r/union • u/Natural_Doubt_6320 • 12h ago
Discussion Is pattern bargaining still good for American manufacturing?
Been following the BP Whiting lockout and some of the recent USW negotiations, and it's got me wondering whether pattern bargaining still makes sense for American manufacturing.
I get why it worked decades ago, but with manufacturing becoming more specialized and companies facing global competition, is pushing for the same agreements across an industry still realistic? In my opinion it makes no sense you potentially lose jobs.
Especially in steel / manufacturing, where companies like Cleveland Cliffs can't necessarily pick up production if US Steel loses capacity. At what point does pushing too hard risk sending more jobs and investment overseas?
Obviously workers deserve fair wages and benefits, but I'm curious whether these bargaining tactics are still protecting American jobs in the long run.
Anyone else in the industry have thoughts?
