r/warcraftlore • u/Acrobatic-Eggplant97 • 3h ago
Discussion "And you are?": Political Schools of Thought among the Forsaken
I'm an older Warcraft fan who belongs to the wave of middle-aged nerds returning off the release of Forever, and enjoying the renewed interest and curiosity about how the lore and peoples of Azeroth actually work (with the experienced fan understanding that, really, most of the time, they simply do not).
I've spent a good deal of time just pondering the Forsaken, specifically, and what a people in their unique historical circumstances would think, debate, and try to prove amongst themselves and to the outside world. Being out of the scene for some time, I know that some of these questions or ideals have been explored or realized, and many of them are some vague machinations of the Jailer or what-have-you, so my perspective is very Vanilla/Forever-forward.
Are any of these schools of thought or internal arguments missing a big story development I forgot to consider? Are there any other real or extrapolated political terminologies that could apply to any, true to the Forsaken's comically severe and exacting personality? Any places where additional strands of politick could form and create schism?
On Dark Ladyism:
The central axiom of any and all Forsaken Thought involves Sylvanas Windrunner, she who died among, and then awoke, the People. Reverence, worship, and fealty towards The Dark Lady probably doesn't even register as a political question amongst the Forsaken, but merely an unalienable fact of their material and spiritual reality. Questions of free will and the Queen's Fiat probably go in endless circles such as:
"The Dark Lady is the wellspring from which all Forsaken actions flow, and therefore all that we do or say is, by default, by her assent and according to her will."
"Ah, but our very ability to question our free will evinces the presence of that free will, with which we can defy or even, heh, forsake the Dark Lady and her agenda."
"Pain is merely the body registering disagreement with the mind, but it does not mean the mind is not sovereign of the body and that the body does not act in the mind's ultimate interest."
"And of what mind do you speak? Certainly not the dead, inert, matter dripping out of your ears; but rather, the magical presence that both animates our form and our personality - given to us, in whole, by the Dark Lady, of course! Such is her benevolence and belief in us as a true, free, people!"
And so on.
I understand that many of these questions of Sylvanan Determinism vs Forsaken Free Will is explored primarily after Wrathgate, with Varimathras - a non-Forsaken with secret loyalties who helps drive policy and holds a position of authority over an organ of the Forsaken state - being an interesting wrinkle in the conundrum of fealty among the Magic Zombies and Their Zombie Messiah.
The schools of thought I find most interesting to consider, especially for player characters, are those that arise from the tensions between the Forsaken civilization's rather unique triple-blended identity.
The Forsaken as a continuity of Lordaeron: The Scourge was merely an Historical Force
Many Forsaken clearly identify as Lordaeronian. They live in Lordaeron, their political grammar largely mimics Lordaeron - replacing a Menethil with a Messiah - and much of their military objectives in the Eastern Kingdoms revolve around asserting or redefining the previous Lordaeronian jurisdiction over the land, with the Undercity replacing the Menethil Throne.
Lordaeron Continuists likely disagree over if the Forsaken Project is a revival of the old Lordaeronian identity or a reconstruction of a new Lordaeronian identity - regardless, they seem in agreement that this identity is not extended to the still-living humans on the Undercity's now-claimed (or always-possessed, depending on political outlook) territory.
A comically hard-line position amongst Lordaeron Continuists would be a sort of monarchist literalism which takes every public action of their lawful prince, Arthas Menethil, at face value. Specifically, a Forsaken could argue that Arthas's statement that he was "succeeding you, [King Terenas Menethil of Lordaeron]" was technically a proclamation made in open court regarding an upcoming royal vacancy and the hereditary line of succession. The Sack of Lordaeron which came from this, then, was merely the next step in a state-building agenda. That Prince Arthas (who does indeed declare himself King to Kel'Thuzad before assigning him stewardship of that Kingdom) then absconded to Northrend for reasons and duration unknown is of little matter: if and when the prince returns, legalism demands that he resume his position as monarch, and the Forsaken resume their position as Lordaeronians.
The Forsaken as a continuity of the Scourge: Lordaeron was merely an Historical Place
How the individual Forsaken think of themselves is one thing, but the fact of the matter is that they speak like the Scourge, look like the Scourge, have developed culture and war doctrines suitable for reanimated corpses of the Scourge, and many of their aesthetics are direct continuations from the Scourge.
Importantly, the Dark Lady was never and is not a Lordaeronian subject of the Menethil authority she now defacto inhabits. The Scourge, then, is seen as not only an annihilating force, but a uniting one, amongst Lordaeronians, Quel'Thelassians, and other fallen regional polities. All of these peoples were erased by the Scourge as many, but awoke as one in the Forsaken.
Recognizing this, even with the harshest qualifiers, is likely not at all a popular or well-received position within and without the Undercity. No one wants to say that they're the inheritors or breakaways of the Scourge state, and no one wants to ally with such a state. And yet, the Forsaken appear to be unable or unwilling to not live in spooky haunted houses with bubbling cauldrons of poison and skull edifices everywhere, or construct Abominations, or utilize plague-as-weapon, or continually and consistently draw a line between them and "the living".
Scourge Continuists may not all view their necromantic heritage as "evil", even. A strong argument could be made that the Forsaken are, indeed, a specific and unique people for whom undeath(s) is a complicated, but unambiguous, ethnogenesis. Some may argue that the proper lens to understand Forsaken personhood is not "person who was raised by death and continues to be that person", but rather "a new person raised from a mortal's death, indifferent to that mortal's life". One can debate the "good and evil" of necromancy all night, but this misses the more crucial debate of the fact that, good or evil, necromancy created a new person where one was not before, and this new person is permitted to define their existence as separate from whatever existed prior in their animated flesh and bones.
The Forsaken as a constituent of the Horde: Convenience, Client, or Comrade?
Even moreso than a magical dictator, undead immortality, and the bugbear of free will, I would say that the Forsaken's voluntary confederation into Thrall's Horde raises the most difficult political questions among them.
The general party line among players, early manuals, and in-game narration is "the Forsaken are uniquely independent among the Horde, and enjoy a certain degree of separation from them, and both Orgrimmar and Undercity understand it to be a coldly congenial alliance of political convenience and geographical strategy; oh, and the Forsaken are going to betray them." I understand that much of this is explored, validated, or challenged post-Wrathgate. I ultimately view the "convenience" reasoning to be a gameplay and lore design convenience itself, allowing questing zones and factions to be a little more distinctive from their segregation and siloing. Realistically, the alliance between the Horde and Forsaken is so bizarre (even moreso than the alliance between the Kal'dorei and the Alliance of Stormwind) that more nuanced and complex political opinions would inevitably emerge from both sides.
One extreme and, again, ridiculously hardliner position, would also have to benefit from a fact that I'm not sure is or will be spread amongst the Forsaken: that the Lich King was ultimately an intermediary local commander of the Burning Legion, and an Orc warlord of Draenor, besides (that he is captive and eventually rebels, of course, bears mentioning). If the Forsaken had access to this knowledge, it could be very convincingly argued that the Seduction of Arthas and the Scourge were in continuity with the Horde/Burning Legion's previous attempts to conquer Lordaeron. Their alliance to Orgrimmar, then, is not so much voluntary as it is a necessity compelled by the ravaged and vulnerable condition the Forsaken are left in due to the Scourge, due to the Lich King, due to the Horde or Burning Legion. Thrall's Horde, though it has wildly different objectives, asserts itself to be the successor of Doomhammer's Horde - essentially, the Horde has achieved its ancient war objectives in Lordaeron, with several extra magical and geographic steps inbetween. It would not at all be a popular idea, but it could be a cogent one, that Forsaken are viewed as clients or vassals to Orgrimmar by right of conquest, and their submission to the Dark Lady is secondary to their submission to the Warchief.
A friendlier position, and one that I think a lot of players drift towards, is a full or progressive embrace of the Horde as a faction of camaraderie amongst the Forsaken and their Kalimdor allies. Both the Orc and the Forsaken identity, after the Third War, are open to a variety of interpretations. Solidarity, for example, could emerge between the two, as both are the rebels or descendants of rebels of a Burning Legion slave army.
Both civilizations also represent a ravaged people (the Orcs are veterans and descendants of a military vanguard, not a tribe who prepared and developed a migratory culture; the Forsaken have no predictable tempo for the growth or specialization of their population's productivity, etc), and could find a useful synthesis, or bitter conflict, in attempting to join their economies and militaries to bolster one another. Horde Unionists could lobby for the Deathstalkers or the Royal Apothecary Society to integrate more strongly into the Horde's combined arms military; and in the same breath, they may have to audit troop deployments to minimize Second War Veterans being placed under certain Orc commanders, or vice versa. Brain drain and cultural exchanges between Tirisfal, Durotar, Mulgore, and Sen'jin could ameliorate or complicate these types of decisions, as well as the generally-assumed fealty of Forsaken towards Sylvanas.
On the other hand, increased awareness and discussion of both culture's complicated historical context could create awkward demands. Prisoners or descendants of prisoners of Orc Internment may make overtures at reparations from their former jailors; or Forsaken survivors (or risen non-survivors) of the Horde's own war crimes may make competing bids of Orgrimmar. In fact, one of the largest political projects of the Horde and Forsaken could be a years-long effort to craft and ratify a general Amnesty policy between the two, in order to progress as a confederacy.
And all of this is to say little of even more pressing political quandaries for the Forsaken, such as the economics and identity politics of immortality, itself, or the stacking and conflicting authorities among different Plagueland families and dynasties, or the Forsaken's separation from the living making them genocidaires or psychopomps, or The Perfidy of Hillsbrad, or the personhood of Ghouls, or The Cannibalism Question. What other political bugbears or nuances have you observed in the lore, in Forever's past and Retail's (to me) completely-incomprehensible present?