like the percentage area increase shrinks when you add a constant 2 inches of diameter, the boost in limiting magnitude also shrinks (dropping from a 0.63-magnitude gain down to 0.40). It takes progressively larger absolute jumps in aperture to keep pushing the magnitude limit deeper.
2. The Power of Ratios: Because magnitude is logarithmic, equal ratios of diameter yield identical magnitude gains. Notice that moving from 4.5 to 6 inches and from 6 to 8 inches both use a diameter multiplier of ~1.33x. Consequently, both steps grant the exact same boost in faint-star visibility (+0.63 magnitudes), even though the 6-to-8-inch upgrade adds more physical square inches of light-gathering mirror surface.