r/waterloo • u/friend_of_the_ion • 11h ago
A financially SANE alignment to save the Cambridge ION extension

Hi all,
Since ION stage 2 is de facto dead, I wanted to find an alignment (purple) that is financially sane. The core problem with the unfunded plan (in dashed red) is that it requires building a new bridge over the Grand river, a flyover of the 401, a new bridge over the Speed river, and then ripping up Hespeler Rd (a virtual landmine of buried utilities). All of this completely ballooned its cost to something unfundable, all to provide land uplift to big-box stores on Hespeler Rd that might be redeveloped within a generation.
The shown alignment (outside of downtown Galt) is either on low utilization/abandoned/deleted rail corridors (owned by CPKC, CN, or the city) or wide municipal country roads. The core advantages of this alignment can be summarized as:
- NO new bridge over the Grand river
- NO new bridge over the Speed river
- NO flyover of the 401
- DOES NOT rip up Hespeler Rd for an indeterminate period of time
- Requires essentially no expropriation
- All of which should make it dramatically cheaper than the present unfunded plan
- Has a massive dedicated right-of-way
- Provides redevelopment opportunities for commercial/light industrial property that was built around this rail corridor a century ago.
- Provides greenfield housing development opportunities next to a rapid transit line on Maple Grove Rd. Indulge your urbanist, walkable, transit-oriented fantasy today.
- Provides extensive station opportunities for connecting into existing residential neighbourhoods, providing the residents of Cambridge with land value uplift rather than big-box stores
- Puts hundreds of residential buildings within 200m of reasonably located stations
- Resurrects pieces of our industrial heritage
- Services major centres of employment: Freeport Hospital, Toyota and the 401 industrial park, Conestoga College's Reuter Drive campus, Cambridge Memorial Hospital, the UW School of Architecture, along with downtown Hespeler and Galt and comes pretty close to downtown Preston.
- Is directly setup for future GO integration (at Hespeler Rd north of 401) with platform to platform transfers
- Brings ION service to HESPELER, Preston and Galt, making it politically uncancellable
- LARGELY BUILDABLE WITHIN AN ELECTION CYCLE
A broad summary of my alignment is as follows:
- Fairway Station --> Highway 8 rail/Fairway Rd underpass
- The underpass is huge, at least 50' wide; no problem with achieving spatial separation.
- Highway 8 underpass --> Freeport rail bridge
- The Waterloo subdivision is not double stacked, used a few times a week at night, and thus can be shared ala the situation in uptown Waterloo)
- Potential Stops: King Street, River Road East, Freeport Hospital @ The Grand
- Freeport Rail bridge --> 401 Industrial park:
- This is mainly to avoid CPKC's very busy yard that services Toyota and because CPKC is not willing to share their 401 underpass. At least this is what I have gathered from the publicly available planning docs.
- Follow the rail spur until you hit the trail that is legally Boychuck Dr (yet to be paved). Follow it up to the paved Boychuck Dr and then meander through the industrial park to maximise station usefulness.
- Provides an opportunity to provide transit to the industrial park
- Potential Stops:
- Maple Grove Rd / Cherry Blossom Rd
- Cherry Blossom Rd / Saltsman Dr
- Conestoga College @ Blossom Rd / Fountain St N
- Toyota (the largest employer in the region)
- 401 Industrial park --> Hespeler via maple Grove drive/Fischer Mills
- Maple Grove Drive is a country road with overhead (not buried) utilities, with a massive city owned land footprint extending far beyond the road itself. Run the ION on the south side parallel to the road.
- Even though this stretch is long, the ION can cruise at its top speed (80 km/h) for a significant amount of time here. By my math, this stretch would take roughly 4 minutes.
- Following this road into Hespeler unlocks the Fergus spur. This spur provides a FREE bridge over the Speed river, a FREE underpass under Hespeler Rd, and a FREE underpass under the 401.
- The CN Fergus spur is essentially abandoned, a massive liability for CN, sees ~1 train a week, and CN seems to be looking to sell given what I can find in the news.
- Hespeler (the town) --> Hespeler Road/Fergus Spur
- Again, this section of the spur is essentially in complete disuse.
- FREE Speed river bridge
- FREE Hespeler Rd underpass
- This is the ideal location for a future "Cambridge 401 GO" (north-east of the Hespeler Rd underpass). Extending the ION through this underpass would allow for seamless platform to platform transfer between the ION and future GO service while pulling a meaningful number of cars off the 401 due to Hespeler Rd having a direct interchange.
- Future GO expansion might require double tracking and possibly replacing the bridge deck of the Fergus Spur Speed River Bridge
- Hespeler Road --> Eagle Street
- FREE 401 underpass
- Again, this track is essentially completely disused.
- Potential Stops: Eagle Street
- Eagle Street --> Concession Road via the Fergus Spur
- This section of track is totally abandoned and completely overgrown, and I believe is now owned by the City of Cambridge.
- I walked this section. It's completely overgrown, is being used as a free dump site and is nestled beyond the fences of this entire neighbourhood. Surprisingly, people have not extended their property lines on the corridor... yet.
- The right of way is HUGE. It's wide enough to fit double ION tracks and a walk/bike trail parallel to it, probably with room to spare and for most of the corridor the drainage situation is not that bad either.
- Potential Stops: Oakwood Ave/Durham Avenue (there is an existing cut through the corridor), Lawrence Street, Montrose Street N
- Concession Road --> Hespeler Road
- Massive, essentially completely separate right-of-way large enough for full spatial separation between ION and freight
- Potential Stops: Cambridge Memorial Hospital, Hespeler Rd (the geometry is weird here; see below)
- The Hespeler Road underpass
- This is genuinely a problem.
- The underpass itself could (by my measurements) support another track. But it would certainly require (afaik, for liability reasons) either temporal separation, which would impose a 10-minute delay twice a day or a crash barrier, which is expensive AF
- It might also be worth investigating assuming this liability from CPKC for derailments in this location.
- CPKC might be hesitant to give up expansion capability for their underpass under Hespeler road when this spur serves a customer as important as Toyota.
- Alternatively, one could have the ION hop the MSE walled embankment just north of the underpass, plop an intersection at Broklynne road, and then have it hop back down into the right of way. This probably requires bribing the car dealership and maybe a resident for their property. Nevertheless, this would be the only expropriation required to make this work.
- There are many ways to solve this specific bottleneck. Repurchase option, eventually replacing the overpass.
- Hespeler Road underpass to Samulson Street CPKC Mainline underpass
- Following the Hespeler Road underpass, the right of way is MASSIVE, nearly 50M. This used to be a totally separate competing railway. There is 0 problem with achieving the required spatial separation here.
- Potential Stops: Roxboro Rd, Samuelson Street
- Everything after is essentially a continuation of the existing unfunded plan. Follow Mill Creek Trail into downtown Galt and then start seriously considering what streets are going to be ripped up to make way. Personally, it seems like Valour Pl is the winner, as it allows a straight cut through parking lots to reach Water street and directly passes the bus terminal.
This is NOT a fantasy map paint. I literally wrote python code to check the POLARIS property line data to see if the corridor is wide enough for both the existing use and the ION. From what it has returned, verified against on the ground measurements/observations, everything seems to check out.
From the regions document that I have seen, no proposal investigated by the region ever considered blowing the ION all the way into Hespeler and hopping onto the Fergus Spur for essentially its entire length. There are bits and pieces of it, but the key features are completely ignored. My only explanation is that there was a mandate to service the mall on Hespeler Rd, and this didn’t fit that.
So please, I beg you, find my error.
I am sick of whining and opining about transit lines that never get built. The existing plan is unfunded and is never going to happen. This proposed alignment has a large number of advantages and might actually have a shot at being funded.
I am working on a more thorough map that shows a number of extra pieces of information, including:
- Measured corridor widths, from distances I measured, through the bottlenecks of: Freeport bridge, Speed River bridge, Hespeler Rd underpass (north of 401), 401 underpass, Hespeler Rd underpass (in Galt)
- Estimated travel times between the proposed stations, under presumably a traction limit --> power limit --> cruise --> normal deceleration regime, or honestly with whatever info I can find on the vehicles
- A nicer-looking and online interactive map
If you're interested in seeing more of this route (I have a ton of pictures and measurements) or just want to talk about ION expansion generally, I am giving a 5 minute lightning talk on this alignment at UW's GIS Day this Thursday at ~3:30PM in EV2 2002.