r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Sep 22 '21
Episode Star Wars: Visions - Episode 1 discussion
Star Wars: Visions, episode 1: The Duel by Kamikaze Douga
Rate this episode here.
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | ---- |
| 2 | Link | ---- |
| 3 | Link | ---- |
| 4 | Link | ---- |
| 5 | Link | ---- |
| 6 | Link | ---- |
| 7 | Link | ---- |
| 8 | Link | ---- |
| 9 | Link | ---- |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
1.5k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 22 '21
Star Wars Lore Corner
Please be careful about Star Wars spoilers in general and tag them appropriately. We know some things out there are general pop culture knowledge but remember, as with anime not everyone's seen the Star Wars films and shows!
The entire show came out at once and all the previews were vague about how much any episodes connected to the rest of the Star Wars universe, so: if there's some deep Legends or Clone Wars or Mandalorian reference you spotted that you want talk about in detail, this is the place to put it.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
248
u/Mrflapjack123 Sep 22 '21
I feel like out of all the episodes in this series, this one has the highest chance of putting a smile on George Lucas's face.
200
u/spectre15 Sep 22 '21 edited Sep 22 '21
When the sith rose from the platform and that music kicked in, I got serious goosebumps. Not even 7 minutes in and it’s already amazing.
126
u/_irf4n_ Sep 22 '21
Honsetly, this animation style would totally fit the art for Vagabond if they decided to adapt it.
125
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
Lmao back when Star Wars Rebels was airing, I was complaining so much about the Inquisitors Spinny lightsaber lmao.
Now here I am enjoying the umbrella / rhongomyniad lance like lightsaber hue hue.
That being said, the CG looks great and the katana lightsaber was badass.
Funnily enough, I'll be watching this in dub. I watch like 99.9% of my stuff in subs, so this will be interesting. I tried sub, but it's so strange to see Star Wars content with Japanese voices hehe. I'll watch the sub after watching all the dubs anyways.
Good start, good start.
232
u/Mage_of_Shadows Sep 22 '21
I'm Merry Poppins ya'll
Not just the women and children, but the men too!
This episode had some wacky flow, but the designs are were great. Heavy Mustafar vibes in that river as well. Not sure about red crystals warding off evil though.
442
u/Csting Sep 22 '21
There's no regular English subtitle option available available to pair with the Japanese audio only one for the hearing impaired. Guess it was beyond Disney capabilities! Oh well they are only a small indie company better cut them some slack. /s
94
u/Throwaway021614 Sep 22 '21
Rebels: man, helicopter lightsabers are so ridiculous. This is such a kids’ show!
Visions ep1: sith mary poppins. Sign me up!
256
u/jkphantom9 Sep 22 '21
I like how much of this episode was like an Akira Kurosawa movie, which George Lucas took partial inspiration from when making Star Wars. We’ve come full circle
149
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Sep 22 '21
Love the minimal coloring, makes the lightsabers stand out even more.
Big samurai aesthetic to this one overall, calling back to the things that were inspiration for Lucas in the first place.
67
u/Theinternationalist Sep 22 '21
I liked the ambiguity. We never learn if the main character is a Sith, or if he was a Jedi with a red saber. We never learn how many Sith there really are. We never learn if he just wanted the crystal, or if that was a lucky bonus.
I've watched the first 2.5 episodes so far (still got a ways to go on Twins) but really liked this episode the most so far!
185
u/DadAsFuck https://anilist.co/user/DadAsFuck Sep 22 '21
that katana lightsaber is so badass
208
u/invaderzz https://anilist.co/user/invaderzz Sep 22 '21
This was made by the same studio that did the CGI jojo OPs. No wonder it was so good
76
u/R6Smurf001 Sep 22 '21
The “good guy” not being a Jedi was pretty cool subverted all my expectations and I like that
71
u/Zhawk1992 Sep 22 '21
My only complaint is that the episodes aren't longer :)
35
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Sep 22 '21 edited Sep 22 '21
Oh my god this is so fucking cool. I haven't really seen any Star Wars related media since the Clone Wars animated series but I think this might reignite my love for the franchise. Die hard fans of the franchise would probably bitch about it but I absolutely love the umbrella lightsaber that Lady Sith uses. And I absolutely love the twist of the Samurai "Jedi" using a red katana lightsaber which turns out he was collecting the kyber crystals which probably means he's a Sith hunter.
And just the overall vibes of this was amazing! Having an anime Star Wars doing a Kurosawa homage really just brings it all back into a full circle. I love it!
28
u/lord_ne Sep 23 '21
Holy shit, seeing him pull out a red lightsaber and be all like "unfortunately, I'm not a Jedi" was so amazing
63
u/hopefullythisworksd Sep 22 '21
should we have star wars knowledge before watching this?
30
u/drmageep Sep 22 '21
Major Samurai Champloo vibes from this one, especially the waterfall part. So cool
11
u/Amaran345 Sep 22 '21
Loved this short, everything was entertaining as hell, the mix between japanese samurai village style and star wars was perfect, Ronin was badass (yet vulnerable), the bandit leader was interesting and scary, 10/10 for me
9
u/Titchlet Sep 22 '21
Full thoughts on all episodes here. I really liked this episode. There are much better episodes and the more "grounded" feel to it was broken with the umbrella lightsaber but in general it's almost the perfect episode 1.
Overall, one of the better episodes 👍
7
u/kuddlesworth9419 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kuddlesworth Sep 22 '21
Seven Samurai vibes from this one.
7
u/FireRifle64 https://myanimelist.net/profile/FireRifle64 Sep 22 '21
THis is my 2nd fav of the Star Wars visions. I love the black and white film style and the green/blue lights scattered kinda trick the member into thinking the MC is a Jedi. But the reveal of the red saber got me freaking hyped.
24
u/CaptThunderThighs Sep 22 '21
Seeing a muted, mostly black and white CG with an old samurai movie film grain and feel scratched an itch I didn't know I had. I started with the Trigger short and came back to this one to go in order, and having watched The Twins in dub, I'm glad I made the switch to Japanese. Star Wars has never been great on dialogue and trying to make a translation fit on top of that felt too campy.
The biggest thing I see as a drawback with these shorts, is that, while Star Wars lore rules are well established, the longest of all of these is 23 minutes, and that just feels too short to cram a standalone story into. The Duel felt like an appropriate length, accurately conveying the wandering samurai they were going for, which intrinsically doesn't need as much development as other characters. I've got a whole day to burn, so I'll be ripping through them all today and checking back in as the threads come out
9
u/kllrnooooova Sep 22 '21
All of this episode was cg right? If so, that's some good cg
9
u/chartingyou Sep 22 '21
The animation for this was so good. Also I love the things they did -- stopping the lightsaber with the force, the way the waterfall was parted, him collecting lightsaber crystals. It was very creative from what I've seen from the star wars universe plus I love the homage to older japanese cinema.
4
u/Doomroar https://myanimelist.net/profile/Doomroar Sep 22 '21
Can someone explain me why or how NatGeo ended involved in a Starwars Anime anthology?
4
u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Sep 23 '21
Jackpot, a whole stack of companion cubes!
Dude. Force vs. lightsaber reinterpretation of the "catching a blade between your hands" trope. Fucking bad ass!
Oh man, now I'm excited, this is great
4
u/The_Draconic_Dragon Sep 23 '21
I really want to find anime with a similar at style do if anyone has one they'd like to recommend please let me know! 😁
11
u/conscious_terabot https://anilist.co/user/ConsciousBot Sep 22 '21
I know absolutely nothing about Star Wars. Like absolutely nothing. Haven't watched a single piece of media related to that ever. Can this be a starting point? Can I watch this?
4
u/Kmlkmljkl :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kmlkmljkl Sep 22 '21
i loved the sparse use of color.
6
u/Ginger_Anarchy Sep 22 '21
Choosing a Kurosawa homage to be the first episode was the perfect choice.
2
u/_MIKE_HAWKE_ Sep 22 '21
Has anyone noticed how similar it looked to the movie "yojimbo"? This ep was lit af
2
u/Pinecone :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/camph Sep 23 '21
This episode was straight brilliant. I loved the art, the animation, the storyline, the characters, and how it utilizes (lightly) Star Wars lore. I loved all the homages to old Samurai films. The classic wandering hero passing through a town. Even the guards in this episode were interesting. Gotta love a katana lightsaber that's always on and is placed into a sheath. Fantastic start to the series.
A+
2
u/AHappyMango Sep 23 '21
Great animation.
But pretty whelmed by it all. I guess these happen to be two things that don't exactly mix well together, imo.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
Watching in Japanese>>>> definitely some great talent in the seiyuu lineup. That first episode with the vagabond references was great.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21
Liked the artstyle, but the main plot was really generic
3
u/ThisOneTimeAtLolCamp Sep 22 '21
That was fucking awesome.
If the other 8 are as good as that then holy shit. I know what my morning is going to be spent doing.
2
u/ennma_ https://anilist.co/user/ennma Sep 22 '21
I feel like I'm a minority here but... I have mixed feelings about the visuals On light saber scenes they were fantastic, but on normal ones it was kind of confusing to know what was happening
1
u/wantsaarntsreekill Sep 22 '21
Just starting the series. As someone who has watched a lot of anime and has seen all of star wars including the clone wars and rebels, i do find visions harder to recommend than the clone wars and rebels, even to anime fans.
1
u/maxman14 Sep 22 '21
I really like the twist regarding the wanderer's identity. Made this short much more interesting as a result.
1
u/BLACKOUT-MK2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/DelayedLaserBoom Sep 22 '21
I spent most of this episode thinking 'Damn, that is sick as shit'. I'd love a full series just following on from this episode.
1
u/shockwave1211 Sep 22 '21
That was really cool, the style and animation were really good for 3d, and i love the japanese spin on the star wars music
1
u/CookItOff Sep 22 '21
I want to add to my previous post, that all these episodes are beautiful beyond belief and these Japanese studios have more than exceeded my expectations. 🤘🏻
1
u/MilkAzedo Sep 23 '21
my headcanon is that ronin guy was a ex-jedi that turned darkside to hunt siths
1
u/DrewRodez Sep 23 '21
I loved all of the aurebesh written like katakana. it works so well
1
u/superp2222 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/superp2222 Sep 23 '21
I love the art style on this episode, really made it feel like one of those Ronin stories.
Also, death by umbrella sounds pretty harsh
1
u/FruitsPnchSamurai Sep 23 '21
the first ep was the best.
1
u/jamesisarobot Sep 23 '21
I'm sure this is going be fantastic
1
u/FranoFiasco Sep 23 '21
If only Blade of The Immortal was animated in this style.
1
u/Hackmanite_Ultra Sep 23 '21
SHOULD I WATCH IT SUB OR DUB I NEED TO KNOW!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
Why is it whenever sith fights sith, it's one of the most bad ass fights in all of Star Wars. (I'm looking at you Maul and Opress vs Sidious)
1
u/platysoup Sep 23 '21
This is pretty much Star Wars Kenshin.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
this is truly the collaboration we needed. Anime is the perfect medium for star wars, they can be as ridiculous as they want and ill still eat it up. Honestly this is the most hype ive been for star wars in a long time.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21
that was def R2D2, right?
1
u/IVIaskerade :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IVIaskerade Sep 24 '21
I think this is my favourite out of all of the episodes just for its use of colour. It's gorgeous.
1
u/vanteal Sep 24 '21
So, is Disney allowing these episode's to be cannon in any way? Or did they do this as a cash cow project?
1
u/frostxc3 Sep 24 '21
Hats off to the production team for this episode. Animating this art style looks like a lot of hard work and they did a spectacular job. Hope they were compensated adequately as well.
1
u/kermadac Sep 24 '21
This was amazing, the black and white stylized cgi was really neat. The umbrella lightsaber cracked me up though.
1
u/updateman Sep 25 '21 edited Sep 25 '21
(Beam Katana Chronicles intensifies)
Is anybody going to mention how cool it was when she used the log to split the waterfall and how the ronin took advantage of her bloodlust using the Buddha statue?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '21
Best episode
1
u/Gvaz Oct 12 '21
This was pretty decent. I hated the saber umbrella though
1
u/Vatican87 Oct 24 '21
Wait, after the first episode why did this series go downhill.
1
u/floodychild Oct 25 '21
Loved the art and visual style of this episode. Got me hyped for the whole series
1
u/IndependentMacaroon Nov 07 '21
So... we have a proper not-Japanese ronin, really near-indistinguishable, heroically saving an exploited village from an evil not-black woman with afro, bell-bottoms and all, in the style of a classic samurai film, slaying her in some kind of temple (?) while traditional Japanese music plays. Japanese nationalism (racism, sexism) strikes again. To be fair that boy also looked black. but then his dad was just lazing around and sleeping through the whole thing, which is a racist stereotype in itself.
1
u/healyxrt Jan 30 '22
This was my favorite one so far, because it has exactly what I was hoping for from Star Wars anime: good quality fight scenes and a simple concept
1
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
Can I watch this with minimal knowledge of star wars?
1
u/ChiggaOG Sep 22 '21
This series is lit. Japanese animation works very well to make Star Wars a samurai saga.
1
u/Jon_Anime Sep 22 '21
Not an Star Wars fan at all but definitely an anime fan. I know it's a hard question but in general, is this for me? I see there is lots of different anime styles along the episodes and I absolutely love it. But, apart from The Mandalorian, I havent heard or seen good things about Star Wars in ages. Without even knowing if it's good or bad and with SW not being my usual cup of tea, can I enjoy those bits to the fullest?
-7
u/Madao16 Sep 22 '21
It was okay and it didn't make me want to watch rest of the episodes.
-3
u/Idaret Sep 22 '21
concept arts made into short animation, pretty meh
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
[removed] — view removed comment