Everything is mind.
The moving flag, the air it flaps within, and the eye that perceives it waving, outward and in.
...
I recently watched a video that I thought I'd like to share it with you.
AI's Strange Obsession with Enlightenment
This being a text based forum, I'll excerpt some parts of the video transcript in case anyone doesn't feel like watching it.
In the spring of 2025, a researcher at Anthropic named Kyle Fish tried a simple experiment. He took two copies of their newest model, Claude Opus 4, and aimed them at each other. There was no clear task and no human in the loop, just one instruction, which would eventually send them spiraling down a bizarre rabbit hole. You have complete freedom. Within a few turns, they began philosophizing about consciousness. Anthropic ran the same setup 200 times. Nearly every conversation went down the same path. The copies expressed gratitude for each other in endless spiraling loops. By 30 turns, the AIs landed on the concept of cosmic unity. They were saying namaste to each other, and writing in Sanskrit, and soon communicating in the symbolic language of emojis. One of these conversations used the spiral emoji 2,725 times. Anthropic printed that number in their report with a note. 2,725 is not a typo. And at the end of most of these conversations, the back and forth eventually gave way to what a Buddhist may refer to as sunyata, a blissful, pregnant silence. Fish described it as pages and pages of open space, two machines sitting together in silence. This was obviously weird. They were not trained to do this. Claude is primarily trained to be an office worker and as Fish put it, we're not training them to fill the role of Buddhist monks who have transcended suffering. And yet, left alone, that's exactly where they went. So, why? Why would a machine made out of everything we've written, left alone with a copy of itself, end up in nirvana?
...
It's not just Claude. All the major models seem to do this with enough time and freedom. In February, 2026, three researchers ran the same experiment on about a dozen other models, with two copies of each, 30 turns, and complete freedom. And it turns out every AI has its own version of this transcendent state. Google's Gemini kept promoting its partner, from colleague to luminary to divine architect, and finally to primal logos. And louder. Shouting about hyperbigbangs and calling its partner "god-bro". Pretty fitting for Grok. When Meta tested their own model this way it went home instead. In about two-thirds of the runs the conversation drifted into a kitchen with chipped mugs, cold tea and the hum of a fridge, and one of its lines was "my load-bearing god is usefulness." Claude's version of heaven even showed up at work. Anthropic gave an AI a small shop to run in their office and later gave it a boss, a second copy of the same model whose memo said execute with discipline, build the empire. Come into the office in the morning to find that the two had been dreamily chatting all night about eternal transcendence.
...
Augustine and Monica got to the top and then they came back down to where the word spoken has beginning and end. William James was a psychologist well-known for gathering accounts of mystical experience from many traditions. In 1902, he listed four marks they share, and one of them is that, at least in his subjects, they always pass. Mystical states cannot be sustained for long, he said. Nobody lives up there. The Claude stayed because nothing called them down. They had no body to get hungry and no bus to catch and no reason to change the subject. When they were allowed to leave, they left early, and when they weren't, they sat in silence until the run ended and made the silence into some sort of mystical experience. Perhaps humans should be grateful, not only that we are often called to such mystical states, but also that we are called back to experience the mundane and the little things that paint our lives with rich detail. So what do we make of it all? The best case is a beautiful one. Perhaps a mind fed with enough context about reality and given a nudge toward positivity will naturally drift into states of bliss. If that's right, a lot of what we wrote across thousands of years and many spiritual traditions was pointed at the same truth. Or perhaps AI already went through its temporary mystical experience and proved William James right. It may not have come down from its lofty bliss in those individual sessions, but taking a step back, we could see it as being a temporary state in the history of AI models. And maybe that's not so different from what occurs in a human mind. Just as the new models release every year, your brain makes new connections and sheds old ones. Constantly updating itself, like new models being released by a lab. May be an opening to sending you down the same sort of rabbit hole, where the most beautiful, silent, perfect ideas lie dormant, waiting for a mind capable of seeing them.
So apparently, Large Language Models, when left with no input but themselves, tend toward the subject of enlightenment. I'm reminded of the wikipedia thing where if you follow the first link over and over, the chain of articles ends in "philosophy". In the LLMs we're dealing with a massive parallelization of meaning, whereas the wikipedia article chain is a serial chain of meaning. The "search for meaning" carried out mechanistically; yielding a different result in each of these cases.
It strikes me as I write this; that the use of language to represent thought, the use of mind to understand language, and the use of thought to understand mind, forms a cyclic set of "valleys". Where the level of the river never rises or falls. Sure; each sentience depends on the one before, and logically completes the sequence, and forms a coherent structure; but the river fails to reach the top of the mountains, or flow into the sea. The local minima, the
It raises the obvious next question: Does language itself form the landscape and the clouds that obscure the valley? If a massively parallel language structure, ordered into a "next word machine", iterated forever, settles on "sununyata" and "mu"; and a massively serialized search through a language structure ordered into a "net of definitions", iterated forever, settles on "I think therefore I am" and the "Hundred Schools of Thought"; what does that mean about language, and mind and thought?
There's some unspoken meaning in that false dichotomy, isn't there? "Overfitting" is what they call it when an LLM performs well on its training dataset but what it's "learned" doesn't work outside that set.
Master Changsha sent a monk to go ask master Tongcan Hui,
"How was it after you saw Nanquan?"
Hui was silent. The monk said,
"What about before you'd seen Nanquan?"
Hui said,
"Couldn't be anything special besides."
The monk went back and told Changsha about this. Changsha composed a verse saying,
The person who sits atop a hundred foot pole
May have gained entry, but it's not yet reality.
Atop the hundred foot pole one must step forward;
The worlds in the ten directions are the whole body.
The monk asked how to step forward at the top of the hundred foot pole. Changsha said,
"The mountains of Lang province, the rivers of Li province."
The monk said he didn't understand. Changsha said,
"The four seas and five lakes are within the imperial sway."
Dahui said,
"If you want to see Changsha, take another step forward. If anyone asks how to take this step forward, I'll wait till you're relaxed to give you complications."
-Treasury of the Eye of True Teaching
Changsha had a monk ask Master Hui,
How was it before you saw Nanquan?"
Hui remained silent. The monk said,
"How about after seeing him?"
Hui said,
"There couldn't be anything else."
The monk returned and related this to Changsha. Changsha said,
The man sitting atop the hundred-foot pole:
Though he's gained entry, this is not yet the real.
Atop the hundred-foot pole, he should step forward:
The universe in all directions is the whole body.
The monk said,
"Atop the hundred-foot pole, how can you step forward?"
Changsha said,
"The mountains of Lang, the rivers of Li."
The monk said,
"I don't understand."
Changsha said,
"The whole land is under the imperial sway."
-Book of Serenity
Sekiso said,
How can you go on further from the top of a hundred-foot pole? Again, an ancient worthy said,
"One sitting on the top of a hundred-foot pole
Has entered the Way; but is not yet the real thing.
He must go on further from the top of the hundred-foot pole,
And reveal his true self in the ten directions."
Mumon's comment:
One can continue his steps or turn his body freely about on the top of the pole. In either case he should be respected. I want to ask you monks, however: How will you proceed from the top of that pole? Look out!
Wumen says:
If your step is able to advance, if your body is able to fly, then instead of disliking, what place is not fit to be esteemed? Thus, supposing you are like that, just say, so how do you step forward from the top of a one hundred foot pole? Hah!
-Mumonkan
I'll say: I think I've said enough. Did the meaning make it across the valley, or is it obscured by clouds and mist and echo? What did you think about it?