So when I posted a little while ago about English speakers' use of the different pronunciations of the article "the" - ie, my mistaken belief that it was common usage across the board (if you'll pardon the idiom) to use [ði] before a vowel phoneme and [ðə] before a consonant phoneme - I was quite taken aback by the wide variety of different opinions on it! Some believe it to be a generational convention, some believe it to be more of a regional/dialectical thing, and some just believe it to be a personal "whatever feels right at the time" sort of choice. Whatever the answer, I definitely learned that it is not a hard rule, thus explaining why it is generally not explicitly taught as one. But in my research into this, I discovered yet another controversy that I'd love to hear some opinions on!
The reason I always assumed it was a "rule" was due to the nature of "flow," so to speak. When using [ði] in front of a word that begins with a vowel phoneme (note, the phoneme is the important thing here! A word like "one," for instance, begins with a vowel, however the phoneme is a consonant - *wʌn* - thus, following this convention, would use [ðə] despite starting with "o"), the two words can be tied together without stopping; for example, "ði⁀æpəl," creating a sort of faux dipthong which makes for a nice flow and allows the speaker to maintain speed and efficiency. The way I perceive it, [ðə] cannot "flow" into a vowel phoneme but rather requires the epenthesis of a glottal stop before the new vowel phoneme can begin - ie, "ðə ʔ æpəl." To my ear, it sounds off because the stop breaks up the flow of the sentence. I noticed quite a few commenters on my original thread shared my opinion that it sounded "off" somehow, and I suspect that this breaking up of the flow is also what is causing it for them as well... but I also noticed the alarming amount of defensiveness in the form of downvotes from those who don't follow this convention. Needless to say I was intrigued.
Much of my research so far has been online, as almost everyone I know uses the same [ði]-vowel convention I do (which does give credence to the regional argument), but I did manage to find someone I know who was not originally from my area (Northeast US) and does not follow it as strictly so that I could ask about it. So I asked if they felt their flow was broken up by the insertion of the glottal stop. What I found VERY interesting was that in their perception, they don't even hear themselves making the glottal stop at all! They believe they are smoothly connecting the schwa with whatever vowel sound comes next! But to my ear, the break, no matter how small, is quite obvious! We even went on youtube together to find some examples of other people using [ðə]-vowel so they could hear someone other than themselves using it, and the perceptual difference remained! Truly fascinating!
So I included one of the examples - it's from some random TED talk, but the relevant thing is his use of "ðə" before the word elevator. She insists she hears it as "ðə⁀el.ə.veɪ.t̬ɚ" whereas I can only hear it as "ðə ʔ el.ə.veɪ.t̬ɚ." The stop is short, granted, but I definitely hear it, and it still breaks up his sentence to me, as opposed to if he had said "ði⁀el.ə.veɪ.t̬ɚ."
So I'm curious, fellow language lovers... what do you hear? Is the stop noticable to you like it is for me? Or does it flow nicely for you like it does for my [ðə] loving friend, haha? And whichever way you hear it, is it representative of how you normally speak?
Do you believe this phenomenon is more regional or generational - the guy in the TED talk looked pretty young, as is my friend... but then again, my friend is not from the Northeast originally (she moved from the midwest) and I can't tell where that guy in the TED talk is from.
I love that this turned out to be a WAY more interesting a topic than my initial question!