I have had a Venmo credit card for a few years now. I signed up when there was a promotion to earn an extra percentage per spend category. So many details about the card company policies, as well as the app, are an absolute mess. I want to start this off by saying that the vast majority of the customer service reps I have spoken with have been perfectly polite and helpful, and my frustrations are largely based on higher-up company policy issues.
1) There is no forgiveness for missed payments. I have only underpaid the required balance in order to not be charged interest one time. It was within a month of my wedding, and the app doesn't make it easy to know what you have to pay in order to avoid being charged interest. I always pay the full balance on time or early, and thought I was paying enough to avoid interest around my wedding, but apparently I was incorrect in that. I called and asked if there was a one-time forgiveness policy, and was told no. Every other credit card company I've ever interacted with has a one-off forgiveness policy.
2) The fraud department is an absolute mess. About 2 months ago, I had a total of over $2100 charged to my credit card at grocery stores, fraudulently. I received fraud calls from a Venmo sister company, Synchrony, I believe, and quickly spoke with someone to verify my recent charges. There were a total of 4 transactions on my card that I did not initiate. I was told that the issue would be resolved soon, and that I would not be responsible for the fraudulent charges. Within a few weeks, I was credited for a purchase that I DID make around the same time as the fraudulent activity, in an amount around $9. I called to speak with someone about this, and apparently one of the 4 fraudulent charges that I had reported was not included in the investigation, and a much lower transaction that I did initiate, and know for an absolute fact that I never stated as fraud, was entered in it's place. The rep said that they corrected the issue. When I asked when I would see the fraudulent charges credited to my account, they said it could take up to 60 days. I am almost positive the first person I spoke with did not tell me that timeframe. Today is roughly 64 days after the initial fraudulent activity, and the fraudulent charges are still included in my balance. I was just now on the phone for roughly 40 minutes, in which I was informed that the misreported and unreported transaction issue was not reported correctly (the ~$9 charge wasn't reflected correctly, nor was the other actually fraudulent charge reported correctly). Also, my understanding from what the rep I spoke with today said is that the whole process needs to be started all over again, as the fraud was misreported, and I would see a resolution and credited balance WITHIN 60 DAYS. At this point I feel like I'm just being jerked around. I know that the reps were just following their required policies, and that mistakes happen, but this has been a headache for far longer than the process should have lasted.
3) No call reference numbers. Right before the previously listed fraudulent activity occurred, I received an email from Venmo saying that, if I clicked to activate an offer, I would get an extra 2% back per spend category for the next 30 days. I activated the offer, but some issues with the activated offer occurred due to the fraud, and I didn't get the full rewards I was due. When I realized this, I called to ask for help, and the rep noted my details and said that I should receive my additional owed rewards within 2 billing cycles. When I asked for a call reference number, the rep said that they don't do that... the rep was helpful and seemed to care, and this isn't her fault, but based on my experience with the Venmo credit card, I wanted some sort of confirmation/something I could refer back to when I (very realistically), don't receive the correct rewards as promised.
4) You can't use your Venmo credit card to pay people on Venmo. Honestly, the assumption (ultimately unbased) that I would be able to was one of the main reasons I chose to get the card. Of the frustrations listed above, this is the least of an issue, but I think card holders should be able to send money through the credit card without incurring a 3% charge. I totally understand if you can't get rewards for the transaction, but I really don't think users should be charged this fee when their Venmo transfer and credit card features are all housed within the same app.
The app asks all the time for me to refer someone for a small reward, but based on my experience, I'm not sure why I would want to refer anyone I like.