r/CFB • • 26m ago

Discussion The Committee Hasn’t Shown Too Much SEC Bias This Year, It’s Just Bama Bias

7 Upvotes

There’s been a ton of discourse about SEC bias and the committee treating the other 3 conferences unfairly, but I don’t think any SEC team outside of Alabama has received particularly favorable treatment. An SEC team (Tennessee) has arguably received the most disrespect.

I know plenty of people are upset about the 6-4 teams in the 20s, but it’s easy to complain about them without advocating for who actually deserves it. I’d swap Duke for South Carolina, but have Memphis or Liberty really earned a ranking? Liberty has played absolutely no one, and Memphis lacks impressive wins and lost to an awful Tulane team. It’s just a weird year with a lot of parity. Other P4 teams could’ve easily made claims for those spots but ruined their arguments with bad losses (SMU, Wisconsin, Oklahoma State, Penn State).

There are small changes you could make solid arguments for (Utah over Georgia, Kentucky a bit high, Miami/IU/ND above Texas), but none of those are egregious in my opinion.

I do think the SEC is clearly the best conference this year, and the rankings reflect it. If Bama was ranked appropriately I think there would be far less complaints about SEC bias in general; when you look at the resume of pretty much any other SEC team their spot seems sensible.

TLDR: The placements of all other SEC teams are fine, Bama’s ranking is so horrific that it’s causing grievances with the whole conference


r/CFB • • 3h ago

Discussion [Mandel] Look up any published SOS ranking. All of them have something like 9 of the top 10 are SEC teams. Which started when the SEC went 10-2 vs. P4 out of conference. But I realize that doesn’t fit with the conspiracy theories.

Thumbnail x.com
0 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 11h ago

Discussion Two of the top five teams in the CFP Rankings have had losing streaks this season; is this unprecedented?

0 Upvotes

#3 Alabama and #5 Texas each suffered consecutive losses earlier in the season, combining to go 0-4 from October 10-17.

I can’t find another example of a time when there were multiple teams ranked in the top five who had posted losing streaks earlier in the season.

Of course, it’s understandable in a year with only *eight* remaining 0 or 1 loss teams in the P4+ND.

…….

Also worth noting is the record number (4) of 6-4 teams in this CFP poll, all SEC.

The only conclusion is that this season’s SEC must be lightyears ahead of any previous conference in terms of quality and competitiveness.

And here I was ready to blame Elko. Poor guy never stood a chance.


r/CFB • • 6h ago

Analysis How does the CFP committee favor certain conferences? I compared the 2025 and 2026 rankings

0 Upvotes

I wanted to see whether the CFP rankings show a consistent conference bias, so I compared the top 25 from equivalent points in the 2025 and 2026 seasons, when teams had played approximately ten games.

I ran a simple linear regression to predict each team’s ranking based on its number of losses, then compared that prediction with its actual ranking. I averaged the differences across every ranked team in each conference.

Positive numbers mean teams ranked higher than their records alone would predict. Negative numbers mean they ranked lower. The numbers represent ranking positions.

Conference ranking differential (2025 → 2026):
SEC: +2.53 → +2.53
Big Ten: −0.15 → +0.22
Big 12: −1.69 → −1.34
ACC: −3.34 → −3.06

2025: 43 combined losses among the top 25
2026: 54 combined losses among the top 25

That’s a 26% increase in losses, yet the conference ranking bias has barely changed.

Both years also featured exactly nine SEC teams, six Big Ten teams, five Big 12 teams, and three ACC teams in the top 25.

Conclusion: same as it ever was (but with more parity)

Sources: Official CFP rankings, November 18, 2025, and November 17, 2026.


r/CFB • • 5h ago

Discussion Live Stream the Committee

0 Upvotes

What if ESPN put up a live stream? they had it going on ESPN plus and their YouTube channel and then you could see and hear all of the discussion like C-SPAN but for college football.
It doesn’t mean backroom deals wouldn’t be happening and off camera conversations, but at least it would give you a peek into the room where it’s happening.


r/CFB • • 5h ago

Opinion [Vannini] If you hate the committee, just understand the computers like the SEC even more than the committee does. There’s no perfect solution. The SEC is 10-2 against other P4 leagues. Miss St destroyed Minnesota. It was always going to turn out like this, this year.

Thumbnail x.com
526 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 5h ago

Discussion Significance of Non-Conference P4 Records

0 Upvotes

Looking at the rankings each week, I have to think a major factor in the SEC's takeover of the Top 25 is the overall non-conference records of the Power 4 against one another.

Head-to-head records between P4 conferences this season:

SEC: 10-2

Big 12: 6-7

ACC: 6-13

Big Ten: 4-10

Without even looking further into the actual matchups, quality of opponents in those matchups, etc., I can at least see where I think the committee's justification might be coming from.

Defintiely not saying their rankings are accurate or that I agree with them, but I have to imagine this statistic carries significant weight in their evals.


r/CFB • • 14h ago

Discussion Pods

7 Upvotes

maybe I just didn’t notice because I really only started paying attention to this bullshit towards the end of last year, but when did these “pods” start being a thing? I remember they dropped it a couple times leading up to the end of last year, quite a bit in the final rankings, and then all the time this year. Its absolutely the dumbest way to rank teams and the only possible reason they implemented it is so they could do whatever the hell they want


r/CFB • • 2h ago

Discussion Disney has activated its SEC sleeper agents on the CFP Selection Committee

0 Upvotes

After years of careful planning, Disney has reportedly activated its sleeper agents embedded within the College Football Playoff Selection Committee.

Some of these operatives have been undercover for DECADES.

  • Mark Dantonio: Played at South Carolina in the 1970s. That's right. Disney planted him before South Carolina even joined the SEC. Unbelievable foresight.
  • Mike Riley: Played at Alabama under Bear Bryant. Has spent the last 50 years pretending to have other professional interests.
  • Carla Williams: Played basketball and worked at Georgia. Disney knew the women's basketball to CFP committee pipeline would eventually pay off.
  • Wesley Walls: Played at Ole Miss. Has been patiently awaiting his activation since the 1980s.
  • Chris Massaro: Worked at South Carolina for nearly two decades. Deep cover.
  • Doug Gillin: Previously worked at Missouri. Another carefully positioned asset.

The activation phrase was reportedly "It just means more."


r/CFB • • 21h ago

Opinion USA Today: Curt Cignetti's criticism isn't the problem. College football's gatekeepers are

Thumbnail usatoday.com
73 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 2h ago

Discussion This is the problem with expanding the playoffs . . . . .

16 Upvotes

When the field was only 4 teams, you knew that, at the very least, the 4 teams getting in actually had some business being there.

Now that we are at 12, there are 7-3 and some 6-4 teams complaining about the criteria needed when in all honesty they shouldn’t be anywhere near the conversation at all.

Next year, we’ll be at 24 teams, and there is no way in hell you can look at the bottom of the 24 this year and say some of those teams deserve it or warrant being watched outside of being filler til the real games started. A team like Florida this year would not be deserving of a spot.

I believe 8 should have been the number, and we should’ve stopped there.

Now next year will just be more crying from coaches, teams, and fans, of why their underwhelming team should be allowed in, and for what?


r/CFB • • 1h ago

News [Grant Reacts] Heather Dinich fully breaks down the NEW metric the CFP Committee is using which is called "Strength of Conference".

Thumbnail x.com
8 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 2h ago

Discussion Alabama is #3 so Georgia can be #1.

0 Upvotes

Because Texas Tech got blanked last year, the committee has intuited that the Big XII is shit. They don’t want to rank a Big XII team #1, nor do they want to rank UCLA #1 because UCLA is being looked at the same way as 2024 Indiana - a team with a good record who’s only played scrub teams(whether that’s true or not is up to you). If Alabama was behind UCLA, ND, and Texas at a more reasonable #6, that would mean Georgia’s best win isn’t that much better than Utah’s best win such that Utah is the clear #1, with a comparable best win and no ugly home loss to an unranked 6-4 team. Alabama has to be that much better than BYU for Georgia over Utah to make sense. The committee consistently shows that they work backwards and top-down: they decide who’s on top and then rank the rest of the teams accordingly.

What that means is that we can expect Alabama to drop to a more reasonable(still top 10) ranking if Georgia beats Texas or Tennessee in the SEC championship, because them being #3 will no longer be the anchor of Georgia’s case for #1. This goes double if Utah loses the Big XII championship, because Utah would no longer have a case to be over Georgia.


r/CFB • • 3h ago

Discussion For fans of non-CFP participants, join me in boycotting this year's games.

0 Upvotes

I certainly understand the fans of teams that get in wanting to watch your team compete for a national championship. If WVU were in, I'd 100% hold my nose and watch, praying to win. However, the overall lunacy of our current system has to change and the powers in charge have to know fans are not ok with this. Declining viewership is the only realistic push towards transparency.

For those that still want to watch, I completely get that, too. It's still the greatest sport in the world, I just can't stand to see what it's become. I'm not supporting it anymore.


r/CFB • • 2h ago

Postseason [D3football.com] Headin' to California (DIII playoff matchup of a team from Alabama playing a team from Los Angeles)

Thumbnail d3football.com
1 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 16h ago

Weekly Thread CFP Rankings Discussion, 2026-11-17

51 Upvotes

For serious discussion, see here.

CFP Rankings

RankTeamRecord
1Georgia Georgia9-1
2Utah Utah10-0
3Alabama Alabama8-2
4UCLA UCLA10-0
5Texas Texas8-2
6Notre Dame Notre Dame9-1
7Miami Miami9-1
8Indiana Indiana9-1
9Tennessee Tennessee8-2
10BYU BYU8-2
11Wake Forest Wake Forest9-1
12Texas Tech Texas Tech9-1
13Oregon Oregon7-3
14Ohio State Ohio State7-3
15Iowa Iowa8-2
16Kentucky Kentucky7-3
17Boise State Boise State9-1
18USC USC7-3
19Arizona Arizona7-3
20Houston Houston7-3
21South Carolina South Carolina6-4
22Oklahoma Oklahoma6-4
23Louisville Louisville7-3
24Florida Florida6-4
25Ole Miss Ole Miss6-4

r/CFB • • 2h ago

Opinion Having four 6-4 teams in CFP Poll is a terrible look

255 Upvotes

Last night marked the first time since 2021 that the CFP committee included a 6-4 team in the poll. And it decided to feature not one, but four 6-4 teams and it waters down college football’.

But I wouldn’t know how to convince anyone to steer the ship in a different diffraction while we take this unfeeling, over-intellectualized approach to evaluating teams with computer models. While at the same time, randomly divvying up mulligans for some injuries but not others. And saying a poorly-played win counts against you, but sometimes it shows your mettle.

So pardon me for struggling to find the agreed-upon criteria for why New Mexico and/or other promising 8-2 mid-majors would be a better fit for CFP poll than a random unsatisfied 6-4 program.

But for me, I just want more successful teams in the poll than there is now. In no way is Ole Miss’ season a success. But New Mexico’s season has been. Plus the Lobos didn’t participate in schedule tomfoolery to lift up its record.

New Mexico is 24 spots ahead of 6-4 Florida in SP+ and 19 spots ahead of the Gators in SP+ Resume ratings. I can only assume that Florida is valued more highly by the committee because of being 25 spots ahead of New Mexico in strength of record. Never mind that Alabama is sixth in that metric.

It is sad we are going down this road, especially in a world where mid-majors like New Mexico are still showing they can go toe-to-toe with power conference teams.

Bottom of CFP Poll

RankTeamRecord
21South Carolina6–4
22Oklahoma6–4
23Louisville7–3
24Florida6–4
25Ole Miss6–4

 


r/CFB • • 18h ago

Weekly Thread [Game Thread] CFP Rankings, 2026-11-17

73 Upvotes

TV: ESPN

Follow along with the selection show here.

Once the full results come out, two threads will be posted: a thread with the results, and a serious discussion thread where jokes, memes, and off-topic comments will be removed.

RankTeamRecord
1Georgia Georgia9-1
2Utah Utah10-0
3Alabama Alabama8-2
4UCLA UCLA10-0
5Texas Texas8-2
6Notre Dame Notre Dame9-1
7Miami Miami9-1
8Indiana Indiana9-1
9Tennessee Tennessee8-2
10BYU BYU8-2
11Wake Forest Wake Forest9-1
12Texas Tech Texas Tech9-1
13Oregon Oregon7-3
14Ohio State Ohio State7-3
15Iowa Iowa8-2
16Kentucky Kentucky7-3
17Boise State Boise State9-1
18USC USC7-3
19Arizona Arizona7-3
20Houston Houston7-3
21South Carolina South Carolina6-4
22Oklahoma Oklahoma6-4
23Louisville Louisville7-3
24Florida Florida6-4
25Ole Miss Ole Miss6-4

r/CFB • • 15h ago

Opinion [osterman]More from Hunter Yurachek on Alabama. Points not just to margin of victory, but offense-defense balance. “When we watch film, when we watch their games, we really feel like they’re one of the best 3-4 teams in the country.”

Thumbnail x.com
173 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 23h ago

News [Dylan Dawson] BREAKING: Starting Mike LB Kooper Ebel announced today that he will return to Penn State in 2027 for his final year of eligibility. Ebel has collected 60 tackles, 3.5 TFL, 3 PD, 1 sack, and 1 FR through 10 games this season.

Thumbnail x.com
14 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 2h ago

Discussion Combining the CFP Committee with the BCS Rankings (Week 11)

3 Upvotes

Becuase the CFP is an entertainment product whose purpose has NEVER been to rank the teams as "Best or Most Deserving," this will never happen. The whole point of the CFP is to add countless more click and ad revenue. That is why there is a (way too long) show every week (that never starts on time - how many commercials did you watch during the basketball game that overlapped when the CFP show was supposed to start); and that's why they rank teams controversially: They want us to engage and debate.

The easy solve is using a "committee" or any logical system to clean up the BCS. It wouldn't be perfect, there would still be debate, but it would be WAY too simple and would eat up WAY too much of ESPN's bottom line.

There is still an argument to be had for several teams, sure; for instance, I would move Ole Miss to the bottom with the rest of the 8-4 SEC Teams and order them specifically, 22 Oklahoma, 23 Florida, 24 Ole Miss, 25 LSU (honoring all of the head to heads). But I'm honoring the BCS Rankings here.

EDIT: The "Revised" Ranking below takes the BCS Rank, but then honors head-to-head results if teams are near each other (moved Alabama below Texas and Tennessee). The number in the brackets is the difference between the Revised Rank and the Current CFP Rank.

https://imgur.com/a/aanLFQc

RankRevised (CFP Difference)BCSCFP
1Georgia (9-1) [0]Georgia (9-1)Georgia (9-1)
2Utah (10-0) [0]Utah (10-0)Utah (10-0)
3Notre Dame (9-1) [+3]Notre Dame (9-1)Alabama (8-2)
4UCLA (10-0) [0]UCLA (10-0)UCLA (10-0)
5Miami (9-1) [+2]Miami (9-1)Texas (8-2)
6Indiana (9-1) [+2]Indiana (9-1)Notre Dame (9-1)
7Texas (8-2) [-2]Alabama (8-2)Miami (9-1)
8Tennessee (8-2) [+1]Texas (8-2)Indiana (9-1)
9Alabama (8-2) [-6]Tennessee (8-2)Tennessee (8-2)
10Wake Forest (9-1) [+1]Wake Forest (9-1)BYU (8-2)
11Texas Tech (9-1) [+1]Texas Tech (9-1)Wake Forest (9-1)
12BYU (8-2) [-2]BYU (8-2)Texas Tech (9-1)
13Oregon (7-3) [0]Oregon (7-3)Oregon (7-3)
14Ohio State (7-3) [0]Iowa (8-2)Ohio State (7-3)
15Iowa (8-2) [0]Ohio State (7-3)Iowa (8-2)
16Boise State (9-1) [+1]Boise State (9-1)Kentucky (7-3)
17Kentucky (7-3) [-1]Kentucky (7-3)Boise State (9-1)
18USC (7-3) [0]USC (7-3)USC (7-3)
19Ole Miss (6-4) [+6]Ole Miss (6-4)Arizona (7-3)
20Arizona (7-3) [-1]Arizona (7-3)Houston (7-3)
21Houston (7-3) [-1]Houston (7-3)South Carolina (6-4)
22Louisville (7-3) [+1]Louisville (7-3)Oklahoma (6-4)
23LSU (6-4) [N/A]LSU (6-4)Louisville (7-3)
24Oklahoma (6-4) [-2]Florida (6-4)Florida (6-4)
25Florida (6-4) [-1]Oklahoma (6-4)Ole Miss (6-4)

r/CFB • • 15h ago

Discussion [Hale] Anger Index: Why Texas Tech and Tennessee and the Group of 6 Should be mad

Thumbnail
espn.com
90 Upvotes

r/CFB • • 5h ago

Discussion Which 12-25th Ranked Teams Can ACTUALLY Make the CFP? (Nov. 17th Rankings)

6 Upvotes

Made a post last week evaluating the 12-25th ranked teams and what their chances were at making a run towards the playoffs. This week, there are likely going to be much more clear lines. Once again, I'm not going to put Boise St in this since they're the only G6 team ranked.

CONTROL THEIR OWN DESTINY:

  • Texas Tech- the good news for Texas Tech is that if they win out, they can make the Big 12 CG and if they win that, they get an automatic berth. But I'm starting to get convinced Texas Tech is going to be the team left out if they don't win the Big 12 and everyone in front of them wins out. To move down after a convincing win over Ok St shows they really have no room for error.

NEED HELP:

  • Oregon- I did think the Committee would move Oregon over Iowa if it came down to it. Houston losing gave them their opening to do it. Bad news for Oregon, their Big 10 title hopes took a big hit with Indiana beating USC. Good news for them is Houston and Kentucky lost and they jumped Iowa, they just need two more teams in the 6-12 range to lose imo for an at-large.
  • USC- they would have controlled their own destiny had they beaten Indiana. Luckily for them, enough teams lost last week that they're not completely out of it. An undefeated UCLA could be a big resume boost for USC if they win that. I'm not sure if that alone would get them an at-large with three losses but it keeps them alive. More than likely, they will need Oregon and two other teams to lose.
  • Ohio St- believe it or not, this was actually a good week for them. They won when a lot of their competition lost. Biggest thing of all was that Ohio St jumped Iowa in the rankings. Ohio St now needs Indiana and Oregon to lose to sneak into the Big 10 CG or about three teams in front of them to take a loss for an at-large.
  • South Carolina- I'm surprised they're still ranked in all honesty. I'm leaning towards they're being propped up for Georgia and Bama but is there a small chance they pull an upset if Sellers comes back? The Georgia game coming up is the only thing keeping them in this group. Like it or not, a win over the Committee darling and #1 would carry significant weight. I don't think that alone would get the Gamecocks in but it keeps them in the mix if they somehow pull it off. I'll say I think this is the least likely team to get in in this group.

NEED ABSOLUTE CHAOS:

  • Iowa- I said last week that Iowa had a strong chance of getting jumped by Oregon if it came down to it. Not only did that happen but Ohio St also jumped them. At this point, Iowa is only getting in if there's another week where everyone in front of them loses.
  • Kentucky- same boat as Iowa, they really put themselves in a pickle losing to Florida. Getting ranked behind Ohio St really doesn't help either. They also have no game big enough remaining to make a significant jump without chaos imo (I don't think they'll be a bid thief beating Louisville).
  • Arizona- valiant effort against Utah and I'm glad the Committee recognized that by moving them up despite the loss. However, for playoff hopes, they need even more chaos than the two teams above them for an at-large or Texas Tech and BYU would have to collapse to sneak into the Big 12 CG.
  • Houston- I'm really disappointed they lost to Colorado, there was a real path to the playoffs if they won out. Now, they're really in a similar position as Arizona needing one of the above chaos scenarios to happen.
  • Louisville- props to the Committee for ranking them, they've quietly been on a nice winning streak after that brutal NC St loss to make them 2-3. However, I think it's too little too late. No way they get an at-large and they'd need Wake Forest to lose out to even have a chance at the ACC.

DRAWING DEAD:

  • Oklahoma- unpopular opinion, I really don't have a problem with Oklahoma being ranked. This is kind of a down year for the G6 and the Sooners quietly have some decent wins over Texas, Ole Miss, New Mexico, and I guess Florida. With that said, they're just a fill-in team to complete the rankings in a week with really no good options, no shot at the playoffs.
  • Florida- same as Oklahoma, no shot at the playoffs but they've had a brutal schedule and just beat #11 Kentucky on the road so they're a fill-in team.
  • Ole Miss- I thought they were hanging on by a miracle thread last week. Now, they're lucky to still be ranked. I had high hopes for them after beating LSU too, it's a shame.

So, that's my list for this week. Likely gonna start seeing more ranked teams drawing dead as we go along. Do you agree with this list?


r/CFB • • 16h ago

Weekly Thread CFP Rankings, Serious Discussion, 2026-11-17

200 Upvotes

This thread is for serious discussion; jokes, memes, etc. may be subject to removal. For the general discussion thread, see here.

CFP Rankings

RankTeamRecord
1Georgia Georgia9-1
2Utah Utah10-0
3Alabama Alabama8-2
4UCLA UCLA10-0
5Texas Texas8-2
6Notre Dame Notre Dame9-1
7Miami Miami9-1
8Indiana Indiana9-1
9Tennessee Tennessee8-2
10BYU BYU8-2
11Wake Forest Wake Forest9-1
12Texas Tech Texas Tech9-1
13Oregon Oregon7-3
14Ohio State Ohio State7-3
15Iowa Iowa8-2
16Kentucky Kentucky7-3
17Boise State Boise State9-1
18USC USC7-3
19Arizona Arizona7-3
20Houston Houston7-3
21South Carolina South Carolina6-4
22Oklahoma Oklahoma6-4
23Louisville Louisville7-3
24Florida Florida6-4
25Ole Miss Ole Miss6-4