r/Anu • u/PlumTuckeredOutski • 23h ago
The AFR View - Universities are own worst enemies on independent governance
Nov 17, 2026 – 5.18pm
If the sector wants the government off its back and to demonstrate that Canberra’s regulatory overreach is intrusive and unwarranted, university governors must urgently get their own house in order.
For institutions tasked with educating the nation, Australian universities have increasingly made headlines over the past decade for a troubling inability to govern themselves properly.
Swinburne University of Technology is the latest tertiary institution to have fallen foul of basic institutional standards. As The Australian Financial Review’s Sumeyya Ilanbey and Maani Truu reported on Tuesday, the university’s deputy chancellor Anthony Mackay urged vice chancellor Pascale Quester to back chancellor John Pollaers before staff concerns about his behaviour and leadership were properly investigated.
It follows a confidential investigation launched by the Melbourne university into its workplace culture a year ago. The report found that a culture of fear and mistrust had festered in the institution’s highest echelons, alongside an undercurrent of disdain for Pollaers and the 12-member governing council. Current and former employees alleged the chancellor, who was appointed in 2019, frequently berated staff and asked them to perform tasks tied to his own interests. The investigation detailed that as many as nine employees had left the university after raising concerns about the chancellor.
It is not the first time Pollaers has drawn scrutiny. During his 2022 bid for the board of AGL Energy, he boasted of having “carried out 16 major company transformations during his career”. This was curious arithmetic given that, as Rear Window pointed out at the time, his own LinkedIn profile showed he had worked at just four companies across his entire executive career.
In the Swinburne investigation, Pollaers – who has repeatedly denied wrongdoing – was ultimately cleared after investigators found his conduct “in most cases” fell within the expectations of his remit. Yet in a seeming sign of dysfunction, the investigator’s report said Quester, the former vice chancellor, had told the inquiry she did not feel safe raising red flags for fear of retribution.
Toxicity at the university governing level will do little to repair a sector whose social licence has been wearing thin for years. The stewardship of the Australian National University under former chancellor Julie Bishop and former vice chancellor Genevieve Bell was marred by concerns over governance, internal culture and leadership. Both leaders were caught up in the backlash over a poorly executed cost-cutting exercise to save $250 million in the ANU budget.
“Universities are largely to blame for handing the government the ammunition for a regulatory crackdown.”
Discontent among staff fuelled accusations and scrutiny about opaque leadership appointments, excessive remuneration, the engagement of expensive consultants and a lack of transparency about the university’s true financial position. An unwanted consequence of the ANU leadership saga is that it opened the floodgates for the university regulator, the Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency, to intervene in the recruitment of a new chancellor. Normally, that responsibility lies with the university’s governing body.
Universities are largely to blame for handing the government the ammunition for a regulatory crackdown. Even for those wary of state overreach, it is little wonder that TEQSA feels compelled to tighten the screws on higher education. Alongside governance and reputational problems, public goodwill towards universities has been squandered across multiple fronts, from a failure to rein in campus antisemitism and eye-watering pay packets for vice chancellors and consultants, to the growing perception that institutions have become unmoored from the very raison d’être of higher education. That includes sidelining free thought, quality teaching, research and student experience in pursuit of lucrative international fee revenue and global research rankings.
TEQSA’s traditional role has been to register higher education providers, conduct compliance and quality assessments and accredit courses. But as Education Minister Jason Clare outlined at Tuesday’s TEQSA conference, Canberra is preparing to hand the regulator a much heavier stick. Upcoming reforms will empower the regulator to enforce threshold standards as a condition of registration, give it stronger powers to act on systemic risks to the sector, direct providers on how to fix breaches, and raise civil penalties of more than $2 million if universities fail to meet beefed-up governance standards.
But a top-down central planning approach is likely to corrode the autonomy, standing and ethos of universities and divert attention further away from their core mission. Handing Canberra the reins to micromanage campuses could create perverse new distortions such as infantilising university councils and dissuading universities from taking risks and innovating.
Rather than outsourcing oversight to federal bureaucrats, institutions need to focus on recruiting committed, talented, and competent leaders to their governance council and executive ranks.
If the sector wants the government off its back and to demonstrate that Canberra’s regulatory overreach is intrusive and unwarranted, university governors must urgently get their own houses in order. Upholding basic standards of transparency and probity in running their internal affairs is the bare minimum.