r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jan 04 '26
Meta Meta Thread - Month of January 04, 2026
Rule Changes
- No rule changes this month.
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: December 2025 | November 2025 |October 2025 | September 2025 | August 2025 | July 2025 | June 2025 | May 2025 | April 2025 | March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | December 2024 | November 2024 | October 2024 | September 2024 | August 2024 | July 2024 | June 2024 | May 2024 | April 2024 | March 2024 | February 2024 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/chilidirigible Jan 04 '26
December Mod Report
Welcome to 2026.
December by the Numbers
14
u/OrangeBanana38 https://anilist.co/user/OrangeBanana38 Jan 10 '26 edited Jan 10 '26
As per my conversation with baseballlover in State of the subreddit 2025:
I think there is a prominent early comment bias in episode discussion threads. People who comment early tend to get early upvotes, letting them rise up. Then people tend only read the top few comments, upvote them and leave, making them rise up even more in a positive feedback loop.
I think this is a problem because source readers can recycle source memes or pre-type comments and post them within the first 5 minutes. This lets them rise to the top before the anime-onlies have even had a chance to finish the episode. More so, this discourages longer comments as they take longer to type, and for bigger threads the top comments can already be established within the first hour or so. Shorter comments are already favored by Reddit as a platform, so giving them even more advantages might be undesirable.
Some proposals that might help mitigate these issues:
12
u/baseballlover723 Jan 26 '26 edited Jan 26 '26
Ok, I ended up not really doing too much more data digging for karma and episode discussion comments. So this will be my post that wraps things up.
This is a graph of average karma based on how many minutes after the thread was posted for the first 24 hours of episode discussions posts life's. This is the graph not truncated to 24 hours. And this is a zoom in of the first 60 minutes of an episode discussion's life.
This is a graph of how when comments are made in relation to the age of the thread on episode discussion threads in the 2025 for the first 24 hours of the thread's life. And this is a graph of the same, but for all years and also normalized so any differences in total comments year to year are negated. This also means that the y axis is no longer the number of comments anymore, but instead 100 represents the amount of comments that are to be expected in a 60 second interval over the entire year. Basically it doesn't matter that 2021 had way more comments in total, it's only measuring the relative distributions of comments. So you can use this graph to conclude that in 2022 and 2023, there were relatively more people posting in the first 15 minutes compared to other years. But generally the overall pattern of people commenting hasn't really changed much over the years.
As a result, I am going to be proposing a vote in the near future (the next few days) to change the default sorting algorithm for strictly episode discussion threads. I won't post the full vote, because it's complicated as fuck, with all the different levers there are. But essentially the levers are
Also as a note, this is simply the setting a default sort, users would be able to manually change the sort to something else. Just like how you could sort this meta thread by best instead of new if you wanted.
Anyway, people have opinions on this (like if you think this is a good spread or if I'm missing something), or any ideas how to efficiently structure this vote without having like 8 billion voting options, I'm all ears.
11
u/baseballlover723 Jan 05 '26
r/anime State of the Subreddit Tech Winter 2026 Edition
I'mma try and make a mini state of the subreddit in regard to the tech stuff behind the scenes. Cause I've spent a ton of time doing tech stuff for the sub and I'll continue doing that for the next year at least, and I think a lot of it isn't really stuff that's very visible.
2025 In Review
May not quite be in order, cause I'm going off of memory for this.
10
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jan 13 '26
Why is civility not part of the report options?
17
u/BeatBlockP https://myanimelist.net/profile/Animemes_chan Jan 16 '26
I know this was visited a number of times, but I think it's still time to re-visit the bot discussion post time. It makes NO SENSE that the post is the second the episode comes out. Any normal, non-cheesing viewer needs 25 minutes to watch it. Putting it up 30 minutes after the air time makes hell of a lot more sense, and even allows fast posters to actually put some thought into their comment.
Instead, we get this on Frieren - the flagship anime of the year:
Here are the top comments, 8 hours after the publication (+how many minutes after the thread was posted). The top 5 comments had only one comment made after double digit minutes - the rest were posted within mere minutes from the posting of the thread. You can see that almost all of the very quick postings were karma hoarding, or karma hoarding + edits, with fairly little substance. While actual discussion is then forced on sub-comments or way way below.
Why are promoting this race to the bottom? What is the benefit here? I can see the harm - very lazy comments grabbing the top positions and stifling discussion, while people who actually watch the episode are, well, watching it. But what's the upside?
2) +4 minutes [772]: A completely generic upvote-party comment, which really shouldn't be the 2nd top comment
3) +6 minutes [311]: Again, upvote party comment, which was later edited to add a minor detail (so it's double bad, since basically users are encouraged to quickly hoard karma, then edit their comment)
4) +10 minutes [405]: A comment actually talking about the episode (Even though by that point it wasn't really clear, so I guess this user watched the raw first or had great intuition about the direction of the episode)
5) +4 minutes [319]: Again, upvote party comment which was later edited to make use of being highlighted
6) +5 minutes [202] - A comment only possible through watching to the very end of the episode, meaning the user watched the raw and then commented
7) +29 minutes [128]: First comment from a real user who watched the show, and it has insights about the actual episode and a major theme in it.
8) +10 minutes [147]: It's hard to know exactly what was the original comment since this comment too was edited after the fact (30 minutes in). It seems to be about a specific moment in the episode that happened about exactly when it was posted.
9) +22 minutes [125]: A normal comment discussing the character dynamics (enhanced with an edit after a few minutes)
10) +91 minutes [58]: Finally we start seeing comments made not before or directly at the end. This comment has 58 points though, which is far far less than the rest, this is already "buried" territory.
7
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jan 10 '26
Speaking of the awards - are there any plans to re-introduce a summary page of our nominee votes, similar to what we had before?
7
u/baseballlover723 Jan 22 '26 edited Jan 22 '26
Opinions wanted!
Do you think that the Review flair should contain offsite reviews (that otherwise meet the current Review requirements (of having at least 1500 characters per anime) and given that the reddit user has at least 10 r/anime comment karma)? We are currently holding a vote on this and would like more opinions on what the Review flair should mean and thus what it should contain.
It should be noted that this content is already allowed on r/anime under the Misc. flair, so no post would be either newly eligible or newly ineligible. It would only have post volume effects relating to people deciding to post more of that kind of content (which could be affected by people seeing other posts and deciding to copy their own, similar to how Cosplay posts ended up becoming more popular months after the fact). It should be noted that it would be trivial to add specifically offsite reviews (or separately weighted from the current review flair) frequency limits like Cosplay and other types of user based embedded media to limit spam if that ends up being an issue.
So essentially this vote would be strictly about flair categorization, moving linked posts that would be colloquially be described as a review of anime from the Misc. flair to the Review flair. I should also note that one can search for only selfpost Review posts by adding
self:trueto the search, which would yield the exact same results as the current Review flair search.7
u/Charmanders_Cock Jan 27 '26
I’m not sure if this has already been discussed anytime recently, but with all of the discourse surrounding episode discussions, and general visibility of threads, I think there should be consideration for other community related posts as well. I was going to post this as a reply in the best girl thread, but it felt too meta so I’m just gonna leave it here.
It’s something I’ve thought for a while, but posts like “best girl”, “awards nominations”, or any other community-related threads aren’t as visible as they should be. The comment thread I was originally going to reply to in the Best Girl 2025 thread was basically a discussion about how many more people would have participated if they even knew the contest was going on to begin with. There’s a lot of generally similar discourse in that thread too.
Even as someone who lurks through “hot” and “best” multiple times a day didn’t see the threads for it show up until maybe midway through the competition. I knew it was going on because I also read through the daily thread, but that’s probably not true for most casual subreddit members. For the awards thread I literally had to use a refined google search to find it.
I’m probably not the best example to use for these situations though as I mostly use iOS Safari for Reddit, which is basically the most nuked version of the website you can imagine because the Reddit devs want to push mobile users to the app; it’s why I’ve sort of brushed it off as a consequence of my own stubbornness until now. However, seeing a significant number of people express similar sentiments about these kinds of threads makes it apparent that it’s a pretty broad issue.
I’m not that keen to how much/in what ways mods are able to influence these things, so take this with a grain of salt, but I think doing more rotation of the community highlights tab would at least help the issue a bit. I know that it would only be a bandaid because it’s basically only a function for shreddit users, but I think swapping out a couple of posts, maybe on some sort of alternating schedule might be a way to increase visibility for the more important community driven threads; threads like announcing the beginning of a contest/survey/etc. or the results for them.
Again, I don’t know the logistics that well but wanted to give my two cents, and apologize if something like this has already been discussed.
6
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Jan 07 '26
Looks like the daily thread is still pointing to last month's meta thread.
6
u/Castor_0il Jan 19 '26
Can I suggest a revision for the clip & video edit rules?
I'm pretty sure you mods have noticed that the current rules allow 2 clips and 2 video edits per month, that's 4 submissions each month. From what I've noticed on a very specific user is that their video edits are pretty much just stitched sequences from either the same episode or from a different episode, but they are still pretty much just 2 or more clips stitched together. To me it's just low effort content and a way to find a loophole in the original 2 clip per month rule to avoid flooding in the main page.
From my very own personal opinion I feel that the video edit submissions should be reserved for amv type of content, edits that require more labor in editing tools other than just "stitching" 2 or more clips. Either that or limit users to submit only 2 clips/edits per month.
That's just my 2 cents.
6
u/UMP45isnotflat Jan 29 '26
This has probably been mentioned before and probably been discussed, but the community contests should get stickied in some sort. They just get no visibility as of now, I often only notice it happening when its almost over.
I understand the amount of stickied posts is limited, but maybe we could get one sticky for all contests combined? And if for whatever reason that gets pushed of the top, atleast a mention with the link in the daily stickied post?
10
u/lolhopen Jan 04 '26
can we please finally ban all these "what should i watch? i liked aot and frieren" and "does anyone else have post-anime depression" posts? these posts are all the same, low-quality, AND take half of my main feed
5
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Jan 15 '26
Love Through a Prism. I notice the batch discussion are eps 1-10. Netflix site shows eps 1-10 for me but the piracy rips have eps 1-20. I don't think late discussions are going to be any less dead than normal and it shouldn't matter for several hours as it feeds back to the it'll take at least 8 hours to watch (eps are variable length, 23-40 minutes in the eps 1-10 range and judging by filesizes the latter half is no different).
5
u/CerberusZX https://myanimelist.net/profile/CerberusZX Jan 17 '26 edited Jan 17 '26
A few things have been on my mind for a while now regarding the video edit rules as written.
Both clips and video edits are listed as 2 per 30 day period. I assume it's 2 total and not 2 of each, but I also assume the bot looks at tags and treats each separately. I can see how it would make sense for them to be separate as I've seen some creative compilations that feel like their own thing, but then simply stitching 2 scenes from one episode also qualifies as a video edit while being basically a clip. I don't intend on doing more than 2 total, but I can't help but wonder if 2 of each would be allowed.
The lack of a maximum length on video edits is also something I have been thinking about. Again, I've seen the creative compilations and it makes sense not to stifle that creativity, but when scene splicing also counts as a video edit the rules don't explicitly forbid posting an entire episode of something with eye catches removed or something equally egregious. Whenever I trim a clip I always end up thinking "can I get away with going over the limit by making it an edit instead?"
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jan 25 '26 edited Jan 25 '26
Sigh.
I've made an edit that shows three clips side by side (actually, vertically, because widescreen). So, I've removed the audio. Okay?
It's also only 27 seconds long. This edit is for the purpose of comparison of a single scene.
4
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jan 07 '26
It looks like The Place has not placed for today
4
u/BaytaCosmico https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnimeBayta Jan 17 '26 edited Jan 17 '26
I got a comment removed notification about this comment citing that my spoiler tags were off. I was actually happy that I got them right on the first go. There are no issues that I can see and the comment itself is still up as well (the OP I replied to deleted their comment though for some reason). Did the bot send out an incorrect notification?
4
u/oops_i_made_a_typi Jan 31 '26
are we giving up on modding for other series spoilers with Fate/strange Fake? it feels like we need someone who at least is familiar with F0 and FSN to remove the most common and egregious spoilers there.
and on a somewhat related note, what are the official rules on spoilers involving info that's been provided in official media like series websites and stuff if it's info that hasn't been revealed in the anime itself yet?
3
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Jan 11 '26
With official subs for Kimengumi released after the anime got picked up by Prime Video, is the episode thread being made again or what?
2
u/Nebresto Jan 23 '26
The 'Show information' links in Fire Force threads still link to S3 part 1 entries
2
u/qwertyqwerty4567 https://anilist.co/user/ZPHW Jan 31 '26
Highly recommend making awards posts self posts to drive way more engagement.
I know that it's never been done this way, but thats pretty much the way it has to be done to get any engagement from the mobile audience.
4
u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Jan 14 '26
It’s close enough to a meta topic that I don’t want to be nuked in any of the other threads, but for the awards are shows only eligible for one genre category?
Cause Mono not even being an option for Comedy seems wild if that isn’t the case.
2
u/Charmanders_Cock Jan 14 '26
The idea of “light anime” being considered anime here is just so wrong to me for a lot of reasons. Its existence is as obtuse as the conception of “anime cannon” which is literally just a marketing term to cover up the negative connotation of filler. The companies creating it call it anime to get people reading their slightly moving pictures. It’s basically just manhwa cut up in a slideshow but with a few gifs Instead of jpegs.
I know I’m probably barking at the moon here but it peeves me enough to say something wherever I can.
1
u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Jan 14 '26
Who marked My Melody and Kuromi as a Drama? Da fuq?!
1
u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Jan 14 '26
Who was smoking crack making these categories? I want some of that, cause The Colors Within in SoL and not Drama is crazy to me, but apparently My Medoly and Kuromi counts.
Like I’m running out of things to pick in SoL because whoever decided the categories decided that all the funny ones aren’t comedies and the big dramatic one isn’t a drama.
1
u/SnabDedraterEdave Jan 25 '26
Moderation of cross franchise discussion has become completely out of hand
Now people cannot even make comparison of one series (A) with the story of another series from the same franchise that was released years ago (B) without being slapped with a spoiler warning, even though most of the anime onlies of A will have most likely known the story of B inside out by this point in time.
Its like forbidding discussion of MCU Phase 1 movies in discussion of new MCU series that may or may not have chronologically taken place before those Phase 1 movies.
Consider this a formal complaint.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment