r/AskBaking • • 18d ago

Weekly Recipe Request Thread Monthly Recipe Request Mega-Thread!

3 Upvotes

If you're looking for a recipe, or need an alternative to one you've tried, this is the place to make that ask! This is also the place to ask for recipe ideas or ideas of what to make.


r/AskBaking • • 3h ago

General What to do with the results?

2 Upvotes

I do like to bake and struggle with time and making it a priority like others I am sure. I can follow a recipe and have a lot of fun cookbooks.

The question is what do I do with the finished product? Even if I cut the recipe in half I will have more baked goods than is healthy for me to consume.

How do others handle this situation? Do you share at the workplace? Does it make you nervous to share with coworkers? Any other ideas?


r/AskBaking • • 1h ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Should you bake a tres leches cake in Aluminum or Ceramic Pans?

Thumbnail
trangskitchentable.com
• Upvotes

I'm making a tres leches cake and the recipe calls for 9x13 but I only have aluminum catering pans and a ceramic dish in that size.

My concern with the aluminum is that you will be able to taste it especially after soaking, and it also has ridges that would make the cake hard to serve or remove.

My concern with the ceramic dish is that the sponge won't be able to grip (the recipe features whipped eggs). Also since the heat transfer/retention is worse would the rise be bad?

Note: the shapes of the pans are different so I can't just move the cake from the aluminum pan to the ceramic pan after baking.

Which is the lesser evil?

Edit: I can't bake with 2 smaller pans because it would be too hard to transport


r/AskBaking • • 23h ago

Bread Decoding grandma's magnum opus

Post image
56 Upvotes

Hi!

Going through my late grandmother's handwritten recipe cards and boy are they lacking details. Unfortunately this recipe doesn't have a common alternative that I've found so here's my description of the final product. We called it coffee cake but it's neither cake nor includes coffee. Imagine a rye bread consistency but sweet, with a creamy chocolatey swirl inside like a Swiss Roll cake.

I've put together all the clues from the various recipe cards and put them on one sheet.

Can you help me figure out the yeast and the butter?

2 yeast packets would be how many grams? What kind of yeast?

Do I use the butter in the bread dough or in the filling, using additional butter to spread over the dough before rolling?

Any help would be greatly appreciated !


r/AskBaking • • 2h ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream What type of frosting to use?

1 Upvotes

The situation: need to frost and decorate my daughter's birthday cake. 2 layer 8 inch with a 2 layer 2 inch as the 2nd tier. Was just going to do 2 batches of American buttercream but realized today I only have enough powdered sugar for a half batch.

Do I stretch half batch American buttercream as the filling and crumb coat then what powdered sugar free frosting would be good for the outer layer and piping decor?

Or if American buttercream is the best option for piping, what powdered sugar free frosting would be best as the filling, crumb coat, and outer frosted layer?

If it matters: the cake is a yellow chiffon with strawberry bits. Filling will also contain strawberries, either a frosting with some strawberry jam mixed in, or thin strawberry slices laid in.


r/AskBaking • • 10h ago

Ingredients Hershey kisses alternative

5 Upvotes

Hi I’m looking for something besides Hershey kisses to use this year for making reindeer treats.

I use the Snyder’s round pretzels, put a kiss in the center, put in the oven for a couple mins, and then put an m&m in the center.

These last two years the Hersheys kisses haven’t been melting and just turn very hard. Looking for something else that’s round that I can use that’s still tasted good


r/AskBaking • • 7h ago

Pie Chiffon Pie- replace French with Swiss meringue?

1 Upvotes

Every year for Thanksgiving I make a pie of my grandmas- it’s a pumpkin chiffon. I never think about it but this year I’m pregnant and it uses French meringue (uncooked) as a major part of the recipe. I’m wondering if I could replace the French meringue with a Swiss meringue. Would it negatively affect the texture? would I need to change the amount of sugar and egg whites used?


r/AskBaking • • 3h ago

Cookies could cinnamon stretch baking time?

0 Upvotes

my mom has a tried and true sequilho recipe (Brazilian shortbread cookie, would be my best description)

recipe is:

200g AP flour

200g potato starch

200g margarine/shortening

100g sugar

method: mix all ingredients, allow 1h rest, shape into 2cm balls and indent with a fork; bake for 15min at 350ºF

my conundrum: I made 3 batches today - plain, orange (with zest from 1 orange rubbed into the sugar) and cinnamon (2 tsp cinnamon added)

the first two baked perfectly; the cinnamon one won't set!!! it's been 30min and still soft

can someone offer ideas as to why?!? I'm utterly stumped...


r/AskBaking • • 7h ago

Macarons Macaron Batter Dry Ingredients

1 Upvotes

I live in India (its humid here) and I've made macarons multiple times but my batter turns out to be very clumpy. Mixing for more time only makes it stiffer. Ive tried the Preppy Kitchen recipe and all the others recipes I found were only a 5-10 g difference in ingridients. This time I used about 30% less dry ingridients and my macronage was closer to the "lava" consistency.


r/AskBaking • • 13h ago

Bread Why is the top of the banana bread not pretty and how to make it even?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/AskBaking • • 20h ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes How do you make a cake fall on purpose? Genuine question.

11 Upvotes

I'm aware it is an odd question, but it is genuine. My father's birthday is coming up, and he said that he wanted a "clunk cake". That is, he wants a normal cake that has fallen and become denser instead of rising.

I'm going to use box mix (Dark Chocolate Fudge from Duncan Hines)

Still, i'm more than a little worried, especially about the edges. Would slamming the tin on the counter help? Should I add something to the mix? Mom mentioned overstirring as something that could make cakes fall, but I've had batters that were mixed for half an hour and turned out fine!

Please, if you have any advice, it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you very much.


r/AskBaking • • 8h ago

Cookies I made these banana bread cookies. Why were the cookies baked for 3 minutes longer bland, while the cookies baked for less had a better banana flavor?

1 Upvotes

So I tried this recipe from Scientifically Sweet after someone posted about them in another subreddit, and because I had some bananas on the counter. I made them twice. Once a couple months ago, and just this week.

The first time I made them, I thought that they were so flavorless. But I had reduced the sugar in the recipe by I can't remember how much (because I prefer less sweet cookies), so I assumed that it was my fault.

I decided to try making them again but sticking to the recipe as is, which I did this week. The recipe says to bake for 10-12 minutes. I baked for 12. They were still so soft, like almost couldn't hold shape when trying to move them, even after cooling on the sheet for a few minutes. But I was lazy and starving and transferred them. The next cookies I flattened a bit and baked for 15 minutes.

The 12 minute cookies, after cooling a bit were fine. Definitely on the gooey side. The 15 minute cookies had the chewy texture from the title. But the 15 minute cookies were also so flavorless. I just got to the bottom of the cookie tin, to the last of the 12 minute cookies, and they don't taste super flavorful, but they do taste significantly more banana-y, and they have a great texture now.

I don't think I like this recipe enough to remake it again, but I'm just curious why those 3 minutes of baking resulted in different tasting cookies?


r/AskBaking • • 8h ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Baking temperature

1 Upvotes

Hello!! I’ve been trying to make a fruit cake loaf and I haven’t been able to get it right, my first attempt it was way overcooked and the last attempt I did it was undercooked, I have a fan assisted oven and the recipe says 160C/315F/Gas 3. I was told that was 140 for my oven but that’s seems quite low I think? These are the ingredients for the cake: 185g unsalted butter, 155g caster sugar, 4 eggs, 185g self raising flour, 60g plain flour, 260g mixed dried fruit, 100g glaze cherries, 125ml milk


r/AskBaking • • 8h ago

Pie Freezing pie

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone I will be traveling for thanksgiving and wanted to premake some dishes. I was wondering if I made an apple pie and froze it unbaked and traveled about 12 hours via car with the pie in a cooler with a lot of ice if the pie would stay froze and if the pie did thaw a little if that would impact texture once baked?
Any tips or suggestions for this scenario?

Also if I mixed up the pumpkin pie custard filling and froze it as well would that thaw out ok or would it be better to keep it refrigerated? If so, would it keep refrigerated for 2/3 days?
Thanks


r/AskBaking • • 11h ago

Ingredients Using dark rum essence

1 Upvotes

I'm planning on making a Banana Cake and Rum Caramel recipe (Goh and Ottolenghi), but because I can't legally buy hard liquor yet, the best option I have is using dark rum essence. How much should I use? The cake requires 2 tbsp and the caramel needs 1.5 tbsp.


r/AskBaking • • 22h ago

Ingredients Will Tapioca Starch work as a substitute for Cornstarch in Pudding cubes? “Snow Cubes” recipe included

Thumbnail
recipekeeperonline.com
6 Upvotes

(Reposting from r/baking) The Asian 85*F Bakery sold these delicious “Snow Cubes” coconut pudding once at my local location, but I haven’t seen them again in over a year.

I recreated them once using this recipe, but the cornstarch took forever to gelatinize (boil until it didn’t taste starchy), and the mixture got so thick that I ran out of arm muscle and had to get out a hand mixer—which was not a safe idea to do over a gas stovetop.

Fortunately, I survived but I am craving this recipe again… I heard that I could try substituting the cornstarch for half the amount of tapioca starch, as tapioca has a lower gelatinization and boiling point. However, the tapioca may not provide as much structure. Would it likely end up soupy, or can it form the cubes I desire?


r/AskBaking • • 13h ago

General How to keep the sour taste in baked goods while using baking soda?

0 Upvotes

I started baking banana bread using baking soda recently and I noticed it tasted different from how when I made it before when I didn't use baking soda. The kind of banana I use is quite acidic and I love the taste of it but it lost all acidity in the banana bread.

Can someone suggest something I could do to keep the acidity in my banana bread?


r/AskBaking • • 19h ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Christmas Tree Cake

1 Upvotes

Hi! I am making a 3d Christmas tree cake using 8 tiers of graduated rounds. The the largest is about 7.5 inches in diameter and about an inch thick. The smallest is 1 inch x 1 inch. Assembling with American buttercream. Do I need a center dowel and/or a cake board above a middle layer? I,ve stacked all the layers up to see it with just parchment in between. It looks pretty stable but I have to transport it. Any thoughts?


r/AskBaking • • 20h ago

Creams/Sauces/Syrups Am I the only beginner baker who's a little scared of whipped cream dispensers?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm still pretty new to baking, and so far I've only ever made whipped cream using a hand mixer.

I've seen people using whipped cream dispensers, and honestly, they kind of scare me. I know they're designed to be safe when used properly, but the thought of a pressurized canister suddenly bursting or exploding makes me nervous. 😅

I'm also not great with noisy kitchen appliances. Even the buzzing sound of a meat grinder makes me uncomfortable!

Are whipped cream dispensers actually safe and easy to use for beginners? Has anyone else felt a little intimidated before trying one?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Ingredients Mead in baked goods and Non-Alcoholic Replacement?

3 Upvotes

Hi all,

Every year at Thanksgiving I make these honey cakes. My wife and regular guests go nuts for them, the pan is awesome, the honey mead drizzle is great and very moist, etc. Mead is used in both the cake and the soaking syrup.

This year, however, my wife is pregnant, and I'm hyper concerned about the alcoholic content of both the cake and the soak. I still want to make them for her, because they're her favorite thing, but I've heard that not all the alcohol necessarily bakes or simmers out when you cook with it, so I'd like to replace it in both places.

- For the cake, the amount is very low (1/4 cup). I know baking is largely chemistry; will there be any issues if I replace this with like an apple cider? As in, is the alcohol needed to activate or do anything in particular?

- For the syrup, I'm less worried about the chemistry, but looking for good recommendations. I've looked at non-alcoholic meads, and I can mail-order them right now, or I can also go with a cider or some other juice, I think?

I know this is probably being overly cautious, and I think I already have my solutions, but I want to make double sure I won't mess up her favorite dessert!!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cookies Can I swirl caramel sauce into cookie dough?

10 Upvotes

Made some miso caramel sauce and I want to use it up. For some reason have become fixated on making a espresso chocolate chip cookie with a caramel swirl. From what I've been seeing, it looks like most caramel swirl cookies don't use a cooked caramel.

Wondering if anyone has had any luck with swirling caramel sauce into cookie dough? Or would it be best to freeze it and stuff the cookies instead?

Thanks for the help!


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Pie Making apple pie for the first time and realized I forgot to grab a lemon for the filling. Can I do without?

Post image
78 Upvotes

r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

General Need help plsss

0 Upvotes

I recently bought cocoa powder from a new brand and tried baking using some of my usual recipes but they just won’t cook. I tried to make a cake and some brownies using that cocoa powder but no matter how long I keep it in the oven it just won’t cook.
I have tried adding more flouring, blooming the cocoa powder and even tried new recipes but nothing works 😔


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Can I keep buttercream in the fridge for a couple of days?

1 Upvotes

Okay so for context, I have a birthday party on Saturday which is in 3 days. As much as I want to make the cake the night before, I'm doing evening shift on Thursday and Friday at work.

Now my question is; if I make the buttercream today, will it be okay if stored in a fridge for 2 days?

Only asking because I'm not sure if it can cause the buttercream to taste weird or any other negative side effect 🤔


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Cookies Do sugar sprinkles on shortbread cookies freeze well?

Post image
8 Upvotes

I made some short bread and wanted to freeze them to put it in cookie boxes during Christmas. Some of my cookies have these coloured sugar sprinkles. Any idea on how they freeze and if I defrost will they bleed? I currently have 3 cookies in the freezer to test try but still curious in advance lol

Update: I test froze 3 cookies in an airtight container overnight and defrosted them. They didn’t bleed!! I’m amazed