r/anime • myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • 17d ago

Meta Meta Thread - Month of November 01, 2026

Rule Changes

Fanart posts are no longer allowed to include a version with nudity in the comments.


This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.

Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.

Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.


Previous meta threads: October 2026 | September 2026 | August 2026 | July 2026 | June 2026 | May 2026 | April 2026 | March 2026 | February 2026 | January 2026 | December 2025 | November 2025 | Find All

New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.

37 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

•

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 17d ago edited 17d ago

October Mod Report

October by the Numbers

  • Total traffic: 33,122,395 pageviews, unique visitors: 7,237,959
  • Total posts: 7,150, unique authors: 4,575
  • Total comments: 150,946, unique authors (excluding mod bots): 28,243
  • Removed posts (by moderators): 606, Removed posts (by bots): 4,155, Removed posts (distinct): 4,735
  • Removed comments (by moderators): 2,834, Removed comments (by bots): 937, Removed comments (distinct): 3,688
  • Approved posts: 968
  • Approved comments: 3,798
  • Distinguished comments: 1,778
  • Users banned: 356, Users permanently banned: 258
  • Users unbanned: 21
  • Admin/Anti-Evil Operations: removed posts: 43, removed comments: 79.
→ More replies (3)

38

u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan 17d ago edited 17d ago

We envy those not following the short history of Reddit's changes. But we now have a final end date of March 2027 where everything useful will break.

TL;DR


External things you see

Internal stuff

  • 🟡 Core Custom Moderation Automations (/u/AnimeMod) - Currently discussing a migration with Reddit, but much of what we use the system for is outside the bounds of what they want to allow. (/u/baseballlover723)

Our present general philosophy:

  • As of this time we are not concretely committed to completing anything above (🟡 can turn to ❌).
  • Reddit believes that their new developer platform will cater to all needs, but it's not as feature-rich and comes with additional constraints.
  • This puts the onus on us to migrate everything, requiring an enormous time investment from the few individuals on the team with technical skill.
  • We're open to suggestions for alternatives or anyone interested in working to restore some of the functionality we will lose, please reach out to us if you'd like to help.
  • This whole thing is ongoing and we will continue to provide status updates.

38

u/baseballlover723 17d ago • Mindblown

As the main mod doing moderation automation stuff on the team, and the one who pays the ~$27 a month fee for hosting our servers to run our automations. I would like to give my thoughts on this whole thing.

Core Custom Moderation Automations (/u/AnimeMod) - Currently discussing a migration with Reddit

I should note, these discussion started in like April, so like 6 months ago. Though there have been slow communications on both sides contributing to that.

So far, I've been offered 2 contracts (for me personally to get paid to migrate part of our stuff). The first one I explicitly turned down, as it was so egregiously aggressive and hostile to me that it was in my opinion, a risky financial decision to accept it. I should note that I did look over it with a lawyer in my family (as I have do with any contract I am considering entering into).

Just some of the things that were wrong with it.

  • There was a loophole where they didn't actually have to pay me. They were only liable up to the amount they actually paid me, which if they just didn't, would be $0. In this case, I would have no recourse, as there was no exception in cases of breach of contract. Me on the other hand, all of my liabilities were unbounded. Basically every section where I would be on the hook for something it was unbounded, and every section where reddit would be on the hook, it was bounded to hell and back.
  • I could be personally bankrupted for reasons beyond my control. There was an indemnification clause. Which is basically, if someone sued reddit for the code I wrote, I would be on the hook for their lawyer fees, without bound. So someone could arbitrarily decide to frivolously sue reddit for some reason, and reddit could decide (without consulting me) to actually take that to court, and then I am now on the hook for paying for an entire team of cooperate lawyers (which are not cheap).
  • There was an NDA that was explicitly incompatible with the formal procedure I told reddit at the start this would need to go through on our side (ie, it would need to be voted on by the other mods). So by signing said contract, I would immediately become in breach of it, as the copy of it that would have been voted on would be in violation of the contract. And this is despite the fact that they explicitly gave me the contract to the other mods could vote on it.
  • There was a non disparagement clause for 2 years after the contract ended. Ie, I wouldn't be allowed to publicly criticize reddit. Something, I frequently do (you can find me in many of the mod announcement threads) as someone who speaks their mind when they disagree with reddit's decisions (which is quite often these days). This contract was originally estimated by reddit to be like 2 months in duration. It also did not matter if my disparagement was related to the contract work or not. I think it's quite obvious to see how excessive this clause was.
  • Reddit could cancel the contract without reason, without downside, so long as I was given 10 days notice. In order for me to cancel the contract, I would have to prove that reddit was in breach of the contract. Also reddit could cancel the contract if I missed a milestone delivery date by more than 5 business days. Despite them telling me that they did not want the milestone dates to be a significant factor and they were highly flexible for it. It goes without saying, but this is not my day job. I work on r/anime stuff in my free time, of my own volition. Sometimes I will spend an entire whole weekend doing something. Sometimes I'll go weeks or months not doing anything. That is how I do hobby work.
  • It also legally bounded us to Devvit ToS, which made it extremely clear that we were required to honor user deletions. User deletions are something that should never be able to be used to escape moderation imo. A classic example is if someone types out a horrible message to someone (presume they are circumventing any filters in place, so it actually goes through), which gives the recipient a notification. And then 15 minutes later they delete it. There is a good chance that no moderators will have checked that comment in that 15 minutes (we usually check mod queue sporadically throughout the day as we have time). And if the person who got the nasty message then informed us mods about it (as they rightfully should), we would be put in a conundrum. We could either

    1. Not ban the sender because we cannot verify that a rules infraction has occurred.
    2. Trust the reporter that a ban worthy rules infraction did occur and ban the sender, sight unseen. Note, screenshots are not reliable pieces of evidence, as they are trivially faked.

    The best option here, is to have access to the deleted comment, and verify the content for ourselves, and make the appropriate judgement. In case 1, we let people have a method to send nasty things to people without punishment. And in case 2, we allow others a tool to witch hunt others. Both of which suck.

    Reddit has suggested to us that we could retain deleted content for up to 30 days (which would solve this specific case), but that would still be limiting to us. A good example of that is our Clip rules. We only allow users to post 2 Clips per 30 days, and crucially, we count deleted Clips too (though we will entertain requests to strike those from the record if they were not meaningfully posted. Ie, they were posted, and then quickly deleted to fix something and repost it).

    People have in the past, seen that rule, posted their 2 Clips for the month, and then gone back and deleted one of their previous Clips, and post their 3rd Clip. That is not in the spirit of the rule. And while this also fits in the 30 day time period, that's the max this kind of thing can work in. We would not be able to say that you get 7 Clips per season or something. Or do something like, once a year, you can post 3 Clips in a single month. Because we would not be able to automatically enforce that like we do today.

    I do not find it very attractive that this migration would put additional restrictions on how we can moderate.

Those were the big ticket things that were wrong with it, though there were many some other things I ended up requesting changes to, like fixing references to non existent sections and actually defining what the work to be done was. But when doing a formal business contract, you can't just take someone's word over what literally written in the contract. So I obviously declined it and told them at length what I thought was wrong with it.

And to reddit's credit, they fixed most of those things in the 2nd contract they offered me. They later told me that the first contract they gave was basically their general contractor's contract. Which makes sense to me, these conditions are much more inline with actual employment by a company. But that's not at all what this contract is. This contract was a sweetener to encourage us to get ahead of the curve (a lot of good that did), and that is fundamentally different than contract for hire work.

As of currently, their 2nd contract has not been rejected or accepted by us. And it still has some issues, though mostly minor ones, like references to things that no longer exist and the contract words still being contradictory to their communications to me in minor aspects. Many of those are minor mistakes of the hand and we have agreed in principle to fix the contract to match our mutual thoughts. But some of the requests I requested were turned down by reddit, and so still pose a problem to me.


Additionally, it is unclear to me at this point, what is the exact value of entering into this contract. There are open questions about if the migration model we talked about way back in April is even still kosher, or is considered an end destination by reddit.

To be clear, the migration model we originally talked about (from the start) was one where we make a thin Devvit app that basically takes the place of our reddit API client. This was the only viable migration method in my opinion (and I told them very clearly that at the start, and they agreed), as we have more than 5 years of development work made over the years. This would only have us rewrite a very small segment of our code (maybe like 10%~20%), and would let us retain full control of our business logic (ie, reddit can't spy on what we're doing, or mess with our things). I should also note, that despite the fact that Devvit is hosted by reddit, us migrating would not reduce our server fees at all (from $27 a month). As Devvit does not support relational databases, which is an integral part to virtually all of our automations. I inquired about relational databases on Devvit to reddit, and they told me it was not on the roadmap at all.

Our database is quicker and more powerful than querying reddit for information. With reddit's Devvit functions, they are mostly generic functions that cannot do much filtering (IIRC I haven't checked in a while). They cannot efficiently do things like: "Find all comments made by X user in Re:Zero Episode discussion threads, and classify them as either in the Source Material Corner or not" (this is btw, something I have written and I use it when I investigate people claiming to be anime only). This would be prohibitively expensive (time wise) in Devvit, if it is even possible in the first place. I'm pretty sure you'd have to fetch like every post that has been made on r/anime since they created their account, find which ones are the relevant Episode discussion threads, and then find all of the comments to those posts, and then check in code for comments by that specific user. That would likely take minutes to hours (given rate limiting) on Devvit, and like 1 to 30 seconds in Postgresql.

Thus, our database is a highly essential part of our automation.

30

u/baseballlover723 17d ago

These days, with each reddit announcement coming in that I disagre with and with things like old reddit being sunset, and AutoMod also being sunset and replaced with a far less capable version and an LLM to automate moderation, I question more and more if reddit is something I want to spend huge amounts of my time on helping anymore.

And if I go to the current end goal, will that actually be the end? Or will they the rug from under me and tell me I have to do more.

I will say, doing a lot of work, for money I don't need, to help a platform I think is going in increasingly the wrong direction, for people (the admins) who have made it clear they don't care about me or my efforts, all to get a mildly worse product than what we currently have today, seems like a bad deal to me.

24

u/Verzwei 17d ago edited 17d ago

You're touching on a lot of the reasons why I stepped down from the moderation team back in 2023, right down to citing the "landed gentry" comment and the other hostility from reddit administration toward subreddit moderators during the API changes which killed third-party apps and hindered or broke useful tools, and the resulting "blackout" protests.

Good, well-curated communities take a lot of work. More work that I ever even realized before joining the team. My own usual contributions were comparatively small -- clearing modqueue, looking for spoilers in threads/shows I followed, and only the bare minimum of automod changes. The most in-depth work I did tended to be crafting votes for rule or procedure changes, or manually parsing data that couldn't be fully automated, such as when the subreddit-karma-to-post rule was initially trialed. Durinthal was able to automate a list of posts removed by the trial, but then we had to manually investigate each (attempted) post and categorize them based on which other rules (if any) they would have failed regardless of the karma filter. Basically, we had to see if the karma filter was good for blocking bad or inappropriate posts without also blocking too many "valuable" posts.

I was good for grunt work and rambling talking, and even that could take a surprising amount of time. Then there are mods before and during my time, like /u/durinthal and /u/badspler who put in a monumental amount of work behind the scenes developing and maintaining all the features that made moderation easier for less-technical team members like me. Or /u/fetchfrosh who handled a huge amount of images for the new icon-based flair when the old CSS text flairs were retired. That's not to speak any less of other mods because all tasks were important, but the point I'm trying to convey is that good moderation is a volunteer position that can be quite involved. And reddit admin gleefully takes that point entirely for granted. Massive amounts of unpaid labor is what keeps their best communities running, and not only does reddit admin fail to appreciate that effort, oftentimes reddit admin is outright disdainful toward that effort.

Tin-foil hat conspiracy theory: What I find darkly humorous is that I believe a lot of reddit's recent enshittification and stripping of features is because they are trying to clamp down on the extent that AI/LLM scrapes their site. When reddit admin is being exploited without compensation, suddenly they don't like it, even though they've been fine with unpaid moderators hard-carrying the site for years. The fact that a contract was offered and they're willing to pay you at all is shocking to me, but I wouldn't trust them at all.

In short: Fuck reddit. The only reason I'm still here is because I like this community, and this is one of the few large platforms where people can communicate uncensored (within reason) but as soon as old.reddit is killed for real, or some viable alternative site pops up that can host a community like this one, I'm out of here. If such a place ever appears, I genuinely hope to run into many of you there.

5

u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz 17d ago

and this is one of the few large platforms where people can communicate uncensored (within reason) but as soon as old.reddit is killed for real, or some viable alternative site pops up that can host a community like this one

I've used both reddit and 4chan for many years for different reasons, but the latter definitely feels more open to uncensored discussion (albeit not long form) than whatever reddit has been pushing for the last half decade or more.

12

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod 16d ago

I think that the "within reason" part of /u/Verzwei's comment is doing a lot of heavy lifting. I believe he meant uncensored as in people don't have to worry about their comment being removed for saying a fictional character should die painfully, not uncensored as in other people may call you racial slurs.

14

u/Verzwei 16d ago

Yeah, that's the gist of it.

Depending on specific subreddit rules, users aren't policed on general language. If I want to say fuck or shit or damn for whatever reason, I don't have to worry about my comment getting moderated or pushed to low visibility. People can discuss whether or not a popular show's main character is a pedophile without having to use algorithm or keyword loopholes like PDF. You even see people self-censor words like "sex" into "s*x" sometimes, presumably because other platforms have conditioned them to. I see that one often enough that they can't all be referencing Shimoneta.

But a minimum level of protection is a good thing. Racial or identity slurs have zero place in any discussion that is even remotely pretending to be civil.

5

u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz 16d ago

I'll take insults and the whatnot over having your opinion stifled after being downvoted to oblivion because you decided to go against the grain.

4

u/SplooshU 16d ago

I haven't touched 4chan since moot sold it. I would dread having to go back.

28

u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 17d ago

While I would be sad to see /r/anime go, I want the mods to know that I would be perfectly ok with you throwing the hands in the air and walking away from this. Reddit's enshittification is ongoing and reaching levels that are becoming hard to ignore. Nobody can expect you to work around that forever.

22

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 17d ago

The internal tooling is technically only one item on the list but it's really a stack of more than a dozen different utilities in a trenchcoat (and this list isn't comprehensive, it's just what I'm currently aware of off the top of my head):

  • It takes snapshots of the front page every hour to give us metrics on what kinds of posts are popular and how long they stay there.
  • It gives us the numbers for the monthly mod report with how many posts/comments were made and how many users participated.
  • It lets us know when /r/anime posts are mentioned in another subreddit in case of potential brigading.
  • It lets us know when admins remove a post or comment, or any other unusual activity happens like adding or removing mods.
  • It gives us a feed of posts and if they were removed/approved by a mod or why they were removed by AutoModerator.
  • It updates the links in the sidebar for new daily, meta, Casual Discussion Fridays, and Anime of the Week posts (and locks the previous CDF and adds a comment on the previous daily/CDF threads redirecting to the new one).
  • It updates the previous daily thread to link to the next one and can optionally post a sticky comment prepared ahead of time (or should have at least, I don't know what was going on with the Question of the Day issue at the time).
  • It helps take mod applications from submission form to voting while doing research on the user applying.
  • It can restore posts/comments by users who were incorrectly taken out by Reddit's spam filters and had all of their history removed.
  • It can check for people making certain types of posts more frequently than allowed by our rules and automatically filter them. This includes people deleting posts to try to get around those rules.
  • It can check for and remove gallery posts with fewer images than are required or video posts that are too short.
  • It can count who participated in specific rewatches frequently so we can give them a special flair.
  • It adds Source Material Corner comments to Episode threads so they aren't automatically collapsed on most clients like AutoModerator comments are.
  • It keeps a backup of the wiki so we can quickly identify when specific changes were made.

While some of that can be replaced by tools on the developer platform, some parts explicitly can't for reasons that are out of our control and Reddit refuses to support after multiple direct requests from our side.

And unfortunately for us, even if we were happy to work with Reddit and move everything over to the developer platform there are a lot of technical challenges that we'd have to figure out how to navigate. It's in a completely different programming language than everything we have built to this point and has additional restrictions in what's allowed to be done, sort of like going from making a sculpture using whatever medium we wanted to needing to use LEGO bricks and there's a limited selection of shapes available.

In all, not great. Even though I just came back I don't have a lot of enthusiasm for contorting myself to fit the hole Reddit wants to put us in.

19

u/baseballlover723 17d ago

It's in a completely different programming language than everything we have built to this point and has additional restrictions in what's allowed to be done, sort of like going from making a sculpture using whatever medium we wanted to needing to use LEGO bricks and there's a limited selection of shapes available.

It's kinda like doing a manga -> anime adaption. Sure, it like already exists, and you aren't starting from scratch. But you still have to actually redo the whole thing. Which is a ton of work even if nothing logically changes. Oh, and like you can't use the color blue because reasons.

Devvit is fundamentally more limited than the public API. It's a framework that can only exist in Javascript (or languages that compile to Javascript). The public API on the other hand, is language agnostic, and can be used with any programming language of choice (though some obviously have more support infrastructure already built for them than others).

The public API is like USPS or UPS, where you just drop it off with the proper markings and they make sure it gets to where it goes. And Devvit is like a specific company offering door to door pickup / delivery. And they only serve letters to/from the top 10 cities. So get fucked if you need to ship packages.

10

u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW 17d ago

It's a framework that can only exist in Javascript

This does not compile with my use java for everything philosophy

18

u/baseballlover723 17d ago

For some god forsaken reason, the admins when building Devvit, knew they only had resources to support 1 programming language (which is quite reasonable to start with), and instead of picking Python, you know, the most popular programming language generally and for specifically reddit, they picked Javascript. A language that nobody ever used to program shit for reddit, is just as slow as Python, has way more footguns, and has far less analytical libraries that might be of use.

9

u/Charmanders_Cock 16d ago

If you take all of this in tandem with the company’s general feelings toward mods (i.e. “landed gentry”), and the way mega corporations have shifted toward treating employees at large, it seems logically purposeful.

I wager that they *wanted* to make it as difficult as possible for everyone to migrate. By doing this they weed out everyone and anyone who is going to make a fuss instead of buckling down, licking their boots and complying like good corporate slaves would. It’s the Amazon/Walmart model in slow motion.

I just woke up, so my brain isn’t ready for it, but I might come back and edit this comment to add the full spectrum of my thoughts. There are myriad reasons why this all looks like an intentional power play to me.

10

u/chilidirigible 16d ago

I just woke up, so my brain isn’t ready for it, but I might come back and edit this comment to add the full spectrum of my thoughts. There are myriad reasons why this all looks like an intentional power play to me.

It has been said on a number of occasions already that Reddit Inc. is applying the boiling frog model to us, that they have been slow-rolling their changes so that they only lose small amounts of their userbase at a time such that no single hit affects them enough to seriously affect their profits/market valuation/pageviews/etc. Ending the API will hurt some major subreddits, but they've spent the past three years creating a scenario where the present userbase is unlikely to care, just as hostile to moderation as before, and unlikely to support any thoughts of a Blackout 2.0 (not that the first one ultimately did much to stop the steamroller).

8

u/Charmanders_Cock 15d ago

Most of what I would have added to this specific line of thought has more or less been said elsewhere and would be redundant so I’m just going to add a couple of thoughts I’ve had since. Otherwise you make  good points that I wholly believe to be true to at least some extent. 

I’ve since done a bit more digging into the situation generally though and I think there are likely other factors at play specifically regarding the speed with which they’re rolling these changes out. Reddit has publicly recognized their need for the volunteer moderation teams several times, and not just in throw-away interviews or other MSM-related ways, but at IPO filings, directly to major investors, etc. 

If they were staying true to boiling the frog (at a competently efficient level), they would be easing into things more so than they are right now imo. They clearly want mods to migrate to Devvit, but the entire platform seems like a half-baked unfinished venture, which is where the root of a lot of this conflict lies.  They’re seemingly moving faster than they initially intended, which begs the question of why. 

There are too many potential reasons to say for sure, but I’d wager it’s either partially or wholly relevant to both/either AI tech and its capabilities evolving unexpectedly fast, and/or the slew of recent successful class action lawsuits against social media companies at large. 

Regardless of the exact reason, whether it be vulnerability, perceived opportunity to change, or both, the company is rushing things which is part of why these specific changes feel especially damning to moderators and users alike. 

15

u/Amndeep7 :IG:https://myanimelist.net/profile/asmLANG 17d ago

thank you mods for the work that yall have done and are even still considering on doing to transition to devvit. i've got a simple bot to make it easier to remind folks to submit to the contest that i run on CDF, but like /u/verzwei said, "fuck reddit", I ain't bothered to move it to devvit even though it probably could be just fine unlike much of the stuff that yall have done. folks are gonna have to accept a worse time due to admin decisions.

10

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ 17d ago

You probably already thought about this, but I suggest putting up an absolutely neutral CSS up at the end of February so that you don't have some 2026 stuff permanently enshrined on the page, if it turns out that you can't update anything ever again.

/u/baseballlover723

11

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 17d ago

Outside of the sidebar images and seasonal comment faces I'm not even sure any of that gets touched on a regular basis?

The entire top nav's items are defined from a wiki page, technically, so can still be updated without any CSS changes.

9

u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW 17d ago

The reddit API change has its own post here if you want to link it instead of the modnews post that doesnt actually source it - it does source it, that was a skill issue on my part

9

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 17d ago

It's also directly linked in the line about API changes in the monthly report pinned at the top of this thread.

5

u/soratoyuki :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/soratoyuki 16d ago

Time to migrate to https://ani.social/c/anime. Reddit is unsalvageable.

14

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 16d ago

Personal opinion here, not reflecting any official stance of the mod team.

Over the past few years I went looking for alternatives and that kind of site was a consideration. Speaking solely on the technical side and not about that community specifically, Lemmy is interesting but copies a number of design problems I have with Reddit without attempting to fix them while introducing some new complications in federation. Not that anything I would have in mind is guaranteed to be better, it would just fit my idea of what I'd want from a site rather than someone else's and be more suited for some kinds of communities than others.

I also wouldn't necessarily want to encourage a mass migration to a different community that's already been established and potentially overwrite that culture with an outside one if enough people show up without attempting to integrate with those who were there first. And aside from the cultural fit I'm not sure how well a lot of the things listed here would be able to be ported to a Lemmy instance; if comment faces and user flairs don't exist there either it's trading one form of a downgrade for another.

20

u/wjs018 15d ago

Head mod of the ani.social/c/anime community here to weigh in a bit after somebody shared this thread with me.

On the technical side, I agree that there would definitely be some hurdles that would be insurmountable for a 1:1 transition. I have worked a lot with the lemmy and piefed APIs at this point, and run a pretty heavily modified version of the holo episode discussion thread bot that /r/anime uses (named rikka). Some things just don't exist in the threadiverse software yet (nor will they), but if I start going through them all here, it would be way too big a post.

On the social side, a mass migration would be pretty overwhelming for our community. As I am writing this, we have had ~200 active users in the past 24 hours. That means even a relatively modest migration would be very much felt. I don't want to discourage people from joining or migrating, but it is going to be a very different experience compared to this sub (smaller and quieter mainly).

Speaking as a mod, I would be happy to answer questions that other mods may have about running communities on a lemmy or piefed instance or technical limitations, so feel free to reach out if you (or other mods that see this) have any. Back during the API blackout, one of the /r/anime mods did start chatting with me, but I just checked and they are no longer a moderator here (nor are they active any longer on their lemmy account).

From a personal perspective, these changes and the impact they will have on this subreddit are really saddening. In moderating my community, I have often looked to this subreddit as a "community on a hill" that is an example of how to do it right. Thanks for everything you and the rest of the mod team have done over the years to make it such a great place.

8

u/ptd163 17d ago

If we can no longer have anime bracket contests I'm going to be angry. It's something that's not episode threads or news I come here for. Also they're, if nothing else, an annual reminder, that we don't hate Date A Live enough.

8

u/Baaasbas https://myanimelist.net/profile/WVBasvanD 17d ago

It will most likely continue. How users are going to be verified is still the main question though. What is good? I don't think we really know at this point

The team is at least motivated enough to continue and are of course in discussions with the team over at animethemes

3

u/Ashteron 15d ago

If I had a nickel for every time a digg clone I'm using constantly tried to sabotage itself, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.

13

u/Charmanders_Cock 6d ago

Just want to rant about how blessed this sub is to have a meta thread. Trying to communicate with moderators in other subs is like banging your head against a wall. 

r/manga just got an actual mod team for the first time in a long time (ever). They immediately did away with the only reason I even regularly visited the sub, which was a stickied weekly thread about “what have you read this week”, or at least they unstickied it making it a chore to find in the sea of one-shots and patreon bait.  

I reflexively went to look for the meta thread and then remembered that, oh yeah, most of Reddit sucks. After messaging modmail to radio silence I felt blessed for this community. I know things are due for suboptimal changes in the near future, but at the very least thanks for your work guys. It becomes painfully apparent how cool this mod team is any time I venture outside the sub.  

11

u/cppn02 4d ago

Getting a whole bunch of notifications throughout the day from years old replies to my comments. Was there anything done on the mods' end (like reinstating a whole bunch of comments) or is it reddit being weird.

13

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod 4d ago

I've been approving (via a script) comments from accounts that were improperly shadowbanned by reddit. This includes both accounts that are still shadowbanned and accounts that were shadowbanned in the past where reddit did not properly restore comments upon unshadowbanning. So that is the most likely the reason for the comments in your inbox.

7

u/Yay295 :LJ::LK: 4d ago

Do you happen to be using a Devvit script, or something more custom? I've been manually approving some old comments from banned accounts that Admin Tattler notified me of.

9

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod 4d ago

We have a script for it. It depends on already knowing the ids of comments you want to restore, though, so it's probably of limited utility to you.

7

u/avboden 4d ago

ohhhhhhhhhhhh.

well that explains it. ngl been pretty annoying getting 3 year old notifications but sounds like it'll just be a temporary issue once the backlog is completed by the script

10

u/baseballlover723 4d ago

The admins have been doing a wave of spam related things. We've mostly seen removals, but it seems like there are some approvals in there. There have been many account nukes that we've seen in our logs (individually, for each comment they had).

If you see anything you shouldn't, please report it. We aren't really closely tracking them, and when the admins approve comments like this, it skips over automod.

10

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ 17d ago

I disagree with the moderation here since meta discussion of bittorrent sites e.g. the fact of their existence is not forbidden, to my understanding.

I have edited out the name of the organization, which was not a link to a site, and I didn't think even still had a site (which, in addition to any site of torrent links they may run, is also a political party).

6

u/cppn02 17d ago

I have to even question if this is against the rules, because IIRC the very naming of a site or group in a meta sense itself is not against the rules.

I always thought that groups are fine but sites are not.

7

u/VoidEmbracedWitch https://anilist.co/user/VoidEmbracedWitch 17d ago edited 17d ago

I learned the annoying way (through a like 8 comments long reply chain that's the reason I have a mod note ) that the exception only applies specifically to groups that make their own fansubs. You get hit with removals if you mention for example webrip groups.

7

u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod 17d ago

Your comment contained 3/4 of the name of a pirate site that still exists today. All I would have to do to convert it into the name of said active site is remove spaces and add .org to the end. And while discussing the existence of piracy sites is allowed, naming them is not. Our rules forbid "leading others to illegal streams or torrents, [which] includes explicitly mentioning specific streaming/torrenting sites."

is also a political party

I am sorry, but you are misinformed. There are various (minor) political parties that call themselves "Pirate Party," but that is an entirely different term than the one used in your comment.

9

u/minnieboss 17d ago

Are seasonal surveys done forever?

17

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 17d ago

"Forever" is a long time, but they aren't happening in the next few weeks at least.

Historically, the seasonal surveys have been run by /u/DragonsOnOurMountain. We have reached out to them, but they're currently non-responsive. Assuming they're gone for good, we may have a solution and/or replacement sometime in the future, but it's not something we're currently working on.

6

u/minnieboss 17d ago

Thank you for the info!

4

u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW 17d ago

7

u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt 16d ago

No requests, just halfway through Mayoiga and wanted to acknowledge the stroke of genius that is naming your automod bot AutoLovepon.

4

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead 15d ago

Mayoiga actually birthed AutoLovepon!

6

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ 11d ago

Instead of a final season comment face contest, you should do a final niche comment face contest.

3

u/baseballlover723 11d ago

It's an open question what we'll do to send off comment faces. But it is likely that something will be done at the end of the year.

5

u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead 15d ago

Will the stuff like the wiki, rewatch archive, watch order guides etc. all disappear or exist in stasis once the happening happened? Do we need to make backups?

7

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 15d ago

I don't believe there will be an issue with the wiki, or at least there hasn't been any indication I'm aware of that the old wiki will become disabled with the API.

Worst case if it somehow vanishes overnight we do have a backup up until the API closes (though that automation will break and not much that can be done there) and can figure out another way to host/update it.

5

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii 15d ago

Playing Sister is now on MAL.

(It's not listed in the info section of the episode threads).

5

u/Charmanders_Cock 11d ago

Is pointing people toward piracy subreddits barred under piracy rules?  

4

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler 11d ago

Yes.

5

u/Charmanders_Cock 5d ago edited 5d ago

Why are my comments in some threads getting crowd controlled? Or shadowbanned. I don’t know the right word for it I just know it’s a reddit function that hides a users comments from everyone besides themselves, usually apparent by the fact that they get eternally stuck at 1 view, signifying that they either got shadow-blocked by automod or the user is under mod-sanctioned crowd control functions.

Specifically right now it‘s any comment I make in this thread.

Edit: just to be clear I triple checked this by using a VPN to check the thread on two other non-logged in IP’s. My comments don’t exist in it.

5

u/baseballlover723 5d ago edited 5d ago

I don't see any comments by you in that thread. And we have crowd control disabled, along with many of the other black boxes reddit offers subs.

Edit: I do see comments by you in this thread though. But those look normal. They are hidden on sh reddit, but that's just because sh reddit hates long comment chains and very aggressively hides them behind a load more button. Which it does to everyone.

5

u/Charmanders_Cock 5d ago edited 5d ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/s/j3SGUUdJSf

Here is one of the two comments that I have posted that have been disappeared. I don’t know if that link even works for others though because I can’t access it unless I’m logged in. 

Edit: This one isn’t in a comment chain so I don’t know why it would be hidden.

7

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 5d ago

Looks fine to me in all forms I've checked. Notably, there are two threads with similar titles that might have lead to some confusion:

5

u/Charmanders_Cock 2d ago

Forgot to respond to this chain after the problem seemed to resolve itself.

I think it was a combination of things that you and u/baseballlover723 brought up, because I couldn’t seem to replicate the issue in my desktop (initially on iOS web). There being two different threads also threw me for a loop though and I probably would’ve gone in circle if you guys didn’t point it out. 

Sorry to waste time. Reddit makes iOS mobile web a most dreadful experience generally so I’ll give things more time in the future before raising alarm. 

I’ve been subject to shadowban stuff on other subs before more than once recently which is probably why I jumped to the conclusion. 

7

u/baseballlover723 2d ago

Sorry to waste time.

No worries, it really didn't take too much effort on our side. I'd rather waste 10 minutes (though I doubt I spent even that much on this) than have you have a real problem and just stew on it.

User reports like this are oftentimes how we find out that reddit is fucking with shit.

6

u/Emi_Ibarazakiii 5d ago

As a non-mod I do see this comment in the thread just fine.

The thread you liked above is a different thread (with similar title).

3

u/baseballlover723 5d ago

Looks fine to me in incognito (and in my mod view). Reddit might be fucking with you in particular. They do experiments without telling anyone and you might be picked for something dumb. But it doesn't seem to be applied globally.

4

u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta 14d ago

Oct 16 Casual Friday thread is pinned instead of the latest one. This is on mobile web, new reddit. The new thread was also briefly pinned but the Your Name anime of the week one pushed it out. Oct 16 thread seems to be perma-pinned.

5

u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal 13d ago

Basically the API/old reddit two-sticky system doesn't play well with the newer "community highlight" one so anything beyond the first two slots involves some manual management.

Fixed now, though will have to poke at it again tomorrow once the new CDF goes up.

4

u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta 13d ago

Ah ok. If I'd known, I would've waited till the new one was up before bringing this up. 

4

u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 1d ago

There is no thread for Crunchyroll theater release of Alice in Wonderland -Dive in Wonderland

3

u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler 1d ago