r/CharacterRant • • 12h ago Popcorn Bravo

General Surf Dracula was never that much about surfing. You guys need to actually rewatch the older stuff and see

298 Upvotes

After the conclusion of Michael Bay’s Surf Dracula film trilogy; I have seen a lot of discourse about how “they’ve missed the point of Surf Dracula” and that the psychological and political ramifications of him on the wider world takes away the magic of this setting. And I’m just like… No? The whole point of Surf Dracula is him balancing his secret life with his life back in Transylvania!

Surf Dracula The Animated Series (1997 - 2001) had 52 episodes and I counted about 11 of them that were purely just surfing action. And this wasn’t because that’s ALL Surf Dracula was about— it’s mainly due to how shows were made back then. Serialized television wouldn’t become mainstream for a couple years later. Back then, monster of the week plots helped pad out a show’s length.

And even then, the most memorable episodes of the SDTAS were always the ones where Dracula doesn’t surf as much. Anyone remember the episode where Dracula suffers a near-fatal wound and spends the episode fighting demons in his nightmares? It was a brilliant psychological examination character study. And that’s what makes the new, more dark, gritty and mature Surf Dracula content work so well. This character has always been deeper than just a surfing Saturday morning cartoon superhero, and I’m tired of pretending it’s not.


r/CharacterRant • • 10h ago

Games I actually respect Rockstar for putting in a reputation system in GTA 6

167 Upvotes

Minor spoilers but there is a reputation system in GTA6, similar to how you had honour in RDR2.

And it WILL affect the ending you get.

Guess what gets you a bad reputation?

Indiscriminately killing innocent people and blatantly committing crimes in broad daylight.

Unsurprisingly a lot of people don't like this. A common sentiment I'm seeing is "why would you punish me for 'murder and crime spree-ing' in the murder and crime spree-ing simulator?"

Me personally, I actually respect the guts to do this.

A reputation system, which encourages you to NOT do the thing (murder sprees) that you've literally done in the past games.

Time will tell if this is good, but I respect the willingness by the devs to introduce what is almost antithetical to arguably the biggest game released in decades.


r/CharacterRant • • 18h ago

Comics & Literature DC is really better at making alternate universes than marvel is

95 Upvotes

When it comes to experimentation, DC seems to always be better at succeeding in it than marvel is, idk for some reason DC's alternate universes are more memorable and many of them are graphic novels.

Kingdom come, red son, all star superman, the dark knight returns and recently the absolute universe.

For marvel they are either mixed or really really bad and never great like DCs. Original ultimate spiderman is the one good example i can think of but even it has it's short cominga particularly how it handled its villains.

Ultimate green goblin was a mixed bad but absolute joker is an instant icon.

The new ultimate universe was not radical enough, they may have had some interesting concepts but they never really knew what to do with it or even write it properly. New ultimate spiderman was just made for fanservice regarding Peter and MJ where MJ is "well written" by always agreeing with peter and never having any real conflict. Basically mark and eve version of marvel in terms of how interesting they are.

And the midnight series, the supposed answer to DC's absolutw universe, pure edgelord slop with nothing interesting to tell.


r/CharacterRant • • 7h ago

Comics & Literature Marvel has more interesting cosmology and lore and world building than Dc imo

25 Upvotes

Even if we pick some aspects, like the magic side of Marvel and DC, and go by the popular saying that DC does magic characters better (I don't agree, but even if I did), it still doesn't change the fact that Marvel builds its universe and conceptual and magical entities way better than DC does.

Now, DC does have some good ones, but they’re always contradictory or self-contained in a way they don't add to the universe . For example, Vertigo doesn't even feel like it’s part of the same multiverse as DC, and yet the Endless exist in DC, and DC characters exist in Sandman. I love Animal Man, but Grant Morrison’s explanation of the Red in Animal Man goes against what was explained in later comics. Other similar entities, like the Green, the Blue, and the Rot, removed the complexity of the Red (which is God)—just an example.

I just have to give respect to Marvel's cosmic and magic lore; it's great asf for an endless comic universe. Even just a preview of Al Ewing’s Immortal Thor really showed respect for the elder gods.

Recent Great stories that either explained or expanded on marvel world building.

-History of the marvel universe by Dan slott (mogs the dc version he did)

-ultimates and ultimates 2 by Al ewing

-Defenders and Defenders beyond by Al ewing

-Immortal thor by Al Ewing

-silver surfer runs by Dan slott

-G.O.D.S by Jonathan hickman

This is my opinion, though. And it has been lingering in my mind for a while


r/CharacterRant • • 20h ago

Comics & Literature Sam Wilson as Captain America Is One Of The Most Narratively Enriching Legacy Dynamics Of All Time [Marvel Comics]

21 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This is speaking for the comics only.

I do not care about the MCU Sam.

I almost want this to act as the definitive essay backed by easy to comprehend examples and literature symbolism to explain why Sam as Captain America is one of the most enriching aspects of the mantle. More importantly, why his continued existence as Captain America strengthens both the mantle and the legacy behind it.

I'm here to argue, that Sam is one of the few legacy character's whose legitimacy is never dependent on the absence of Steve.

But the only way to understand why Sam should always be (a) Captain America, you need to first understand Steve Rogers narratively. I will go section by section, to try to avoid the massive wall of text this may turn into

The Subtext behind Steve Roger's Standard

Steve Roger's is at his core, perceived to be an unattainable standard. The subtext echoed throughout his mythos reinforces this unattainability:

  • His super soldier serum, a one-of-a-kind creation, can never be perfectly replicated despite the Marvel Universe’s advanced science and magic.
  • He hails from a romanticized past, a time we can only look back on with nostalgia but never return to. "The Greatest Generation".
  • Characters in the Marvel Universe strive to match Steve’s moral goodness but often fall short, as he’s portrayed not just as a good man but as a near-mythical figure.

Steve Rogers represents the unattainable American Ideal. America does not try to be like Steve Rogers despite him being the goal. In short, the Marvel Universe placed Steve Rogers on a pedestal so impossibly high, and not to honor him... but to spare themselves the effort of the climb. The ones who tried to climb fall short. That's how we get the John Walkers. John Walker's failure reinforces the unattainability.

Steve Rogers Leads By Example

Doesn’t matter what the press says. Doesn’t matter what the politicians or the mobs say. Doesn’t matter if the whole country decides that something wrong is something right. This nation was founded on one principle above all else: the requirement that we stand up for what we believe, no matter the odds or the consequences. When the mob and the press and the whole world tell you to move, your job is to plant yourself like a tree beside the river of truth, and tell the whole world — “No, you move.”

Amazing Spider-Man #537 

This quote in actuality encapsulates HOW Steve operates in political partisan discourse.

Steve's defining approach is not to use the Captain America mantle as a platform

Steve takes his stance. Plants his feet. and waits for America to follow his lead. This ideology is shown time and time again:

  • Civil War (Where the quote is taken from)
  • Nomad
  • The Captain

He isn't going to try and convince the people he is right (He values true freedom), but he for darn sure isn't going to go along with you. He will resist you if you try to move him. Sticking to your principals and enforcing/teaching your principals are vastly different ideologies.

Steve classically does not use his status to sway the masses towards agreeing with him, even though he very much could. That's why Steve doesn't use his iconic status in the political field intentionally.

Steve's speech seems like a moral hardline. But it's based on a almost blind faith of believing in the best of the American people. Believing In The Soul of America. This is not a Gary Stew moment. It's revealing a character flaw that is 100% accurate to Steve's classical iterations. This flaw is why Steve's particular interpretation of Captain America cannot necessarily speak to everyone's experiences. Not everyone can rely on that faith. It's nice to think of Steve as a unifier due to his principals, but in functional practice, inspiration will not reach every systematic injustice, or every disenfranchised population. Leading by example can only get so far.

This trait literally opens the door for literary commentary on his potential responsibility as Captain America, allowing characters like Sam Wilson to characterize his own use of the mantle:

Sam Challenges Steve's Foundational Argument

If Steve is the unattainable goal, Sam Wilson is the How To Guide. Sam builds on this premise with every narrative tentpole of his identity

Here was a man I’d been as close to as two human beings could be—but in that moment, I saw—maybe for the first time—we’d always been miles apart. Because Steve Rogers, in his heart, believes that when the chips are down, when its values are at stake—his country will do what’s right. And me? In my heart? I can only hope it will
...
I have a side. That's right. I have opinions. Strongly held beliefs, even. And here's the thing. The more I saw the people I believe I was standing up for being walked on. The more I heard the noise machine sprouting intolerance and fear drowning common sense out. The more I wondered shouldn't Captain America be more than just a symbol? Steve always tried to stay above the fray and I respected him for it. He took a stand when he had to, but as far as politics went, he played it close to the vest. But if really believed I could make a difference, if I really believed I could change some minds, do some good - Then wasn't I obligated to try

Sam Wilson: Captain America #2 (2015)

Sam Wilson DOES try to convince you. The fact that Sam uses the mantle to amplify his voice in order shed light on partisan topics, systematic wrongs, and social issues is a direct critique of Steve Rogers use. Note, that this isn't a meta agenda; This is true to Sam's origin as a Social worker. You become a social worker because you want to assist people in helping themselves. His politics is reflected in his origin.

Sam Wilson Is Not Steve Rogers' moral inferior

  • Sam IS as good a person as Steve. This is not a philosophy Sam acquires by becoming Captain America. It predates the mantle. Sam was a social worker before he was Steve Rogers' partner, and his understanding of helping people was established before he ever carried the shield.

Sam guides people to Steve's moral code through advocacy

  • Sam being political is the point. It's a metaphor of political action being used to shape America closer to Steve's Rogers moral ideal. You want to be like Steve? Sam won't just be an example of how, he will guide and show you. He will use the mantle to amplify systematic issues in the political sphere. Who better to guide America to Steve's ideal, then the person who guide Steve when he came out the ice.

Sam's lack of blind faith allows him to be a representative of Captain America to the folks who Steve simply can't represent.

  • Sam remains Captain America in the Marvel 616 even while Steve is active. His 2025 ongoing didn't justify it by making Sam so great at being Captain America that he earned it. Sam Wilson: Captain America by Nick Spencer justified it by making readers look at America as a thematic whole. America cannot be represented by one unattainable moral paragon. It is a melting pot of different cultures, ideas and beliefs. Sam’s journey is about inspiring those who need a Captain America and being the bridge towards Roger's ideal. This isn't even subtext at this point. It was the entire dialogue of issue #24 of Captain America: Sam Wilson (2015).

Both Sam's and Steve's approaches are valid. In fact, they become more meaningful together.

And that makes Sam as Captain America an enriching expansion of the mantle rather than a replacement for Steve. In fact, Sam's continued existence as Captain America is a thematic necessity.

America contains different experiences, histories, communities, and perspectives. A national symbol that claims to represent all those people benefits from having multiple legitimate interpretations.

  • Steve's existence doesn't invalidate Sam's.
  • Sam's existence doesn't invalidate Steve's.

Their coexistence creates a conversation that the mantle benefits from. A lot of legacy characters try demonstrate that the original hero's legacy can survive without them. That's their goal. Sam doesn't need to prove he can exist without Steve. He demonstrates why the legacy of Captain America is better with both of them.

Steve Rogers represents the America we aspire to be. Sam Wilson represents the journey to that ideal.

This Thread is somewhat of an encapsulation of my previous rants finally combined:
"No, You Move": You Are Interpreting This Captain America Speech Wrong : r/CharacterRant

MCU Sam Wilson is a Fatal Misread : r/CaptainAmerica


r/CharacterRant • • 9h ago

Comics & Literature The time Star Wars made tie-in media for a hotel.

17 Upvotes

I think we've all heard of the infamous failure of Star Wars's "Galactic Cruiser" hotel experience. Better people than me, such as Jenny Nicholson, have already talked about it, so I'm not going to talk about it in detail too much.

But what makes the hotel's failure even sad yet hilarious is that it actually had tie in media for it.

Yes. Seriously. A comic book limited series showing the in-universe "Halcyon Legacy" in different Star Wars time periods, and a novel "The Princess and the Scoundrel" focused around Han and Leia going to the hotel on their honeymoon.

Now I have not read either of those as of yet, so for all I know they could be really good (in fact, it wouldn't surprise me if they were; Star Wars under Disney has a really good track record with its novels), but the content/quality of the books isn't really the point here.

The point is their mere existence is just kind of sad and depressing yet hilarious, because these are two pieces of Star Wars media advertising an experience that doesn't exist anymore. They'll just be here forever, carved into the Star Wars canon, showing off something that isn't doable anymore.

For bonus points, The Princess and the Scoundrel also has its own share of minor controversy. See, it's the novel depicting the post-Lucasfilm buyout canon version of Han and Leia's wedding, and there were a decent chunk of fans who weren't happy that a lore-important event was being used as part of a tie-in to a crappy hotel.

It didn't help at all that it came out the same year the writer of "The Courship of Princess Leia," (The Legends version of Han and Leia's wedding), Dave Wolverton, passed away.

It's just another awkward story in the history of Star Wars.


r/CharacterRant • • 20h ago

Comics & Literature Genuine question,why do a lot of people act like Batman's villains can't just pick up a Gun and shoot Frank as well?

17 Upvotes

I always see people claim that the Punisher is "Who Gotham needs" and That Frank would "Clear Gotham" and whatnot and Let's be so deadass...if Jason Peter Todd,someone who was trained by Batman and kills can't even clean up Gotham,what in the world makes you guys think that Frank is doing any better?

Maybe he's taking out the big crime families like the Falcones, Penguin,Two-Face, etc..then it really gets iffy and insane when dealing with wild cards/Lunatics like Joker and Scarecrow..Him fighting Deadshot and Deathstroke and Lady Shiva could go either way but I'm putting it on them but anyone above those like Clayface or Bane or Killer Croc,and so on..he's getting demolished and hell,I wouldn't be surprised if Commissioner Gordon and Batman had Frank Arrested and in Cuffs within his first murders and I'm sorry but Frank can't even clean up his own city,and you guys expect him to do any better there?

Also why does it feel like nobody acknowledges that Frank's nonsensical and never ending war on crime is meant to be a toxic flaw and problem for him and in general?

He basically seems himself as the Judge,Jury and Executioner and it's so weird how Batman and Joker are the only ones who get this shit but no other superhero and their villains get that flack and it just feels like bias and how come Jason doesn't get any fraud allegations for not being able to kill Joker or any of the other villains but all the blame is placed on Bruce?

Just feels like people glaze anti-heroes and such way too much to be sensible and also..Joker has almost been killed by Batman+ left to die and such multiple times,dude just has plot armor.


r/CharacterRant • • 11h ago

Comics & Literature Thanos being jealous over deadpool is some poorly written shit (why does thanos keep going through the same character arc?)

16 Upvotes

So it's a common "fact" that thanos is jealous over how deadpool gets to hanoogle with death; so he placed a curse on him that made him immortal. Yes this did happen and it keeps getting brought up for some reason (mainly in poorly written books like thanos vs deadpool and the 2018 ben reiley run). But here's the weird thing, thanos knows death sees other people. You know how he knows that? He's shown greeting Captain Mar-vell into the afterlife alongside death. Like he's lowk chill with it because death comes for us all.

So why the hell does he care that it's deadpool entering her kingdom? I guess it's because it's implied she gives the guy more special attention, but she doesn't? Not in any way that would make thanos care. Even dumber, by the time Thanos even bothered cursing wade, he was already on the outs with death. Yeah, he actually didn't gaf about her after the first infinity trilogy. He was busy doing his own shit.

But then randomly he's obsessed with death again, and this is one of the few instances where you can't just say it was a clone or some shit (thanks a lot mark waid). Also, why is thanos able to just banish people from death's kingdom? Does he somehow have more power than a multiversal constant?? At least it's better than how bendis writes him tbh.

And then a little after that, thanos learns that death would prefer it if he didn't try to hard. As if he didn't already learn that in both the death of captain marvel and infinity gauntlet #5. No seriously, he's shown in docm hand in hand with death, acting as a guide for other lost souls; and infinity gauntlet #5 he realized that he was trying way to hard with death and pretty much drove her away.

There's also this idiotic part in thanos: samaritan where death tells thanos that she never wanted him to kill all those people. Except she did. She explicitly wanted thanos to kill half the universe, he wasn't doing that to impress her, he was doing it because it was his job, from her!! The reason she was mad, was because he made himself more powerful than her.

Think of it like this, imagine thanos and death are some old married couple right. Thanos getting the gauntlet is like him getting a new sports car or buying a gun. Sure, it's cool, but she just wants him to take out the trash (kill half of everyone), but does he? No, not until she nags him (through her weird skeleton intern thing). So the reason she's so peeved at him, isn't because he's showing her affection and tbh kinda simping for her. That's what she likes, cause she's a diva like that. What she's annoyed by is that he's more powerful than her, and lowk inattentive.

But no here comes samaritan trying to claim that she never wanted that? What!! That was the whole point of infinity gauntlet was that she wanted it and now she's going back on her word. Wtf mistress death?? (You can see why their relationship is so toxic). And honestly that kind of sucks because the rest of Samaritan is pretty well written, it's just this one bit that really takes me out of the story.

Then twenty-ish years later, thanos is obsessing over death again like a weirdo, and making a fool out of himself for "reasons." It's not explained why, he has no reason for it; he's just now pining over goth skeleton pussy despite not wanting it any more in Ultimates (also btw he got with her after annihilation as well, so take that people who think death didn't give thanos the time of day).

Honestly their whole relationship after thanos imperative made no sense whatsoever. He doesn't love her any more, then he loves her much more boring younger cousin (hela), now he's trying to steal her because she's now a pebble? It's really stupid and I think he's "dead" now after the shitty knull mini series, so we'll wait and see how that turns out.

And honestly all that is way more intriguing than the idiotic eco-terrorist they made him in the mcu. Instead of being a "I'm doing it for the greater good" soft sci-fi villain, he resembles a more shakespearean doomed lover archetype, with some classical anti hero sprinkles tossed in. He's not some crazy general guy like mongul, or a force of nature like darkseid; he's a protagonist that happens to be in a villainous role (after infinity gauntlet, before that he lowk was just purple dorkseid).

And my next marvel spotlight will release, I swear, not that anyone gives af.


r/CharacterRant • • 18h ago

Anime & Manga Capricorn should've been a Blackwall AI in Cyberpunk Edgerunners 2

8 Upvotes

Cyberpunk has a concept called a digital neural engram, which is the digitized consciousness of a human being, this is basically the entire plot of 2077 with Soulkiller. In Edgerunners 2, this also is the plot with Capricorn, who is revealled early on to be an Engram os multiple digitized psyches instead of one, effectively a gestalt personality.

However, the gestalt aspect is not really utilized much in the story aside from a major plot point: splitting its powers and personalities across our two main characters: D & Talia. I would say this is less focused on "personality" split and more of a program losing its core functions.

The powers of Capricorn in Edgerunners 2 are all over the place, this can be excused as Trigger taking creative liberties but the things both D & Talia can do are borderline impossible given how we understand Engrams in 2077. They primarily achieve this by shooting out red lightning / "sparks" (as the show calls them) to hack objects and technology.

  • With D, Capri was able to alter the power grid of multiple blocks, hack entire vehicles, using mechanisms to launch them into the air or take over their auto-driving computers. Then famously shut down MaxTac and triggered a large riot, ultimately requiring custom technology to stop him. Its possible he was able to fend off max threat level security during this point.
  • With Talia, she used the magnets in her body to construct large weapons and a new body, a body larger than multiple blocks and tall enough to surpass skyscrapers. A body that was so powerful they NEEDED to air strike Night City and use an entire EMP on just to disable it, even after that, Talia was strong enough to repel bullets with the magnets.

We know these powers aren't innately tied to D or Talia, as when Capri was ejected out of their bodies, they lost these powers and went back to normal. D went from hacking entire machines, power grids, blowing up vehicles, constructing machines or bodies, fighting off entire armies, and instantly vaporizing people to a normal hacker who needed to be in close distance to hack. With Talia, she went from a normal cyborg with impressive movement to the most dangerous entity in Night City or history.

In Cyberpunk lore, the "Blackwall" is the old internet, the one we're currently using, which had been infected by various rogue AIs and was thankfully barricaded off in cyberspace by NetWatch via another AI. Its stated MULTIPLE TIMES that if the Blackwall is undone or if the rogue AIs are able to freed, it could end the world, be it by hacking all sorts of vital technology, destroying Cyberware, or launching weapons of mass destruction alla SkyNet. Hell, the entirety of Project Cynosure in the Phantom Libterty DLC was an attempt to capture rogue AIs as weapons.

  • Hell we get to witness one in the base game with Lilith, who was summoned through a whole entire demon ritual in an ICE bath, leading to multiple deaths. The boss glitches out V's HUD and even teleports (though that's likely because of a Sandevistan). One of the Cyberpsychos say that Lilith comes from the "concealed 10th circle of hell". A rogue AI is more or less percieved or used as a metaphor for a demon in this setting.
  • However by far the most damning ability is the Militech Canto Mk.6, where you gain the Blackwall Gateway Quickhack, and the Erebus SMG, which can inflict the same Quickhack. Its implied to communicate with rogue AIs where it attacks by literally summoning red lightning that shoots upwards and destroys the target through lethal damage and insta-killing them if 33% HP or lower, nearly IDENTICAL to how D kills Kate Miller and leads to the riot.
  • In Phantom Liberty, Songbird gets injured and V creates a neural bridge, gaining access to the Blackwall. They quite literally unleash pulses of red lightning that instantly kill MaxTac soldiers, spreads across them, and disables helicopters. They can further unleash it by calling down bolts of red lightning. These bolts manifest in realspace, just like how Capri manifests to Roman on his camera.

Essentially, the Blackwall Gateway is almost identical to what D and Talia continually unleashe when using their abilities. The thing about the two, is that it cannot possibly be their innate abilities, D has been shown to be an okay Netrunner and Talia is extremely athletic, but with Capri they basically become more powerful than V. Engrams are not capable of doing these things as shown in the case of Johnny.

With the lore presented in Edgerunners 2, it doesn't make sense how Capri is able to pull any of this off if she's just an Engram, Johnny was unable to pull anything like this off besides ressurection (although he was a prototype), and basically was more or less a hallucination. So by applying the lore of Blackwall tech and rogue AIs to Capri, almost everything makes sense. The red lightning hacking the city, amplyfing magnetic fields, overloading equipment, nearly destroying Night City, etc.

Hell this even lends to Capri's origins. She was used on multiple hosts for war capabilities, killing many scientists in the process. After being stolen by Kyoko, she inserted the AI into multiple innocent civilians in her storage room, most tied with many being hung up. Its similar to how humans would sacrifice people to conjure demons. Even Capri being plugged into D & Talia, she slowly beckons them with superpowers or revenge, like a demon making bargains with humans, similar to Lilith.

Heck, Capri's visual and some frames show her being very demonic in appearance, she has very saturated and aggressive colors, sharp lines, multiple scenes or her appearing "shattered" and with dozens if not hundreds of eyes. She even is shown to polymorph into fish for fun, or do 4th wall comedic shenanigans like gliding across the screen or warping the HUD. In-universe this is the definition of a corrupted program or a being capable of doing impossible stunts.

This is even more amplified by how she appears in D's psyche, exclusive to him, playing around with him, uploading data to his brain without permission, and showing still of his dead clan. During the riot, D let himself be completely controlled by Cpari and looked borderline inhuman and monsterous, like demonic possession. With Talia this is even worse, she discards all of her clothing and her hair becomes so erratic that we cannot see her face outside of a single glowing red eye.

Furthermore, the idea of a gestalt entity is not utilized in any capacity. Outside of being eccentric, restless, and chaotic, Capricorn doesn't give the implications she's made of multiple human brains, if she was she'd likely have multiple voices, constantly change colors, would give conflicting information, and all sorts of personalities, etc. But no, Capri is a pretty static character throughout the show.

With all that being said, Capricorn being a Blackwall AI seems so obvious. The gestalt entity never really elaborated, explored, or explains her powers to warp Night City. But a demon that was pulled from the Blackwall, injected into multiple human sacrifices, threatened the entirety of Night City, and nearly annihilated Kang Tao both is more interesting from a worldbuilding perspective and shows how ONE ROGUE AI caused all of Edgerunners 2.

It even plays into the setting of Cyberpunk, that humans are easily controllable by higher powers and are willing to easily be submitted by them to exact revenge, for the murders of clans or terrible childhoods, something that demonic possession is often used as a metaphor for. It also shows how terrible corporations are, as they are willing to extract demons just for profits.


r/CharacterRant • • 3h ago

Films & TV The Walking Dead season 2 is great because Netflix didn't release it today

7 Upvotes

So I was rewatching the early seasons of The Walking Dead in preparation for another post on how the early seasons were wonderful and also a piece of media that works best because it was released during its time and the schedule it had. But when I rewatched season 2, I realized it is easily the best example of how great a show can be when episodes are released weekly, and Chandler Riggs actually looks like a child in season 3. This is easily one of the most beloved seasons for its character-driven storytelling, the smaller-scale setting of the Greene Farm, and all the countless memes we got out of Jon Bernthal's portrayal of Shane.

Looking back at it, the conflict and the tension between Shane and the rest of the crew work well because Season 2 of The Walking Dead has episodes. That's right. Unlike modern shows that you see on Netflix with their usual batch of 8 episodes or so, The Walking Dead 2 gives you a set of 13 episodes. And this works well because the show has time to explore the main conflict deeply and humanize the characters.

Exhibit 1: More episodes = Shane gets more to do than just argue with Rick

One of the biggest plot points of season 2 is Shane Walsh and his fallout with the rest of the group. Shane is easily one of the most memorable characters because of the way he develops. Even today, people argue about Shane's moral status. Some see him as a man who was ahead of the curve and right about a lot of things, from Rick needing to take harder measures to protect his family, to the search for Sophia being a wasted effort, and his complete distrust of Randall because of the threat he posed to the rest of the farm. Some even say that Shane and Rick would be an unstoppable force if it weren't for their conflict over Lori and Carl. These are the kind of people who would say that Shane was justified in shooting Otis and running away and that it was ultimately necessary to ensure Carl's survival. Both were wounded; walkers were closing in. That the walkers still had a gap to cover before reaching them doesn't make a difference because walkers never get tired, while an overweight man like Otis would surely give out before making it to the car, dying to the zombies anyway with the bag filled with goods needed to save Carl, rendering their efforts worthless.

They point to Season 5, when Rick killed people who came to rape and murder his family (Joe and the Claimers) or murder and eat his family (Terminus Cannibals), as the show admitting that Rick ultimately needed to absorb Shane's worldview to protect his family from people who utterly deserved to be killed at his hand. Some even say that Shane only died early because he simply couldn't overcome his obsession with Lori and Carl. On the other hand, you have people who see Shane as a man too weak from the start. They point to his attempts to have Lori (against her will) and call him out for abandoning the search for Sophia too early. Some of them say that shooting Otis was not really about saving Carl, but just Shane taking the easy way out to ensure his own survival. You can also point out that Fort Benning was not a good idea in the slightest.

No matter what you think of Shane, the reason he is still so discussed is because the show has 13 episodes with runtime of around 40 minutes. What does that mean? It means that the show has time to show moments of humanity that are not tied to the direct conflict with Rick himself. Shane gets to talk to Lori and admit that his attempt at the CDC was a mistake. Shane gets to talk to Carl in private and tell him that he shouldn't use foul language. Shane gets to have a little arc that revolves around him teaching Andrea how to shoot. He gets a fleshed-out conflict with Dale over things that Rick isn't even aware of. Jon Bernthal gets to rub his head a lot of times and say, "Let me tell you something".

Exhibit 2: The show has time for longer arcs with detours

Sophia is lost very early on in the season. The search for Sophia becomes the focus as a very long search for her, in which multiple things can happen. Carl gets shot. The entire Otis and Shane side mission happens. Different characters get to deal with the search differently.

Shane sees the search as a fruitless effort for many reasons. Multiple search rounds amount to nothing in the end. No matter what one thinks of Shane, he is right to point out that finding a doll doesn't mean anything in the long run. Rick gets to insist on the search and hold on to hope. Daryl Dixon gets several good scenes because he goes out there and runs into trouble on the way, affirming Shane's points about how the search is putting their lives at risk for a little girl who is most likely dead. We have scenes in which Carl gets to be a child and talk to his mother about how Sophia is out there and how he wants to find her.

In between all of that, Glenn gets to meet Maggie on a more intimate level and struggles with her initial rejection after their first time. His talks with Dale about how Maggie treats him do not have to be part of the whole Sophia arc; they work as their own thing. Needless to say, the show then manages to interject those arcs beautifully. Because Glenn got too close to Maggie, he gets the idea that they do it at the barn. Only then does he find out that the barn is full of walkers. Something that he confides in Dale and the rest of the group.

And Lori is pregnant. The whole conflict about Rick and Shane is no longer just about their differences regarding Sophia, but now Lori is put on the spot because she might just bear the child of her husband's best friend. This then flows into the larger arc of Shane. He sees the barn as a threat that needs to be dealt with urgently, Hershel be damned. Rick wishes to get Hershel's approval first. Why does he need Hershel's approval? Because Hershel is very clear that he wants the group gone sooner or later, something that Rick cannot just allow. The farm is like paradise compared to the rest of the world that is overrun by infested zombies and hostile survivors, as the group later learns.

Now, here is the thing: we are not even at episode 7 yet. The season is halfway done, and a cast filled with Rick, Shane, Hershel, Glenn, Andrea, Daryl, Maggie, Carl, and Dale all had something to do. They each had moments to voice their opinions and further a narrative that is not just exclusively tied to the main plot. Dale and Glenn can talk about the latter's (lack of) experience with women in scenes that do not obviously curve into the main conflict of the season. The characters are more humanized that way.

Exhibit 3: weekly episodes = more tension and time for theory

When the season came out, you watched one episode a week. When Shane shot Otis and shaved his head, you couldn't just immediately watch the next episode and see how his dynamic with Rick and the others unfolded. You didn't watch Sophia get lost only to see her dead 6 hours later, if you really wanted to see her dead 6 hours later. Instead, you had time to think about each episode and talk with your friends or peers who also watched the show. Everyone was mostly on the same page if you kept the pace. This also meant that the falling out between Rick and Shane was more uncertain when you watched it originally. You couldn't just skip ahead and see that Shane was actually right when he said that Sophia was gone. You also couldn't just skip ahead and see that he'd later snap a character's neck as part of a murder plot. Which leads to

Exhibit 4: the subsequent Randall arc is better for it

After the farm was busted open by Shane and they shot down all the walkers because Shane pretty much forced them to, a reanimated Sophia exits the barn. The entire group, even Shane, is left speechless. Carol is desperately crying out for her daughter as Daryl holds her back. Oh, did I mention that 13 episodes mean that Daryl and Carol get ample screen time that further their relationship? That Daryl Dixon, the antisocial brute of the club, gets to see and deal with the fact that someone he perceives as weak actually believes in him and sees him as a good man despite his foul relations with the rest of the cast? That this arc can also very easily stand on its own?

In any case, Hershel is devastated by this loss and relapses into alcoholism for a while. Rick and Glenn find him inside a bar he used to frequent. They run into 2 survivors who pose as friendlies at first, trying to learn more about Rick's group, like where they live. Rick sees through the bullshit and attempts to firmly assert that none of those men are getting near their family. They draw first, but Rick is faster. After a shootout with the allies of the 2 men Rick had just shot, they rescue a young man named Randall who ran along with the group. Once he is at the farm, Shane insists that he is a threat and shouldn't be allowed to live. His hostility is affirmed when Daryl beats it out of Randall: a group of 30 or so men with heavy weapons who like to kill men and make women wish they were dead.

After watching 7 episodes that very clearly establish how characters like Shane and Rick go about things, the viewers had 7 weeks to think about their development. They now have more time to assess the Randall situation at hand and see how the relationship between Rick and Shane takes its final nosedive. In any case, the show had time to establish this group as a potential threat even after several episodes of a hopeless rescue search, Carl's almost fatal bullet wound, Lori coming clean to Rick, and several other arcs. Especially Rick's and Shane's dynamic reaches a low point when they physically fight over Randall's life, which ultimately results in their final confrontation, where Shane is very openly venting his frustration with his former best friend. He kills Randall and lures Rick out with a lie so he can kill him and take control of the group once again through lies, thinking that he can actually have Lori and Carl for himself again. After a series of weeks where the viewers saw his moments of madness and humanity, he finally succumbs to the former and is no longer able to coexist with the rest of the group. Rick understands that and tearfully puts Shane down in one of the best scenes of the entire show. This scene only works so well because it is the culmination of weeks worth of buildup. Because the characters involved both had a fully fleshed-out dynamic with the group they are fighting for. Not every moment before this scene had to openly lead to this outcome.

Why it wouldn't work today.

If The Walking Dead season 2 released on Netflix today, we'd have 8 episodes. Sophia is lost in episode 1 and is found (dead and reanimated) at episode 4. The entirety of the Randall arc encompasses episodes 5-7. Shane dies at the end of episode 7. Episode 8 plays out just like episode 13 did in the original; a horde overruns the farm. The Ricktatorship arc begins. The prison is shown at the end. Season 3 comes out 3 years later. Chandler Riggs no longer looks like he did at the end of season 3. Therefore, the fact that seasons 2 and 3 are just a winter apart is less believable. They'd either have to work in a longer timeframe to pass or just fuck it and ball. A lot of the scenes that humanized Shane are just gone because it has fewer episodes. He gets like 1 or 2 scenes where he glances sadly at the dead Sophia in between all the scenes where he is yelling and arguing with Rick, and that is all we get to humanize him. The affair is revealed a lot faster. Daryl and Carol get fewer scenes. A lot of scenes that are funny or just let the characters breathe a little are cut out.

But the worst part? Most viewers do not see it as a slower, character-driven season that keeps you guessing about its story. Most will see Shane shave his head and see his death scene 8 hours later. You will see Sophia go missing, only for her to pop out of the barn like 4 hours later. There is no time for theorizing or guessing in between episodes when the next episode is just a click away. Around 6 hours after you watch one episode, you can already Google the show, and "TWD season 2 Shane death" will show up immediately. You may also wait for like a few years or so and see season 3 by the time you have forgotten a lot about season 2 already. Good thing that some shows tend to include recaps at the beginning now. All of it wouldn't be nearly as good or nearly as satisfying.


r/CharacterRant • • 5h ago

Batman killing his villains wouldn't really change things in-universe

5 Upvotes

They would just come back to life, in a year at most. He literally tried to kill the Joker at the end of Death in the Family, and we know that it didn't work.

"But that's meta reasoning" -> The reason why Batman's methods don't work is meta too, it goes both ways. He totally has the resources and influence to try and make an actually effective prison for villains, not to mention that most of them should have already been put into death row a thousand times. The plot is the reason why they are able to escape so there can be conflict, and it would be the reason why they would be able to come back to life if Batman killed them.

I just think discussions about what Batman's methods should be should focus more in "Do I like the themes Batmnan's stories are touching about sanctity of life and the way it's written?" rather than what would be more effective in-universe. Because neither trapping the villains nor killing them is effective in-universe.