r/AskBaking • • 17d ago

Weekly Recipe Request Thread Monthly Recipe Request Mega-Thread!

3 Upvotes

If you're looking for a recipe, or need an alternative to one you've tried, this is the place to make that ask! This is also the place to ask for recipe ideas or ideas of what to make.


r/AskBaking • • 12h ago

Cookies Can I swirl caramel sauce into cookie dough?

6 Upvotes

Made some miso caramel sauce and I want to use it up. For some reason have become fixated on making a espresso chocolate chip cookie with a caramel swirl. From what I've been seeing, it looks like most caramel swirl cookies don't use a cooked caramel.

Wondering if anyone has had any luck with swirling caramel sauce into cookie dough? Or would it be best to freeze it and stuff the cookies instead?

Thanks for the help!


r/AskBaking • • 2h ago

General Need help plsss

1 Upvotes

I recently bought cocoa powder from a new brand and tried baking using some of my usual recipes but they just won’t cook. I tried to make a cake and some brownies using that cocoa powder but no matter how long I keep it in the oven it just won’t cook.
I have tried adding more flouring, blooming the cocoa powder and even tried new recipes but nothing works 😔


r/AskBaking • • 3h ago

Ingredients Mead in baked goods and Non-Alcoholic Replacement?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

Every year at Thanksgiving I make these honey cakes. My wife and regular guests go nuts for them, the pan is awesome, the honey mead drizzle is great and very moist, etc. Mead is used in both the cake and the soaking syrup.

This year, however, my wife is pregnant, and I'm hyper concerned about the alcoholic content of both the cake and the soak. I still want to make them for her, because they're her favorite thing, but I've heard that not all the alcohol necessarily bakes or simmers out when you cook with it, so I'd like to replace it in both places.

- For the cake, the amount is very low (1/4 cup). I know baking is largely chemistry; will there be any issues if I replace this with like an apple cider? As in, is the alcohol needed to activate or do anything in particular?

- For the syrup, I'm less worried about the chemistry, but looking for good recommendations. I've looked at non-alcoholic meads, and I can mail-order them right now, or I can also go with a cider or some other juice, I think?

I know this is probably being overly cautious, and I think I already have my solutions, but I want to make double sure I won't mess up her favorite dessert!!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Pie Making apple pie for the first time and realized I forgot to grab a lemon for the filling. Can I do without?

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/AskBaking • • 10h ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Can I keep buttercream in the fridge for a couple of days?

1 Upvotes

Okay so for context, I have a birthday party on Saturday which is in 3 days. As much as I want to make the cake the night before, I'm doing evening shift on Thursday and Friday at work.

Now my question is; if I make the buttercream today, will it be okay if stored in a fridge for 2 days?

Only asking because I'm not sure if it can cause the buttercream to taste weird or any other negative side effect 🤔


r/AskBaking • • 22h ago

Cookies Do sugar sprinkles on shortbread cookies freeze well?

Post image
7 Upvotes

I made some short bread and wanted to freeze them to put it in cookie boxes during Christmas. Some of my cookies have these coloured sugar sprinkles. Any idea on how they freeze and if I defrost will they bleed? I currently have 3 cookies in the freezer to test try but still curious in advance lol


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting First ever pavlova - trying for a softer more mashmallow-y interior and a slightly more structured crust

Post image
10 Upvotes

Overall very happy with this but the inside was really light and fluffy and I want a bit more chew/marshmallowy.

My aunt is also wanting the crust to be more....solid? It's quite light and melt-in-your mouth and she's looking for a bit more bite.

4 egg whites

220g caster sugar (would like to reduce)

1/2 tsp cream of tartar

Splash of vanilla

1 tbs corn starch

Sugar added in stages starting once tbe egg whites start getting foamy

Mix in cream of tarter and vanilla around medium-hard peak stage

Whip to hard peak

Fold in corn starch

Baking paper shaped

Preheat oven to 130°C no fan

Drop oven to 100°C no fan and bake 90mins (we dropped it to 95°C about halfway as we were worried it was browning)

Hit me with suggestions. Really want a SLIGHT chew to the inside.


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream SOS SMBC Help- What is this?

Post image
11 Upvotes

What are these tiny specks and dots showing up in my Swiss meringue buttercream? I’m guessing bits of egg white, but I have no clue why this is happening.

- They are tasteless. They just ruin the appearance, which is very important when decorating cakes.

- I constantly stir my egg whites and sugar when cooking. I also strain it before adding it to the mixer to catch any potential small egg pieces.

- I’ve been making smbc once a week for about three years and it’s only started happening in the past three weeks or so. It’s happened multiple times.

- I do occasionally hear some of the buttercream up in the microwave to help get the batch to a mixing consistency. But I do it in small intervals, I’ve done this for years, and there’s no way around this in the cold weather.

- The eggs and whites are not expired.

- It was fully warm and mixed, they aren’t cold bits of frosting.

I’m sure there are a bunch of things I’m forgetting to mention, but it’s none of the typical solutions. I feel like the answer has to be egg white pieces, but I have no idea why this is suddenly happening to me after making hundreds of batches of Swiss meringue buttercream. Please help!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Brownies/Chocolate Adding white chocolate to inside of brownies without melting them?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Im so lost on how to make white chocolate INSIDE brownies work.

I know for the top all I have to do is open the oven halfway then put the pieces on top the continue. But what if I want pieces inside the brownies?

I just put Ghirardelli brownies mix and a bunch of big white chocolate chunks into it then baked them on 325 for 50 minutes as recommended on the box. But the white chocolate came out tasting burnt and caramely? What do i do to make them stay sweet, not burned, but inside the brownies?

Im usint bakers white chocolate


r/AskBaking • • 21h ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Trying to write my own recipe for the first time. Date Tea Loaf spiced with Ginger and Cardamom. Here is V1 and V2.

2 Upvotes

Batter was same for both. I liked it; it was soft and tender and crumbly so I kept the batter quantities the same. It is 180g SR flour, 50g butter, 50g brown sugar, 2 eggs. I understand this is not conventional ratios for a tea loaf but it genuinely worked well for me. My consideration of not having too much sugar loaded with dates and steering away from something too rich and focusing on what a tea loaf is like helped.

The date and tea mix that is steeped before making the batter was as following:
V1:
150g dates
140ml strong black tea (1 tea bag)
1 tsp ground ginger
3 cracked green cardamom pods

Tasting Notes:
Strongly ginger-led and warm aroma. Tea lacked a maltiness, Cardamom didn't really come through and dates were too sparse. Felt this worked better as a non sticky ginger cake.

V2:
180g dates
170ml tea (2 tea bags)
1 tsp ginger
5 cracked green cardamom pods

Tasting Notes:
This time, the cardamom came through and was very floral. I got some feedback for this which, paraphrased, was "more dates" and "less tea". I made the mistake of increasing both volume AND concentration of the tea.

Plans for V3:
- I think I will focus on V1 and increase concentration of the tea by just brewing 140ml in 2 bags?
- I am unsure whether to increase the dates again or not. Did the dates feel scarce because the loaf wasn't densely packed with them, or because the high volume and concentration of tea washed them out (if you like)
- And how much ginger and cardamom, I don't want the ginger dominance to be replaced by dominance in another flavour. I want something that is a nicely integrated flavour profile.

My initial plan is
140ml tea - 2 bags
180g - 200g dates (I do not want to push too high and go into the lower bound of a fruitcake rather than a loaf)
1.5tsp (?) ginger
4 cardamom pods

Would love any advice on this


r/AskBaking • • 18h ago

Cookies Does anyone have experience vac sealing cookies?

1 Upvotes

I'm shipping some cookies/treats this holiday season. Should only take a few days to arrive, but we all know how hectic shipping is this time of year so it may take longer.

4 items: Rice crispy treats made with froot loops. Shortbread topped with peanut butter and dipped in chocolate. Typical chocolate chip recipe but with orange zest/cranberries ilo chocolate and glazed with orange juice/powdered sugar mix. Pistachio gooey butter cookies, which are a soft cake like cookie, very moist and somewhat delicate.

Vac sealing seems like a great way to keep them moist and protect from breakage or sticking together. Sticking together is a big concern. My vac sealer has a manual option so I'm not too concerned about smooshing them.

What I am concerned about is possibly locking in too much moisture and accidentally sending a moldy biohazard instead of delicious cookies.

Has anyone vac sealed cookies like this before? I know I can go the tedious route of plastic wrapping them in pairs instead if necessary.


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Ingredients Powdered Butter for Flavor?

Post image
178 Upvotes

I found several posts on using powdered butter as a substitute for ‘real’ butter, but has anyone used it to boost buttery flavor in cookies?

Sometimes butter extract tastes odd to me, so I’m curious! But I don’t want to commit to a tub of the stuff yet and was curious if it’s anyone’s secret ingredient.

Thanks!!!

EDIT: this is about using the powder as a flavor booster in addition to real butter, not in place of it! No apocalypse baking for me yet!!! I hope….


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Ingredients Do I absolutely need brown sugar for banana bread or will peasant (normal) sugar be sufficient ?

1 Upvotes

I am very new to baking and I only bake sponge cakes. I wanted to try something different so I looked up for banana bread recipes and all of them have brown sugar listed and I don't have brown sugar and I don't plan on buying any SO PLEASEEEE HELLPPP MEE!!!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Equipment What’s a good brand for a large electric tabletop oven for cookies & cakes?

1 Upvotes

Looking for a good electric oven for cookies & cake. It must fit at least a large cookie sheet. My oven is really bad and I can’t decide on a good oven

Any ideas?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Mini mandarin curd cheesecake

3 Upvotes

I'm going to make a layered sweet app that'll be 6cm tart filled with mandarin curd and topped with a basque cheesecake layer. There are really no recipes like this that I can find (I saw the original layered pastry on a bakery's social media and it was inside a danish), I was wondering if you guys had any tips on baking the basque cheesecake without completely killing the curd underneath. I know this could be a complete fool's errand, but any tips or tricks would be appreciated, thank you :)


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Cookies Matcha Powder Alternatives?

Post image
22 Upvotes

I regularly make matcha white chocolate cookies that ask for 1tbsp of matcha powder. What other kinds of powders/extracts can I use to switch things up? I’m already planning on making an ube one that uses ube jam. Thank you for any input!!!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes What adjustments should I make to time and/or Temperature?

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

New to this community but hopefully some here may be able to help. I have a tried and true Rich Christmas Cake recipe that I have made for well over 30 years as 1 large cake (8-9 inch square tin).

This year my the area I work in has had a major increase of people 5 2 years ago now around 16 and its a group that typically all do the buy gifts thing… I have decided I can’t afford to buy gifts for that number of people (without breaking the bank, or loo looking like Scrooge).

Anyway I have found silicon cake moulds for small individual cakes approx 4 x 2 inches. Just dont know how I should adjust baking time and/or Temperature to allow for the smaller individual cakes.

Original instructions call for 2-2.5 hours starting at 160 C for an hour then reducing to no less than 130 C for remaining 1 - 1.5 hours


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Custard/Mousse/Souffle What went wrong with my Flan?

Post image
9 Upvotes

My clan is done & is slightly wobbly in the center, but it came out with a puff in the upper middle which looks weird. I baked at 300F for about 75 minutes. I’m not sure what went wrong

Here is the recipe I used:
1 can sweetened condensed milk, 350g heavy cream, 3 large eggs + 5 egg yolks, 1 tbsp vanilla, 0.5 tsp salt

I whisked the ingredients then poured through a sieve

I will note though that my oven is very bad and sometimes fluctuates temperature. I hope it will be edible though cuz it looks kinda promising except for the weird puff

Edit: used a water bath as well


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Techniques Galette for a crowd - one big one, or two regular sized?

4 Upvotes

I'm making a double recipe of this galette (https://carolinagelen.com/fall-squash-galette/) for a crowd and I can't decide if I should make one big one on a baking sheet or if I should make two smaller ones.

I've made it before a few times and have had challenges getting the filling all cooked so I assume with a big one I'd have to change something about bake time. The final result is amazing though and I always relish the opportunity to eat it.

Anyone have thoughts?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Pastry How to prevent filling spilling out of pastry

Post image
4 Upvotes

Made bear claws for the first time as well as danish dough. The lamination looks pretty good but I had trouble sealing the dough. Any advice? Thanks!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Equipment Repost because my last post got removed: What to buy for a novice baker?

2 Upvotes

Hi, my daughter has recently taken up baking, so for Xmas I want to surprise her with all the essentials.

This will be the first time in 15yrs (she's 21) that I've managed to think up an actual surprise for her (because she is not materialistic at all) and I want to make it special!

She is autistic and has dyspraxia so I'm looking for equipment that is easy to set up/use and also tools that don't require much practice or skill. She wants to focus on baking cakes, not cupcakes or bread, so we don't need equipment for that.

She definitely wants to make things look look pretty but is too scared to do any intricate piping cuz of her dyspraxia, so anything beyond basic piping is beyond her current capabilities.

My budget for essential equipment is around £200. I've looked up "beginner baking kits" on Amazon but it all seems to revolve around cake decorating.

EDIT: THANK YOU, EVERYBODY! I'VE SCREENSHOT EVERY COMMENT AND WILL BUY AS MUCH AS I CAN ❤️


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Bread Crescent Roll Dough Substitute

2 Upvotes

Hi AskBaking! I have this braided garlic cheese roll recipe that I make for just about every holiday. It is always very highly requested by my friends and family. It is pretty simple and calls for canned crescent roll dough. The thing is, I don’t love it myself. I think I am just not a fan of the sweetness and texture of the cresent roll dough.

Any suggestions for easy dough substitutions?

I recently got into sourdough and think I could make a sourdough copycat of the crescent roll dough, but wont have time to experiment with that before thanksgiving. I also want to use something that will keep the process quick.

Maybe pizza dough?

Recipe for reference: https://olivesnthyme.com/easy-twisted-garlic-cheese-rolls/

Thank you for your help!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting How would you make this recipe?

3 Upvotes

My grandmother used to make a coffee buttercream of sorts. I have the ingredients, but whenever I follow the recipe, it turns out like soup and/or splits. I’m assuming I’m missing a step/doing something wrong, but given this list of ingredients, how would you make this frosting?

2 Cups strong brewed instant coffee
Wondra (amount not specified, but I usually use quite a bit)
2lbs Confectioners Sugar
6 egg yolks (not cooked)
1lb butter

The recipe basically goes: boil the coffee, add wondra until really thickened. Once cooled it’s about as thick as gelatin. In a stand mixer, combine sugar and egg yolks. Mix for a long while because the mixture will go from dry/crumbly to thick/smooth. Add coffee gelatin. Mix on high, then add in butter in chunks (I use slightly cooler than room temp butter).

Every time my frosting splits and/or is runny. Using milk to brew the coffee instead of water is apparently a sin according to my mother, so I’m not sure how to stop it from splitting.

Does this recipe seem right? And what pitfalls am I probably falling into (wrong temp butter? Too thick or not thick enough coffee mixture?)