I've heard "Let Me Down Easy" by Case (pretty good!), from his album The Rose Experience, and I'm trying to understand why the recording sounds...poor...compared to other professionally released R&B records.
To my ears, there are a few things I noticed:
- Audible distortion that sounds like clipping
- An overall mix that sounds muddy and poorly balanced
- Significant gaps or unusually weak areas in the frequency spectrum, making the recording sound like it's missing portions of its frequency content
And before anyone suggests it's just a bad streaming copy: I actually went out of my way to track down and purchase a physical CD of the album. I searched online, ordered a copy, and performed a lossless, error-corrected rip specifically to investigate whether the streaming versions were the problem.
Unfortunately, the exactly same issues appear to be present in the CD version as well. I'm curious what could cause these characteristics in a commercially released recording.
Could this be the result of aggressive limiting or clipping during mastering, problems with the original recording/mix, or maybe degredation that happened during digital encoding or distribution?
I'm not necessarily looking for a subjective critique of the song. I'm interested in understanding the technical causes of the audible things happening and how an engineer might identify them.
Song: Case - Let Me Down Easy (The Rose Experience)
Apple Music: https://music.apple.com/us/album/let-me-down-easy/306009978?i=306009984
CD Rip: https://files.catbox.moe/1qjggw.m4a (25 MB)
EDIT:
I think I found a pattern. All of the tracks that were produced by “Liggio” have oddities and artifacts in them, and every other track sounds just fine. Maybe this guy had something going on in his recording or production equipment.