r/Ultralight • u/TrainingPerception32 • 1h ago
Purchase Advice 7D vs 10D for a do-it-all 3-season bag? Stuck between X-Lite 400, Hyperion 20 and Rockfront 450 (UK, 6'1")
Hey all, I've been going round in circles on this for ages, so I'm hoping some of you can talk sense into me.
I'm after one UL bag I can just grab for pretty much anything outside proper winter and not have to think "am I going to be cold tonight?", without lugging a heavy bag around. So I'm looking at something around 20F/-6C.
At the moment I'm using an Aegismax Dusk II. I've had it down to -4C and was fine, but I'd have liked to be a bit warmer. It's also a 7D shell, and it's already got a few holes where the zip has caught and ripped the fabric. That's what's got me stuck: do I stick with 7D for the weight, or go 10D for a bit more durability? Or am I overthinking it and should I just go 20D?
The ones I'm stuck between:
- Cumulus X-Lite 400: comes to about £473 for me with DHL and UK import VAT, which stings. I think it's 7D, same as what's already ripping on me.
- Therm-a-Rest Hyperion 20 UL Long: about £380 from a UK shop, 10D.
- Rockfront 450 UL
A bit about me and how I'll use it:
- I'm in the UK, so it's mostly damp cold, and condensation is a thing.
- Next year I'm doing the Camino del Norte straight into GR5/TMB, about 2.5 months back to back. I know -6C is overkill for most of that, but I want the margin, and the bag needs to survive months of daily stuffing and damp mornings.
- I'm 6'1" (185cm). The X-Lite Regular maxes out at exactly 185cm, which makes me a bit nervous, especially with a puffy on.
- I'm a warm sleeper.
- Base weight is usually 3-4kg. Shelter is a MLD Cricket Pro tarp in silpoly with a Tyvek bivy, so it's pretty open and the bag will see a fair bit of damp and breeze.
- Mat is a Robens zigzag CCF, with a 1/8" pad under it when needed. I've got an XTherm for winter.
- I've already got a Rab Ascent 900 for winter, but I want this to be my go-to for most trips.
- No quilts please, I've tried them and just don't get on with them.
So my questions:
- 7D vs 10D: has anyone done a long thru-hike with either and how did the shell hold up? Is 10D actually noticeably tougher, or is it worth going 20D?
- Has anyone used two or more of these and can compare them?
- Is the Cumulus worth roughly £90 more after import fees?
- Anything else I should be looking at? I've seen the Alpkit Pipedream 400, Rab Neutrino 400, ME Helium 400 and Criterion Quantum 450 mentioned.
Cheers in advance