So I was rewatching the early seasons of The Walking Dead in preparation for another post on how the early seasons were wonderful and also a piece of media that works best because it was released during its time and the schedule it had. But when I rewatched season 2, I realized it is easily the best example of how great a show can be when episodes are released weekly, and Chandler Riggs actually looks like a child in season 3. This is easily one of the most beloved seasons for its character-driven storytelling, the smaller-scale setting of the Greene Farm, and all the countless memes we got out of Jon Bernthal's portrayal of Shane.
Looking back at it, the conflict and the tension between Shane and the rest of the crew work well because Season 2 of The Walking Dead has episodes. That's right. Unlike modern shows that you see on Netflix with their usual batch of 8 episodes or so, The Walking Dead 2 gives you a set of 13 episodes. And this works well because the show has time to explore the main conflict deeply and humanize the characters.
Exhibit 1: More episodes = Shane gets more to do than just argue with Rick
One of the biggest plot points of season 2 is Shane Walsh and his fallout with the rest of the group. Shane is easily one of the most memorable characters because of the way he develops. Even today, people argue about Shane's moral status. Some see him as a man who was ahead of the curve and right about a lot of things, from Rick needing to take harder measures to protect his family, to the search for Sophia being a wasted effort, and his complete distrust of Randall because of the threat he posed to the rest of the farm. Some even say that Shane and Rick would be an unstoppable force if it weren't for their conflict over Lori and Carl. These are the kind of people who would say that Shane was justified in shooting Otis and running away and that it was ultimately necessary to ensure Carl's survival. Both were wounded; walkers were closing in. That the walkers still had a gap to cover before reaching them doesn't make a difference because walkers never get tired, while an overweight man like Otis would surely give out before making it to the car, dying to the zombies anyway with the bag filled with goods needed to save Carl, rendering their efforts worthless.
They point to Season 5, when Rick killed people who came to rape and murder his family (Joe and the Claimers) or murder and eat his family (Terminus Cannibals), as the show admitting that Rick ultimately needed to absorb Shane's worldview to protect his family from people who utterly deserved to be killed at his hand. Some even say that Shane only died early because he simply couldn't overcome his obsession with Lori and Carl. On the other hand, you have people who see Shane as a man too weak from the start. They point to his attempts to have Lori (against her will) and call him out for abandoning the search for Sophia too early. Some of them say that shooting Otis was not really about saving Carl, but just Shane taking the easy way out to ensure his own survival. You can also point out that Fort Benning was not a good idea in the slightest.
No matter what you think of Shane, the reason he is still so discussed is because the show has 13 episodes with runtime of around 40 minutes. What does that mean? It means that the show has time to show moments of humanity that are not tied to the direct conflict with Rick himself. Shane gets to talk to Lori and admit that his attempt at the CDC was a mistake. Shane gets to talk to Carl in private and tell him that he shouldn't use foul language. Shane gets to have a little arc that revolves around him teaching Andrea how to shoot. He gets a fleshed-out conflict with Dale over things that Rick isn't even aware of. Jon Bernthal gets to rub his head a lot of times and say, "Let me tell you something".
Exhibit 2: The show has time for longer arcs with detours
Sophia is lost very early on in the season. The search for Sophia becomes the focus as a very long search for her, in which multiple things can happen. Carl gets shot. The entire Otis and Shane side mission happens. Different characters get to deal with the search differently.
Shane sees the search as a fruitless effort for many reasons. Multiple search rounds amount to nothing in the end. No matter what one thinks of Shane, he is right to point out that finding a doll doesn't mean anything in the long run. Rick gets to insist on the search and hold on to hope. Daryl Dixon gets several good scenes because he goes out there and runs into trouble on the way, affirming Shane's points about how the search is putting their lives at risk for a little girl who is most likely dead. We have scenes in which Carl gets to be a child and talk to his mother about how Sophia is out there and how he wants to find her.
In between all of that, Glenn gets to meet Maggie on a more intimate level and struggles with her initial rejection after their first time. His talks with Dale about how Maggie treats him do not have to be part of the whole Sophia arc; they work as their own thing. Needless to say, the show then manages to interject those arcs beautifully. Because Glenn got too close to Maggie, he gets the idea that they do it at the barn. Only then does he find out that the barn is full of walkers. Something that he confides in Dale and the rest of the group.
And Lori is pregnant. The whole conflict about Rick and Shane is no longer just about their differences regarding Sophia, but now Lori is put on the spot because she might just bear the child of her husband's best friend. This then flows into the larger arc of Shane. He sees the barn as a threat that needs to be dealt with urgently, Hershel be damned. Rick wishes to get Hershel's approval first. Why does he need Hershel's approval? Because Hershel is very clear that he wants the group gone sooner or later, something that Rick cannot just allow. The farm is like paradise compared to the rest of the world that is overrun by infested zombies and hostile survivors, as the group later learns.
Now, here is the thing: we are not even at episode 7 yet. The season is halfway done, and a cast filled with Rick, Shane, Hershel, Glenn, Andrea, Daryl, Maggie, Carl, and Dale all had something to do. They each had moments to voice their opinions and further a narrative that is not just exclusively tied to the main plot. Dale and Glenn can talk about the latter's (lack of) experience with women in scenes that do not obviously curve into the main conflict of the season. The characters are more humanized that way.
Exhibit 3: weekly episodes = more tension and time for theory
When the season came out, you watched one episode a week. When Shane shot Otis and shaved his head, you couldn't just immediately watch the next episode and see how his dynamic with Rick and the others unfolded. You didn't watch Sophia get lost only to see her dead 6 hours later, if you really wanted to see her dead 6 hours later. Instead, you had time to think about each episode and talk with your friends or peers who also watched the show. Everyone was mostly on the same page if you kept the pace. This also meant that the falling out between Rick and Shane was more uncertain when you watched it originally. You couldn't just skip ahead and see that Shane was actually right when he said that Sophia was gone. You also couldn't just skip ahead and see that he'd later snap a character's neck as part of a murder plot. Which leads to
Exhibit 4: the subsequent Randall arc is better for it
After the farm was busted open by Shane and they shot down all the walkers because Shane pretty much forced them to, a reanimated Sophia exits the barn. The entire group, even Shane, is left speechless. Carol is desperately crying out for her daughter as Daryl holds her back. Oh, did I mention that 13 episodes mean that Daryl and Carol get ample screen time that further their relationship? That Daryl Dixon, the antisocial brute of the club, gets to see and deal with the fact that someone he perceives as weak actually believes in him and sees him as a good man despite his foul relations with the rest of the cast? That this arc can also very easily stand on its own?
In any case, Hershel is devastated by this loss and relapses into alcoholism for a while. Rick and Glenn find him inside a bar he used to frequent. They run into 2 survivors who pose as friendlies at first, trying to learn more about Rick's group, like where they live. Rick sees through the bullshit and attempts to firmly assert that none of those men are getting near their family. They draw first, but Rick is faster. After a shootout with the allies of the 2 men Rick had just shot, they rescue a young man named Randall who ran along with the group. Once he is at the farm, Shane insists that he is a threat and shouldn't be allowed to live. His hostility is affirmed when Daryl beats it out of Randall: a group of 30 or so men with heavy weapons who like to kill men and make women wish they were dead.
After watching 7 episodes that very clearly establish how characters like Shane and Rick go about things, the viewers had 7 weeks to think about their development. They now have more time to assess the Randall situation at hand and see how the relationship between Rick and Shane takes its final nosedive. In any case, the show had time to establish this group as a potential threat even after several episodes of a hopeless rescue search, Carl's almost fatal bullet wound, Lori coming clean to Rick, and several other arcs. Especially Rick's and Shane's dynamic reaches a low point when they physically fight over Randall's life, which ultimately results in their final confrontation, where Shane is very openly venting his frustration with his former best friend. He kills Randall and lures Rick out with a lie so he can kill him and take control of the group once again through lies, thinking that he can actually have Lori and Carl for himself again. After a series of weeks where the viewers saw his moments of madness and humanity, he finally succumbs to the former and is no longer able to coexist with the rest of the group. Rick understands that and tearfully puts Shane down in one of the best scenes of the entire show. This scene only works so well because it is the culmination of weeks worth of buildup. Because the characters involved both had a fully fleshed-out dynamic with the group they are fighting for. Not every moment before this scene had to openly lead to this outcome.
Why it wouldn't work today.
If The Walking Dead season 2 released on Netflix today, we'd have 8 episodes. Sophia is lost in episode 1 and is found (dead and reanimated) at episode 4. The entirety of the Randall arc encompasses episodes 5-7. Shane dies at the end of episode 7. Episode 8 plays out just like episode 13 did in the original; a horde overruns the farm. The Ricktatorship arc begins. The prison is shown at the end. Season 3 comes out 3 years later. Chandler Riggs no longer looks like he did at the end of season 3. Therefore, the fact that seasons 2 and 3 are just a winter apart is less believable. They'd either have to work in a longer timeframe to pass or just fuck it and ball. A lot of the scenes that humanized Shane are just gone because it has fewer episodes. He gets like 1 or 2 scenes where he glances sadly at the dead Sophia in between all the scenes where he is yelling and arguing with Rick, and that is all we get to humanize him. The affair is revealed a lot faster. Daryl and Carol get fewer scenes. A lot of scenes that are funny or just let the characters breathe a little are cut out.
But the worst part? Most viewers do not see it as a slower, character-driven season that keeps you guessing about its story. Most will see Shane shave his head and see his death scene 8 hours later. You will see Sophia go missing, only for her to pop out of the barn like 4 hours later. There is no time for theorizing or guessing in between episodes when the next episode is just a click away. Around 6 hours after you watch one episode, you can already Google the show, and "TWD season 2 Shane death" will show up immediately. You may also wait for like a few years or so and see season 3 by the time you have forgotten a lot about season 2 already. Good thing that some shows tend to include recaps at the beginning now. All of it wouldn't be nearly as good or nearly as satisfying.