r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Sep 22 '21
Episode Star Wars: Visions - Episode 5 discussion
Star Wars: Visions, episode 5: The Ninth Jedi by Production I.G
Rate this episode here.
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | ---- |
| 2 | Link | ---- |
| 3 | Link | ---- |
| 4 | Link | ---- |
| 5 | Link | ---- |
| 6 | Link | ---- |
| 7 | Link | ---- |
| 8 | Link | ---- |
| 9 | Link | ---- |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
737
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 22 '21
Star Wars Lore Corner
Please be careful about Star Wars spoilers in general and tag them appropriately. We know some things out there are general pop culture knowledge but remember, as with anime not everyone's seen the Star Wars films and shows!
The entire show came out at once and all the previews were vague about how much any episodes connected to the rest of the Star Wars universe, so: if there's some deep Legends or Clone Wars or Mandalorian reference you spotted that you want talk about in detail, this is the place to put it.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
245
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
Easily the best one. This honestly felt like a pilot to a show, it was fresh and new but had the unshakeable star wars DNA.
212
u/Tehoncomingstorm97 https://anilist.co/user/tehoncomingstorm97 Sep 22 '21
I love the premise of this episode, that there's one final sabersmith left, and he's trained his daughter how to fight with a lightsaber. It makes the fight scene at the temple much more believable - as the sith who show up have likely not used a lightsaber, and so Juro and Kara have the advantage. And the fight sequence was just epic in itself.
187
u/Samuawesome :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EroMangaFan Sep 22 '21 edited Sep 22 '21
Came for Simu Liu, stayed for the cool lightsaber fight x droid chase.
Also, what a plot twist lol.
165
u/mayateka Sep 22 '21
I wish this short would get a part 2
164
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
I loved the idea that light saber color depend on the force of its user, and how blade color get more solid as its user grow in the force.
Too bad its not canon
175
u/Mage_of_Shadows Sep 22 '21
Another wipe transition!
This was probably the closest to both Star Wars and the most a studio has stuck to their classic artstyle. The episodes are becoming more closer to feeling like a fully fledged anime?
75
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Sep 22 '21
Goddamn! I can't believe they got me with this one! The entire episode I was already expecting the obvious trap especially when they showed the Margrave's mask and the very imposing giant droid watching the temple. Like they definitely looked like bad guys! But that twist! I was kinda expecting at least one of them is going to backstab the others but I didn't expect that six of them were Sith! And the twist doesn't even stop there! Apparently one of them is the Margrave's spy and his lightsaber even turned back into purple which was pretty awesome.
And as far as MCs goes, I already love Kara! Her fight against that Jedi hunter was already sick but that scene where her lightsaber turns from grey to green was so cool! This does not feel like a short at all! It seems that Production IG might've made this as a pilot for a future Star Wars anime and I definitely wouldn't mind if it actually becomes one! Come on Lucasfilms! I know you have your social media people browsing through these comments, make this a real thing! I neeeed an entire season of The Ninth Jedi.
68
u/Ginger_Anarchy Sep 22 '21
I would love a full series based around this short. It has some really unique ideas for Star Wars, but feels like its own fleshed out concept.
45
u/drmageep Sep 22 '21
Holy SHIT that was awesome! Idk why but it gave me heavy Bebop/Avatar vibes. The 1st episode was unfairly cool but this is definately my 2nd favorite so far
42
u/HenchHinch Sep 22 '21
Once I saw Production I.G was doing the ep I knew it was going to be good. The whole ep had incredible action sequences and fights.
This episode felt the closest to the normal series so far.
42
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
Is no one talking about the rocket trebuchet?
83
u/morgoth834 :IG: Sep 22 '21
This was easily my favorite episode. It was, perhaps, the most Star Wars-esque of all the shorts but was also very unique. I also loved the designs and the action was great.
37
u/PeachyCoke https://anilist.co/user/PeachyCoke Sep 22 '21
This episode was probably the most similar to a typical anime in terms of style and composition, but that is far from a bad thing when it's this good. I really liked the concept of the lightsabers changing color, as that is a fantastic way to visually represent internal changes in a character, and with it important story moments. Kara's lightsaber turning green was a big moment for her and the episode. It represented her finally becoming strong enough in the Force. The beast guy's lightsaber turning back to purple was AWESOME and made my jaw drop! We got to see another vapaad user, and specifically one get consumed by the dark side in real time. I was geeking out so hard after that!
Also, I need more Kara in my life. Everybody out here talking about Sith waifus and I'm over here wanting more cute anime girls with side tails, nice fathers, and green lightsabers.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
Best one so far!
23
u/Bad_Doto_Playa Sep 23 '21
There are several great things about this one and only 1 thing I had an issue with (and that's a feat for my cynical ass).
Firstly, and I think most would agree, the concept of light sabers changing colour as well as shape depending on who was wielding them is great. It also makes complete sense that he had asked the saber smith to temper them that way because..
Secondly I liked the setup for Kara as well as, they flat out state she has had lightsaber training (likely from Juro) and this explains her fighting ability.. unlike a certain other person. There are also a few cool moments in the fight, like her attacking the dude with the blue saber at the beginning, because she assumed he would just get in the way or die (and her judgements was right). Not to mention she still couldn't compete with Juro's apprentice (I assume?) since he was pretty much doing a 2v1 himself with her and the other dude, which makes sense.
The only thing I didn't like with the fight was her doing strength battles with the big guy, seemed a bit silly, especially since she went full agile mode on the last one.
Thirdly, the way Sith are handled in this is quite different from their usual depictions. Due to the rule of two, Sith are destined to betray their masters(or vice versa) but in this they are actually comrades and clearly care for each other. This could make losses on either side feel more emotional and less "EVIL LOSE" than typically found in star wars, especially since the dark side isn't inherently evil. Additionally, since they said they are acolytes, it seems that the Sith have done away with the rule and are trying to rebuild the Sith order as well (or it's there, either is fine). What this ultimately does is setup the Jedi/Sith War again BUT this time the roles are reversed (as the Sith are the ones with power in the galaxy), and that's a really interesting place to start a new series from.
Lastly because she was still living with her father until recently (Jedi are separated from a very young age to remove attachments) there's an opportunity for her to become tempted by the dark side or have her the poster child to prove that you don't need to give up everything to be a Jedi.
All in all, this was by far the best episode and I they get to tell their own AU story (in fact the main story could have been written by these dudes tbh, the new trilogy is just... lmao).
21
u/MurderousPaper :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MurderousPaper Sep 22 '21
Easily the standout episode for me, which is highly surprising considering I went into the show expecting Trigger’s shorts to be my favorites. Apart from what everyone else is saying, the music was beyond phenomenal — on par with the films IMO.
It’s pretty amazing how well the writers fleshed out the main cast in the limited runtime of the episode. The other episodes did great jobs too, but The Ninth Jedi was something else.
17
u/hatstraw27 Sep 22 '21
Fuck only 27 comments for one most star-wars like episodes, where y'all star wars fan at huh ??
27
u/dreamphoenix Sep 22 '21
This one felt like a finished episode one of the series compared to all others which were rather self sufficient. Def would watch the show.
11
u/Bonvantius Sep 22 '21
The production value was so good on this one. Especially love the meaty blows of the lightsaber hits.
10
u/FreshNothing Sep 22 '21
Best one so far!
10
u/MumblingGhost Sep 22 '21
I like the idea of lightsabers changing color depending on who is holding them as it allows some interesting visual storytelling.
10
u/Titchlet Sep 22 '21
Full thoughts on all episodes here. This is 100% the best episode. I genuinely want a full series of Kara's journey and growth.
Production I.G never disappoint, it was flawless.
9
u/electricoomph Sep 22 '21
Kara's moves on the frozen lake were smooth af.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '21
Can we please get more of this?!
6
u/desaan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/desaan Sep 22 '21
A full season of this one yes please
6
u/Neverx_13 Sep 22 '21
Holy fuck this was amazing, that plot twist was great
6
u/NotMCherry Sep 22 '21
This looks more like a pilot episode than most pilot episodes, looks like they were trying to convince disney to give them a full series. I would love to see how the sabers would interact with different people as the forger said, looking different and stuff, I was kind of disappointed that all the red sabers looked the same
6
u/superp2222 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/superp2222 Sep 23 '21
Seeing Kana's saber turn green in the heat of battle makes this fight so badass. Also love the plottwistception going on this episode
5
u/FireRifle64 https://myanimelist.net/profile/FireRifle64 Sep 22 '21
This was my most favorite one. Production IG designs were so good and the fighting was great. I loved how the trap became a trap for the Sith. I liked the whole lightsabers changing color based on the person. So, we have the one Sith slowly turn to purple b/c he went too much to the Sith.
5
u/MisoRamenSoup Sep 22 '21
Biggest studio in the list doesn't disappoint. It worked far better than the others I've seen so far. Had a nice simple plot that worked and looked great,felt like star wars. The sort of quality you'd expect from Kamiyama.
Everyone was hyping Trigger, knew this would be the standout though.
5
u/bobsjobisfob :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bobsjobisfob Sep 23 '21
damn best episode yet, i actually loved this one. when the concept of "lightsabers that change color based on the wielder" was brought up, i was like "PLEASE tell me that one of the 'jedi' pick it up and it turns red, and theyre just like 'oops, looks like my cover is blown'" but it turned out to be all six of them. i was expecting more a single imposter situation. i also liked the main character bait-and-switch. "oh, this boring nerd guy is our main character?" and then it focuses on kara for the entire episode. though i kind of wished that her lightsaber didnt turn the generic green color.
this is the first episode that makes me sad that this isnt a pilot for a new anime
4
u/Captain_Grimm Sep 22 '21
This one was so gooood, definitely my favorite out of the bunch.
4
u/suyaandsammie Sep 22 '21
This one was the best and I hope to see a full series!
4
u/Draffut https://anilist.co/user/Arekku Sep 22 '21
Hated how she didn't use the extrndo saber in combat, but I think it changed colors as she was fighting? That's cool.
4
u/BosuW Sep 22 '21
Man some of these are begging to be full seasons. DISNEY PLEAS!
4
u/NotMCherry Sep 22 '21
When they all their lightsabers on I screamed out loud, amazing momment, and its not like an empty plot twist like those done for the sake of shock only, it makes the second viewing much better
4
u/BlankHeroineFluff Sep 23 '21
I wish The Ninth Jedi actually became an anime series on its own. It was the best one of the Star Wars Visions shorts for me imo, that twist near the end was awesome. I really want to see Kara's growth as a fledgling Jedi while she tries to find her father.
4
u/Pinecone :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/camph Sep 24 '21
Can I just say
holy shit
This episode encompasses everything good about Star Wars Visions. Gorgeous visuals, perfectly complex storyline (without being predictable), breathtaking animations, and beautiful implementations of the Star Wars universe. You can argue it's canon/not canon but within the context of this episode the fact that the creators got to use lightsabers in this fashion was perfection.
Seeing Production I.G make an episode like this is no surprise. That speederbike chase through the forest and over ice, the multiple lightsabers being activated at once, and the final battles are exemplary. I think I'll give this episode an S grade.
13
u/leave1me1alone Sep 22 '21
This ep was a better version of the force awakens imo. This girl is a better version of Rey
3
u/VeryDesperateSoul Sep 22 '21
I loved this one, I'd say it is my fav ! It has this distinctive Star Wars vibe... could be canon
3
u/xtsim https://myanimelist.net/profile/xtsim Sep 22 '21
I only watched the First movie and was just OK with it but I love this episode alot. Production IG is on a roll with this one. I want a full season or movie or something on this....
2
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
The only reason why this episode doesn't seat on top for me is because I want an entire series for it ratjer than just one episode.
Same with Top & Ocho.
2
u/st0rmyc Sep 23 '21
Ok, I haven't finished all of them, but I'm going to leave it at #1 and #5 as the two best. The rest so far have put me to sleep. If they could expand upon both of those, then I would be happy.
2
u/Electric-Guitar-9022 Sep 25 '21
I thought that lightsaber color switching based on it's user was really cool
2
u/Syokhan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Syokhan Sep 26 '21
Okay, where do I sign for a full series of this with Kamiyama at the helm? That was freaking amazing.
2
u/liatris4405 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/liatris4405 Sep 26 '21
To be honest, I didn't really like Kamiyama's recent works, but this one was great. I felt the original Star Wars vibes in the way he switched scene and the battle scenes.
If this is as good as it gets, I can very much look forward to his Lord of the Rings anime.
1
u/Vsifsz Sep 22 '21
Best episode.
1
u/Meapcuteee Sep 22 '21
Best one so far
1
u/redblueberry1998 Sep 22 '21
Holy shit this actually felt like Star Wars. Really loved it and that twist actually got me lol.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21
Tf this part was actually really good. The best one so far.
1
u/jeremythecool Sep 23 '21
The best so far!!!
1
u/THExDANKxKNIGHT Sep 23 '21
I'm gonna need a whole series of this.
1
u/Fiztz Sep 23 '21
I've watched up to ep 6 and so far this is the only one I think is actually a good piece of media in its own right. They managed to tell a full story that was more than basic tropes wrapped in fan service and seemed to make a more true connection with the original films.
1
u/andsavs Sep 23 '21
Definitely want a part 2
1
u/Ltholland :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LtHolland Sep 24 '21
Best of all the shorts, if one could get a full-feature anime, this would be it.
1
u/Ryuuyami47 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkfiend47 Sep 24 '21
Best thing about Star Wars Visions........we get Star Wars Waifus!!!
But seriously all of these eps have been so good, unique and fresh. This is the best one so far. This as close to a serious star wars anime episode as it gets. Just what I was expecting when I began this. The lightsaber fights were awesome, the plot and characters too were great. Not to mention some great twists all in just 20 mins.
Most ppl would have had high expectations since its Production IG and it definitely exceeded them. Would have liked a continuation and still wish there'd be a full fledged Star Wars Anime.
Regardless, on to the next!!
1
u/kermadac Sep 24 '21
Hands down the best one, it felt like a real Star Wars show and not just star wars flavored anime. I hope this becomes a series.
1
u/Satin_Jacket Sep 25 '21
100% needs to be made into an actual series. This one was so well done. The moment when the group of jedi's turn on their lightsabers and they're all red was such nice twist. Everything was on point this episode. 10/10
1
u/Gvaz Oct 12 '21
Not sure how I feel about lightsabers as mood rings, but it wasn't bad.
1
u/TerronScibe Oct 17 '21
I know Ep: 1 and 4 was awesome and are also my favorites; yet it's Episode 5 that felt like Star Wars. I really want to see more fresh lore- and in in this Animation!
1
u/floodychild Oct 25 '21
How she was slipping on the ice was such a cool visual.
1
u/CarbonFlight Oct 26 '21
GIVE US THE SHOW FOR THIS ONE BLEASE DISNEY
-3
u/kosuna Sep 22 '21 edited Sep 22 '21
WTF was that ending where the last standing Sith was like "whoops my bad" im a friend now. Absolute bullshit scene that makes it 8/10 instead of a perfect 10. Best episode so far and I hope they choose this one for serialization