r/CharacterRant • • May 06 '24

Special What can and (definetly can't) be posted on the sub :)

133 Upvotes

Users have been asking and complaining about the "vagueness" of the topics that are or aren't allowed in the subreddit, and some requesting for a clarification.

So the mod team will attempt to delineate some thread topics and what is and isn't allowed.

Backstory:

CharacterRant has its origins in the Battleboarding community WhoWouldWin (r/whowouldwin), created to accommodate threads that went beyond a simple hypothetical X vs. Y battle. Per our (very old) sub description:

This is a sub inspired by r/whowouldwin. There have been countless meta posts complaining about characters or explanations as to why X beats, and so on. So the purpose of this sub is to allow those who want to rant about a character or explain why X beats Y and so on.

However, as early as 2015, we were already getting threads ranting about the quality of specific series, complaining about characterization, and just general shittery not all that related to "who would win: 10 million bees vs 1 lion".

So, per Post Rules 1 in the sidebar:

Thread Topics: You may talk about why you like or dislike a specific character, why you think a specific character is overestimated or underestimated. You may talk about and clear up any misconceptions you've seen about a specific character. You may talk about a fictional event that has happened, or a concept such as ki, chakra, or speedforce.

Well that's certainly kinda vague isn't it?

So what can and can't be posted in CharacterRant?

✅ Allowed:

  • Battleboarding in general (with two exceptions down below)
  • Explanations, rants, and complaints on, and about: characters, characterization, character development, a character's feats, plot points, fictional concepts, fictional events, tropes, inaccuracies in fiction, and the power scaling of a series.
  • Non-fiction content is fine as long as it's somehow relevant to the elements above, such as: analysis and explanations on wars, history and/or geopolitics; complaints on the perception of historical events by the general media or the average person; explanation on what nation would win what war or conflict.

❌ Not allowed:

  • he 2 Battleboarding exceptions: 1) hypothetical scenarios, as those belong in r/whowouldwin;2) pure calculations - you can post a "fancalc" on a feat or an event as long as you also bring forth a bare minimum amount of discussion accompanying it; no "I calced this feat at 10 trillion gigajoules, thanks bye" posts.
  • Explanations, rants and complaints on the technical aspect of production of content - e.g. complaints on how a movie literally looks too dark; the CGI on a TV show looks unfinished; a manga has too many lines; a book uses shitty quality paper; a comic book uses an incomprehensible font; a song has good guitars.
  • Politics that somehow don't relate to the elements listed in the "Allowed" section - e.g. this country's policies are bad, this government is good, this politician is dumb.
  • Entertainment topics that somehow don't relate to the elements listed in the "Allowed" section - e.g. this celebrity has bad opinions, this actor is a good/bad actor, this actor got cast for this movie, this writer has dumb takes on Twitter, social media is bad.

ADDENDUM -

  • Politics in relation to a series and discussion of those politics is fine, however political discussion outside said series or how it relates to said series is a no, no baggins'
  • Overly broad takes on tropes and and genres? Henceforth not allowed. If you are to discuss the genre or trope you MUST have specifics for your rant to be focused on. (Specific Characters or specific stories)
  • Rants about Fandom or fans in general? Also being sent to the shadow realm, you are not discussing characters or anything relevant once more to the purpose of this sub
  • A friendly reminder that this sub is for rants about characters and series, things that have specificity to them and not broad and vague annoyances that you thought up in the shower.

And our already established rules:

  • No low effort threads.
  • No threads in response to topics from other threads, and avoid posting threads on currently over-posted topics - e.g. saw 2 rants about the same subject in the last 24 hours, avoid posting one more.
  • No threads solely to ask questions.
  • No unapproved meta posts. Ask mods first and we'll likely say yes.

PS: We can't ban people or remove comments for being inoffensively dumb. Stop reporting opinions or people you disagree with as "dumb" or "misinformation".

Why was my thread removed? What counts as a Low Effort Thread?

  • If you posted something and it was removed, these are the two most likely options:**
  • Your account is too new or inactive to bypass our filters
  • Your post was low effort

"Low effort" is somewhat subjective, but you know it when you see it. Only a few sentences in the body, simply linking a picture/article/video, the post is just some stupid joke, etc. They aren't all that bad, and that's where it gets blurry. Maybe we felt your post was just a bit too short, or it didn't really "say" anything. If that's the case and you wish to argue your position, message us and we might change our minds and approve your post.

What counts as a Response thread or an over-posted topic? Why do we get megathreads?

  1. A response thread is pretty self explanatory. Does your thread only exist because someone else made a thread or a comment you want to respond to? Does your thread explicitly link to another thread, or say "there was this recent rant that said X"? These are response threads. Now obviously the Mod Team isn't saying that no one can ever talk about any other thread that's been posted here, just use common sense and give it a few days.
  2. Sometimes there are so many threads being posted here about the same subject that the Mod Team reserves the right to temporarily restrict said topic or a portion of it. This usually happens after a large series ends, or controversial material comes out (i.e The AOT ban after the penultimate chapter, or the Dragon Ball ban after years of bullshittery on every DB thread). Before any temporary ban happens, there will always be a Megathread on the subject explaining why it has been temporarily kiboshed and for roughly how long. Obviously there can be no threads posted outside the Megathread when a restriction is in place, and the Megathread stays open for discussions.

Reposts

  • A "repost" is when you make a thread with the same opinion, covering the exact same topic, of another rant that has been posted here by anyone, including yourself.
  • ✅ It's allowed when the original post has less than 100 upvotes or has been archived (it's 6 months or older)
  • ❌ It's not allowed when the original post has more than 100 upvotes and hasn't been archived yet (posted less than 6 months ago)

Music

Users have been asking about it so we made it official.

To avoid us becoming a subreddit to discuss new songs and albums, which there are plenty of, we limit ourselves regarding music:

  • ✅ Allowed: analyzing the storytelling aspect of the song/album, a character from the music, or the album's fictional themes and events.
  • ❌ Not allowed: analyzing the technical and sonical aspects of the song/album and/or the quality of the lyricism, of the singing or of the sound/production/instrumentals.

TL;DR: you can post a lot of stuff but try posting good rants please

-Yours truly, the beautiful mod team


r/CharacterRant • • 5h ago

Anime & Manga Most anime character don't look white

56 Upvotes

Obviously, there are white anime characters, like the ones in Vinland Saga. However, most anime characters are definitely Japanese, but for some reason, people still think they look white.

It never made sense to me. I mean, is the reason people think this simply because they have light skin? So many Japanese people have light skin.

Is it because they have big eyes? Again, big eyes and double eyelids are not uncommon among Japanese people.

Look at Japanese cosplayers. They often look so much like the characters they're cosplaying. This shows that many anime characters actually look Japanese.

And then there's hair and eye colour. First of all, in manga and anime, hair and eye colours are often used to represent a character's personality. Besides, there are plenty of anime characters with unnatural hair and eye colours, like pink. I've even seen anime characters with black hair and black eyes being called white-looking. So hair and eye colour don't really matter.

Seriously, look up Kanna Hashimoto, she is Japanese actress. If you drew an anime character based on her, people would probably claim that the character looks white simply because she has double eyelids and pale skin.

I don't know how you can draw a Japanese character with big eyes in a simplified art style that isn't very realistic, like Vinland Saga, without making them look white.

If you believe that anime character look white then can you explain why?


r/CharacterRant • • 19h ago

ATLA should be praised for not going back on its premise

345 Upvotes

One of the things I despise the most in stories is when a character is described as "the last X" but then the story cannot stop itself from adding more Xs.

Goku (Dragon ball) starts as a "monkey boy" able to transform into a giant ape but then the story decides that Goku cannot be unique anymore so a number of Saiyans start appearing (Vegeta, Nappa, Radish, Broly, Turles, Tarble).

Same thing happens with Superman, "Kal-el is the last kryptonian!" Well except for Supergirl, Krypto (kinda), Zod and his goons.

Eve Kung Fu Panda does it, we learn in the second movie about the panda genocide but at the end of the same movie we have confirmation there are other pandas alive, Poe was the last panda for 2h.

But in ATLA it doesn't happen, from the first episode until the last Aang is the last Airbender, the premise is never diminished (DBZ, Superman) or nullified (Kung fu Panda). No secret city with escaped airbenders, no lucky survivors, the airbenders are dead and their monasteries are just fancy graveyards.

It's also incredibly refreshing that Aang actually knows the culture he comes from, Poe, Goku and Superman are infants when the extenction of their people happen and barely have a contact with their original cultures, they mostly don't care about them but Aang is different.

While Poe/Goku/Superman simply adopt the culture they were adopted into, Aang is forced to reconcile that the culture he grew up with is dead and accept when the world forces him to bend his love for his culture with the needs of the world (like in s1 ep17).

A lot of stories treat the origin of the main character as just an excuse to give the main character unique powers/appearance or as an excuse to spawn out enemies, ATLA not only doesn't do it but makes an effort in having Aang's origin shape who he is in a way that should be way more common in media


r/CharacterRant • • 1h ago

Comics & Literature Genuine question,why do a lot of people act like Batman's villains can't just pick up a Gun and shoot Frank as well?

4 Upvotes

I always see people claim that the Punisher is "Who Gotham needs" and That Frank would "Clear Gotham" and whatnot and Let's be so deadass...if Jason Peter Todd,someone who was trained by Batman and kills can't even clean up Gotham,what in the world makes you guys think that Frank is doing any better?

Maybe he's taking out the big crime families like the Falcones, Penguin,Two-Face, etc..then it really gets iffy and insane when dealing with wild cards/Lunatics like Joker and Scarecrow..Him fighting Deadshot and Deathstroke and Lady Shiva could go either way but I'm putting it on them but anyone above those like Clayface or Bane or Killer Croc,and so on..he's getting demolished and hell,I wouldn't be surprised if Commissioner Gordon and Batman had Frank Arrested and in Cuffs within his first murders and I'm sorry but Frank can't even clean up his own city,and you guys expect him to do any better there?

Also why does it feel like nobody acknowledges that Frank's nonsensical and never ending war on crime is meant to be a toxic flaw and problem for him and in general?

He basically seems himself as the Judge,Jury and Executioner and it's so weird how Batman and Joker are the only ones who get this shit but no other superhero and their villains get that flack and it just feels like bias and how come Jason doesn't get any fraud allegations for not being able to kill Joker or any of the other villains but all the blame is placed on Bruce?

Just feels like people glaze anti-heroes and such way too much to be sensible and also..Joker has almost been killed by Batman+ left to die and such multiple times,dude just has plot armor.


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago Bravo

General Keeping up with media you hate is bad actually

500 Upvotes

"but hating is fun" not as fun as finding things you enjoy.

"we have to dissect why bad media is bad so we can expect better" Making a writeup about something you dislike doesn't make you a good critic, and it doesn't mean you've helped further public understanding of art or media.

i feel like a lot of online discourse tricks people into consuming media they hate continuously forever, because if you can just have some profound take on WHY it's bad, then you've gained some kind of social standing.

You haven't. You've just consumed media you dislike. that's the baseline. It's bad enough when content creators do it but at least a youtube essay can be transformative. Even if you claim to b fine with spending your time this way, it logically indicates to me that your time, and in many cases your opinions, are WORTHLESS.

Stopping consuming a piece of media because you dislike it is wiser and more genuine than 99% of discourse about why bad media sucks

Edit: when i clicked post reddit AI recommended I crosspost this to the Mauler subreddit, which is funny because he's like one of the biggest offenders in this case

Edit 2: I have failed. I meant to talk about deep hatred, yet I also use the word dislike in my post. I think disliking something is different than hating something. Both in degree and in kind. Hatred leads to the behaviors i criticize. Constantly engaging in something you dislike can be a little sus, but it's ultimately not what i have a problem with.


r/CharacterRant • • 18h ago

General A successor needs to live up to the legacy, not just inherit the title

69 Upvotes

If you can’t handle passing the mantle, put it down…I really dislike when franchises pass on the title or position to a different character, but do literally nothing to work with it.

Now with Doomsday coming up, what inspired this rant, is Sam Wilson and Captain America. I just…really dislike Sam Wilson as Captain America. Not because I don’t think Sam Wilson could be a successful successor to Steve Rogers, but because it’s just so poorly executed to me that it’s such a meh choice. Like, he’s just fucking boring.

Steve Rogers is one of the most iconic characters in the MCU. His entire arc was built around what Captain America represents, the values he holds, the sacrifices he makes etc. By the time Steve passes the shield to Sam he’s supposed to be inheriting an entire legacy. An almost impossible standard to live up to, but one that should at least be acknowledged and meaningfully built upon. And the actual reason for the choice is important too. I’m not a “Bucky shoulda got the shield” typa person, in fact I kinda hate that for Bucky, but if you hinge the idea on the perceived closeness and trust between Sam and Steve, I’m just…not buying it? It was just never properly explored, and this gives a lotta room for people to say, if it was just about who you were buds with, why not Bucky? If we hinge the idea on Sam being noble and selfless while having all the odds stacked against him, what’s he done that’s more selfless or risk-taking than Bucky, Cap, even fucking John Walker?

A successor doesn’t necessarily need to replicate the person they’re replacing, but they do need to live up to the standard of the position. They need to understand why that character mattered in the first place, why people gravitated towards them, and why the title carries the weight that it does. Sam just doesn’t have the sauce. To me, it’s a mixture of the writing in FATWS and Brave New World.

You can make the successor different, you can take the character in an entirely new direction, but you can’t expect audiences to care about the transition if you don’t make the transition itself compelling.
And that’s my biggest issue with Sam. It feels like Marvel wants the recognition that comes with passing the Captain America mantle, without doing the actual work of making that transition feel monumental. Steve’s legacy is constantly invoked, but rarely feels like something Sam is actively wrestling with or building upon. It’s almost as though Marvel expects us to automatically accept the handover because it happened on screen, rather than giving us a reason to emotionally invest in it.
You can’t just pass on the name and expect people to care. You have to pass on the legend too. Otherwise you’re just wearing someone else’s costume.

Wally West is what a successful mantle transition actually looks like.

He spent years being Barry Allen's Kid Flash. His relationship with Barry was established long before he inherited the mantle, and when Barry died, Wally didn't immediately become the Flash in name alone. He had to develop his own identity, and establish what his Flash represented. Eventually, he became so beloved that a substantial portion of fans consider him their definitive Flash, even after Barry returned.

That's the difference. The successor doesn't just inherit the costume, they become someone audiences associate with the costume in their own right. The legacy is the starting point and not the substitute for character development.

Stop handing out mantles and start building successors people actually give two fucks about.


r/CharacterRant • • 22h ago

General People need to realize that you can dislike a character even when they’re kind.

97 Upvotes

I’ve seen this a lot. Every time there’s a fictional character that just happens to be kind, sweet or a nice person overall and someone says something even slightly negative about them they’re immediately bombarded with comments saying stuff like “they’re a literal sweetheart how could you hate them?” “Just say you hate whimsy” etc. And I’m like, you don’t have to like a character just because they’re kind in the show man, especially when it’s a main character 😭 you can hate them because you think they’re not well written, you can hate them because their kindness is very cliché-like or their only personality trait, or the “kind character” isn’t an archetype you particularly enjoy.


r/CharacterRant • • 1h ago

Comics & Literature Sam Wilson as Captain America Is One Of The Most Narratively Enriching Legacy Dynamics Of All Time [Marvel Comics]

3 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This is speaking for the comics only.

I do not care about the MCU Sam.

I almost want this to act as the definitive essay backed by easy to comprehend examples and literature symbolism to explain why Sam as Captain America is one of the most enriching aspects of the mantle. More importantly, why his continued existence as Captain America strengthens both the mantle and the legacy behind it.

I'm here to argue, that Sam is one of the few legacy character's whose legitimacy is never dependent on the absence of Steve.

But the only way to understand why Sam should always be (a) Captain America, you need to first understand Steve Rogers narratively. I will go section by section, to try to avoid the massive wall of text this may turn into

The Subtext behind Steve Roger's Standard

Steve Roger's is at his core, perceived to be an unattainable standard. The subtext echoed throughout his mythos reinforces this unattainability:

  • His super soldier serum, a one-of-a-kind creation, can never be perfectly replicated despite the Marvel Universe’s advanced science and magic.
  • He hails from a romanticized past, a time we can only look back on with nostalgia but never return to. "The Greatest Generation".
  • Characters in the Marvel Universe strive to match Steve’s moral goodness but often fall short, as he’s portrayed not just as a good man but as a near-mythical figure.

Steve Rogers represents the unattainable American Ideal. America does not try to be like Steve Rogers despite him being the goal. In short, the Marvel Universe placed Steve Rogers on a pedestal so impossibly high, and not to honor him... but to spare themselves the effort of the climb. The ones who tried to climb fall short. That's how we get the John Walkers. John Walker's failure reinforces the unattainability.

Steve Rogers Leads By Example

Doesn’t matter what the press says. Doesn’t matter what the politicians or the mobs say. Doesn’t matter if the whole country decides that something wrong is something right. This nation was founded on one principle above all else: the requirement that we stand up for what we believe, no matter the odds or the consequences. When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world — “No, you move.”

Amazing Spider-Man #537 

This quote in actuality encapsulates HOW Steve operates in political partisan discourse.

Steve's defining approach is not to use the Captain America mantle as a platform

Steve takes his stance. Plants his feet. and waits for America to follow his lead. This ideology is shown time and time again:

  • Civil War (Where the quote is taken from)
  • Nomad
  • The Captain

He isn't going to try and convince the people he is right (He values true freedom), but he for darn sure isn't going to go along with you. He will resist you if you try to move him. Sticking to your principals and enforcing/teaching your principals are vastly different ideologies.

Steve classically does not use his status to sway the masses towards agreeing with him, even though he very much could. That's why Steve doesn't use his iconic status in the political field intentionally.

Steve's speech seems like a moral hardline. But it's based on a almost blind faith of believing in the best of the American people. Believing In The Soul of America. This is not a Gary Stew moment. It's revealing a character flaw that is 100% accurate to Steve's classical iterations. This flaw is why Steve's particular interpretation of Captain America cannot necessarily speak to everyone's experiences. Not everyone can rely on that faith. It's nice to think of Steve as a unifier due to his principals, but in functional practice, inspiration will not reach every systematic injustice, or every disenfranchised population. Leading by example can only get so far.

This trait literally opens the door for literary commentary on his potential responsibility as Captain America, allowing characters like Sam Wilson to characterize his own use of the mantle:

Sam Challenges Steve's Foundational Argument

If Steve is the unattainable goal, Sam Wilson is the How To Guide. Sam builds on this premise with every narrative tentpole of his identity

Here was a man I’d been as close to as two human beings could be—but in that moment, I saw—maybe for the first time—we’d always been miles apart. Because Steve Rogers, in his heart, believes that when the chips are down, when its values are at stake—his country will do what’s right. And me? In my heart? I can only hope it will
...
I have a side. That's right. I have opinions. Strongly held beliefs, even. And here's the thing. The more I saw the people I believe I was standing up for being walked on. The more I heard the noise machine sprouting intolerance and fear drowning common sense out. The more I wondered shouldn't Captain America be more than just a symbol? Steve always tried to stay above the fray and I respected him for it. He took a stand when he had to, but as far as politics went, he played it close to the vest. But if really believed I could make a difference, if I really believed I could change some minds, do some good - Then wasn't I obligated to try

Sam Wilson: Captain America #2 (2015)

Sam Wilson DOES try to convince you. The fact that Sam uses the mantle to amplify his voice in order shed light on partisan topics, systematic wrongs, and social issues is a direct critique of Steve Rogers use. Note, that this isn't a meta agenda; This is true to Sam's origin as a Social worker. You become a social worker because you want to assist people in helping themselves. His politics is reflected in his origin.

Sam Wilson Is Not Steve Rogers' moral inferior

  • Sam IS as good a person as Steve. This is not a philosophy Sam acquires by becoming Captain America. It predates the mantle. Sam was a social worker before he was Steve Rogers' partner, and his understanding of helping people was established before he ever carried the shield.

Sam guides people to Steve's moral code through advocacy

  • Sam being political is the point. It's a metaphor of political action being used to shape America closer to Steve's Rogers moral ideal. You want to be like Steve? Sam won't just be an example of how, he will guide and show you. He will use the mantle to amplify systematic issues in the political sphere. Who better to guide America to Steve's ideal, then the person who guide Steve when he came out the ice.

Sam's lack of blind faith allows him to be a representative of Captain America to the folks who Steve simply can't represent.

  • Sam remains Captain America in the Marvel 616 even while Steve is active. His 2025 ongoing didn't justify it by making Sam so great at being Captain America that he earned it. Sam Wilson: Captain America by Nick Spencer justified it by making readers look at America as a thematic whole. America cannot be represented by one unattainable moral paragon. It is a melting pot of different cultures, ideas and beliefs. Sam’s journey is about inspiring those who need a Captain America and being the bridge towards Roger's ideal. This isn't even subtext at this point. It was the entire dialogue of issue #24 of Captain America: Sam Wilson (2015).

Both Sam's and Steve's approaches are valid. In fact, they become more meaningful together.

And that makes Sam as Captain America an enriching expansion of the mantle rather than a replacement for Steve. In fact, Sam's continued existence as Captain America is a thematic necessity.

America contains different experiences, histories, communities, and perspectives. A national symbol that claims to represent all those people benefits from having multiple legitimate interpretations.

  • Steve's existence doesn't invalidate Sam's.
  • Sam's existence doesn't invalidate Steve's.

Their coexistence creates a conversation that the mantle benefits from. A lot of legacy characters try demonstrate that the original hero's legacy can survive without them. That's their goal. Sam doesn't need to prove he can exist without Steve. He demonstrates why the legacy of Captain America is better with both of them.

Steve Rogers represents the America we aspire to be. Sam Wilson represents the journey to that ideal.

This Thread is somewhat of an encapsulation of my previous rants finally combined:
"No, You Move": You Are Interpreting This Captain America Speech Wrong : r/CharacterRant

MCU Sam Wilson is a Fatal Misread : r/CaptainAmerica


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Games It bothers me how rarely Pokemon trainers will try to stack the field in their favor (pokemon)

64 Upvotes

Most of the time, in Pokemon games, battles will take place on a relatively neutral playing field. The only exceptions are places where active background weather is, like the sandstorm riddled Route 4 in Unova, or the stormy Route 218 in Sinnoh.

An exception to this, that I liked, is the final battle against Klara or Avery in the Pokemon Sword and Shield dlc. Where the former will rig the field with Toxic Spikes, and the latter with Psychic Terrain, before the final battle starts. I think this is the only time a trainer takes action before a battle starts to set up the battlefield to be in their favor before the fight starts, and it bothers me. More trainers should do this.

It doesn't even have to be in an underhanded way. Imagine a water type gym leader setting up sprinklers to serve as rain during their battle, or electric leaders running current to give them electric terrain. And you're telling me an evil team leader wouldn't stack the deck before a fight? Like Maxie having harsh sunlight going, or Giovanni having stealth rocks ready to go?


r/CharacterRant • • 23h ago

Save the Last Dance is the best episode in all of Ben 10

40 Upvotes

In case you don't know which episode I'm referring to, it's the one where Big Chill has children. To me, this episode is the best because it's arguably the one that pushes the premise of the show further than any other. The premise of this episode is intrinsically tied to what makes Ben 10 interesting in the first place: the idea that a teenager has access to an entire arsenal of alien species, each with their own biology, abilities, and characteristics, and that these aren't simply different sets of superpowers for him to use.

And that's what I love about it. The story isn't something that could be transplanted into practically any other superhero cartoon by changing a few names and abilities. Its entire premise depends on the unique mechanics of Ben 10. You need a protagonist who can physically become different species, and you need a show that has established enough about those species for their biology to become a meaningful storytelling device. Without the Omnitrix, Big Chill, and the established relationship between Ben and his transformations, there simply isn't a story here.

And honestly, I wish the franchise had explored that side of its premise more often


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Comics & Literature Hey did you remember the time there was a "team" vs x-men, and one of the faction endangered a vast amount of life in an attempt to boost their numbers?

28 Upvotes

I'm annoyed by how some fans keep pushing the narrative the X-Men were always right in these conflicts, despite being exactly opposite positions.

In Inhuman vs X-Men the Inhumans have released the terrigen mists to create more inhumans, which mutate in contact with the air and unexpectadely become toxic for mutants, at which points the Inhuman help the mutants with their plight, the conflict start because of miscomunication and Medusa discovering that the mists are going to encompass the earth immediately states all Inhuman powers aren't worth a single mutant life and agrees to destroy the mists.

In Avengers vs X-Men the X-Men want to let the phoenix arrive with no precaution, while it's destroying every world it's passing, because it MIGHT (with 0 evidence) allow new mutants to be born with the X-Gene active, keep refusing to collaborate with creating countermeasures, despite the phoenix already having a story in driving mad its users and destroying things, and never consider they might have been wrong, or to care for any non-mutant life in the conflict, unlike the aforementioned inhumans.

I've seen the argument that they're ultimately vindicated and proven unambigously right, but that's false, Hope lost control the first time she tried to channel the phoenix, and only learned to use its power during the event.

I've also seen the argument that Rachel would have shown everyone the X-men were right and she never lost control, but the literal second thing she did with the power of the phoenix was steal the lifeforce of the other X-Men in an attempt to erase the universe to destroy the Beyonder, in hope the next universe would be free of his influence.

Not saying "The X-Men are monsters and villains" or that the avengers handled the situation correctly (or that the inhuman didn't make an horrendous blunder and aggravated a bad situation), but I'm really tired of the popularity of the X-Men (and their rightful spite towards editorial trying to sideline them) making them always in the right in these discussions.

My first post around here, hopes to not have been too aggravating.

Thanks for the attention and sorry for the wall of text.

Opinions?


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Games The Chicago Enclave in Hearts of Iron 4: Old World Blues is unironically one of the best written and coded final bosses in strategy games

77 Upvotes

If you’ve spent any meaningful amount of time playing Hearts of Iron IV: Old World Blues (OWB), you’ve probably had your fair share of campaigns fighting against, or as Caesar’s Legion. For years, the Legion has occupied that classic "raid boss" niche in the western and central wastes. They swarm you with endless hordes of tribals, use sheer manpower volume to flood frontlines, and rely on brute-force territory control.

But let’s be completely honest with ourselves: Caesar’s Legion is a paper tiger when you are crazy industrialized.

Give any high tech player enough time to stack sophisticated energy weapons, field power armor divisions and stabilize their industrial base, and the Legion will die after they notice they cannot swarm you to death.

And then, the mods "East Coast Reborn" and "New England Rising" appear, and add a true final boss.

Enter the Chicago Enclave.

Having recently played as them and fought them as the Lyon's Chapter, I can say... They aren’t a nation, they are an army of robots, vertibirds and power armor with a state; they are an automated, hyper-industrialized, technocratic monster.

When you first load into Chicago, you notice a massive elephant in the room: their manpower recruitment capabilities are fundamentally crippled.

Unlike conventional nations that rely on drafting citizens, conscripting local tribals, or drawing from sprawling core populations, Chicago faces severe structural limitations on human recruitment. Traditional population growth and recruitable population factors are throttled, and early on, your resource gain efficiency is slapped with a devastating -90% modifier due to "forced labor."

To an inexperienced OWB player, this looks like a fatal flaw. How can a nation conquer half the continent if they can't recruit millions of soldiers?

That is easy, they do not, and you do not.

Chicago sits behind an impenetrable veil of secrecy. While the rest of the wasteland struggles with intel, Chicago’s internal economy functions independently through specialized mechanics. By trading state press for information blackout protocols, you secure massive combat intel advantages while siphoning resources from puppeted or integrated territories without needing to share your own industrial bounty.

Through brilliant diplomatic manipulation and targeted proxy wars (such as navigating the Long March War and integrating the Stockyard), Chicago becomes a monster. Once you absorb the Stockyard and stabilize regional pacification, your factory count skyrockets into the hundreds.

In classic satirical fashion, Chicago relies on exploiting desperate outsiders. When Chief of Exterior Development Harold Haymon suggests offering citizenship to the Sunshine Outcasts, the Secretary loves it, because the mere promise of citizenship creates an infinitely loyal, easily exploitable workforce.

While Caesar’s Legion relies on quantity, Chicago swarms you with robots which cost almost no manpower and operates strictly on quality to an absurd, game-breaking degree.

Chicago has access to sophisticated tech tiers that other nations take years to research, Black Devil & Hellfire Power Armor unlocked via the Enclave army tree, Hellfire power armor units boast staggering stats, a single division can fight like 10 divisions and still win! During wars against regional powers like Detroit Motors or the DC Settlements, enemy infantry divisions literally cannot pierce your armor.

Deep within the Chicago tower facilities, Dr. Camden successfully clones and enhances soldier DNA in the likeness of Frank Horrigan himself, a super mutant who was heavily modified to be bigger, stronger and more durable. While initial cooling system malfunctions limit full production capacity, this project yields elite mutant-strength super-soldiers, unit leaders, and a steady stream of elite manpower.

Following the dramatic (and bloody) internal political restructuring in Chicago, the Ibot Secretary introduces the C27 humanoid combat platform. These aren't clunky old-world protectrons; they are advanced, highly lethal light robot units with absurd attack stats. And you can spam them!

The Secretary’s obsession with his bonsai tree serves as a chilling thematic anchor for the entire campaign. Control is everything. Pruning the unruly branches is just standard procedure.

Rushed to his absolute limit after discovering hidden nuclear silos in Illinois intended to glass cities like Kansas without his knowledge, Harold snaps. In a magnificent, cinematic rage, he confronts the Secretary, screams that his work is unappreciated, and pulls out a pulse pistol, shooting the Ibot right between the optical sensors. Only for the Secretary to pull out a masterful move, he is actually an AI connected to the entire country, HE IS THE CHICAGO ENCLAVE. A 9-foot combat robot emerges from a trapdoor and then Harold is killed. To maintain stability, the Secretary creates a robotic duplicate of Harold to impersonate him on television.

When they have finished the run, they are a nuclear armed superpower who has unified half the united states. And the only thing that can stop them is either the Navarro Enclave (In the enclave reborn redux submod) or a superpowerful brotherhood of steel who was unified the entire west coast and Mexico.


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago Popcorn

Anime & Manga Dragon Ball Z abridged didn't start the Goku is a bad dad thing Toriyama did he has explicitly said as much

202 Upvotes

Like it's not people lacking media literacy or not reading the text, or misinterpreting Goku's character; he is intentionally written to be a bad father

Toriyama the creator of the manga has said as much on multiple occasions and in regards to the jokes of Piccolo being Gohan's father Toriyama has called Piccolo Gohan's spiritual father

Goku isn't interested in child-rearing, probably. He's completely unqualified to be a father. (laughs) He doesn't even have a job. Goku wants nothing other than to get stronger, and it feels like he doesn't have any other instincts.

https://www.kanzenshuu.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=714258& Kanzenshuu – 2004 Toriyama interview quotation

Goku is a disaster as a father (laughs), so I think Gohan considers him a bad example.

I also made Gohan a disciple of Piccolo and I think this was a success. Piccolo became Gohan's spiritual father and probably made him mature.

https://thedaoofdragonball.com/blog/history/goku-is-a-disaster-as-a-father-says-akira-toriyama/ Dragon Ball: The Legendary Manga, Issue 36 2007 Toriyama

“Vegeta, whose pride had been deeply wounded, sought help from Bulma, and little by little, his ruthless personality changed. Nowadays, you certainly might be able to say that,” the creator told Shonen Jump during an interview about Bardock.

“On the other hand, Goku might not have a sense of family members like Gohan and Chi-Chi except as one of his companions.”

https://comicbook.com/anime/news/dragon-ball-creator-on-whether-goku-or-vegeta-is-the-better-fami/ Shonen Jump interview about Bardock Toriyama 2017

Innately, Saiyans place emphasis on increasing the number of strong people in their race, so bonds between parent and child aren't all that strong. King Vegeta and Paragus aim to use their sons to fulfill their own pride and ambitions, respectively, while Bardock, unusually for a Saiyan and more similarly to Earthlings, seems to have just a bit of fondness for his son. Come to think of it, Toriyama comments, Goku doesn't seem to think about his children all that much.

https://imgur.com/6czIhN5 Dragon Ball Super: Broly anime comic Q&A Toriyama 2019

This is something that Toriyama has stated multiple times, and he stated this in 2004 and 2007, before DBZ Abridged and long before Super came out. So even though I already know he most certainly wasn't influenced by DBZA, an unrelated fan parody of his own character, I did feel the need to point that out. Two of these statements were also made before Super, so he didn't just suddenly forget Goku's character.

This is also something deliberately made apparent through the plot of the story. For example, when Goku had Gohan fight Cell, Piccolo had to be the one to tell him that Gohan doesn't like fighting like he does. This was something Goku was completely unaware of, despite Gohan being 11 and the two of them having spent an entire year together. This is even played for laughs in the series multiple times.

For example, Vegeta says in the Super manga that Goku may not be a bad person, but he is a horrible father. This is in the context of Goku not understanding why Vegeta should be there for his daughter's birth, as he wasn't there for Gohan and Goten's births. Now, I'm not sure if Goku just forgot when Gohan was born because he definitely should've been there, but he wasn't there for Goten's birth. Albeit, that wasn't primarily his fault since he was, of course, dead, but that really isn't the issue at hand here. The issue is Goku not even understanding why it's important for him to be there. The fact that he sees no issue with not being there is the problem.

This sorta similar thing happens with Pan as well, where Goku forgets who Pan was for a second and Vegeta chews him out again, albeit this is with grandchildren, not children, but same issue

https://imgur.com/a/pI0cV55

https://imgur.com/a/XGFDbWH

Also, despite it not being Goku's fault that he was dead, do remember that Goku chose to stay dead. That was something he willingly chose to do. He could have gotten himself revived, and Goku's reasoning isn't exactly great. He argues that he attracts danger to Earth and that Gohan is dependable enough to handle things on his own. But the thing is, not only are most of the threats after Cell unrelated to Goku (Buu, Beerus, Champa, Zamasu, Moro, Granolah, Zeno/Jiren, and Gas), with the only exceptions being Frieza and maybe Cell Max, but Gohan is also 11 years old. For most of that time, his father has either been dead or on another planet. And, as we see in the Buu saga, Gohan isn't dependable enough to handle Buu.

Furthermore, the threats that do come because of Goku are going to come anyway. It's too late; that ship has sailed. Had Frieza been revived and Goku not been around, he would've just blown up the planet. Cell Max was going to be created whether Goku stayed dead or not. But we can also tell that the real factor here for Goku was that he wanted to fight people in the Other World. That's the real reason he stayed dead.

https://imgur.com/beTjZlT

Vegeta even calls him out when he does something similar at the end of Z, where he just up and leaves with Uub. Goku says he wants to train the next protector of Earth, but Vegeta knows that Goku actually just wants to be able to fight Uub. Keep in mind that, in this context, where Super and GT didn't exist, Goku had essentially just abandoned his family.

https://imgur.com/ojqrbMK

This is also a character flaw we see when he convinces Krillin to spare Vegeta. Keep in mind, it wasn't because he thought Vegeta might turn over a new leaf like Piccolo. Goku knew that was unlikely to happen, as he acknowledged when Krillin brought up that Vegeta wasn't like Piccolo. And keep in mind that Vegeta and Nappa had beaten the utter breaks off of and killed multiple of his friends, beaten his son, and intended to finish the job. Goku wanted to keep Vegeta alive because his Saiyan instincts were telling him he wanted to fight him again later, the risk that posed to his family be damned. The fact that Vegeta eventually became good was nothing but a happy accident.

https://imgur.com/a/soLHsN3

Also, similar to him choosing to stay dead, he chose to stay on Yardrat and not see his son Gohan. Porunga outright confirms he did not want to come back, which is why he couldn't bring him there now admittedly the technique he learned there, Instant Transmission, became extremely useful in many later arcs, but that wasn't something goku knew beforehand

All of this is to say that no, Goku being a bad father didn't come from TFS, Super, or different adaptations of the character. Goku is intended to be a bad father as Toriyama wrote him. I don't know why fans cannot accept that.

Characters are allowed to have fundamental character flaws. Goku is not an abusive parent, nor is he one of the worst parents of all time. In fact, I'd say Goku is a loving parent, but being a loving parent and being a good parent are not synonymous. Goku is not a malicious parent, but he is characterized as inattentive at best and totally emotionally negligent at worst. He does not separate parental, spousal, or platonic love at all and cannot really understand his children beyond a basic level. At the same time, Goku values fighting as a higher priority, if not the highest priority, even above his family at times.

Now, Goku is no Yassop, Toji, or Ging. Those guys are actual deadbeat bums, but in terms of a scale of 1–10, those guys would be a 2, and Goku is a 4, maybe 4.5 if we're feeling generous. A 1 is for Ozai, Rasa, and Judge Vinsmoke. 0 is reserved for Shou Tuckers and Bonedrewds. Endeavor ranges from 1.8–3.6. Omni-Man ranges quite a bit, from 1.4 to 6. Vegeta's probably, idk, a 5 or 6. Anyway, Loid Forger is a solid 8, maybe even a 9. Minato is a solid 8. Whitebeard is a 9 or 10. Adam from Record of Ragnarok is definitely a 10. Kuma is another 10. Piccolo is a solid 7. Hughes is an 8.

Anyway, the point being, Goku is far from being a good dad, and that's not really a good thing or a bad thing. It just is what it is. My only real complaint is that this flaw of Goku's doesn't really undergo any development. Goku doesn't really change that much. It's kind of part of why I actually didn't like SSG being absorbed into base (not for powerscaling reasons), like Goku wanted. You see, because before there was this really poignant moment. https://www.reddit.com/r/Dragonballsuper/comments/1xfv2fr/vegeta_humiliating_himself_in_bog_was_actually_a/

That Goku didn't achieve this godly power on his own. Goku, being Goku, wants to push himself past his limits. He doesn't want to receive power as help, but Beerus or Goku, I can't remember which, brings up how Vegeta did that goofy Bingo dance. He humiliated himself just so Beerus would spare the planet. In other words, he let go of his pride because the Earth was more important, which it was. That was part of the reason Goku also let go of his own pride and accepted an unearned power-up for the sake of protecting the Earth, his friends, and family.

So, it also sucks that most versions of BoG remove that Bingo dance. But getting off track here, Goku having to accept power he didn't earn would've been great. Except, using that power allows him to instantly absorb its power and master it, making the power entirely his, as Beerus says. This undercuts the entire moment and regresses that bit of character development almost immediately, and it never has to be addressed again.

How does this relate to my overall rant? While I like that Goku has flaws, I think Goku should've changed a bit, like how Vegeta has. But I'm not gonna pretend that's somehow DBZA's fault, or that somehow this trait of Goku's doesn't actually exist and it's all just Larper's fault for misinterpreting the series, when that very obviously isn't the case.

Like, I feel like I'm being gaslit here, where people are somehow reading a different Goku. It's the same as the prequel fans who say that nobody actually hated the prequels and it was actually all just RedLetterMedia. Like, what are you actually talking about? It's the same as that. The prequels weren't hated because of RedLetterMedia. RedLetterMedia made those reviews because the prequels were hated. It's a chicken-or-the-egg thing. DBZA making jokes about Goku being a bad father didn't make people think Goku was a bad father. Goku being a bad father made people think he was a bad father, which in turn made DBZA make jokes that Goku was a bad father.


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Anime & Manga Magna Vs Dante is my fav underdog fight in Shounen anime(Black Clover)

15 Upvotes

Magna vs Dante is still one of the best underdog fights in modern anime

Just watched the Magna vs Dante fight and I’m still not over it,it was fucking phenomenal

Black Clover is one of the best new gens for me cause

What makes Magna vs. Dante one of the best fights in Black Clover is how it completely subverts power-scaling: by using Secret Flame Magic: Soul Chain Deathmatch to divide their total mana evenly, Magna forces an arrogant, regeneration-reliant devil host into a war of attrition where mana efficiency, preparation, and raw hands matter infinitely more than raw powereries for me and this fight is a big reason why. Magna, a straight-up commoner with no special bloodline, no devil, no nothing, walks up to one of the Dark Triad and takes him on 1v1. No Asta, no Yami, no backup. Just him. That alone is already different from most fights we get these days.

The way it plays out is so good. Dante treats him like a complete joke the whole time, and Magna just refuses to stay down. The moment he starts matching the gravity and you realize this random Black Bull is actually pushing him is still one of the hardest “holy shit” moments in the series. The desperation, the animation spikes, the music… it hits different because you can feel how outmatched he is and how hard he’s clawing for every inch

Yuki Tabata doesn’t really do anything out of the box. He’s not reinventing the wheel or coming up with some super unique concept. But the way he wrote Black Clover is just fucking great. The characters feel real, the underdog moments land, and fights like this one actually mean something. It’s not just flashy powers colliding for hype. You care because Magna earned that fight through pure grit.

A lot of modern new gen fights are either pure spectacle with low unearned stakes or just constant power scaling until nothing feels impressive anymore. This one still feels earned. Magna fought that battle alone and made it personal. That’s rare

Don't know why people still atleast in this sub called it generic or something,cause this fight alone proof that black clover is really great imo

Still one of my favorite fights in the whole series. Peak Black Clover energy

Also i still you not,If Black Clover had amazing production from the start as Mha or Ds,it wouldn't have been hated like it was

Yea I love Black Clover a lot


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Films & TV While I wouldn’t say the Star Wars sequel trilogy made everything that was accomplished in the OT and after it pointless, it still doesn’t make the direction they went in any less disappointing.

18 Upvotes

I obviously can’t speak for all fellow Star Wars fans, but I imagine the vast majority for a long time imagined what kind of world Luke and the others created post ROTJ. Barring of course what was done in the old expanded universe. What sort of new government may have replaced the empire? Luke training new Jedi and how would he approach doing such a thing? All that jazz. I was certainly one of those fans. So imagine my disappointment when The Force Awakens slammed it’s fist hard into the reset button so that almost everything is identical to how it was in the older movies.

Both the republic and and Jedi Order are destroyed yet again. The former happens halfway through the movie before we can learn anything about it, and the latter happening before the movie even begins. There’s an empire like faction that needs to be stopped, and it’s primary opposition is this small scrappy band of rebel freedom fighters. A complete snap back to status quo of the OT in a lot of respects.

None of this necessarily makes the past struggles of the OT heroes pointless. A few decades without much war is still something, and the war against the first order in the ST only lasts for a year. But this is one of the last directions I would have chosen to take sequels to the OT in. I can imagine a story set some time in the future where Luke and new Jedi under him are trying to figure out how their small and fledgling order should operate, and this might cause a bit of a rift between some of the characters. Particularly with Ben Solo if you still want him to have a big part in all this.


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Films & TV I can kinda understand why Lucas was reluctant to let go of the Ewoks. (Star Wars)

165 Upvotes

In case you're unaware, while writing the script for Star Wars: Return of the Jedi, Lawerance Kasdan and George Lucas were clashing about what to do about the climax. Whether or not to set it on the Imperial home world (at the time it was known as "Had Abbadon" because Courscant didn't exist yet) or a new second Death Star, which, of course, the latter was the one that made it into the final film.

Kasdan had wanted to set it on Had Abbadon because he found the second Death Star repetitive, but Lucas wanted to go with the Death Star with the whole plan on the forest moon of Endor.

The reason why Lucas was so insistent on this? He couldn't figure out how to work the Ewoks into the Had Abbadon material.

Now at first glance, this might seem like Lucas was putting merchandising over what's best for the story, but it's actually a bit deeper than that.

See, in case you're unaware, the idea of a bunch of primitive natives helping to bring down the Empire was something Lucas had been wanting to do since the first film. Yavin-4's inclusion in the story started as the home planet of the Wookies, who would be the ones to help bring down the Empire, which obviously didn't happen in the final version.

This is a plot point/line that was really important to Lucas. He's always said that the Empire was meant to be America and the Rebels were the Viet Cong. This would have been one of the ways this theme was carried. With a bunch of primitive natives fighting back against the Empire with simple technology and winning.

It was something Lucas had been wanting to do ever since he started this project, and since Return of the Jedi was going to be the final film in the trilogy (Lucas wasn't sure if he was going to do the sequel trilogy at the time of producing Episode 6) this was probably his literal last chance to do so.

So from that lens, Lucas's desire to not let go of the Ewoks becomes a lot more understandable.

I'm not saying you have to agree that keeping the Ewoks was the right call or feel Lucas made the right choice; I'm just pointing out the choice went far deeper than "Let's make Star Wars teddy bear merch for kids!"


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Comics & Literature When Batman's Ideals Come at the Cost of His Son

10 Upvotes

I think Bruce's treatment of Jason is a lot worse when you actually look at everything that happened between them, rather than treating his death as one isolated tragedy.

Bruce took a former street kid, whose background heavily implies he had resorted to prostitution to survive, and made him Robin at just twelve years old. He exposed Jason to all kinds of violence and trauma, including human trafficking, sexual assault, and murder. He also increasingly relied on Jason to keep him emotionally stable, particularly during and after Batman: The Cult. Their relationship was already deteriorating because of Bruce's instability, and it got to the point where Jason had to physically pull him away from multiple rapists he was about to beat into comas or kill. Bruce's excessive force even resulted in a repeat offender getting away shortly before The Diplomat's Son.

Then there's the Felipe Garzonas situation. Bruce knew Felipe was never going to face consequences for his rapes, yet still brought Jason along to investigate him for drug crimes without considering that he might be released before deportation. When Felipe's latest victim killed herself after receiving a threatening phone call, Jason was the one who found her body. Bruce did very little to help him deal with any of this.

When Jason eventually confronted Felipe, he fell to his death. Bruce immediately questioned whether Jason had pushed him. Things got even worse when Felipe's father kidnapped Jim Gordon to lure Batman into a confrontation. Bruce, already convinced Jason had pushed Felipe, decided not to bring him and didn't even tell him what was happening. Jason ended up hiding in the Batmobile anyway and actually saved Bruce's life during the fight. Bruce's response was to lecture him about consequences and make him feel responsible for what happened.

Then comes A Death in the Family. Bruce notices Jason becoming increasingly moody and reckless, but instead of trying to understand why, he just gets angry with him. During the investigation involving child sexual abuse material, Bruce even acknowledges that Jason is just a kid, yet still treats him like someone who needs to work off his aggression. Alfred later tells him that Jason has repeatedly been found crying over pictures of his parents. Does Bruce talk to him? No. He assumes Jason hasn't gotten over their deaths and decides to take him off the job.

Jason then discovers that Catherine wasn't his biological mother and starts looking for his real mother. He doesn't even consider asking Bruce for help because he's convinced Bruce wouldn't care about something that has nothing to do with catching criminals. When they eventually meet during the investigation, Jason initially gets excited because he thinks Bruce has come to help him. Instead, Bruce tells him he's there because of the Joker's nuclear threat. Jason's response says it all. There's nothing glamorous about hunting down a runaway.

Even after they start working together, Bruce still doesn't understand how important finding his mother is to Jason. He leaves him behind to deal with the Joker, expecting him to follow orders and stay put. Jason goes after his mother and is murdered by the Joker while trying to protect her.

Bruce's response afterward is arguably just as bad. He spends years describing Jason as reckless, violent, and disobedient, despite these behaviors being relatively recent developments. He practically reduces Jason's entire Robin legacy to his worst moments and eventually moves on to Tim, almost as though Jason had never been Robin in the first place.

And then there's Under the Hood, which brings everything full circle.

Jason comes back from the dead and confronts Bruce about the Joker. He wants Bruce to kill the man who murdered him and continues terrorizing Gotham. Bruce refuses, and when Jason makes it clear he'll do it himself, Bruce physically intervenes.

He throws a Batarang at Jason, striking him around the shoulder and neck area. Jason is left bleeding heavily and collapses. People can argue about whether Bruce intended to hit his shoulder, whether he misjudged his aim, or whether he was too emotionally compromised to control what he was doing. But honestly, I think too much time gets spent debating the exact circumstances instead of looking at what happened.

Bruce wounded his son to protect Joker. He was willing to risk Jason's life rather than let him kill the man responsible for his murder. This is the second time Bruce has effectively put Joker ahead of Jason's wellbeing, and it's especially difficult to overlook given everything that happened before.

Bruce was so determined to find a third option that he couldn't accept Jason taking revenge for his own murder. But what did that actually accomplish? Jason was denied his own closure, Joker remained alive, and his future victims were left at risk. Bruce's refusal to compromise his methods came at the expense of the very people he claims to protect.

I think there's too much focus on defending Bruce's intentions, explaining his trauma, or pointing out that he was trying to do the right thing, while Jason's actual experiences get pushed aside. Jason was a child who was repeatedly exposed to horrific situations, left without the support he needed, blamed when things went wrong, and eventually killed. Even after his death, Bruce continued to diminish his experiences and legacy.

At what point do Batman's principles stop protecting people and start failing them?


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Simpsons episode Testing 1-2-3 where Lisa gets a psychological evaluation was bad

10 Upvotes

Testing 1-2-3 was explicitly promoted by Fox as the one where Lisa undergoes official psychological testing. Naturally you would expect Lisa to get diagnosed with something, much like Bart has been canonically diagnosed with ADHD, but she was never diagnosed with anything. I'm not saying Lisa has to be diagnosed with something, but promoting the episode as one where Lisa gets evaluated, making that the entire premise of the episode, and then completely dropping that plot point, seems manipulative.

I wrote another post on this episode, which was downvoted, I think because people think I'm saying all characters who seem potentialy autistic need to be diagnosed on screen, which was not my intended point. My other examples are also weaker than this Simpsons episode and I think the episode is bad enough to deserve it's own thread.

In this episode Lisa can't focus on a test due to ordinary classroom noise, and tries to get access to the quiet accommodated testing center. Based on this she should perhaps at least be diagnosed with sensory processing disorder. She could also potentially have autism or OCD, and she has been clearly shown traits of anxiety and depression. It's also possible Lisa experiences episodes of symptoms which are too brief and unobtrusive to qualify for any particular diagnosis, but the episode didn't establish that either.

Lisa's symptoms of depression were explored in the classic episode "Moaning Lisa," where her depression leads her to meet Bleeding Gums Murphy and discover a passion for blues music, which becomes an important part of her character going forward. She was also prescribed antidepressants in another episode. Yet she has never been officially diagnosed with depression, even though in real life, you can't get a prescription without a diagnosis.

The episode features Rachel Bloom. I like Rachel Bloom because Crazy Ex Girlfriend was a really good series, and it's also a series well known for good depictions of mental illness. However her performance was completely wasted as a psychologist who does nothing.

Lisa sits down to take a psychological test consisting of a piece of paper asking if she has various symptoms. She then thinks of various other characters whose behavior fits those symptoms. Principal Skinner is strongly implied to have autism, Comic Book Guy and his wife Kumiko both have OCD, Homer has ADHD.

At the end of the episode Lisa fell asleep during the test and isn't diagnosed with anything. They make this into a lame joke about her being denied "extended time on tests." Then the episode cuts to a cringe song about neurodiversity. This song is pure toxic positivity neuroslop. The lyrics include "everybody's got a little something" and "we are all a little bit crazy!" I think this is condescending and diminishing the seriousness of mental disorders. It conflates ordinary superstition with OCD symptoms and generally treats disorders like personality quirks.

Again, I'm not saying Lisa HAS to be diagnosed with something, but if you're not gonna diagnose her why make that the entire premise of the episode? Imagine if they did an episode where Patty considered if she was lesbian or not (she already came out as lesbian canonically so just pretend this didn't happen yet) and instead of confirming or denying Patty's sexuality the episode just concludes "everyone is a little bit gay" without saying anything about Patty in particular.

We all know modern Simpsons isn't exactly a paragon of brilliant writing, but I was expecting a little bit better than this. Bart Simpson is weirdly probably the best canon ADHD representation in any media, it's been very consistent in his character, and some episodes convey how ADHD seriously impacts him rather than just treat it as a joke. Such as the episode Bart Gets an F.

In this episode on the other hand, Homer's ADHD is portrayed in a very frivolous "oh look a squirrel" fashion. It's hard to portray it any other way because Homer's modern character is so unintelligent, bumbling and unserious, but it's annoying when Bart's ADHD seems a lot more meaningful. OCD is also shown as pretty silly and unserious.

My other thread focused on another aspect of the episode I found very strange: the word "autism" is never used. Characters are explicitly labeled OCD and ADHD, but while autism is strongly implied, the word is never said. Why? Does anyone really give a crap if Skinner is autistic or not? Is the marketability of Principal Skinner going to plummet if someone calls him autistic on screen? Nobody is shocked that a 44 year old virgin who lives with his mother is autistic.

To summarize my complaints:

  • Rachel Bloom did nothing.
  • The premise was Lisa being evaluated but she wasn't said or implied to have any disorder.
  • Autism symptoms were heavily implied but the term autism was deliberately avoided.
  • The episode takes a patronizing "everyone is a bit crazy" approach.
  • The Breakfast Club parody was unfunny.
  • This is the epitome of modern lazy safe meaningless checkmark style "representation."

r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Films & TV ALAN MOORE is right and Hollywood adaptations are vapid and shallow!

104 Upvotes

This isnt a character rant but it fits the comic book/superhero genre so...

I am an avid fan and collector of comic books, leaning heavily but not exclusively on the superhero genre. As a result, I enjoy most superhero and comic book movies.

But Hollywood does not understand either the comic book medium or the superhero genre.

Writer Alan Moore, since the late 1980s, has criticized the idea of Hollywood adaptations. This man has been wronged by the industry and used to air his grievances... He's older now and has largely abandoned superheroes and comics and has stopped talking about them... BUT HE IS RIGHT!

When you watch a "MAKING OF" documentary, you have all of these sycophantic actors, producers, and Hollywood media people spewing bullshit to promote their project. Perhaps you think this is normal and should be expected? FAIR ENOUGH. But it is just so shallow and lazily done.

It just infuriates me to see Jessica Alba talk about growing up with Fantastic Four comics and finally getting to fulfill her dream of playing THE INVISIBLE WOMAN. BULLSHIT!

Dwayne Johnson has said that when he was growing up BLACK ADAM taught him about honor. HONOR? Black Adam is a murderous despotic power-mad supervillain from DC who was largely absent in culture until this movie came out, and you didn't know who TF he was when you were growing up.

It infuriates me to hear Hollywood producers get philosophical about WATCHMEN or Spider-man or Batman and then refer to them as characters from "graphic novels." BULLSHIT... when you were a kid they were called "comic books" but your industry is so embarrassed and ashamed that superhero movies have become a 20+ year phenomenon that they have to attempt to elevate them by calling them "graphic novels" because they don't think highly of the genre.

Alan Moore predicted all of this in 1988... that, because of BATMAN (1989) one of my fav. movies BTW, that the future would bring a sea of people who never read a comic book in their lives professing to be life-long fans, superhero readers, and even experts on comic books because they will find themselves attached to "HIGH PROFILE HOLLYWOOD FILMS WITH BIG-BUDGETS" and they will be forced by the industry to promote them. Alan Moore would later say that no film will ever be able to capture the rich mythology, the essence of any superhero character, or their inner lives in 2 1/2 hours and that most comic books are actually un-filmable, no matter how good technology gets because the movies will offer surface level action or cartoon violence, and ignore actual themes.

Perhaps most maddening is that people are spoon-fed this marketing about Hollywood loving superheroes and they buy it.

To clarify... I love many of these films... but they are not deep. These are escapist popcorn flicks. The industry is a shallow, grubby parasite that wants you to believe its marketing. And it sucks!

Thanks for reading.


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Battleboarding Debunking the "6D / Immeasurable Speed / NEP2 Qliphoth" Black Clover Meta (With Chapter & Page Context)

5 Upvotes

[this post here]

I keep seeing the same copy-paste Qliphoth cosmology scale get used to argue 6D AP, Immeasurable speed, and Type 2 Non-Existent Physiology (NEP2) for Black Clover top tiers. Black Clover already has great hax and consistent FTL+ speed, so it doesn't need inflated dimensional scaling to hold its own. Looking strictly at the exact chapters and pages used in that argument, the entire scaling chain breaks down at every step.
1. "Lucifero became the cosmological tree" (Chapter 315, Page 3)
The argument opens by claiming that when Lucifero fused with the Qliphoth in Chapter 315, he literally became the cosmological structure containing the entire Underworld.
In reality, that monster wasn't even full Lucifero. It was an incomplete, makeshift manifestation created by mashing together the low- and mid-ranking devils from the first two gates using Morris's modification magic. More importantly, the Tree of Qliphoth is a magical channel/conduit built to connect the Underworld to the human world so devils can cross over. Fusing with a magical gate construct does not mean you suddenly absorb the mass, space-time, and energy of an entire realm.
2. The "20 Years Ago" Report (Chapter 331, Pages 10-11)
The meta argues that because Damnatio's reports from 20 years ago listed which devils were "matched" to the Qliphoth (and Megicula replaced Astaroth), the Qliphoth is a permanent higher-dimensional cosmic structure rather than a ritual.
All Damnatio's report proves is that the hierarchy of the ten supreme devils corresponding to the ten positions of the Kabbalah Tree of Qliphoth existed in the Underworld before the Spade ritual. When Astaroth vanished, Megicula took his spot in the supreme devil hierarchy. The actual physical tree channel connecting the two worlds still had to be grown and opened via the Advent of Qliphoth ritual using William's World Tree Magic and Yami's Dark Magic.
3. Nacht's Diagram & Volume 22 Cover (Chapter 263, Page 7 & Chapter 280, Page 1)
This is where the 6D math comes from. The post takes Nacht's visual diagram of the seven levels of the Underworld, notes they are drawn as separate horizontal layers aligned in a straight line, and concludes each floor is an equidistant, independent spacetime—making the Qliphoth a 6D container (4 spatial axes + 2 temporal axes). It also cites Volume 22's cover blurb saying the battle with Zagred "transcended time and space."
First, back-cover promotional blurbs like "a battle transcending time and space" are classic shonen hype text, not literal dimensional tiering statements. Second, Nacht's diagram in Chapter 263 is a simple 2D infographic explaining to the Magic Knights how the Underworld is divided into seven floors (strata) with stronger devils residing deeper down. Taking a flat chalk-style diagram literally to claim "the lines are equidistant, therefore it has 4 spatial axes and 2 time axes" is pure headcanon. Nowhere in the manga is it ever stated that each floor of the Underworld has its own separate timeline or temporal axis.
4. The "Immeasurable Speed" Leap
Because the scale assumes each Underworld floor has a separate dimension of time, it claims Lucifero fusing with the Qliphoth made him move "across multiple directions of time at once," granting him and anyone relative to him Immeasurable speed.
Since the Underworld layers don't have separate time axes, this entire speed argument collapses at step one. Beyond that, the manga blatantly contradicts Immeasurable speed. Hundreds of chapters later in the Final Arc, Yami explicitly states that Paladin Morgen's Light Magic moves at light speed, and characters still rely on Ki sensing, Mana Zone, and physical velocity to react to attacks. If characters had Immeasurable speed, light-speed attacks wouldn't even register as a threat.
5. "Dark Magic = Beyond-Dimensional Non-Existence (NEP2)"
The final claim argues that because Dark Magic creates real darkness, and darkness is the absence of light (and would still be absent if spacetime didn't exist), Dark Magic and the Qliphoth possess beyond-dimensional non-existence.
This is just a wordplay fallacy confusing physical absence with metaphysical non-existence:TL;DR
The copy-paste Qliphoth argument relies on taking a 2D infographic diagram literally, treating promotional volume cover hype text as literal dimensional geometry, and confusing "darkness = absence of light" with metaphysical non-existence. Black Clover has great hax and solid FTL+ combat speed, so it really doesn't need 6D fanfiction to be respected.

(*also if you have any black clover wank post. you can post a debunk post on r/blackcloverdebunked*)


r/CharacterRant • • 2d ago

The Jedi can't end slavery (Star Wars)

216 Upvotes

One common, reoccurring criticism of the Jedi Order in Star Wars is that slavery exists in the galaxy that they don't put an end to.

I'll be the first to say George Lucas screwed up by not having the Jedi themselves inform Anakin that his mother had been freed from slavery and remarried by a local on Tatooine instead of him finding that out from Watto. In other words, I'd have clarified that the Jedi checked on Shmi but discovered she was doing alright and so there was nothing for them to do.

That said, the criticism goes well beyond the Prequels sloppy writing, to imply that the Jedi are essentially complacent in slavery or don't care about it at all. That they should drop everything they're doing and focus all of their efforts to end slavery immediately, and so on.

There are several problems with that.

1. Everyone forgets that Anakin and Shmi had bombs planted in them.

There's a reason Qui Gon didn't try to smuggle them both away and had to legally (for Tatooine) purchase their freedom from Watto. And that's because they have bombs planted in them that can be remotely detonated if they run away, Anakin even said he tried to find his with a scanner but couldn't so it's not simple to remove either.

This would naturally complicate efforts to free slaves but that's not all!

2. The Jedi are apart of the Republic, and that affiliation is the only thing that gives them ANY authority.

People often criticize the Jedi for their association with the Republic, saying it makes them too political and they should break away from them... The issue that, if they did do so, they would not have the legal authority to do ANYTHING of note.

As much as people hate the association, the Republic grants the Jedi the ability to act within a system that grants things like trials and human rights so it's not simply a group of superhuman beings enacting their will upon others. If they weren't apart of the Republic they'd essentially be acting as either vigilantes or a paramilitary organization because how else would they accomplish anything apart from engaging in the democratic process, which the Order is already a piece of.

3. The Jedi do combat slavery but they can't effectively end it altogether.

First off, the Republic itself has outlawed slavery. So supporting the Republic itself does make sense if you're against slavery. Furthermore, it was the strong enough to last a thousand generations and defeat the Sith at their height so that they resorted to infiltration instead.

As for slavers? Star Wars: The Clone Wars has an arc featuring a former slaver empire attempting to rebuild. They attribute their prior defeat directly to the Jedi, and the arc ends with them being defeated again by the Republic. So the Jedi do in fact combat slavers when they can.

4. The Sith are themselves huge proponents of slavery and the Jedi always oppose them.

We see it all over the place when the Sith come to power. They almost always end up enslaving a good chunk of the population to work for them. The Jedi Order are their most consistent enemies so by nature of this rivalry alone the Jedi prevent quite a bit of oppression by stopping them from taking power.

5. The Jedi are few in number relative to the problems of the Galaxy.

I think it's even less than this but let's say the Jedi have 10,000 members... well the Separatist Alliance alone consisted of as many systems. That means there's less than one Jedi per planet in the Republic alone.

Furthermore, solving issues is not some immediate thing you can do by your lonesome. Star Wars has a habit of naming some random problem anywhere and then going, "Why don't the Jedi stop this!" when frankly I wouldn't be surprised if they hadn't even heard of it.

Let's say you're a Jedi and learn about bad working conditions in the Republic that are tantamount to slavery. Well, you'll probably need to file a report to Senate after an investigation, work with authorities, deal with attempts to subvert or minimize the impact of your work, etc. It could take a while is what I'm saying. And while you're doing that problems will fester elsewhere, so good luck keeping up on EVERYTHING.

6. Finally, the only way to the Jedi to end slavery... would be to go to war with the Outer Rim. Without the Republic.

But circling back to the topic at hand. Let's say the Jedi decide they're sick of Tatooine practicing slavery and they're going to put an end to it. They could do only by invading the planet without Republic support (unless they somehow convinced the Senate to go to war with the whole Outer Rim).

If you think they have bad PR now, imagine how reviled the Jedi would be if they were depicted as a crusader army that invaded planets. They'd be accused of being imperialist, warmongers, bloodthirsty, hypocritical, and far more.

They'd also be hunting tribes like the Tuskens through the desert to free their slaves too much I'm sure people would be normal about.

Oh and don't forget the bombs implanted in the slaves that'd detonate if they freed them. Which I'm sure people wouldn't blame the Jedi for.

Finally this is assuming they'd even win the war if the Outer Rim decided to fight back. Remember there's 10,000 of them to go around against hundreds of planets worth of firepower.

Tl;dr on Clones since they'll probably come up several hundred times here: They were drafted into war by the Republic who also got the Jedi to fight in it. The shows depict and directly state that the Clones began to exhibit greater personality and independence due. They also initially meant to be automatons rather than sentient beings (messy writing, like I said) but are never depicted as slaves so much as a drafted army in-universe, with the Jedi also being drafted to fight in the war. In short, it was a messy plot but they weren't treated as slaves in the narrative and the Jedi were shown to be their closest friends.

Conclusion

In short, the Shmi plot was sloppy because not enough was explained and George had the Jedi not know anything about what happened to her. The issue is not that the Jedi's philosophy forbids actively combating slavery, and they need a connection to the Republic to have the legal authority to act to the degree they do.


r/CharacterRant • • 2d ago

Anime & Manga Lack of action shoujo is reason why women writing conversation in manga exist

208 Upvotes

Whether we like it or not, action is the most popular genre, whether in manga, comics, movies, or video games. It is a favourite genre for many people, and many people primarily watch anime or read manga for the action. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

Some people genuinely enjoy and want to watch stories featuring well-written female characters in action roles or even female protagonists in action series.

Now, unlike Japan, other countries don't have manga magazines or divide their media based on gender like Japan do.

Just look at the most popular shoujo and shounen manga magazines. You're far more likely to find action series in shounen magazines. The most popular shoujo manga these days tend to focus on high school romance, whereas shounen magazines have everything like action, gag comedy, romance etc

There are action shoujo manga like Magical Girl dandelion but they're quite rare.

If there were more action-oriented shoujo manga, people who want action stories with well-written female characters could simply read them. But since they're so rare, those people read battle shounen instead.

Plenty of female manga artists in Japan have complained about not being able to write non-romance stories for shoujo magazines, which is why some of them turn to shounen or seinen magzine instead.

Editors seem to think that teenage female readers in Japan are only interested in romance stories.

Obviously, The Apothecary Diaries is a mystery rather than an action series, but around 70% of its readers in Japan are women.

I don't remember the exact demographic breakdown for Ascendance of a Bookworm, but it's a fantasy series, and the last time I checked, its female readership was also 70% +.

So I think there's clearly a market for genres other than romance among female readers


r/CharacterRant • • 11h ago

Films & TV Why in the actual fck are people shipping spiderman x jean grey

0 Upvotes

I just finished brand new day yesterday and I liked the movie yes. But just today I get to see the madness and stupidity of the internet because people are literally shipping jean grey x spiderman like wtf is wrong with people?

Jean grey is everything spiderman is against of and don't even get me started on the stupid reasons people bring to justify this ship.

1)We need a new ship dynamic: I would have agreed on this since in the cinematic universe a lot of ships aren't canon comic wise but are so well written it's irreplaceable like Tony stark and pepper potts. But we are giving this opportunity to the character that needs it the least. This spiderman has arguably one of the best and healthiest relationships with MJ unlike the Tobey Maguire one who was the worst. We have much better characters that can do it.

2)They are made for each other: no the fck they are not. Jean grey is everything opposite to what spiderman stands for. The main reason for Spiderman is that he is the personification of responsibility, to put others before himself and to help those who can't help themselves. Jean is literally the opposite of that: all power and no consequence. Granted she was a teenager but the amount of bs she got away bcoz of 'oh my sister got killed' is infuriating. Like ya your sister got killed but what about all the innocent lives you have ruined. Don't they have a family? Not to mention that even before her sister's capture she was literally abusing her powers on random people. No wonder why people hate mutants in other universes because they are all powerful with no consequences. I swear to God, this is the worst argument one can bring.

3)He took a bullet for her: As he would regardless of whoever else would be in Jean's place because that's what the entire point of spiderman is. He literally learned in no way home that this will not fix anything but just add in an extra deal of pain he had to carry for the rest of his life. Almost all of spiderman's villains are merciless against peter yet peter still holds back and the same applies to jean. She did up and beyond to ruin Peter's life but he still forgave her because he is Spiderman.

4) MJ moved on so why shouldn't he: Because he kept a promise to remind her and ned everything after the spell takes effect and because a part of him couldn't give up. Also about the boyfriend, I don't think that relationship will last long but only time would tell about this tbh. (Also if this may be paul rabin then it's going down faster than ever)

Imo, peter would be an older sibling figure to jean grey like her late sis and nothing more. They both are shaped by grief and peter knows how to use it instead of being used by it. And after jean read Peter's mind, I doubt that she will go back on the rampage again because that's how goated spiderman is.

But ya that's all for me ig


r/CharacterRant • • 1d ago

Comics & Literature Why there aren’t any “fun” books for adults (and how movies and TV are heading in that direction)

27 Upvotes

Lately, I’ve seen people on social media making video essays and posts about how comedies in media for adults such as TV and movies are dying or are dead, and how all the media is replaced by witty dramedies or sad or bleak dramas. People are very much tired of this type of content that’s prevalent everywhere now and long for the days of “comfort” media, the days when TV shows and movies were just fun, and silly. This sentiment made me think of moments where stuff like this happened before, because if you can believe it this sort of thing has happened before. 

Something was set up that used to be fun and was very prevalent and popular and existed for generations but then overtime because it became more boring and lame, and it just became a drag to sit through and very few people want to sit through it. Theater was seen as huge and fun and was something everyone was into…until it wasn’t. Radio was seen as huge and fun and was something everyone was into…until it wasn’t. And this is where we move on to the main topic of this post. 

There’s a gaping hole in the adult literary world, and no one seems to be talking about it. While TV and film have embraced ridiculous, over the top humor for grown ups, such as The Office, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, What We Do in the Shadows, or Barb and Star Go to Vista Del Mar, books have, strangely, left this lane almost completely empty. Specifically, I’m talking about the lack of goofy, absurd, lowbrow yet clever comedy books for adults. The kind of books that delight in nonsense, revel in humor, and proudly feature a fart joke on page one and a talking animal sidekick by page two.

As kids, many of us were raised on hilarious, imaginative, and totally bonkers books. Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Captain Underpants, Wayside School, Dr. Seuss, and of course, the works of Roald Dahl (Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, James and the Giant Peach). These books didn’t worry about being “realistic” or “literary.” but were just wild fun stories based on a simple premise. The plots made no sense. The characters were unique. The illustrations were crude but full of energy. And yet, they were page turners. They sparked joy, and made kids laugh out loud and kept us engaged. 

So where did those books go?

As we age, literature seems to take itself more and more seriously. The humor section in any bookstore is overwhelmingly filled with essay collections, satire, or quirky memoirs about people’s childhood traumas. If you’re lucky, maybe there’s a collection of wry observations about being in your thirties. Where’s the Captain Underpants for people who pay rent? 

It’s not like adults don’t enjoy goofy humor. People love comedy that’s unhinged but clever, but well-crafted. So why aren’t we getting that in book form? It’s not that humor is absent from adult fiction entirely, sure there’s satire, there’s dark comedy, there’s witty banter. But that specific style of “goofy premise, rapid-fire nonsense, and unapologetically silly tone” seems to vanish once you leave middle school. The literary world seems hesitant to embrace goofiness unless it’s masked as either highbrow surrealism (Kafkaesque) or veiled in postmodern irony. But what if you just want to read about a guy who wakes up with spaghetti for arms?

There’s something deeply joyful about pure, unserious nonsense. And it’s not immature to want that. In fact, it’s kind of refreshing. We live in a world that’s full of pressure to be productive, performative, and perpetually “mature.” Sometimes, reading about a magical or bizarre office is exactly what the brain needs.

Let’s go into why this goofy literary void exists. Why is there no adult version of Archie and the Accidental Chicken Heroes? Why is there no book equivalent to Dumb and Dumber, Hot Rod, or Anchorman, those joyfully idiotic, deeply quotable movies that aren’t trying to win awards, just trying to make you laugh until you snort?

The first reason is literary gatekeeping. There’s a long-standing (and frankly outdated) cultural idea that books are supposed to be serious. Even comedic fiction is often expected to have some kind of “literary merit” such as clever subtext, thematic depth, and sharp commentary. If a book dares to be purely silly or structurally ridiculous, it gets shoved into the “novelty gift” section or dismissed as juvenile fluff. Meanwhile, theater, movies and TV don’t carry the same baggage. They’re allowed to be dumb, and dumb often sells.

You can walk into a theater and see a funny scene, and no one questions the medium. But if that same scene existed in a book it would either be labeled as children's literature, or people would assume it's some kind of metaphor about late stage capitalism, when it's not. Sometimes it’s just a joke.

There’s also a misperception that adult readers don’t want silly, that once you pass a certain age, you’re only interested in psychological thrillers, historical fiction, or literary meditations on grief. This couldn’t be more wrong, as adults are binge watching sitcoms and quoting Step Brothers ten years later. They’re sending each other memes. The desire for comedy never goes away, but just doesn’t have a home in books.

Another factor is the publishing risk-aversion. It’s hard to market a comedy novel that doesn’t fit a known genre mold. Slapstick is too visual. Gross-out humor is not “sophisticated” enough. Anything remotely resembling “juvenile” gets shuffled off to the kids’ section. As a result, most comedy novels for adults stick to safer formats such as satirical essays, rom coms with quippy dialogue, or genre fiction with a humorous twist. These are fine, but they’re not loud. 

And I also suspect, it could just be that writing funny books is hard. Comedy on the page is notoriously difficult to pull off. In film and plays, actors, timing, music, and visuals carry the hold thing. In books, it’s all on the writer’s words and their pacing. That means fewer writers are attempting full throttle goofball comedy, and fewer publishers are willing to take the leap. That doesn’t mean it’s impossible, but underexplored.

But maybe the biggest reason is that the book world doesn’t want to embrace being stupid on purpose. Stupid is treated like a flaw, not a style, and yet, we love “stupid” when it’s executed with heart and commitment. Anchorman is an objectively idiotic movie but it’s smart in its stupidity. That’s what we need in literary fiction. The same way kids have Dog Man and The Day My Butt Went Psycho, adults should have Reginald and the Time-Traveling Taco Bell Manager or Karen vs. the Sentient Printer That Runs Her Office.

Let’s talk about the elephant in the library. There’s a reason kids devour books by the truckload and then, somewhere along the line, just… stop. People like to blame school, or say “required reading killed the joy,” or “adults are too busy to read,” or “we’ve all just gotten lazy and turned to screens.” But what if that’s not entirely true? What if the real reason people stop reading is simpler, and more damning? The books just got boring.

As a kid, books were magic. They had titles like The Butt That Saved Christmas, or Aliens Don’t Wear Braces. You’d get one at the school book fair, flip to a page, and suddenly you were in the middle of a story. They were imaginative, unpredictable, loud, and didn’t care about being “prestigious” or “grounded.” They were designed to hook your brain and make you laugh.
Then you grow up, and the tone shifts, and now you’re being told to read a novel about a thirty something guy named Greg who’s emotionally unavailable in Brooklyn. It’s no wonder adults drift away from reading. Books stopped being fun. Kids read more because they’re given books that feel like a treat, not a chore, but adults get assigned literature that often feels like homework in disguise.

When we say we miss reading, we’re really saying,  “I miss stories that surprised me. I miss laughter, and I miss books that aren't afraid to be ridiculous.” We didn’t grow out of reading, rather reading just forgot how to grow with us. If the publishing industry gave adults the same kind of pure, unfiltered, joy that kids get in their books, we would be in a reading renaissance. People would be turning pages like it’s 2005 and the next Captain Underpants just dropped. Book clubs would be reading fun books instead of dissecting yet another slow-burn novel about suburban ennui.

Believe it or not, this whole idea that books have to be serious, “literary,” and emotionally devastating to be considered real or important is actually a pretty recent development.
For most of human storytelling history, goofy was the norm. Going all the way back to Shakespeare, half of his plays are ridiculous comedies with literal fart jokes, people cross-dressing, falling into mud puddles, getting tricked into kissing goats (okay, that one’s metaphorical, but still). A Midsummer Night’s Dream is basically a story about forest fairies doing drugs and ruining everyone’s night. Much Ado About Nothing is just high octane banter with romantic misunderstandings and a fake death thrown in. Even Hamlet has a scene with two gravediggers arguing over how skulls work.

Geoffrey Chauncer wrote The Canterbury Tales which featured action stories like The Knight’s Tale and tragic stories like The Pardoner's Tale, but it also had stories that featured a fart joke and a joke about tricking someone into kissing their ass. 

Back then, comedy and tragedy lived side by side, you could be able to read both. There was no shame in writing stories that were completely unserious, as long as they entertained. Fast forward a few centuries, and something strange happens: prestige starts to equal seriousness.  The “great novels” become long, slow, and meditative. Meanwhile, comedy, especially loud, dumb, ridiculous comedy, gets pushed to the side, it’s treated like a lesser form.

Somewhere along the line, literature developed a kind of insecurity complex, and stopped trusting that goofy stories could say something real, and stopped allowing joy. And so we ended up with shelves and shelves of “serious fiction,” where everything has to be slow, sad, and centered around broken relationships and horrible dystopias. And that’s not to say serious books are bad, they're not. We need serious books, and we need books that are dry but important. But when everything has to be prestigious to be respected, you lose variety and the kind of stories that people don’t just admire, but love. 

TV and film didn’t fall into this(at least for a while). That's why you get an Oscar winning film one week, and the next you’re watching Wedding Crashers. You can both watch Breaking Bad and then the Office. Anchorman can be just as iconic as The Godfather, just in a different way. 

I have a potential theory, another theory, as to why comedies and fun media became irrelevant around the mid-2010s with movies and TV. What's happening right now with movies and TV already happened with books. We are seeing the gradual disappearance of goofy, full throttle, unapologetically comforting comedy. Remember when theaters were flooded with movies like Dumb and Dumber, Zoolander, Hot Rod, Napoleon Dynamite, Anchorman, Step Brothers, Superbad? People quoted them endlessly, and became pop culture fixtures. Try naming the last big, dumb, laugh-out-loud comedy that wasn’t secretly a drama today. Today, it’s difficult to name a single movie or show nowadays that isn’t something like that anymore. 

And there's nothing wrong with those movies and shows. Many of them are incredible (The Holdovers, Barb & Star Go to Vista Del Mar sneaks in there, bless its weird heart.), but they’re not what we’re talking about when we think of comedies. What’s happening to movies and TV now is exactly what already happened to books. Goofy comedies are being replaced by prestige adjacent, emotionally deep “comedies” that are actually dramas with some jokes here and there. We’ve entered the era of the “respectable laugh.” The kind where you chuckle politely and say, “That’s clever,” not the kind where you fall out of your chair. 

In books, it started centuries ago. Comedy gave way to commentary, and silly dumb comedy books got labeled “for children,” and fun books got pushed out of the adult section unless it was satirical or ironic. Now films and TV are heading down that same path, chasing awards, critical respect, and emotional complexity, even in comedy. But the loud, dumb, joyous comedy, the one that just wants to entertain you for 90 minutes and maybe make your stomach hurt from laughing, is on life support. Notice all the only prominent genres of media nowadays - prestigious dramas and dramedies, romantic films and erotica, dark satires about cruel rich people, apocalypse and dystopian fiction, murder mysteries, gritty fantasy. All of these are already the most popular genres of fiction for books decades ago. They were the only books you could read as an adult back in the 90s and 2000s when comedies were dominant in movies and TV.

Also, notice how the only comedic films and television nowadays are children’s media - stuff from Disney and Illumination and animated children’s movies and shows on streaming services. This is very similar to how most children’s books are comedic now and have illustrations, and how illustrations are seen as something you “grow out of”, illustrations are something you should only see in children’s books, you should just “remember it in your head”. The very similar viewpoint you see with animation and cartoons are something widely held for illustrations for books. But that’s a different subject for today but you get it.  

Once a medium becomes too respected, it starts taking itself too seriously, and in doing so, it squeezes out the kind of humor that doesn’t need layers of meaning. We’ve seen this before, as books led the way. Now we’re watching films and TV follow suit. And again, those stories have value, but they shouldn’t be the only type that is to value. If we’re not careful, we’ll end up in a world where all our art is “important,” but none of it is fun.

And here’s what really keeps me up at night. What if, years from now, people who grew up loving movies and TV when they were kids, really loving them, suddenly stop enjoying films and television and don’t know why? What if they start to feel about those the way many people already feel about books? What happens when those kids grow up and the only stuff available to them are prestigious dramedies, bleak dystopian fiction and dramas, or mystery fiction? Or indie media about how hard it is to be in your thirties? Or yet another reboot, stripped of humor and weighed down with “meaning”? Will they think they’ve changed? Will they wonder if they just “don’t get movies and TV anymore”? Will they, like adults now do with books, just slowly stop watching and blame themselves? 

And just like today’s adults say, “I used to love reading as a kid, but I don’t read anymore,” we’ll hear people say, “I used to love movies and TV when I was younger, but now I just scroll TikTok.”