Discussion The Committee Hasn’t Shown Too Much SEC Bias This Year, It’s Just Bama Bias
There’s been a ton of discourse about SEC bias and the committee treating the other 3 conferences unfairly, but I don’t think any SEC team outside of Alabama has received particularly favorable treatment. An SEC team (Tennessee) has arguably received the most disrespect.
I know plenty of people are upset about the 6-4 teams in the 20s, but it’s easy to complain about them without advocating for who actually deserves it. I’d swap Duke for South Carolina, but have Memphis or Liberty really earned a ranking? Liberty has played absolutely no one, and Memphis lacks impressive wins and lost to an awful Tulane team. It’s just a weird year with a lot of parity. Other P4 teams could’ve easily made claims for those spots but ruined their arguments with bad losses (SMU, Wisconsin, Oklahoma State, Penn State).
There are small changes you could make solid arguments for (Utah over Georgia, Kentucky a bit high, Miami/IU/ND above Texas), but none of those are egregious in my opinion.
I do think the SEC is clearly the best conference this year, and the rankings reflect it. If Bama was ranked appropriately I think there would be far less complaints about SEC bias in general; when you look at the resume of pretty much any other SEC team their spot seems sensible.
TLDR: The placements of all other SEC teams are fine, Bama’s ranking is so horrific that it’s causing grievances with the whole conference