r/tolkienfans • • 11h ago

REMINDER: There is no discussion of Amazon's Rings of Power on this subreddit. Click here to see where you can discuss episodes 5 and 6

209 Upvotes

/r/tolkienfans does not allow discussion of any adaptations, including Amazon Prime's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. However, we recognize that some users here will wish to discuss the most recent episode together, and so when the show started we prepared a different subreddit, /r/RingsofPower, run by the some of the same mods, where users from our subreddit can go to discuss this together, from the perspective of the books.

Click here for the /r/RingsofPower post linking all threads for the recent episode releases.

For people interested in other places to discuss the show, there is also /r/LotR_on_Prime, which tends to have a more supportive outlook, and /r/rings_of_power, which tends to have a more critical outlook. Every subreddit has a slightly different feel and you're encouraged to find the one that best fits your needs. Some of the more general subreddits like /r/lotr will also have their own discussion threads, as will other Tolkien communities outside of reddit.

However within /r/tolkienfans all discussion about this show and other adaptations is not allowed. To this end, this post itself is being locked. You are encouraged to report threads and comments that fall foul of the rules whilst showing patience and civility to newcomers who are learning more about Tolkien for the first time.


r/tolkienfans • • 5h ago

How to pronounce "Orodruin"

29 Upvotes

Hello! I am writing a song about Mordor and wondering how to pronounce Orodruin. I think I know how but I want to make sure. Thanks in advance!


r/tolkienfans • • 10h ago

Theory: Númenorean admiral Ciryatur as Ringwraith (and possibly the Witch-King)

49 Upvotes

So we know that three of the Ringwraiths were Númenorean Lords, and it's heavily implied and likely that the Witch-King is one of these three. If we look at the ~550 year time period between the fall of Eregion (1697) and the first appearance of the Ringwraiths (2251) when the Nine would've been gifted out, Númenor was at this time engaged in transitioning from good men who came to Middle-earth as teachers and healers and allies of the Elves to military men and oppressive conquerors.

Following Numenor's decisive victory over Sauron in the War of Sauron and the Elves in 1701 thanks to Tar-Minastir's fleet led by Admiral Ciryatur, the Numenorean Kings became greedy of wealth and sent many lords, governors, and military men to Middle-earth to extract riches and subjugate the local peoples. The likelihood that some or all of the Númenorean Ringwraiths were these colonizing lords is very high, given the timeline.

But what about the naval admiral Ciryatur himself? He has no birth date and no death date. All we know is his savvy military strategy utterly crushed Sauron's forces and Sauron was chased out of Eriador because of him, possibly by Ciryatur himself. Ciryatur could've been a young man when he led Minastir's fleet, and thus could have lived to see what his victory had wrought on Númenor. He would've served Tar-Minastir, one of the last good Kings of Numenor allied to the Elves, and lived to serve his son Tar-Ciryatan who began Numenor's imperialist efforts on the coastlands. Who better to head up these efforts than the hero that humiliated Sauron at the Battle of the Gwathló?

My theory is that, jaded with the way Númenor was going following his supreme military victory, Ciryatur became cynical and even sympathetic to the native Men of Middle-earth they were oppressing, feeling guilt maybe at the role his own military triumph had brought on. He began to hate the spoiled and greedy son of the good king he once served. Perhaps he decided to go 'rogue', leave behind the colonialist efforts, and went after Sauron years later to 'finish the job he started'. Out East he became ensnared in his manipulations and accepted a Ring of Power. Perhaps Sauron offered power to restore Númenor to its former glory? Or perhaps he was so jaded and sympathetic to the plight of the local populations of Middle-earth that he was offered power to rule over them himself and drive Númenor off into the sea?

And as for Sauron, he kills two birds with one stone- 1). he gets a brilliant military strategist (who beat even Sauron himself) under his control with intimate knowledge of the Númenorean colonies and access to the Kings' inner circle, and 2). he gets to spend the next three and half thousand years mentally and spiritually torturing the man who defeated and humiliated him in the Second Age.

Regardless of if he's the Witch-King or not, Ciryatur's the only Númenorean mentioned during that 550 year period of Sauron handing out the Nine that's that's not a Númenorean King or have a death date for. And while not a king or sorcerer, he fits the bill of a 'warrior' and Númenorean Lord. I'd say the chances of him being a Ringwraith are high, or at the very least he fits very easily into the profile and time scheme, and doesn't contradict anything.

(As a side-note the only reason I never considered Ciryatur as a Ringwraith before is because I thought he was the same character as Tar-Ciryatan due to the similarities of their name and the fact that Ciryatur served under Minastir whereas Ciryatan was Minastir's son.)


r/tolkienfans • • 5h ago

Could Feanor’s crusade succeed?

15 Upvotes

Ok so Feanor and 90% of Noldor were really determined to leave. And they left. Spilled kin’s blood, lost men on the ice, we know the story. Let’s imagine Manwe took different course of action: permitted (if not outright advised) Olwe to lend his ships for Feanor’s quest. Then a lot of things could be different:

  1. Feanor’s warriors are not lost in Alqualonde and later to Uinen’s wrath;

  2. Fingolfin’s troops are not diminished while crossing the ice;

  3. Finarfin has no excuse to return, so his men too join the War of the Jewels;

  4. All hosts arrive to Beleriand a lot sooner, not exhausted, and without much of that mutual hostility and distrust;

  5. No Teleri blood was spilt – Thingol can be recruited as an ally;

  6. Morgoth may still be recovering from his battle with Ungoliant, he probably hasn’t yet fully rebuilt his strength in Angband.

With all that in mind, could Feanor win the war and get rid of his Oath by actually fulfilling it? Valar’s Messenger told him that he could not overcome a Vala even if Eru made him “thrice greater”. But we’re not talking about single combat here. Take Gil-Galad, Elendil and Isuldur: I don’t think any of them was individually stronger than Sauron, yet together they overcame him. Fingolfin alone dealt Morgoth a lot of serious blows: the Dark Lord lost lots of blood and was left with a life-long disability. Now imagine a few thousand very angry Noldor, light of Valinor still bright in their eyes, hacking at Morgoth with their long bitter swords. Poor guy will promptly regret he ever left Mandos.

Tolkien’s letter 131 adds an important detail about the prospect of challenging the Valar race in principle: it says that “Númenóreans directed by Sauron could have wrought ruin in Valinor itself”. So if an army of humans (+1 maia in HQ) could have waged a successful war against all the remaining Valar together, why a united host of mighty 1st Age Noldor couldn’t have wrought ruin in Angband?


r/tolkienfans • • 44m ago

Ungoliant, Shelob and Nameless Things oh yeah

• Upvotes

plenty of terrors for 4th age, independent of the evil men do


r/tolkienfans • • 16h ago

Could it be that the Pelori (save Taniquetil) were destroyed when Eru removed Aman from Arda?

8 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this because Aman itself was not completely spared from destruction when the world was changed, as we see by the landslides that buried Ar Pharazon and his armies (which considering the size of his host must have been enormous), plus whatever destruction came from the ocean.

But most of all because when Frodo goes to Valinor he sees "white shores and a far green country", whith no mentions of tall mountains, which also could not have been present if he could see so far inland as to see fields and forests.

Also i would discard the idea that he was talking only of Tol Eressea, because even with that island in the way, mountains so high should have been a prominent feature of the landscape (as it was for Tuor when he spoke with Ulmo).

Addendum from the Akallabeth:
"These lost sailors saw the curved world sink beneath them and reached the lamplit quays of Avallónë or the farthest beaches of Aman. There, they beheld the White Mountain (Taniquetil) "dreadful and beautiful" right before they died."
Again no mention of mountains save for Taniquetil.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Can someone explain why craftsmanship and skills like building, forging, and others are so integral to prestige and wonder in Tolkien’s writing?

40 Upvotes

So I find that a lot of emphasis is placed on the wonder and skill of ancient crafters and builders. The elves of old and the numenoreans were excellent craftsmen, yet, in my naive view, a lot of work like that today is considered blue-collar or less than.

In Tolkien’s stories it seems like craftsmanship and skill in building is reserved for the elites and I’m wondering how that came about in Tolkien’s writing. Is it more like the architect gets the acclaim and status while the actual builder is the nobody who builds it?

I hope my question makes sense. Sorry if it’s dumb


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

The impact of the existence of Sauron to Middle Earth

10 Upvotes

After the bewilderment at the destruction of the War of Wrath and the vow of repentance to Eonwë, I see Sauron returning to "his original powers" - shapeshifter, technical/artistic knowledge (elements from the time of Aulë's tutelage), but with maintenance of aspects linked to Melkor: cheating, deception and acting.

We then have the centuries of decadence and obscurity in the Middle-earth, with men in a primitive state, given the cataclysm in Beleriand and the natural loss of knowledge - in the mold of the Legend of the "Enigma of Steel" portrayed in Conan: a civilization or belle Époque suffer a catastrophe of great proportions is a synonymous with obscurity and technological primitivism - a kind of Dark Age in Middle-Earth.

The first centuries of the 2nd age - time of the wandering Sauron. The geopolitical situation was based on the formation of the elven kingdoms and a kind of Noldor renaissance in Eregion. But the monsters, orcs, beasts, and other servants of Morgoth were scattered and leaderless. Regarding men, Sauron must have used Clarke's 3rd Law to co-opt them to his cause:

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

In this scenario of decadence, obscurity and primitivism, a "benevolent god" arrives and brings technological teachings that impact on the social, economic and political development of societies that interact with this walking deity - at best Sauron was already thinking about the long term: military strengthening, submission and technological dependence of prehistoric men for a future conquest of the opposing pockets that were in the northwest of Middle-earth - mainly in Eriador. This is equivalent to an interference in the normal development of a culture or society, hindering it. if any and all freedom or innovation (social, technology, government, etc.) that could attempt or question this false Prometheus. Through the teachings of metallurgy, engineering, agriculture (etc) to men under their dominion:

"In the east and south well nigh all Men were under his dominion, and they grew strong in those days and built many towns and walls of stone, and they were numerous and fierce in war and armed with iron."

It reminded me of an aspect covered in Star Trek - the Primary Directive:

The Prime Directive prohibits Starfleet personnel and spacecraft from interfering in the normal development of any society, and mandates that any Starfleet vessel or crew member is expendable to prevent violation of this rule.

and

As the right of each sentient species to live in accordance with its normal cultural evolution is considered sacred, no Starfleet personnel may interfere with the normal and healthy development of alien life and culture. Such interference includes introducing superior knowledge, strength, or technology to a world whose society is incapable of handling such advantages wisely. Starfleet personnel may not violate this Prime Directive, even to save their lives and/or their ship, unless they are acting to right an earlier violation or an accidental contamination of said culture. This directive takes precedence over any and all other considerations, and carries with it the highest moral obligation."

In this demonstration of miracles and powers (in my view it was the use of technologies and knowledge from his time with Aulë), ignorant men began to understand all this in a strictly religious sense - transmuting technological production into rituals, imposing dogmas to avoid questioning about this "divine" knowledge: As if they were mystery cults, in which only the priestly elite could have access - more or less what Planet Terminus did in Isaac Azimov's Foundation Trilogy, when it monopolized knowledge and provided the apparatus to uneducated planets who understood such knowledge to be magic or divine favor.

What do you think of this idea?


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

How much power did the Valar really have over the Chlildren of Iluvatar, including the Elves in Valinor?

21 Upvotes

There's all this talk of bans and doing something against their will, etc. but the impression I get is that, in effect, the Valar can't really do much. They can keep the fea of Elves like Feanor in Mandos until the End of Time, and they can seize and imprison someone like Morgoth, but I don't think they can do anything with the peoples of Middle-earth, or even Valinorean Elves.

The most extreme case was when Numenoreans landed on the shores of Aman, and even then all the Valar did was lay down their guardianship of Arda for the time, and let Eru decide what to do.

I guess they did have the power not to admit the Exiles back into Aman, but they did let them go back to Tol Eressea at least.


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

The mystery of what became of Ungoliant after she devoured herself

124 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about Ungoliant lately and how little we’re told. She flees into the forgotten south after helping Morgoth, then apparently consumes herself in her endless hunger.

Is that the full story, or could there be more? Tolkien leaves so many threads like this open. She’s described as existing before the Valar in a way that feels distinct from the Ainur, yet she’s not one of the named powers. Her darkness seems almost a force unto itself.

Did anyone else ever wonder whether she might have lingered in some diminished form, or if her end was truly final? The idea that even Morgoth grew afraid of her is striking.


r/tolkienfans • • 1d ago

Beyond "evil for a generic villain reason": A more logical timeline for Sauron’s fall and betrayal

0 Upvotes

In the beginning, Mairon (Sauron) descended and helped the Valar in their war against Melkor. Here, their first encounter took place, and Mairon was struck by Melkor's immense power. At this time, Mairon wanted to forge a perfect world alongside the Valar, whereas Melkor did nothing but destroy. But Melkor's goal was not destruction for the sake of destruction—or at least, that is what Melkor made Mairon understand. He told him that he intended to destroy everything so that he could later rebuild something that could actually be controlled, doing it the way it truly ought to be done under absolute power. This idea eventually took root in Mairon.

Shortly afterward, Tulkas descended, and Melkor fled from the world. In the long years to come, Mairon would help Aulë and the Valar shape the world and build the Two Great Lamps. Yet, Mairon saw this world as imperfect because the Valar chose not to eliminate 100% of the damage caused by Melkor. During this time, Mairon may have communicated with Melkor from time to time, and his seduction continued its course, though it did not fully culminate just yet. Through these conversations, Melkor realized that the Valar were so absorbed in the shaping of the world and the lamps that they would not notice his return; therefore, together with the spirits of fire that would later become the Balrogs, he returned to Middle-earth and secretly began the construction of Utumno.

Here in Utumno, Melkor poured his taint into Arda, channeling almost all of his power into it and thus forging "Morgoth's Ring." In the midst of the chaos, Melkor slipped away, succeeded in destroying the Great Lamps, and took shelter back in Utumno.

Although Mairon loathed both events, what he detested most was the Valar's decision to abandon Middle-earth and focus solely on the building of Valinor, leaving the rest at the mercy of Melkor's taint. This final fact was what convinced him to permanently abandon the Valar and join Melkor. His idea, at first, was to help Melkor destroy the Valar's creation so they could subsequently rebuild something greater and more perfect.

What do you all think of this narrative? Could it be canonical? Could it have happened this way? These motives seem much more coherent given what we know about Sauron.


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

The sadness when The Silmarillion was coming to an end

104 Upvotes

While reading the final paragraphs of The Silmarillion, I was reminded of the entire journey of sacrifices, heroic deeds, courage, victories, and defeats of the great characters in this grand love letter from Tolkien to the myths that constitute the legendarium.

I felt a kind of melancholy, and it seems that the ending reflects this feeling:

Yet the lies that Melkor, the mighty and accursed, Morgoth Bauglir, the Power of Terror and of Hate, sowed in the hearts of Elves and Men are a seed that does not die and cannot be destroyed; and ever and anon it sprouts anew, and will bear dark fruit even unto the latest days.

Here ends the SILMARILLION. If it has passed from the high and the beautiful to darkness and ruin, that was of old the fate of Arda Marred; and if any change shall come and the Marring be amended, Manwë and Varda may know; but they have not revealed it, and it is not declared in the dooms of Mandos.

There was a triumph, many factors (and heroes) contributed to it, but it was all interspersed with sadness and pain. This feeling of melancholy began, at least for me, when Fingolfin and Finrod died. There I felt a kind of "beginning of the end" of this great saga. Something ephemeral (and paradoxically eternal), an unspoken experience, that was ending along with the great characters who were also disappearing/dying.


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

Melkor and the void after his banishment

55 Upvotes

I just wanted to put this out there. Its pure speculation.

Once Melker was banished to the void, that place outside of Arda.

He is still bound by the chain Angainor, still bearing the beaten collar of his once great iron helm that housed the Silmarils.

I like to think that Eru would leave his timeless halls to go to Melkor. To show him from afar how he still helped achieve something greater.

The fire, passion and eventual rage that defined Melkor had its ultimate source in Eru. As far as i understand all of the Ainor where but a part of Eru's mind and borne from it.

This makes me think that of any being, Eru could understand Melkor and his reasons despite how warped they became.

Melkor did in the end, achieve much of what he was meant to do within Arda. He just achieved it while attempting to spite Eru. He was ultimately trapped by his purpose. Even the dispersion of Melkors power into Arda may serve a higher purpose that only Eru might know.

I believe Eru would take a measure of pity on Melkor knowing he fulfilled his purpose as part of the larger themes sung forth at the beginning.

In strife he still;

  • Altered the geography of Arda, raised valleys, laying low mountains, toppling the two lamps creating the sea and landmass.

This likely served Eru's purpose of separating the Valar from the birth places of the 1st/2nd born as they fled to form Aman.

  • "The cunning work of frost" introducing cold and heat helping bring about clouds and rain and the eco system that Yavanna would bring plant life to.

These works alone would have helped the Valar and Maiar indirectly in achieving their goals in shaping middle earth.

Its just unfortunate from the perspective of the Valar and the children that this was achieved through strife rather than cooperation as Manwe would have preferred.


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

What sort of punishment would be expected in Bree for highwaymen and brigands robbing merchants and folk along the East Road and the Greenway?

21 Upvotes

I feel like hanging criminals might be be anachronistic and not quite in Tolkien's tone, but I could be wrong about that. Perhaps capital punishment would be reserved only for murderers? What say you r/tolkienfans?


r/tolkienfans • • 2d ago

“Let my people go”. Why not, Manwe?

14 Upvotes

So Elwe returns from his first visit to Valinor and says this to his people, when discussing migration West: “No doubt (indeed this is guaranteed) we, or any who wish, will be free to return to our homes” (NoME). I don’t think he made it up. So why wouldn’t Manwe honor his own guarantees in time of crisis?

We know that Feanor broke his exile when he compelled the Noldor to leave Aman. But the Doom of Mandos was caused chiefly by the Kinslaying, not by his rebellion alone. It is worthy to note that the Noldor actually never wanted to steal the ships. All they needed was transport back to Middle Earth, a “taxi service”, similar to what Valar themselves secured for their own host during the War of Wrath. HoME 10 however tells us: “no ship would they [Teleri] lend, nor help in the building, against the will of the Valar … we will neither give them nor sell them for any league or friendship.” So several options regarding the ships were on the table: lending, selling, help in building. Teleri rejected all of them, and the reason is given: “against the will of the Valar”. Which apparently means Manwe made sure Teleri knew what his will was. But why not help the Noldor to get back to their homeland?

Noldor were transported to a faraway continent on a floating island. And when they opted to leave, the only option was… a maybe half-frozen ice isthmus in the far North? Had Manwe simply permitted Olwe to lend those ships, Noldorin host would have remained far stronger, not stained by kin’s blood (so could have had Thingol as an ally), and arrived much faster, maybe even before Morgoth fully rebuilt his power in Angband. Such an opportunity missed.


r/tolkienfans • • 3d ago

Recovering a Civilization

20 Upvotes

Did Tolkien ever speculate about how long (if ever) it would take Gondor to relearn the arts and sciences of Numenor?


r/tolkienfans • • 3d ago

If an elf dies and is instantly rembodied...

20 Upvotes

Would that mean there are two bodies for the same soul?

Or would the first one disappear?

I don't know, it would be strange to die, return to Valinor with your body, come back to Middle-earth, and find your body dead.


r/tolkienfans • • 4d ago

Of Melian healing Húrin after his torment by Morgoth, or not

50 Upvotes

Writing about the mental and physical consequences of torture on various characters (unsurprisingly, it mostly turns people bitter, broken and insane pretty much at once, apart from Maedhros, who somehow keeps going while appearing generally sane for nearly six centuries), I stumbled upon an interesting element concerning Húrin. 

Húrin is one of very few characters that we know of whom Morgoth really takes a personal interest in and tortures. Húrin spends 28 years forced to observe his family’s downfall after they were cursed by Morgoth, including watching his two remaining children marry, have sex and kill themselves when they realise that they’re siblings. After his children are dead, Morgoth lets Húrin go to cause havoc and to unwittingly give him further intel. At this point, Húrin is broken, and his final known act is to insult Thingol and flee, most likely to kill himself: 

  • QN (1930): After stealing Nargothrond’s (cursed) treasure: “And the curse came upon the possessors in this wise. Each one of Húrin’s company died or was slain in quarrels upon the road; but Húrin went unto Thingol and sought his aid, and the folk of Thingol bore the treasure to the Thousand Caves. Then Húrin bade cast it all at the feet of Thingol, and he reproached the Elf-king with wild and bitter words. ‘Receive thou,’ said he, ‘thy fee for thy fair keeping of my wife and kin.’ Yet Thingol would not take the hoard, and long he bore with Húrin; but Húrin scorned him, and wandered forth in quest of Morwen his wife, but it is not said that he found her ever upon the earth; and some have said that he cast himself at last into the western sea, and so ended the mightiest of the warriors of mortal Men.” (HoME IV, p. 132) 

(See also Christopher Tolkien’s commentary in HoME IV, p. 188) 

The QS doesn’t get to this point in the narrative, but three later texts do: 

  • Later AB (late 1930s): “Húrin brought the gold to Thingol in Doriath, but he departed thence again with bitter words, and of his fate and the fate of Morwen thereafter no sure tidings were ever heard.” (HoME V, p. 141) 
  • In a post-LOTR annal for F.A. 502, after Húrin in Brethil, come literally two lines about Húrin in Nargothrond: “Húrin comes to Nargothrond and slays Mim the petty-dwarf. He and his men carry off the treasure of Glaurung and bring it to Doriath. Húrin is admitted in pity.” (HoME XI, p. 258) 
  • Concerning the Hoard (1964): “He gathered a great company of violent outlaws, and they came to Nargothrond and slew Mim, and carried off a great part of the dragon-treasure. Dominated by his will and by fear of him they brought this treasure to Doriath, and there Húrin cast it before the feet of King Thingol in a proud gesture of scorn, saying that as “the Lord of the House of Hador” (Húrin) vowed not be beholden to an elf-King for the fostering of his son, nor the harbouring of his wife and daughter. “Here is your fee! More than enough, maybe, for services so meanly performed; but hold me now out of your debt and friendship!” Thingol was amazed at the insult, but answered with patience and courtesy, saying he wished for no ending of friendship with Húrin, whose name was honoured among Elves and Men for his great valour in the last great Battle, and near all Elves and Men had been rather in his debt ever since. But Húrin laughed in contempt and went out, unmolested, into the night.” (Concerning the Hoard) 

So: in all versions, Húrin, utterly broken and bitter but proud until the end, insults Thingol, doesn’t listen to him (or Melian) in the slightest, and leaves. 

Apart from the version written by Christopher Tolkien and Guy Gavriel Kay, that is, which ends markedly differently where Húrin’s furious, mad bitterness is concerned: 

  • After stealing Nargothrond’s treasure: “Now Húrin journeyed eastward, and he came to the Meres of Twilight above the Falls of Sirion; and there he was taken by the Elves that guarded the western marches of Doriath, and brought before King Thingol in the Thousand Caves. Then Thingol was filled with wonder and grief when he looked on him, and knew that grim and aged man for Húrin Thalion, the captive of Morgoth; but he greeted him fairly and showed him honour. Húrin made no answer to the King, but drew forth from beneath his cloak that one thing which he had taken with him out of Nargothrond; and that was no lesser treasure than the Nauglamír, the Necklace of the Dwarves, that was made for Finrod Felagund long years before by the craftsmen of Nogrod and Belegost, most famed of all their works in the Elder Days, and prized by Finrod while he lived above all the treasures of Nargothrond. And Húrin cast it at the feet of Thingol with wild and bitter words. ‘Receive thou thy fee,’ he cried, ‘for thy fair keeping of my children and my wife! For this is the Nauglamír, whose name is known to many among Elves and Men; and I bring it to thee out of the darkness of Nargothrond, where Finrod thy kinsman left it behind him when he set forth with Beren son of Barahir to fulfil the errand of Thingol of Doriath!’ Then Thingol looked upon the great treasure, and knew it for the Nauglamír, and well did he understand Húrin’s intent; but being filled with pity he restrained his wrath, and endured Húrin’s scorn. And at the last Melian spoke, and said: ‘Húrin Thalion, Morgoth hath bewitched thee; for he that seeth through Morgoth’s eyes, willing or unwilling, seeth all things crooked. Long was Túrin thy son fostered in the halls of Menegroth, and shown love and honour as the son of the King; and it was not by the King’s will nor by mine that he came never back to Doriath. And afterwards thy wife and thy daughter were harboured here with honour and goodwill; and we sought by all means that we might to dissuade Morwen from the road to Nargothrond. With the voice of Morgoth thou dost now upbraid thy friends.’ And hearing the words of Melian Húrin stood moveless, and he gazed long into the eyes of the Queen; and there in Menegroth, defended still by the Girdle of Melian from the darkness of the Enemy, he read the truth of all that was done, and tasted at last the fullness of woe that was measured for him by Morgoth Bauglir. And he spoke no more of what was past, but stooping lifted up the Nauglamír from where it lay before Thingol’s chair, and he gave it to him, saying: ‘Receive now, lord, the Necklace of the Dwarves, as a gift from one who has nothing, and as a memorial of Húrin of Dor-lómin. For now my fate is fulfilled, and the purpose of Morgoth achieved; but I am his thrall no longer.’ Then he turned away, and passed out from the Thousand Caves, and all that saw him fell back before his face; and none sought to withstand his going, nor did any know whither he went. But it is said that Húrin would not live thereafter, being bereft of all purpose and desire, and cast himself at last into the western sea; and so ended the mightiest of the warriors of mortal Men.” (Sil, QS, ch. 22) 

This is extremely different. In all other versions, Húrin remained bitter, contemptuous and furious at Thingol. Only in the published Silmarillion does Melian (gently) get Húrin to see the truth, and Húrin ends up apologising to Thingol in word and deed. I wonder where this came from. 

Sources 

The Shaping of Middle-earth, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME IV].

The Lost Road and Other Writings, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME V].

The War of the Jewels, JRR Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins 2015 (softcover) [cited as: HoME XI].

JRR Tolkien, Concerning the Hoard, images at https://www.jrrtolkien.it/2022/07/04/scoperto-manoscritto-che-cambia-il-silmarillion/ [cited as: Concerning the Hoard].

The Silmarillion, JRR Tolkien, ed Christopher Tolkien, HarperCollins, ebook edition February 2011, version 2019-01-09 [cited as: Sil]. 


r/tolkienfans • • 4d ago

Did Orcs fight alongside Elves and Men in the War of the Last Alliance?

160 Upvotes

It is said in the Silmarillion that “All living things were divided in that day, and some of every kind, even of beasts and birds, were found in either host, save the Elves only. They alone were undivided and followed Gil-galad.” - Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age.

According to some commenters on Reddit, this explicitly means that Orcs fought on the side of the Last Alliance, as well. What do you think? While we know that Orcs weren't all subservient to Sauron, and the ones that were could rebel if given an opportunity, it's hard to imagine them joining Men and Elves in the alliance, or be accepted by them.

Two of the ways that quote could be interpreted: 1) Tolkien simply wasn't thinking of Orcs when he wrote that, or 2) he didn't consider Orcs "living things" at the time. Another option might be that, for reasons of their own, some Orcs fought Sauron's forces without actually being part of the Last Alliance.


r/tolkienfans • • 3d ago

Sairon's knowledge of the ring

0 Upvotes

It seems to me weird that

1) He previously thought the elves had destroyed the ring, but

2) He now cannot fathom that anyone would destroy the ring.

Anoth issue:

A) he has a palantir and can see many things.

B) he thinks Aragorn has the ring in ROTK even though he has never glimpsed neither the ring nor its manifest effects through the palantir.

Can you explain these two matters?


r/tolkienfans • • 4d ago

Will i like actually miss out if i read lotr before the hobbit?

14 Upvotes

so im like a total newbie, i dont know anything ab the series. like the only thing i might know is that weird creepy elf thing from the movies that i saw when i was very little (and im not even sure if its even from that lol) but yeah i was at the bookshop and saw the first part of the lotr (there were no other tolkien books) so i got it. and yeah when i was going to read it i js saw a massive "notes ab the text" section. like it was overwhelming and now im unsure if i should go look for the hobbit first


r/tolkienfans • • 4d ago

A personal surprise 😮

32 Upvotes

Reading through Appendix B of The Lord of the Rings and just realised the Battle of Bywater, the Passing of Saruman and the end of the War of the Ring happened on my birthday - November 3!

I’ve read the Lord of the rings before but this time after finishing it I made myself read the Appendices!

If any of you have not yet read them, I strongly advice you to do so! :)


r/tolkienfans • • 4d ago

do we know what happened to the blue wizards?

17 Upvotes

Hi do we know what happened to the blue wizards?

Did they settle in the east and fade away?


r/tolkienfans • • 5d ago

Did Aragorn just carry the palantir of Orthanc around with him after claiming it?

137 Upvotes

In The Two Towers, Aragorn claims the palantir of Orthanc, as the rightful heir of Isildur, after it was recovered by Gandalf. At Hornburg, he uses it to show himself to Sauron. And after that Tolkien doesn't mention that particular palantir until after Sauron is defeated, Aragorn is crowned the King, and anounces that he will keep that palantir. "But the Palantír of Orthanc the King will keep, to see what is passing in his realm, and what his servants are doing."

Did he just carry it around with him (or had it carried for him) through all the events from Hornburg to his arrival in Minas Tirith?

It's said in LotR that Aragorn wrested the control of it from Sauron, does that mean Sauron couldn't use it anymore?


r/tolkienfans • • 5d ago

what do we know about orc society and everyday life in tolkien’s world?

26 Upvotes

i have found myself very curious about orc society and culture beyond their roles as soldiers and antagonists. i’ve read the books, but it’s been over a decade, so it is certainly not fresh in my memory.

some of the questions i have come up with: do orcs have families and friendships? how do they raise their children?

do they have hobbies, leisure activities, or cultural traditions? are orcs generally literate?

do they have jobs besides just outside of military roles?

to what extent are orcs living under sauron or saruman effectively enslaved or coerced into serving them? are there independent orc settlements or communities elsewhere in middle earth? or are orc populations nomadic even??

i’m very open to recommendations for specific passages, letters, or other resources i could read to learn more. and, of course, if anyone is particularly enthusiastic about orc lore and feels like answering some of these questions themselves, that would be awesome too.

edited because of rule 4 ! my apologies. :)