I know I am likely in the minority here, but I’m over Hoid as a narrator. I know he’s a storyteller but still…
A couple of m reasons:
- it’s starting to feel a repetitive concept in Sanderson’s writing which gives concepts that used to feel so distinct and unique a repetitive feel.
- while there is still much mystery to the character, it feels like we keep getting the same side of him - the jovial joking side. This person has survived countless ages and calamities across gods and empires. He has to have more depth, like we saw glimpses of early on in his appearances in the Stormlight books. Instead we get the same flippant side each time.
- he comes across as a caricature of himself in these stories, same here as in Yumi and Tres. Regularly just there for levity and exposition.
- speaking of exposition- it feels lazy repeatedly using him as a way to paint the story except he tells us exactly what we need to know, before or mid-moment. As it’s often said - “show don’t tell.” If that was the method he wouldn’t even be needed.
- an example of this is it used to be fun to “spot” Hoid in a story. Now it’s him narrating- “that’s me.” And something like “I know I’m behaving dumb here, but it’s not my fault…”
I love the unique ideas Sanderson comes up with for his worlds. There used to be a sweet subtlety to other Cosmere references or subtle foreshadowing them payoff. And now sometimes it just feels like the stories are being dumbed down and it takes me out of the story when we are hit over the head with the direct exposition and buffoonery. It’s a bit like the storytelling of a Netflix show.