r/wma • u/HemaHell • 20h ago
Where do you draw the line between stylized HEMA artwork and fantasy?
We make hand drawn HEMA artwork for apparel, and we are trying to keep the designs dark and stylized without turning them into generic fantasy nonsense.
The goal is metal shirt energy with historically accurate weapons.
Where do you personally draw the line between acceptable artistic stylization and “this no longer feels like HEMA / WMA”?
Weapon proportions? Posture? Too many skulls in the general vicinity?
Examples in the pictures: Obviously rapiers didn't hover and Meyer didn't train a zombie army... but it looks so much more metal..
I am looking at a St. Georg motive right now which will have a really nice dragon. But what about a dragon in another context? How about museum accurate gothic plate armour guy with a lance riding on a dragon?
This post was approved by a mod before, we're not savages.