r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Aug 02 '26
Meta Meta Thread - Month of August 02, 2026
Rule Changes
This is a monthly thread to talk about the /r/anime subreddit itself, such as its rules and moderation. If you want to talk about anime please use the daily discussion thread instead.
Comments here must, of course, still abide by all subreddit rules other than the no meta requirement. Keep it friendly and be respectful. Occasionally the moderators will have specific topics that they want to get feedback on, so be on the lookout for distinguished posts. If you wish to message us privately send us a modmail.
Comments that are detrimental to discussion (aka circlejerks/shitposting) are subject to removal.
Previous meta threads: July 2026 | June 2026 | May 2026 | April 2026 | March 2026 February 2026 | January 2026 | December 2025 | November 2025 |October 2025 | September 2025 | August 2025 | July 2025 | June 2025 | May 2025 | April 2025 | March 2025 | February 2025 | January 2025 | Find All
New threads are posted on the first Sunday (midnight UTC) of the month.
•
u/KiwiBennydudez https://myanimelist.net/profile/KiwiBen Aug 02 '26
July Mod Report
Where in the world is
Carmen Sandiego/u/FetchFrosh ?!?!Welp, it's been a while since I've done one of these, so I'll be filling in on his behalf.
I hope everyone's July has been going swimmingly! Staying out of the heat, I hope? As far as current seasonals go, I've been thoroughly enjoying KAIJU GIRL CARAMELISE, much more than I thought I would. Otherwise, I've been first-timing Bleach in my spare time. Already 150 episodes deep!
July by the Numbers
19
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Aug 13 '26
Heya folks, hosts have been selected for the 2026 /r/anime Awards. Say hello to~
/u/aniMayor
/u/CoolVidsFTW
/u/Kenalskii
/u/normalgrinn
/u/protractror
/u/Schinco
/u/SiLeNTxTrYH4Rd
/u/Vaxivop
/u/voidembracedwitch
I'm looking forward to seeing what each of these hosts will bring to the table! If you're unfamiliar with the project, then please check it out at https://animeawards.moe, and if you are familiar, you can provide feedback at https://animeawards.moe/feedback. This feedback goes directly to the moderators and host team.
If you would like to help the Awards as either a graphic designer, video editor, or website developer, then please fill out the Helper Form!
This year, we are also toying with the idea of hosts who only manage categories. More information will be available soon on this, so please stay tuned.
We hope to see you all in a bit!
11
u/PM_me_meta_usernames Aug 05 '26
can we have a rule to disallow entire comments being in a huge font? it's really obnoxious. I won't name anyone but just go into any best girl post and scroll down and you will find them. it's like they believe they deserve more attention for some reason. this also sometimes happens in AQRADT too.
to be clear, I'm not saying any use of big font is bad. I understands it's sometimes useful for dividing a post with titles and such. what I am saying is that typing entire paragraphs like this shouldn't be allowed.
10
u/chilidirigible Aug 02 '26
Meta Fetch Quest
10
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Aug 02 '26
lmao Fetch was supposed to be the mod-of-the-month but he's afk it seems. Some things happened, we got a new mod (say hello u/Mitsuyan_), I'll let Fetch fill y'all in on the details. I just didn't want the new Meta Thread to be without a single comment for over an hour. We're alive, dang it!
Since I'm here, I might as well plug something: host applications for the 2026 r/anime Awards are still open till tomorrow.
Other than that, happy August everyone, how's the summer seasonals coming along for y'all? I'm pretty sure the Writing Club is right about to release a new piece for the seasonals to watch (or not watch).
10
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Aug 02 '26
Less speak now or forever hold your peace, more putting things on the table and I don't know the answer or what the best solution (if any) would even be. For the 4th week in a row Though I Am an Inept Villainess discussion has gone up hours before:
That's pretty unusual as A distinguished post last week said:
Not official sources, hasn't aired on TV, unsure is sounding a lot like a leak but also not at the same time.
Now a counter claim will be the auto rip source is official DNSP (Disney+) and the subs are the same dialogue as will be on CR (for English at least, this is provided to CR as shown by the arial font and lack of advanced styling). The best case scenario is this is a mistaken early upload in some unknown country in parts of Europe or Latin America that have the show there on D+ (per official site that's all the D+ territories...well plus Japan but all Japanese streaming is after broadcast end at the earliest and IDK if D+ Japan has English subs like JP Netflix can for some things).
I find it unlikely that D+ has a license to show it before Japan that would not also cover Hulu or be mentioned on the official website. If the country(ies) could be named it would become sort of similar to standard posting eps when shows are live on B-Global (which is usually immediately after airing in Japan, to prevent fast-forwarding the episode and tweeting spoilers but can be an hour or so before CR).
Unintended leaks are a bit different as it doesn't have the same threshold of being obtained via confidential/privileged data like various leaks that don't have discussions here* (e.g. Ranma 2024 S1) and the viewing experience is not compromised meaning discussion is not taken up with "man this video sucks" (some of these leaks have been low resolution, watermarked and even unfinished eps...literally a completed audio monochrome animatic video for the final ep of Isekai Suicide Squad Isekai).
Past precedent for unintended leaks seems to be no action taken such as a few episodes of To Your Eternity season 3 (an episode was interrupted mid-broadcast by earthquake coverage, despite the fact the episode didn't finish airing in Japan CR still posted it and then pulled it, then next week instead of reinstating the pulled episode they posted the next episode which was also subsequently pulled). Besides, I'd say a discussion based on a limited location limited time release window is not unprecedented as that is film ones posted for cinema releases.
Ultimately assuming unintended mistake it's on Japanese stakeholders to prevent this through citing the license contract or more drastically withholding the materials from the offending parties and these steps may happen before any decision is reached.
Another thing that's making this a bit picky is hours doesn't have the same potential for discussion fragmentation as some things in the past (days, weeks) but needless to say does annoy those who like to be on top of things (it escalating them into having to pirate even if they don't need to and delaying the discussion would still advantage those who have had hours more time to prepare but it should matter less due to random sorting) or use the discussion posts as their calendar (because the CR calendars are retrospective shit or for shows available in Germany).
*-As a sidebar I'm not sure those had serious fansub attempts (there were some subs that looked rather STT>MTL derived) so it's untested and an entire season weeks-months before airing is much bigger problem than individual episodes hours early (no matter how persistent the latter is).
9
u/redlegsfan21 https://myanimelist.net/profile/redlegsfan21 Aug 07 '26
Curious what is going on with this post
https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vhz33x/panty_investigations_lycoris_recoil
Not seeing a mod comment about a removal.
9
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Aug 27 '26
Looks like reddit may have finally killed off the two-character subdomains that were used for CSS filtering as going to any of them redirects back to www for me.
9
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Aug 29 '26
Small update: Voted to allow image posts for [Contest] posts. Note that this flair is just for AnimeBracket contests.
We allowed them for Best Girl earlier this summer, but that was an informal decision, not a formal vote.
17
u/Roskal Aug 17 '26
I'd like for stricter rules or a source material section for pv and teaser/trailer posts. I don't want to see every comment complaining or getting hyped for future manga events, each vague posting in a slightly different way. If a post is about anime on r/anime the discussion should be anime only outside of a source material section.
8
u/cppn02 Aug 02 '26
Why would you post the new comment face batch in the old thread one hour before that's locked and not in here?
8
u/Infodump_Ibis :JY::JZ: Aug 24 '26
Just noticed the Goodbye, Lara • Sayonara Lara discussions the official site link is incorrect as https://kinemacitrus.biz/goodbyelara/ leads to:
The site should be https://goodbyelara.com/
7
u/BorjaDAce :FR: Aug 09 '26
Idk if this goes here but I wanted to know. It´s already late but, ¿Is there a discussion for the scond batch of the Baki Dou series from netflix? I only found it fo rthe first batch,
7
u/cppn02 Aug 15 '26
I know we sometimes get performances of anisongs posted here but I wonder if concerts filmed with a phone really should be within the scope of this sub.
7
u/EuclaseBlue Aug 20 '26 edited Aug 20 '26
So this post seems to be a weird roundabout violation of spoilers: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vt2j3b/rem_would_say_now_stand_up_spoilers_for_rezero_s4/
And this specific comment chain within is a pretty clear indicator at the confusion it caused and that people did get spoiled: https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vt2j3b/rem_would_say_now_stand_up_spoilers_for_rezero_s4/p4qb5fk/
OP posted the clip for all intents and purposes to be a discussion for season 4 as indicated in their comment in said comment chain. Quote:
Even though the clip is from season 2, I feel that this causes it to effectively be in the same spirit as violating the rule stating:
as well as the rule stating:
Aside from having just posted the clip in the episode discussion itself (and not fragment discussion), OP could have just as easily kept it saying S2 spoilers (as well as sensibly removed "Rem" from the title) and people within would just tag S4 spoilers or w/e if they discussed the recent episode. Otherwise, you get poor folks like this guy getting spoiled just from the title alone.
I imagine this comment's gonna be ignored because it turns out a it was a mod of all people to make the post in question, but w/e I'm saying my piece to at least put on record that there's a flaw/edge case.
13
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Aug 03 '26
I'd like to once again ask for a rule that Official Media posts that use an English title must use the title the English licensor uses, and not one from a fan translation or Google translate or whatever.
For example, this post should be A Livid Lady's Guide to Getting Even: How I Crushed My Homeland with My Mighty Grimoires (or at least the first part before the colon), and this post should be The Insipid Prince's Furtive Grab for The Throne.
People can call things whatever they want in discussions, but I think Official Media posts should be, well, more official. If you're not using the title that'll bring it up in the licensor's site search, you're making it unnecessarily confusing.
6
u/Ok-Wheel-4136 Aug 09 '26
Did r/anime skipped best guy contest in 2024?
6
u/baquea Aug 19 '26
The link to the daily thread in the megathreads topbar and sidebar is 2 days out of date.
10
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Aug 16 '26
I wonder, does r/anime sometimes communicate/do collaborative work with other subs?
Because I was thinking of something that could be really good;
We could contact the mods of r/manga, and ask them whether it'd be possible to create 'anime-only' safe havens on their sub, in which anime fans could discuss Oshi No Ko (the anime) without fear of getting spoiled, or to have 90% of the comments being about the manga.
I mean, we're giving the manga readers a safe haven on r/anime where they can endlessly discuss how they feel about the ending of the manga, which causes most anime-onlies to not even open the threads on r/anime anymore, so I was thinking, perhaps they should do the same; I feel like we're doing a lot for them, but they aren't doing anything for us.
So if this collab works out, r/manga could create threads for anime onlies, where we anime fans could go to discuss the anime, and the r/manga mods would deal with any manga readers who'd come into those threads to talk about the manga (because obviously, the r/manga threads would be strictly anime discussions, like the r/anime threads are - almost - strictly manga discussions).
It could solve the problem of anime-onlies feeling like they don't really have a place to discuss the anime without stumbling upon dozens of comments from manga readers (most of which AT LEAST 'spoil' the hype for the series, if nothing else).
And I really don't know if there is a more logical solution than "Anime fans posting about it on r/manga and manga fans posting about it on r/anime".
Though perhaps I'm simply missing something obvious, so if someone can come up with something more logical than that, please tell us!
5
u/cppn02 Aug 07 '26
Since I just encountered this, is there any way to loosen the title length requirement for clips? I don't see any reason why the title couldn't just be a poignant single word descriptor + the show's name.
5
u/Ashteron Aug 11 '26
Reddit bot issuing automatic warnings on a fiction subreddit for describing fiction is certainly something.
5
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Aug 15 '26
(I think I briefly talked about this with a mod in a random thread about comment faces, ages ago)
But I was thinking about that while reading a 3x3 comment in CDF, the thing that swaps themes every week (or is it month?);
It could be fun to have a few 'extra' categories of comment faces every season!
Like, one season we could have SeasonalScream (or SeasonalAngry), next season, SeasonalCute (or SeasonalKawaii to go full weeb), just a character/animal/etc looking adorable. We could have SeasonalLewd/SeasonalHorny (variations of our current #lewd), things like that!
I think it would achieve two things:
There's been some grumbling lately about comment faces being a bit 'generic' (always the same thing/theme, like 'approval' is a random thumbsup 90% of the time, confusion is just swirly eyes sometimes with questions marks on the background, cool is just whoever in sunglasses, shock is whoever with big eyes/open mouth, etc)...
Some extra categories that would rotate every season could spice things up a little, on top of getting people to save more 'special' (non-generic) faces for this purpose, and these faces could even end up being used for other categories, like maybe someone saves a cute animal but turns out it looks kinda smug so it gets the seasonalsmug face.
Food for thought!
5
u/Verzwei Aug 25 '26
Extremely minor nitpick, but probably don't source the Anime of the Week screenshots/thumbnails from other websites. This one looks like shit because it's 1200x630 and has an anime news network watermark on the bottom of it.
5
u/Kenalskii https://anilist.co/user/Kenalski Sep 01 '26
The /r/anime Awards category host applications are now open! If you are curious please check out the post in the subreddit
12
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Aug 16 '26
You know how the comments are like in the Oshi No Ko key visual. I really feel the comments are such a toxic environment. It's just people bitching about how the manga ended.
Even if they don't outright say what the spoilers are any anime-only can figure out and read between the lines. Then you have people in the comments debating the ending of CSM vs. Oshi no Ko. Which is super off-topic.
The discussion threads are good at keeping a space super strict for anime-onlies. I think in these key visual threads the same respect should be there. Any anime-only going into today's key visual is just asking to be spoiled.
4
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Aug 02 '26
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/wiki/index/ no longer loop reloads on my phone, so they finally fixed it or it's a side-effect of getting a new phone with a fresh chrome install (and all my chrome flags got wiped)
4
u/D3k4s Aug 05 '26
This has probably been suggested already. But how about letting fans show off their weeby Anime collection? A bit unrelated but i got the ideia from r/tankporn they allow users to show their collection (Shells, miniature etc) like once a month (I think).
4
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Aug 28 '26
The start of summer (initial post) and end of spring (initial post) survey threads should probably have their flair changed to Survey to match others like the winter one.
10
u/Puddo x3https://anilist.co/user/STPuddo Sep 04 '26
I'm just here to say fuck Animehunch (and CBR) and their pathetic clickbait headlines and selective quoting from interviews and articles from places that actually put in the work. It feels like every time I see a post from them on this sub the headline can have some "West/woke = bad" or "the sky is falling" reading when the actual content doesn't match that. It's the same shit over and over and the world would be better without them. Especially when a lot of people only read headlines. Mods rightfully removed a Cartoon Brew article post a few days ago when the OP changed the headline to some ragebait garbage, but I wish we could also hold websites that want our clicks to some standard. They know what they're doing.
6
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Aug 02 '26
Just to bring up the news here in a fresh meta thread, the new seasonal faces have changed over. You can see them all on the wiki page. Or this image here.
#hattastichas been added as the seasonal hall of fame face for winter.6
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Aug 12 '26
It's kinda funny seeing how downvoted any mushoku tensei thread gets, either previews or the episode discussions. But I want to know, is it stubbornly persistent users doing it or the work of automation? Because it happens within minutes of posts going up.
3
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Aug 06 '26
Are clip limits 2 in a given month or 2 in the time period of a month? Eg this user has posted 3 in 8 days but the month rolled over during that period. https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vh1nqv/12_more_minutes_of_drunk_lesbian_yuri_botan/
3
u/mr_beanoz https://myanimelist.net/profile/splitshocker Aug 08 '26
Was this a bug, or was it an actual new episode?
3
u/zairaner https://myanimelist.net/profile/zairaner Aug 08 '26
Ribbon hero movie discussion seems to be missing.
3
u/baquea Sep 02 '26
For some reason the anime of the week thread for Saki from three weeks ago is currently pinned, rather than this week's one
5
u/ptd163 Aug 05 '26
https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vfjfbl/emilia_and_rem_having_a_fun_time_getting_drunk/
https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vfcqri/a_love_confession_rezero_s4/
There was no issue with this posts. It's not a good look mods. It's going to be even an even worse look if we find out that ZaphodBeebblebrox is an Apothecary Diaries fan.
5
u/Meem0 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Meem0 Aug 09 '26
https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1vjqrlp/when_the_animators_really_really_really_really/
My original post of this got removed because it didn't meet the 60 second requirement for video edit posts; I had to add a few extra seconds at the start with the crowd cheering. It's a video edit rather than a clip, because I spliced together two clips to cut out some dialogue.
A mod informed me that there has been debate over whether posts like mine could fall under a different category than video edit and not be subject to the 60 second requirement.
I'm not super active on this sub so don't have a big stake in this but just wanted to raise the point for consideration. Personally I think my post is closer to a clip than an edit, but I understand that it could be difficult to precisely distinguish it from "20 seconds of Shizuka noises compilation." It just would have been a shame if the scene were a little shorter and I couldn't post it without including a cut to dialogue.
5
u/Nebresto Aug 20 '26
I propose extending the '1 week currently airing clip rule' to also apply to clips that are directly referenced in the latest episode.
Its a pretty good way to get inadvertedly spoiled, either via a direct reference in the post title, or the OP simply only tagging it up to S1, while users in the thread will likely be discussing up to S3 due to the obvious relevance.
2
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Sep 04 '26
No thread for Cocoon which is airing in NA this weekend.
2
u/Asurerain https://anilist.co/user/Asurerain Sep 05 '26
Post rules question : Under which format should I post the teaser for this mysterious anime announcement : https://x.com/_OverOrder/status/2095814137834287178, should I just post the link to the twitter post ? I tried posting the video and linking to the original post but I was removed.
It has been relayed by Anime Corner if you want an English post : https://x.com/animecorner_ac/status/2095821524406026614
2
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Sep 05 '26
How does the NSFW tagging rule works for clips that are mostly SFW?
For an example: Say I want to make a 1 minute clip that's SFW except these two shots.... Does it need to be tagged NSFW?
I'm asking because I'd rather avoid having a NSFW tag (and have people assume it's just horny shit, when it's not) but these shots happen in the middle of the clip so can't really make the clip without them.
4
u/MathRockEnjoyer420 Aug 05 '26
Thank you mods for preventing the constant Re:Zero spam everyday!
2
u/reg_panda Aug 25 '26
Hey! Can you elaborate what you mean by the rule of
? My M.O. is usually: if I don't want to keep a conversation with someone, I tell them, I tell them I will block them, I wait for their reply then I block them. Is that not okay?
2
u/detarameReddit https://myanimelist.net/profile/qTqTdetarameMAL Aug 02 '26
I'm sad that False Memory (Jiyi Guanli Ju) will not be talked about on this subreddit, but you know, that is how it is for donghua. I cannot really complain. Anyway, 2 hours left until the show starts. Hopefully there will be some place on Reddit where I can discuss the episodes.
Donghua aside, I'm interested to see how the new comment sorting will affect comment quality.
0
u/jaroniscaring Aug 02 '26
Could we get an episode discussion thread for False Memory? Cause holy shit I want to talk about it with someone
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment