r/whatsthatbook • • Jun 14 '23

SOLVED Updated rules post

381 Upvotes

Hi everyone, there have been some rule changes since the last post, so here is an updated post. I have taken the section about helpful points to consider when writing a post from the last rules post, with some minor edits.

PLEASE FOLLOW THE RULES.

  1. Post titles must have at least one book detail.
  2. Solved posts should be marked as solved. You can flair your own post as solved by commenting "solved solved solved" on the post. If you see someone else's post is not flaired as solved, you can report it and a moderator will flair it.
  3. A post cannot have more than one book/series. To clarify, multiple books from the same series are allowed to be in the same post. Multiple short stories from the same book are also allowed in the same post. If they're not part of the same book or series, they must be in separate posts.
  4. Posts should be on topic. Posts must be looking for a specific book/series/story that you want to find. Posts looking for general reading suggestions, links to read books you already know the title and author of, or general unrelated content will be removed.
  5. Do not offer money/favors to solve posts. You're welcome to gild or otherwise award a comment after your post is solved, but you can't offer it before the post is solved.
  6. Be respectful.
  7. Always check AI-generated answers against another source before submitting them. We strongly prefer that users avoid AI answers in general, as they almost always match a description to an unrelated or nonexistent title.

Please consider these points when writing your /r/whatsthatbook post:

Your Post Title

Briefly the book, not your situation. Avoid titles like "Help, I can't remember this book..." or "I read this when I was a kid..." or "I NEED HELP"

Include the overall genre of the book in your post title, such as "romance novel" or "scifi"

Posts with vague titles will be removed. The general age range the book is meant for and year are not specific enough on their own. For example, we will remove a post titled "Children's book from 2000s." We will not remove a post titled "Children's sci-fi novel from 2000s." We prefer titles like "Children's sci-fi novel from 2000s about kid whose cousin invents a new telescope and discovers aliens."

The Book

Fiction or non-fiction?

Describe the plot.

Describe notable characters.

What genre is it?

Physically describe the book -- Hardcover/paperback? Book cover color?

When was it set?

How long was the book?

Anything notable about the original language? Did you read it English? If not, what language?

... And You

When (what year) did you read it?

How old were you when you read it? Was it age appropriate?

Where did you get the book? School library, book fair, book store selling new and/or used books, flea market, borrowed from a friend, given as a gift from X person who is about Y age, or from an online store?

Was it new when you read it?

What age range was it for?

Other notes:

We allow posts about short stories, poems, fanfiction, etc. on this subreddit.

If you want to post a picture of a page you found, upload it to imgur and put the link in a post. Please include at least one detail about the events or characters on the page in your title.


r/whatsthatbook • • 2h ago

SOLVED Need help finding time travel story

5 Upvotes

It’s a short story set in the 1800s about a writer (who I forget the name of) that makes a deal with the devil to travel 100 years into the future of some specific date and time in 1997 to the British library, and finds that the only mention of him is in his own story where he’s a fictional character.

I saw a video about the real life prank where somebody recreated it down to the exact time, but I can’t find the video anywhere! Please help me!!!


r/whatsthatbook • • 1h ago

UNSOLVED Romance book my roomate listend to around 2018

• Upvotes

So my roomate started telling me about this book she listened to when she was younger on audible and she swears its real but we both cannot find anything on it. But it was this vampire romace where the male lead was Scottish and was a vampire (apparently alwasy wore kilts), and the female lead was some kind of shifter (she remebers the FL being a feline of some kind with the ML calling her kitty a lot) What she remebers of the setting was that at one point they were in a cave, it was a secret cave that no one was supposed to know about but she brings the vampire man to it anyways. Then theres a pool in said cave (maybe a bed not sure??) Then the woman takes a bath in the pool cause she got in an argument with the scott and then he follows her in and starts making out??. And theres this whole scene about her having on a collar since birth that he takes off of her while making out, to which she could not put it back on. Its not good for her to be with a vampire cause apparently shes some kind of royalty. When they try to leave the cave they find one of the girls haindmaidens(??) walks in, sees the scott with the collar in his hands and then says something like "hello my king" and the girl is like "nuh-uh" and he didnt realize taking her collar off meant he had to marry her. Also the opening scene is about this man going to a highland castle and his friend sees him at the gate and the friend goes "Hay i dont need ID i can recognise that kilt from a mile away" She does not have a reddit account and begged me to make this post, please help me end this suffering of hearing about this book. She swears it exists.


r/whatsthatbook • • 8h ago

UNSOLVED YA gritty fantasy novel from about 2010 - 2015 with a magic system/magic lore

8 Upvotes

When I was a teenager, I was in a local book club and we read a book that I've now become obsessed with finding it almost ten years later. Here are the things I (think) remember about it:

  • The setting was NOT in a formal magic school. It was more like in the woods or travelling around
  • There was a mentor-mentee relationship with an older "hunter" or someone cataloging things in their forest/on their travels
  • I think the protagonist was a boy, but I could always be wrong
  • I remember there being journal entries with small illustrations or a glossary of some kind to lend to it's magic system/lore
  • It was the first entry in a series, but I don't think the series was popular and it was the only entry at the time
  • The cover was one of those typical dark fantasy covers with brown and/or black tones and a genre-typical title (Ash something or Bone something or Shadow something)

I'd say it was something like "Jinx" by Sage Blackwood, but I don't think "Jinx" had any illustrations? At least, the copy I found online didn't have anything like that.

Thnx in advance!


r/whatsthatbook • • 2h ago

SOLVED Y2K style YA book with a new girl becoming friends with MC

3 Upvotes

I've been trying to figure out what book this is for a while. I read it from a Little Library around 2015 and promptly put it back.
It's about a girl, probably around 13, who has been the popular girl forever in her small town. She has a guy friend who plays basketball with her, and they have a pact to basically "break the rule" that girls and guys always fall in love with each other.
A new girl arrives, and MC is immediately impressed with how cool she is. She seems so mature, she dresses more revealing, and she wears bold makeup.
The MC becomes friends with her, and starts to become influenced by her edgy behaviors. MC starts dating a much older guy who's part of the new girl's circle, and texts him often. These events lead her to feel further and further from her mom, and she doesn't tell her mom the first time she gets her period.
The climax is when the new girl invites the MC to a party with the guy she's been talking to, and MC realizes he's been playing her all along and he talks to a lot of girls, and tries to get the MC drunk. The new girl abandons the MC during the party and kisses a strange guy. I think what happens is either her brother or the guy friend gets her out of the party by calling her family.
Afterwards, the new girl doesn't come back to school for a while, and when the MC goes to her house to check, she finds out that the new girl doesn't have a great living situation. The two girls get into a big fight.
At the end of the book, the two girls make up, MC and the guy friend kiss, and there was a specific memorable line about MC feeling happy because she told her mom about getting her period and their periods synced.


r/whatsthatbook • • 4h ago

UNSOLVED Looking for a 1950s–1960s children's book about a little girl who damages a doll

3 Upvotes

I've been trying to identify a childhood book for about 15 years, with no luck. I'm hoping someone here might recognize it!

I read the book in the late 1960s, so I'm guessing it was published sometime in the 1950s or 1960s, possibly earlier.

Here's what I remember:

  • The main character was a little girl with messy, dark, chin-length hair. I think she wore overalls, possibly with one strap hanging loose.
  • She had a doll that she treated very roughly, dragging it around by one leg, sometimes upside down.
  • As the story progressed, the doll became increasingly battered. I remember it losing an eye and much of its hair.
  • One particularly vivid memory is of the little girl standing at the doorway of a house, looking ashamed, with the damaged doll. A tall, nicely dressed woman was leaning out of the doorway, talking to her.
  • There may have been another little girl, much neater and more traditionally dressed. It's possible the doll belonged to this girl and had been borrowed, but I'm not confident about that detail.

I also remember the illustrations being very simple, possibly black and white with one additional color. There was lots of white space on the pages and relatively little text. I think it was a hardcover book, but I wouldn't rely too heavily on my memory of the cover.

The overall feeling I remember is that the little girl had been careless with something precious and was ashamed of what she'd done.

One book I can definitively rule out is Tomboy's Doll by Charlotte Steiner (1969). I actually purchased a copy recently, thinking I'd finally solved the mystery, but it's not the book I remember.

I realize childhood memories can be unreliable, especially after nearly sixty years, so some of these details may be inaccurate.

Does any of this sound familiar to anyone? I'd be thrilled to finally put a title to this book!


r/whatsthatbook • • 6h ago

UNSOLVED A children's illustrated story of Jesus with a scary Mary Magdalene/prostitute scene?

5 Upvotes

That's it that's the post!

Jk. They were big, half- to full-page illustrations. I particularly remember the woman being exorcised (Mary M or another woman depending, idr). It was kinda scary She was, like, green and wet and staring right at the viewer. I remember nothing else, sorry.


r/whatsthatbook • • 12h ago

UNSOLVED SciFi story/short story from 1996 or earlier

10 Upvotes

I am trying to find the name of a science fiction story I read as a kid that keeps popping into my head in the decades since. This had found its way into my middle school library where it had absolutely no business being. I am fairly certain it was a short story in an anthology. I read it in '95-'96 but it very well could have been from before then. It had a very pulpy feel to it that could have been 90s or even 60s/70s.

From what I remember, the story was about a village that had a somewhat utopian but primitive feel to it. The village was structured around houses, each consisting of a man and a woman, who were lovers to each other. Everyone in the village was in their physical/sexual prime. The thing that sticks out to me the most is that each household had a statue of a letter of the alphabet in it, and these letters were alive. My memory has an almost Muppet-like description of them, where they had eyes and could speak, like something straight out of Sesame Street (I think the protagonist was in a house where T was the letter). The village was peaceful, harmonious, and the letters had a spiritual/totemic place in each household.

The twist was that the village was some sort of science/social experiment done by an authoritarian dystopian government, and the protagonist was a member of the team of scientists who was supposed to infiltrate the village or serve as a control variable, but became so overwhelmed with his identity as a villager that he forgot who he was. I seem to remember a scene where he is extracted from the village, and it is revealed that a lot of what he perceived in the village was illusory or some sort of psychic construct. The people, for example, were decidedly NOT all hot and in their early 20s, and I think some of them were actually children which adds a whole layer of grossness to the story which I'm just now starting to unpack.

From what I recall, the story concludes when the experiment comes to an end, the villagers resist the scientists/government, and flee as the village is attacked. The protagonist chooses to remain part of the village community and embrace the hallucination/spell/whatever-it-is that alters their perceived reality. I'm not sure exactly how it ends but I believe it's left ambiguous.

This is an obscure one, for sure. This story has been a splinter in my mind for thirty years now and if I can just figure out what it's called it will stop bugging me.


r/whatsthatbook • • 3h ago

UNSOLVED Trying to identify a pre-1992 science-fiction novel about a boy whose parents are secretly aliens, with a father obsessed with barbecuing

2 Upvotes

I’m trying to identify a science-fiction novel I borrowed from a public library in Illinois sometime before 1992, probably during the 1980s.
I remember it being a very thick, standalone hardcover, possibly 600–800 pages or longer, although the page count could be inaccurate.

What I remember about the story:

  • The protagonist is a boy growing up on Earth, attending school and living in an apparently ordinary American community.
  • Both his parents look human but are actually extraterrestrials.
  • The boy is also an alien, but he doesn’t discover his true origins until later in the story.
  • His parents are trying to fit into human society but are noticeably eccentric and don’t quite succeed.
  • His father is particularly obsessed with backyard barbecuing and grilling meat. I remember this as a recurring detail.
  • The family appears to be hiding from someone or something.
  • The boy has a close male friend and a close female friend.
  • I vaguely remember a plot point involving the boy looking into a mirror and seeing his face turn green or purple.
  • Another plot point involves the female friend falling under some kind of love spell.
  • The story has humorous moments, although I don’t remember whether it was primarily comedic.

What I remember about the book itself:

It was a thick hardcover, possibly intended for adults or teenagers. I remember a predominantly black dust jacket featuring a realistic illustration of a boy’s face and shoulders, viewed from the front, looking upward toward the sky. His face appeared illuminated by a light from above.
The title might have begun with “Alien” or another word starting with A. Alternatively, the author’s name may have begun with A. The protagonist’s name might have been Alan or Allen, but I’m much less certain about these details.
I’ve already ruled out numerous books, including Halfway Across the Galaxy and Turn Left, Aliens in the Family, Alan Mendelsohn, the Boy from Mars, Intervention, Chocky, and The Dark Side of Nowhere (which was published too late).

The detail I remember most distinctly is the alien father being obsessed with barbecuing while the parents unsuccessfully attempt to behave like ordinary humans.

Does anyone recognize this novel, especially readers familiar with obscure or out-of-print science fiction from the 1960s through the 1980s?


r/whatsthatbook • • 12h ago

UNSOLVED Young Adult LOTR ripoff series in late 70s early 80s

9 Upvotes

I’m trying to remember a fantasy book series that I read in 6th grade or so. The cover and baby blue of the paperback reminds me of Stephen R. Donaldson’s The One Tree but I don’t think that was it. I think it would have been a kid or teen friendly lord of the rings ripoff. I think there was a white-bearded wizard on the baby blue cover and it was typical tropes of a group coming together to overcome some challenge.. I’m guessing it would have been about 1980 give or take a couple of years and I probably bought it in a school bookmobile in Tennessee. Any ideas what that series might be? I think if I see the cover it would shake a lot of memories loose.


r/whatsthatbook • • 3h ago

UNSOLVED I read this paperback horror in the 90s with a young girl whose body was stolen and then she started body hopping.

2 Upvotes

I think an old lady switched bodies with her and the there was a car accident and the old lady (with the young girl’s spirit) was dying and she made eye contact with and switched bodies with someone she knew … maybe her aunt? And she said going into her body felt like a comfortable pair of jeans.


r/whatsthatbook • • 19m ago

UNSOLVED Thick trade paperback anthology/bind-up (pre-2013): lab/virus blizzard thriller with some romance/steam + small-town single mom romance

• Upvotes

I’m trying to find the name of a thick trade paperback collection (containing about 3 stories by different authors) that I picked up from a dentist's office free-book bin between August 2013 and August 2019. It had a modern writing style (likely published in the 2000s or early 2010s) and seemed like a multi-author publisher sampler/bind-up (similar to Harlequin/MIRA 3-in-1s or a Reader's Digest volume).
Physical details:

  • Thick trade paperback (not a small pocket mass-market paperback)
  • Each story had its own title page with the title and author, plus its own table of contents page before the story started
  • Mixed genres and mixed steam levels across the stories

Story 1 (the one I remember best – Romantic Suspense/Thriller):

  • Tone: Somewhat steamy, fast-paced, modern writing style.
  • Plot: The heroine (no kids) works at a research lab. Something—possibly virus- or genetics-related—is stolen from the lab. Because of the danger and a bad blizzard, she ends up hiding out in a remote cabin. A handsome stranger also ends up in the cabin with her; she isn't sure at first if she can trust him, though they eventually get romantically involved while hiding from the bad guys who stole from the lab. (Similar vibe to Whiteout by Adriana Anders, though published before August 2013).

Other stories in the same book:

  • Story 2 (Contemporary / Women's Fiction): Much sweeter/cleaner tone. About a single mom in a small town who finds love a second time, builds friendships, and "finds herself."

r/whatsthatbook • • 4h ago

UNSOLVED Looking for a fantasy book i read around 2010

2 Upvotes

I dont remember much about what the book is about. What i do remember is the cover having 2 dragons on it one red and one blue flying like down towards the ground with a tower in between both of them. I read it around 2010/2011 in my school library and i remeber thinking it looked like lord of the rings/eragon type of book. I also remember that it had a male dwarf and a female elf traveling together with maybe a human but i cant be sure.


r/whatsthatbook • • 8h ago

UNSOLVED Novel read in early 2000s, letters between grandmother and granddaughter

4 Upvotes

I have done many searches to try to solve this one with no luck - I believe I read this book around 2006-2008, and it was a fiction novel written as letters and journals between a grandmother, granddaughter, and later a grandson as well. The granddaughter was late teen age and pregnant, and left home to live with her boyfriend in a cabin he built off grid. The granddaughter's boyfriend was abusive and alcoholic, and the granddaughter was trying to save him through love. The granddaughter's brother was the only family member she was not alienated from, so he would still visit his sister in the cabin. The grandmother stayed in touch via letters because she lived some distance away. Eventually the granddaughter is killed by the abusive partner. I believe the setting was somewhere cold and mountainous, maybe northwest US?


r/whatsthatbook • • 11h ago

UNSOLVED witch flying with nilla wafers?

7 Upvotes

So, when I was maybe 5? I really loved this book, from my recollection, there was a witch making Nilla wafers(or something shaped like it) the witch was flying, I remember a tree and I KNOW i was not imagining Nilla wafers because I remember wanting to pick them out of the book because of how foreign they looked and they looked tasty. I think there were children in the book, I don't quite recall much, the witch had a black hat? some parts may be wrong due to memory fog, but if anything sounds familiar to you let me know, I asked my siblings multiple times if they ever heard something like this they said no so now i'm turning to the internet.

also its not: "Old Witch and the Polka-Dot Ribbon" I already checked out that book the one i'm referencing maybe had the same art style or a similar one?


r/whatsthatbook • • 11h ago

UNSOLVED I am trying to remember an older science fiction novel about a tribe of peace people or monkeys that are peaceful and at the end the narrator cynically worries they will be expointed to use their genetics to create peace bombs. I think I read this in the 70s but not sure of publication date.

5 Upvotes

Thanks for any help you can provide in my search.


r/whatsthatbook • • 10h ago

UNSOLVED Early 1900s romance novel

6 Upvotes

Strange one: my grandmother's middle name comes from a book that my great grandma read while pregnant with her...I'm trying to find the book. It was published before the spring of 1920, in English, and was available in America. It was probably a romance, but certainly nonfiction. One of the lead characters was named "Verl" (Verla, Verle, and Veryl as possible alternatives). Any leads on where to start?


r/whatsthatbook • • 10h ago

UNSOLVED [90s-00s] Sci-fi, time travel, meant for teens, multi-part series?

5 Upvotes

I just had this random memory of a book I read years ago and would like to find again. To my understanding it was a sequel to a book dealing much heavier in time travel and world saving, but this one was arguably much more down to earth.

There was a young man, possibly teenager, who had a future pistol tucked in a box under his bed from a previous adventure with tie travel. He is sick and getting sicker but no doctors can figure out what is wrong with him.

One day he is visited by someone claiming to be from the future, where problems have arisen once more. He promises to give the young man the antidote/cure to his affliction, some disease or sickness that he caught while messing with time travel, but only after helping him with some current time issues.

Spoiler for the ending: People / detectives from the future with the young man’s actual interests at heart come and tell him the other time traveler is a grifter looking to steal valuable artifacts from the past. Also that his sickness is coming from the pistol, which is drawing from his life force because its power cell is depleted and it has no other energy source nearby.

There were characters and events mentioned that made it seem like at least a second part in a series, but I’m not too sure. Any help is appreciated!


r/whatsthatbook • • 10h ago

UNSOLVED I am desperately searching for an African book about an elephant

5 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. I trust you're doing well. For some months now i have been searching for an african book about a mother elephant or hippo who had a child it was a boy buh it wasn't a hippo or elephant like her. the beginning of the story was her washing him and dressing him up for an outing i believe they might have been going to the village plaza, the monkey loved playing the saxaphone too at some point she forgot she placed him on her head and throughout the story she was frantically looking for him and asking the village ppl about his whereabouts. At the end, she finds him on her head and scolds him, but the village ppl laughed it off, and on the final page they were all dancing, and he called his mother "sax-y" as a play on words for saxophone and sexy. Thank you very much for reading all the way through. I really hope someone would be able to find this book. A very important detail is that i read this in south africa the book was definitely made before 2014-2016. Thank you all very much =.


r/whatsthatbook • • 6h ago

UNSOLVED Cyber warfare involves trains and teens

2 Upvotes

I dont remember much from this outside of a specific scene.

The character is seperated from their team/friends on a futuristic light train. They get distracted by a cup of water gently shaking (kind of like Jurassic park) when it hits them that that should never happen on a light train. The trains are designed to be a perfectly smooth ride no matter what. This tips them off that the (evil robit ai?) is launching a cyber attack on the train.

Im pretty sure this was pre 2010 as I had read it in middle school. I'm not sure if it was targeted at that age group, but the protagonists were young teens.

This one has been bugging me for a long time.


r/whatsthatbook • • 2h ago

UNSOLVED Book with scary/ghost stories that had illustrations, in particular one of a pillow with a mouth full of sharp teeth

1 Upvotes

I remember reading the book with my siblings when I was a kid in the mid-80s. There were several scary stories but the image of the pillow is what stands out in my memory the most.


r/whatsthatbook • • 2h ago

UNSOLVED Please Help me find this red hardback book of horror stories

1 Upvotes

There is a book that scarred me when I was around 5 or 6. I found it in either 2011 or 2012, I remember it was a hardback book. I wanna say the cover was red, it was a book of short horror stories illustrated in black and red ink. The image that stuck with me the most was from a single page, a pale severed hand in a windowsill dripping with blood. I couldn't even read the book, my bullies forced me to look at the pictures because they knew it scared me. The book was fairly thick as well.

I just want to see the thing that traumatized me or at least know what it came from because it's driving me crazy that memory is so vivid but to no avail in my own research.


r/whatsthatbook • • 6h ago

UNSOLVED Fantasy sci-fi, a space western of sorts

2 Upvotes

I’m looking for a book I read that was way above my reading level when I read it at 11.

It was written for a grown audience, the main character is a grown man. To my memory, he ends up on an alien planet and falls in love with a local woman.

Think, dances with wolves/ Avatar-esque situation.

The cover was a burnt red, with a yellow-y orange desert depicted on it.

I think of this story so often, something about it interested me even though I didn’t really “get” it. I wonder if it even holds up, or if I’d hate it.

Edit: probably post 1960’s; the writing was contemporary to my memory.


r/whatsthatbook • • 7h ago

UNSOLVED Book read in the 1970’s. A prosecutor witnesses an accidental drowning, fails to intervene, and ends up successfully prosecuting the victim’s innocent boyfriend for killing her.

2 Upvotes

Title: Unknown. Psychological crime novel about a French prosecutor who witnesses an accidental drowning, fails to intervene, and prosecutes the victim's innocent boyfriend

Body:
I am trying to identify a standalone psychological thriller/crime novel I read in the 1970s (likely translated from French, or set in France).

Plot Summary:

  • The Witness: The story is told closely from the perspective of a French prosecutor, giving the reader full access to his inner thoughts. Early in the book, he is relaxing in a riverside park, feeling very drowsy and content, with his girlfriend asleep with her head in his lap.
  • The Accident: A young couple riding bicycles along the river stops nearby and has a brief argument. The young man rides off alone. Moments later, the young woman accidentally tumbles into the river and drowns.
  • The Inaction: The prosecutor sees this happen and realizes he should try to save her, but he cannot—or will not—rouse himself to intervene. Afterward, he decides not to report what he saw because he knows it will reflect terribly on him professionally and socially when people realize he was right there and made no effort to help.
  • The Trial: When the woman's body is found, she turns out to be the daughter of a prominent, powerful person. Based on circumstantial evidence from their argument, her male companion is charged with murdering her, and our protagonist is assigned to prosecute the case.
  • The Rationalization & Ending: Knowing the young man is completely innocent, the prosecutor is initially reluctant, realizing he cannot admit he was at the river without ruining himself. Over the course of the novel, the reader watches him rationalize away every moral objection until he throws himself into winning the case. He successfully convicts the innocent man, is lauded as a hero, and receives major career praise—having thoroughly convinced himself by the end that he acted nobly and deserves his success.

Does anyone recognize this novel or its author?


r/whatsthatbook • • 3h ago

UNSOLVED YA Fiction Graphic Novel Series Read Around 2007-2014

1 Upvotes

I don't really remember the plot, I do remember the artwork and it was black and white line work for the most part.

The first book is essentially the main character finding out magic and monsters are real. I believe she's a regular human girl and just so happened to stumble upon the magic world. She was not a "chosen one" She was actually kinda grumpy at times.

I specifically remember one part where she was sick and didn't even leave her room for about 3(?) days. Her parents didn't come to check on her and she comes out thinking they must be worried just to see herself at the kitchen table. Turns out a changeling (imp?) took her place. Went to school and everything. Parents didn't even notice. She confronted this other "her" and it had this weird smile, like sharp teeth. I'm pretty sure she beat it up without a sign of remorse. Later in the same book we find out that the replacement was essentially draining her and that's why she was sick to begin with. I think she has a "sidekick" but IDK if it was

It was a comic/graphic novel that I read from my school library but I can't remember exactly when I read it unfortunately, I can only narrow down when I could've read it.

I know it's not a lot to go off, and the series was never that popular, at least where I'm from. But I did enjoy it and it was fun to read a magic book where the main character wasn't an odd one out for not having powers, or the chosen one. It showed her learning about the magic world but also showed her life in the human world.