r/CFB • u/amstrumpet • 3m ago
Analysis Discourse around 4-loss teams
There's a lot of focus on all of the four loss SEC teams that are being highly ranked in the CFP and AP polls, and on the surface that's a fair criticism, so I decided to look into the numbers a bit more across the power four conferences.
In the power 4, the number of four or fewer loss teams are as follows:
SEC: 12
Big 10: 12
Big 12: 8
ACC: 8
Since every one of those teams has played exactly 10 games at this point, the numbers are somewhat easy: 120 games each for the SEC and Big 10, and 80 games each for the Big 12 and ACC.
Of the 120 games those 12 SEC teams have played, 34 have been against one another, so the minimum number of losses they could possibly have is 34, an average of 2.83 losses per team. The actual number of losses is 38, an average of 3.17 losses per team, meaning they have an average of 0.34 losses to teams outside of their own group of 12.
Of the 120 games the Big 10 teams have played, 27 have been against one another, meaning an average of at least 2.25 losses, and the actual number is 36, for an average of 3, so they have an additional 0.75 losses to teams outside of their group.
Out of 80 games the Big 12 teams have played, 12 have come to each other, an average of 1.5 per team, and they have 21 losses total, an average of 2.63 for an additional 1.13 losses on average.
Out of 80 games for the ACC teams, 10 have come to one another, an average of 1.25 per team, and with 23 total losses they're averaging 2.88, so an extra 1.63 per team.
The overall record for each of these groups against teams that aren't in their group are as follows:
SEC: 82-4 (0.953)
B1G: 84-9 (0.903)
Big 12: 59-9 (0.868)
ACC: 57-13 (0.814)
Obviously all of those are good win percentages, but the fact that across 12 teams the SEC has only 4 losses outside of the ones that were guaranteed just by playing each other is pretty astounding. The Big 10's 9 losses are also very impressive, less than one loss per team on average.
You can absolutely still disagree with ranking these 4 loss SEC teams, but their losses almost exclusively come against each other, with South Carolina alone accounting for half of the 4 losses outside of their group with losses to Mississippi State and Arkansas (ironically making them maybe the least deserving to be ranked despite them being the highest ranked of the 4 loss teams, though Mississippi State was a different team at the start of the season).
Certainly still plenty of room to bitch about the rankings, Alabama shouldn't be in that first group of teams looking at a bye, but I love data and thought this was an interesting stat to dive into and examine further.