I know I'm probably going to get crucified for this, but I always felt like RPG fans can be incredibly unrealistic and defensive when it comes to their choices in previous games. They expect the studio to somehow write the story of the new game in a way that satisfies their respective choices, but that never leads anywhere impactful and said choices are almost always present as easter eggs or unimportant details.
For me, Letho is the best example that comes to mind, because despite being a Viper School Witcher (aka the Witcher school that knows the most about the Wild Hunt), he's reduced to what's essentially an extra in the backround with barely any interactions with other characters, not to mention, the quest he appears in if you spared his life doesn't even make sense with his characterization, because it makes him look naive and stupid. What does Yen have to say about him coming back after he took care of her? Dunno. How does Letho feel about finally fulfilling his purpose to fight the Hunt? No idea. Letho could've and should've been integral or at least important to the plot of Witcher 3 in a way, but we can't have that because some people killed him, so he's just an extra.
Witcher 3 has some of the biggest, land altering consequences in the entire franchise. Meaning the Northern Realms are either still full of witch hunters, occupied by Nilfgaard or ruled by Dijkstra. I personally don't want these three characters to be reduced to extras or small easter eggs in the future. I know we're going to Kovir, but the situation in the North has to be adressed in some form and I don't mean like 3 lines of dialogue that are there for spice, because that's just not realistic. Information about who rules the Northern Realms would be CRITICAL in times like these. NPCs would talk about it non-stop.
That is not even considering the main endings, which means Ciri can either be a Witcher, missing or she tried being Empress for a while and Geralt can be dead or incredibly depressed and have a very strained relationship with his daughter. These are not things that can be adressed in 3 or 5 or even 20 lines of dialogue. These are plotpoints that you can write an entire game around and deserve more than being half-assed. By trying to please everyone, CDPR will squander the potential of big plot points. Just pick the options that are best for the story and write the game around that.