r/mixingmastering • • Jan 05 '25

Announcement READ BEFORE POSTING + Ask your quick/beginner questions here in the comments

12 Upvotes

POSTING REQUIREMENTS

  • +30 days old account
  • COMMENT karma of at least 30 (NOT the same as your TOTAL karma). You can read and learn a lot more about Reddit karma here.
  • Descriptive title (good for searches, no click-bait, no vague titles)

READ THE RULES (ie: NO FREE WORK HERE)

Hot reddit tip: If you don't want to get banned on Reddit, read the rules of each community that you intend to post in. Here are our rules: https://www.reddit.com/r/mixingmastering/about/rules

Looking for mixing or mastering services?

Check our ever growing listing of community member services (these links won't work on the app, in which case please SEARCH in the subreddit):

Still don't find what you are looking for? Read our guidelines to requesting services here. If your post doesn't meet our guidelines, it'll be removed.

Want to offer professional services?

Please read our guidelines on how to do so.

Want feedback on your mix?

Please read our guidelines for feedback request posts. If your post doesn't meet our guidelines, it'll be removed.

Gear recommendations?

Looking to buy a pair of monitors, headphones, or any other equipment related to mixing? Before posting check our recommendations, which are particularly useful if you are starting up, since they include affordable options.

If you want to know about a particular model, please do a search in the subreddit. If your post is about a frequently asked about pair of speakers or headphones, it'll be removed.

Have questions?

Questions about the craft of mixing and the craft of mastering, are very welcome.

Before asking your question though, do a search, A LOT of things have been asked and popular topics get repeated a lot. You are likely to find an answer or a related post if you search.

CHECK OUR WIKI. You'll find books, youtube channels, online courses and classes, links to multitracks for practice and much more. There is quite a bit of information there and it keeps growing! If your question is covered in the wiki, your post will be removed.

If you have questions about technical troubleshooting, this is not your subreddit, you can try the technical help desk sticky over at /r/audioengineering.

For questions about live audio go to r/livesound

If you are having trouble with a specific DAW, check some of these dedicated subreddits:

WANT TO ASK ABOUT A RELEASED SONG WHICH IS NOT YOUR OWN? Please include the artist name and song title in the title of the post! That way there is no click-bait and people in the future doing a search for that song, will find your post. Also, linking to streaming platforms for this purpose is very much ALLOWED.

If you think your question is relevant to what our subreddit is about, have checked the wiki, have done a search and still didn't find an answer, you are welcome to ask it but please make sure it's a good question.

There is a popular saying: "there are no stupid questions", which is incredibly stupid and wrong. Stupid questions are aplenty and actual good questions are rare. This essay on the topic of how to ask good questions was written primarily about people wanting to acquire hacking/programming skills, but the idea very much applies to professional audio too: http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html (if you can't be bothered to sit for about an hour to read the whole thing or even skim through it for a few minutes, here is the one minute version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0KrOxcQd81Q)

Got a YouTube Channel, a podcast, a plugin, something you want to promote?

If it has a LOT to do with mixing and/or mastering and lines with what the subreddit is about we are interested in knowing about it. Before posting, please tell us mods about what you intend to post. We'll walk you through posting it right.

When in doubt about whether your post would be okay or not ask the mods BEFORE POSTING.

We are here to help, so we welcome all questions. But keep in mind we might not be as friendly if you ask the questions after you tried to post and your post got removed. So please vacate all your doubts with us beforehand: https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/mixingmastering

Have a quick question or are you a beginner with a question?

Try asking right here in the comments! Just please don't use this for feedback (you can try our discord for quick feedback).


r/mixingmastering • • 18h ago

Discussion Tell me about your 500-700hz scoop

39 Upvotes

To get it out of the way: I promise we will use our ears when we EQ.

But I guess the point of my post is that my ears don’t seem to detect problems in the 500-700hz area the way that it jumps out to other people. I’m trying to manage the low end, find some pop in the high-mids, and check out how the airy side is sitting up top, and usually once I’ve done that the element that I’m working on sounds good to me and I move on.

I have come to find though that a stack of 80 tracks that are processed that way add up to a muddy mix that I don’t immediately perceive. When I put it up against a clear and more defined mix I can absolutely hear the difference, but it doesn’t raise flags for me the way that a boomy or overly bright mix do.

I’m not asking “What’s your EQ setting for mids?” I’m asking… as a matter of course, when you pull up an element for processing do you tend to automatically take a listen through that area and clean out some of the gunk?


r/mixingmastering • • 3h ago

Question Mixing at higher volume vs low volume

1 Upvotes

Discolosure - total home amatuer

I've been experiencing this weird delimma where the music I'm mixing for our band from the tracks lay and all tend to sound way better when I'm turning up or blasting my monitors listening back

But when I turn them down and listen it all sounds way less good.

What is this?

Apologies for total novice question/may seem silly but it's kinda something I'm genuinely battling right now

update - (This is incredibly good feedback, thank you)


r/mixingmastering • • 5h ago

Feedback Would love some reaction on this christmas song that I made. Hi! :)

Thumbnail voca.ro
0 Upvotes

All elements of the song are mine, from the mix, arrangements, down to production, lyrics and vocals are all mine. I grew up listening to the same set of famous and a few lesser known Christmas songs. I thought I'd make something that truly mirrors my feelings. I just wanted to capture that particular feeling no matter how short. My main genre is avant-garde and experimental so myself in this track is very controlled and "normal", although I think it still ended up sounding experimental. Would love some feedback! :)


r/mixingmastering • • 19h ago

Question How do you guys get that effect where when the Kick hits it kind of like overpowers the vocal because when my kick is hitting, my vocal is still going through clean and it doesn't have that pumping effect where when the kick hits

11 Upvotes

I tried sidechaining the beat and just the kick to a compressor on my vocal, and it doesn't, it kind of does what I'm talking about, but not really good enough. I've heard a lot of songs where that when that kick hits, it just takes over everything for that instance. Are they like pushing it to a limiter and that's what's doing it? Like, I'm confused because I've tried multiple things and it's not doing anything


r/mixingmastering • • 17h ago

Feedback Feedback On Metal/Thall Style Track

3 Upvotes

Like the title says i need feedback on a metal track that I have been trying to mix for months. I have only been mixing for just over a year and have been trying to teach myself. I have been trying to go for that modern thall style production and mixing for this track. Balancing punch and width is one of the main areas I am unsure about as well as the guitars relationship to the bass. I am using odeholm drums, fortin nameless (with a blended horizon devices precision drive pedal), and nuclear bass as well as state machine alt textures for some synth layers. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

https://voca.ro/1iop2fpL6mp3


r/mixingmastering • • 21h ago

Discussion Case - Let Me Down Easy (The Rose Experience): Why does this recording sound so distorted and poorly mastered?

2 Upvotes

I listen to a lot of R&b, and a few months ago I heard "Let Me Down Easy" by Case, from his album The Rose Experience, and I'm genuinely confused by the audio quality of this recording.

I really enjoy the song itself, but the audio quality sounds noticeably worse than other professionally released R&B records from the same era, including literally the next song in the album.

There are a few things that stand out to me:

Possible clipping?: There's audible distortion throughout parts of the recording that sounds like clipping or excessive limiting.

Overall mix quality kind of sucks: The recording is pretty muddy, lacks clarity, and doesn't have the separation or definition I'd expect from a professionally produced R&B album.

Freq Spectrum: I've noticed what appear to be substantial gaps or unusually weak regions in the frequency spectrum. It almost sounds like portions of the frequencies are missing.

I've gone as far as purchasing the actual CD to investigate this. I literally tracked down a physical copy of the album online, ordered it, and performed a lossless, error-corrected rip to eliminate streaming compression as a possible explanation. But, the same problems are present on the CD rip.

I also listened to the album across multiple streaming services, and the quality seems consistently poor.

So I'm wondering...

  1. Does this sound like a problem with the original mix, the mastering, or potentially the source material used to manufacture and distribute the album?
  2. Could the audible distortion be a consequence of aggressive limiting or clipping during mastering?
  3. What might explain the unusual frequency spectrum? Could this maybe indicate that lossy source material was used somewhere in the production or mastering chain?
  4. From a mixing/mastering perspective, what specifically sounds wrong with this recording, and how might it have been avoided?

I'm interested in learning how experienced mixing and mastering engineers would approach analyzing a recording like this, particularly when the same issues are present on a physical CD.

Apple Music: https://music.apple.com/us/album/let-me-down-easy/306009978?i=306009984

CD Rip: https://files.catbox.moe/1qjggw.m4a


r/mixingmastering • • 1d ago

Feedback Feedback on my mix; any help is appreciated!

5 Upvotes

Hello again, it's been a while! I have been busy being a dad so I haven't been able to post as much as I would prefer. I've been working on my own project a little here and there and could really use some pointers to steer me in the right direction. What works, what doesn't work? https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gBlelR7dEdK_ZeOSHiXDSYUvtPdhFUjt/view?usp=sharing


r/mixingmastering • • 1d ago

Question Rookie Mixing Question: Kick drum snap

6 Upvotes

Hello! I've got a basic kick drum mixing question if you have any advice. If so, thanks in advance!

I recorded a band over the weekend. It was pretty casual; just enough time to throw up overheads and mic the kick and snare. Mic was a Shure Beta 52a. The kick drum had a front head and no port. Reflecting, I should have leaned part of blanket on it to dampen it, but things were moving quickly.

The track isn't terrible...no bleed problems, and the drum was tuned, etc., but there's some boom ...the useless kind. In the past, I've used the UAD API Vision strip's compressor and expanding in conjunction with some luck to shape a snappier transient out of that kind of kick sound, but this time, It's proving a little more difficult.

Question: Do you have any general approach or recipe for dealing with it? I might just try replacing it this time, too. The performance lends itself to that - the dynamic is consistent and the part is simple.


r/mixingmastering • • 2d ago

Question How to achieve Parannoul like mixing

5 Upvotes

So i had found this artist and i think the mixing are very unique for me even if it sounds very distorted and now lately im trying to figure out how to mix my new project like in this part, im really confused how to reach that distortion and ended up making it super loud, but no distortion like that what should i do here


r/mixingmastering • • 4d ago

Discussion I'm a mastering engineer and I built a delivery tool for sending mixes, masters and DDPs to clients.

6 Upvotes

Mastrly is a delivery platform for mix and mastering engineers, with some unique features:

  1. Your files stay in your Dropbox or Google Drive at all times. You get full control over who can listen and download, and you can revoke access at any time. We cannot see your files or any of your activity, ever.
  2. Mastrly is a single HTML file which you can host yourself on your own web site, or use our free hosting at Cloudflare if you prefer.
  3. Mastrly is a one-time purchase. As we have no back end file servers to support, we are not reliant on subscription revenue to keep the lights on.
  4. The client player experience is yours to customise with your own look and feel.
  5. There are free Mastrly Player apps for iPhone and Android with integrated commenting and feedback
  6. For mastering engineers, the Pro version includes an integrated DDP player allowing your clients to audition CD masters directly in the browser.

All features as available to try for free at https://mastrly.cloud/app, with no signup or payment of any kind. The one restriction is that clients can only listen to the first sixty seconds of the audio. I am happy to give out trial licenses too if you would like to use it for real projects.

I hope this is of interest, if so please go to https://mastrly.cloud to find out more.

Thanks!

Mark


r/mixingmastering • • 5d ago

Discussion How common is EQ automation on first few seconds of the song?

45 Upvotes

The other day I was listening to In Bloom by Nirvana, current spotify version. In the first three seconds guitars hit really loud. Then, at three seconds in high mids get taken out and guitars get quieter. As the song gets closer to the verse I think lower mids get also taken out a bit, so throughout the intro guitars get thinner and thinner.

It feels like an illusion of sorts. Since guitars there hit loud at first, we perceive it like this for the whole song, even though it actually isn't.

I've noticed this also on a Hoss - Good Grief, but that's about it. Are there other examples like this?


r/mixingmastering • • 6d ago

Question Best lightweight planar IEMs for mixing and mastering? (Neck surgery recovery)

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m looking for recommendations for high-end planar magnetic IEMs specifically suited for mixing and mastering.
Context on why IEMs: I recently had cervical spine (neck) surgery, so I physically cannot wear heavy over-ear headphones on my head anymore. I need a zero-head-weight, reliable in-ear solution that can serve as my main monitoring reference alongside my studio monitors.
Right now, I’ve heard good things about models like the 7Hz Timeless (or Timeless AE), Letshuoer S12 Pro, and Tangzu Zetian Wu, though I know some of these have a V-shaped or bright signature that might require EQ to be viable for studio work.
What are your top picks for mixing/mastering? Are there specific planar IEMs that take EQ exceptionally well to hit a studio-flat target, or ones that are already neutral out of the box?
Budget is flexible, though I’d love to hear options in the $150–$400 range (or higher if it's truly worth it for a main workhorse). Thanks in advance!


r/mixingmastering • • 7d ago

Question Title: Morunas – Love Always Wins: How is the piano reverb so sustained and spacious without masking the individual notes?

7 Upvotes

I've been trying to reverse-engineer the piano space/reverb in Morunas' Love Always Wins, and I'm struggling to figure out what he's doing differently.

I've managed to recreate the underlying felt piano sound pretty closely using the same LABS Soft Piano samples, so I don't think the instrument itself is the biggest difference anymore. It's the way his piano interacts with the space around it.

Reference: [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ve7BJBE5ez4]

If you listen closely to the melody and chords, here's what I'm hearing:

The melody has this beautiful, almost three-dimensional halo around it. It seems to be present immediately when a note hits, but without the wooden attack getting smeared into the reverb.

As the note sustains, the atmosphere almost seems to breathe or swell slightly. There's a subtle sense of movement around the sustained notes.

But what's really throwing me off is how clean everything stays. When a new chord or bass note hits, the previous reverb seems to get out of the way incredibly naturally, almost like it's responding to the phrasing or sustain pedal. Yet the overall mix remains full and connected between notes.

His melody, chords, and bass are all very distinct, but they still sound like they're occupying the same beautiful space.

For reverbs I've tried ProR2, ValhallaRoom and Crystalline, including ducking, gating, modulation, separate sends for melody and chords, etc. I can create a nice reverb, but I'm struggling to reproduce that exact combination of immediate ambience, sustained harmonic energy, clear attacks, and clean phrase transitions.

I'm starting to wonder whether I'm hearing something beyond conventional reverb, like envelope-shaped sustain, early reflections, transient-dependent reverb, or some type of sidechain/automation.

My main question for experienced mixing engineers: What specifically do you hear happening to the reverb in this reference, and how would you build that behavior?

I'm not necessarily trying to identify his exact plugin. I want to understand the processing and routing that would recreate this effect.

I have my piano separated into dry melody, chords, and bass tracks, so I can isolate and experiment with each part.

Would really appreciate insight from anyone who's worked with this kind of intimate, atmospheric piano production.


r/mixingmastering • • 10d ago

Video Interview with Grammy award winning mixer, Bob Horn

Thumbnail youtu.be
15 Upvotes

Episode 2 of The Control Room features legendary Grammy award winning producer and mixer, Bob Horn. This is an ongoing interview series featuring artists, engineers, producers and music industry related careers. Make sure to check out my other videos if you’re looking for educational content on engineering


r/mixingmastering • • 11d ago

Question Anyone here a delay and reverb settings expert? Can you tell me your best guess at what the settings are on “Long Cool Woman in a Black Dress”?

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
4 Upvotes

I really like the sound the Hollies got on the vocals for this song. I know it’s just reverb and some delay but what would you say the settings are? 1/8th note delay lightly mixed in soaking in reverb? Sounds the majority of the song it’s one individual vocal in the center. Is there anything else I’m missing to get that sound?


r/mixingmastering • • 10d ago

Question Which bus compressor should I always be mixing into on my mix bus?

0 Upvotes

My SPL KULTUBE, Stam Audio SA4000mk3 (no mods), or my Heritage Audio Successor?

And why?

I’ve never really mixed into a bus compressor before so I want to give it a shot.

Additionally.. What busses would you use the other compressors for?

I currently use my Stam on drum bus, and the SPL on guitar bus. I occasionally use the succcessor the drum bus too.


r/mixingmastering • • 12d ago

Question If I clip before limiter, will it really clip/distort?

15 Upvotes

Let's say you're a mastering engineer and you're given a song that's mixed a with a lot of headroom and dynamic range. So you turn the volume up before adding a limiter (so the limiter doesn't have to do too much work to avoid pumping etc) but then at some parts of the song, it goes into red a bit on the master channel.

- When you then apply the limiter, the red goes away on the master channel but are you still technically clipping, and is this an issue?

I'm a bit confused regarding this and I've heard a lot of conflicting information about Reaper (my DAW) and floating point etc. being almost impossible to clip, though that might be on invidiual tracks only?

solved: no it won't clip


r/mixingmastering • • 11d ago

Question Do you accept fake guitar amps in your projects?

0 Upvotes

I am always working on random albums and songs of mine. My major albums, I went out of the way to go to a studio (professional and otherwise) to record guitar parts through amps. They sound great and I'm immensely proud of those recordings.

But lately I'm low on money, time (we had a baby), and feel overwhelmed. Sometimes I think fake amps (Guitar Rig, etc, etc) with my guitar plugged into my mac mini sound just fine. I have some of my favorite songs I've recorded where it's fake amps, and I don't care at all.

But sometimes I get mad at myself for being lazy and not respecting the listener and myself enough to capture the power of a guitar sound coming out of an amp. And sometimes I've replaced the fake amps with a real amp and the huge improvement was obvious (so much once that it made me and my friend burst out laughing when we A/B'd the sound.)

Does this matter to you? Are you fine with fake amps, or whatever gets the job done? Is fake amp technology so good now it doesn't matter, or will there always be something missing? What's your approach to this? Thoughts?

And don't get me started on drums.


r/mixingmastering • • 13d ago

Question What’s your actual pre delivery checklist when sending mixes to clients?

13 Upvotes

Random question for the mixing engineers here.
When you're finished mixing something and you're about to send it off to a client, what does your final check actually look like?
Do you have some kind of checklist you go through, or do you pretty much just export everything, give the files a quick once over, and send them?
I'm curious about stuff like checking sample rate/bit depth, making sure all the requested files are there, naming everything correctly, checking for clipping, folder organization, etc.
Also, do you do anything different when receiving files from a client before starting a project?
I'm especially interested in the stuff that's easy to overlook or that has bitten you in the ass before.
Just curious how everyone handles that part of the workflow.


r/mixingmastering • • 12d ago

Discussion When mixing vocals is it best to use a template for the majority of things minus EQ?

0 Upvotes

Only EQ from scratch and then a template is fine for the rest? Would love to know your guys thoughts? I’m pretty solid at vocal mixing but I often find as I do a lot of different genres it’s hard to get it sounding exactly how I want using templates. Lmk what u guys think!

Would love some advice on what you do!


r/mixingmastering • • 14d ago

Question Perceived loudness of vocals should be a bit quieter in mono? (in this scenario)

5 Upvotes

I make shoegaze adjacent music, not totally My Bloody Valentine in terms of quiet vocals but Siamese Dream (Smashing Pumpkins) or a song like Be Quiet and Drive (Deftones).

Lots of guitars layered and hard panned, vocals center and a bit on the quieter side.

Trying to listen to my mix on as many listening systems as I can, phone speaker too (mono obviously) and I keep going back and forth on if the vocals are too quiet or perfect.

On phone I'm starting to think they're slighly too quiet behind the guitars, but I'm thinking: that should be normal? Since panning of guitars (that's lost on phone speaker) will do a lot to separate center vocals from guitars.

Generally true?


r/mixingmastering • • 15d ago

Discussion Mixing tip for any drum cymbal bleed

11 Upvotes

Snare bleed is one of the most annoying things you can have when mixing songs that require really compressed drum sounds. I recently discovered a really useful trick. Try duplicating a raw snare track, on the duplicated track invert the phase than add a stock compressor(set it to the lowest attack, lowest release, highest ratio and don t forget to turn of auto gain and play with the threshold), if the drum is too choked play with the release. Then add both tracks to a snare buss and do all the processing there.
Hope this helped and good luck!


r/mixingmastering • • 15d ago

Question Prepping software instrument tracks for mixing

8 Upvotes

I'm an amateur music composer who's spent the last few years learning how to mix my own stuff, and I have questions about the best way to prep software music tracks ahead of mixing. I don't have any experience with mixing live recordings, so I don't know how I should be prepping tracks ahead of mixing.

The way I make music is to use a keyboard to record MIDI tracks for different instruments, like piano, guitar, bass, synth, trumpet, etc.. I use stock piano sounds, but also have a number of Ample Sound guitar and bass patches. I'm also using EZDrummer for drum tracks. After I'm done composing, I bounce the MIDI to audio and bounce the EZDrummer tracks into stems, then bring them all into a new project and start mixing.

My main question is, what ideally goes into each bounced track, in terms of effects and processing? Do I want to disable all things like delay and reverb, and re-apply them in the mix? Is it better to have a totally clean sound and do everything in the mix? Or do some things while producing the tracks? How loud should things be?

Any tips or suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks!