On this day, November 17, 1929, the Plenum of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) adopted the resolution "On the Group of Comrade Bukharin.”
This marked the organizational defeat of the Right Opposition and the culmination of a profound theoretical and strategic struggle over the nature of the transition to socialism in a besieged, backward country.
The clash emerged from the contradictions of the New Economic Policy (NEP). By the late 1920s, the Soviet Union faced a profound crisis of primitive socialist accumulation. The NEP, with its market concessions to the peasantry, had restored agricultural production but failed to generate the surplus necessary for the rapid industrial expansion required to defend the revolution against imperialist encirclement. The grain procurement crises of 1927 and 1928 exposed the fundamental antagonism between the state's need for capital and the kulaks' capacity to withhold grain, which demonstrated the persistent operational rule of the law of value in the agricultural sector.
Bukharin, the principal theoretician of the Right Opposition, advanced a gradualist path. In his September 1928 article "Notes of an Economist," he warned against the "military-feudal exploitation of the peasantry" and argued for a continued alliance (smychka) with the middle peasantry, allowing the kulaks to "grow into socialism" through cooperatives and market mechanisms, believing if the peasants “enriched themselves” they will be more pliable to socialism and development will prosper with the smychka intact. He charged his opponents with advocating "internal imperialism" through the mechanism of primitive socialist accumulation, which involved the state extracting surplus from the agricultural sector via non-equivalent exchange to fund heavy industry.
Stalin’s faction, however, operated from a different framework. The policy of "socialism in one country" was a practical recognition of the Soviet state's isolation after the defeat of the European revolutions. The survival of the proletarian dictatorship now depended on its ability to build a self-sufficient industrial base without waiting for external salvation or the sluggish market mechanisms of the NEP. The rationale was the party-state could not allow its industrialization program to be held hostage by the peasantry and lag behind due to economic fetters of the NEP.
Stalin, who had previously relied on Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky to defeat Trotsky and the Left Opposition, now turned against his former allies. The Right Opposition’s base lay primarily within the trade union leadership and those sections of the party closest to the peasantry. Yet it proved largely an apparatus affair, doing little to mobilize the working class or the party rank and file behind its alternative. By April 1929, Stalin had dispersed the Right's top leadership from their positions of power, and the November Plenum completed the rout.
The resolution presented the Rightist leaders with a single choice, leave the party or capitulate. They chose the latter.
In a statement published shortly after the Plenum, Bukharin, Rykov, and Tomsky declared that "in this dispute the Communist Party and its Central Committee proved to be right and we were wrong," promising to fight "decisively against deviations from the Party general line, particularly against Rightists."
The defeat of the Right Opposition in 1929 was not the end of Bukharin’s political life, but the beginning of a protracted decline, and ultimately, his death.
Following his removal from the Politburo, he was given secondary roles, most notably as editor of Izvestia, but he never abandoned his theoretical opposition to the forced pace of collectivization and industrialization, and continued to voice opposition and criticism privately and publicly.
The material pressures of the early 1930s, including the famine of 1932–1933 and the consolidation of the Gulag, deepened the party leadership’s intolerance for any lingering alternative authorities or opposition.
The assassination of Stalin’s bodyguard and personal friend, Sergei Kirov, in December 1934 provided the catalyst for a renewed offensive against the opposition.
The security apparatus, under the direction of the Central Committee, began to construct a legal case that transformed political opposition into a charge of espionage and treason. Bukharin was arrested in February 1937 and trialed March 1928.
The indictment accused them of belonging to a “Bloc of Rightists and Trotskyites” that had, for years, engaged in espionage on behalf of British, German, Polish, and Japanese intelligence services. They were charged with systematic sabotage of industry and agriculture, with plotting terrorist acts against the leadership, and with planning to seize the Kremlin and dismember the Soviet Union, and the specific accusation that Bukharin had plotted to assassinate Kirov and others.
Bukharin admitted to the political charge of leading a counterrevolutionary bloc but stubbornly refused to confess to specific acts of espionage and terrorism, unlike Zinoviev and Kamenev in 1936. The court however was not interested in these distinctions.
On March 13, 1938, the Military Collegium found all defendants guilty. Bukharin was sentenced to death and executed by firing squad at the Kommunarka shooting range on March 15, 1938. He was 49 years old.
The following is a letter Bukharin wrote from his cell in the Lubyanka prison to Stalin on December 10, 1937 while he waited his sentencing. It was stored in the Soviet archives and translated into English. The letter was found preserved in Stalin’s personal archives at his dacha.
Very Secret Personal
Request no one be allowed to read this letter without the express permission of I. V. Stalin.
Iosif Vissarionovich!
I am writing this letter as what may possibly be my last letter, my farewell letter before death. Therefore, I ask you to allow me to write it, despite being a prisoner, without any official formalities, all the more so because I am writing it only to you, and the very fact of its existence or non-existence lies entirely in your hands.
The final page of my drama and, possibly, of my physical life is now being turned. I have agonized over whether to take up my pen or not—I am trembling all over with emotion and a thousand feelings, and can scarcely control myself. But precisely because we are speaking of the end, I want to say goodbye to you in advance, while it is not yet too late, while my hand can still write, while my eyes are still open, and while my brain is still functioning in one way or another.
To avoid any misunderstandings, I tell you from the outset that, as far as the world (society) is concerned:
I have no intention of taking back anything I have written.
In this regard (and in connection with it), I do not intend to ask you for anything, nor do I wish to beg you for anything that might divert the matter from the course along which it is proceeding.
But I am writing for your personal information. I cannot leave this life without writing these final lines to you, because I am tormented by things of which you must know.
1.
Standing at the edge of an abyss from which there is no return, I give you my solemn word, on the eve of my death, that I am innocent of the crimes which I confirmed during the investigation.
2.
Going over everything in my mind, to the extent that I am capable, I can add only the following to what I said at the Plenum:
a) That at some point I heard from someone about an outburst, apparently by Kuzmin, but I never attached any serious significance to it—it never even crossed my mind.
b) That regarding the conference, of which I knew nothing (just as I knew nothing about the Ryutin platform), Aikhenvald casually told me, on the street and after the fact, that “the boys had gathered and given a report,” or something of that sort. At the time, I concealed this, out of pity for the “boys.”
c) That in 1932 I acted with duplicity toward the “pupils” as well, sincerely believing that I would bring them all over to the Party, whereas otherwise I would alienate them.
That is all. In this way, I am clearing my conscience down to the smallest detail. Everything else either did not happen or, if it did, I knew nothing about it.
At the Plenum, I spoke the absolute truth, but I was not believed. And here, too, I am telling the absolute truth: throughout all these last years, I honestly and sincerely carried out the Party line and learned to appreciate and love you intelligently.
3.
I had no way out other than to confirm the accusations and the testimony of others and elaborate upon them: otherwise, it would have appeared that I was “not disarming.”
4.
Apart from the external circumstances and argument 3 (above), I have constructed approximately the following conception while reflecting on what is happening:
There is some grand and bold political idea behind a general purge:
a) in connection with the prewar period;
b) in connection with the transition to democracy.
This purge encompasses:
a) the guilty;
b) those under suspicion;
c) those who might potentially arouse suspicion.
They could not do without me here. Some are neutralized in one way, others in another, and still others in a third way.
An additional safeguard is the fact that people inevitably talk about one another and permanently sow distrust between themselves (I judge this from my own experience: how furious I became with Radek for all the things he blabbed about me! And then I myself went down the same path...).
Thus, complete security is created for the leadership.
For God's sake, do not interpret this as a concealed reproach on my part, even in my private reflections.
I have grown sufficiently beyond the swaddling clothes of childhood to understand that great plans, great ideas, and great interests override everything, and that it would be petty to place the question of my own person alongside the world-historical tasks resting above all upon your shoulders.
But it is precisely here that my greatest torment and my most agonizing paradox lie.
5.
If I were absolutely certain that this is indeed how you think, I would feel much more at peace.
Well, then! If it must be so, then so be it.
But believe me, my heart pours out a hot stream of blood when I think that you may believe in my crimes and, deep down, yourself think that I am truly guilty of all these horrors.
Then what does it mean? That I am helping to bring about the loss of a number of people (beginning with myself!), that is, I am knowingly doing evil!
Then there is no justification for it whatsoever. Everything becomes confused in my head, and I want to scream at the top of my lungs and beat my head against the wall: for I am becoming the cause of other people's deaths.
What is to be done? What is to be done?
6.
I bear no malice and harbor no bitterness toward anyone. I am not a Christian. But I have my own peculiarities.
I consider that I am paying for those years during which I genuinely conducted a struggle.
And if you really want to know, the thing that weighs most heavily upon me is one particular fact, which you may perhaps have forgotten:
Once, probably in the summer of 1928, I was at your place, and you said to me:
“Do you know why I am friends with you? Because you are incapable of intrigue.”
I replied: “Yes.”
And at that very time I was running to Kamenev (“the first meeting”).
Believe it or not, but this fact stands in my mind like some kind of original sin for a Jew.
God, what a boy and fool I was!
And now I am paying for it with my honor and my entire life.
Forgive me for this, Koba.
I am writing and crying. I need nothing anymore, and you know perfectly well yourself that I am only making my situation worse by allowing myself to write all this.
But I simply cannot, cannot remain silent without saying one last “forgive me” to you.
That is why I bear no resentment toward anyone, beginning with the leadership and ending with the investigators. And I ask your forgiveness, although I have already been punished so severely that everything has faded and darkness has fallen over my eyes.
7.
When I was having hallucinations, I saw you several times, and Nadezhda Sergeyevna once.
She approached me and said:
“What have they done to you, N. I.? I will tell Iosif to take you under his personal guarantee.”
It was so real that I almost jumped up and began writing to you, asking you to take me under your protection!
That is how reality became mixed up with delirium in my mind.
I know that N. S. would never have believed that I was plotting against you, and it is no accident that the subconscious of my unfortunate self produced this delirium.
And I spoke with you for hours...
Lord, if only there were some instrument through which you could see my soul, all pecked apart and tormented!
If only you could see how deeply I am inwardly attached to you, in a completely different way from the Stetskys and the Talis!
But enough of this “psychology”—forgive me.
Now there is no angel to turn aside Abraham's sword, and the fateful destinies will be fulfilled!
8.
Allow me, finally, to proceed to my few final requests:
a) It would be a thousand times easier for me to die than to endure the forthcoming trial.
I simply do not know how I will manage to control myself—you know my nature.
I am no enemy of either the Party or the USSR, and I will do everything within my power, but my strength in such circumstances is minimal, and terrible feelings rise up within my soul.
Forgetting shame and pride, I would fall to my knees and beg that this trial not take place.
But this is probably no longer possible.
If possible, I would ask that I be allowed to die before the trial, although I know how sternly you regard such matters.
b) If a death sentence awaits me, I ask you in advance—I implore you by everything that is dear to you—to replace execution by shooting with the possibility of my drinking poison myself in my cell (give me morphine, so that I fall asleep and never awaken).
This point is extremely important to me. I do not know what words I must find to beg you for this as an act of mercy.
Politically, it would change absolutely nothing, and nobody would even know about it.
But allow me to spend my final seconds as I wish.
Have mercy!
Knowing me well, you will understand.
Sometimes I look death squarely in the face with clear eyes, just as I know that I am capable of courageous deeds.
And sometimes that same man becomes so overwhelmed that nothing remains of me.
So, if death is my fate, I ask for the cup of morphine.
I beg you for this...
c) I ask to be allowed to say goodbye to my wife and son.
My daughter need not come: I feel too sorry for her; it would be too painful, just as it would be for Nadya and my father.
But Anyuta is young; she will survive it, and I also want to say my final words to her.
I would ask to be granted a meeting with her before the trial.
The arguments are as follows: if my family sees what I have confessed to, they may take their own lives out of sheer shock.
I must somehow prepare them for this.
It seems to me that this is in the interests of the case and its official interpretation.
d) If, against all expectations, my life is spared, I would ask (although I would need to discuss it with my wife):
\)* Either that I be exiled to America for n years.
The arguments in favor are these:
I would conduct a campaign surrounding the trials, wage a mortal struggle against Trotsky, win over large sections of the wavering intelligentsia, and become, in effect, an anti-Trotsky.
I would pursue this work on a grand scale and with genuine enthusiasm.
A qualified Chekist could be sent with me and, as an additional guarantee, my wife could be kept here for six months, until I had demonstrated in practice how I was beating Trotsky and Company to a pulp, and so on.
- But if there is even an atom of doubt, then exile me for at least 25 years to Pechora or Kolyma, to a labor camp.
I would establish a university there, a local-history museum, technical stations, and so forth; institutes, an art gallery, an ethnographic museum, a zoological and botanical museum, a camp journal, and a newspaper.
In short, I would undertake pioneering cultural work, settling there with my family for the remainder of my days.
In any case, I declare that I would work anywhere like a powerful machine.
However, to tell the truth, I do not hope for this, since the very fact that the directives of the February Plenum have been changed speaks for itself (and I can see that matters are moving toward a trial, which will take place any day now).
That, it seems, is all of my final requests.
There is one more thing: the philosophical work I have left behind—I accomplished much useful work in it.
Iosif Vissarionovich!
You have lost one of your most capable generals, one who was genuinely devoted to you. But that is now in the past.
I remember how Marx wrote about Barclay de Tolly, who had been accused of treason, that Alexander I had needlessly lost such a valuable assistant.
It is bitter to think about all this.
But I am preparing myself inwardly to depart from this earthly vale, and toward all of you, toward the Party, and toward the entire cause, I feel nothing but a great, boundless love.
I am doing everything humanly possible and impossible.
I have written everything to you. I have dotted all the i's. I have done this in advance, because I have absolutely no idea what condition I will be in tomorrow or the day after, etc.
Perhaps, being a neurasthenic, I will fall into such a complete state of apathy that I will be unable to move even a finger.
But right now, despite my headache and the tears in my eyes, I am still writing.
My inner conscience is now clear before you, Koba.
I ask your final forgiveness (spiritual forgiveness, and nothing else).
In my thoughts, therefore, I embrace you.
Farewell forever, and do not remember your unfortunate man with ill will.
N. Bukharin
10 December 1937
Original letter in Russian