r/Egypt • Cairo • Oct 08 '21

Rant متعصب We Need to do Better than this…

Post image
370 Upvotes

127 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

7

u/UrbanismInEgypt Egypt Oct 08 '21

This is a false choice. You can have low traffic while having lots of greenery and narrow roads. The main determinant of traffic is excess parking supply and free parking. If they had cracked down on the curbside parking, double parking, and sidewalk parking, they could have fixed the traffic without destroying the are.

6

u/hader92 Alexandria Oct 08 '21

Also wait for a couple of years until induced demand kicks in, you'll get the same bottleneck again

1

u/aothelal Oct 08 '21

Then at least we would have spent less time passing through these streets during these years better than nothing at all using the old scheme. We would have lost the landscapes in all cases tough unfortunately.

5

u/hader92 Alexandria Oct 08 '21

Well, the solution then is not to lose the landscape at all and instead of patching traffic for a year, actually providing a long-term solution. Unfortunately, almost all urban "planning" in Egypt is super near-sighted and only looks for short term gains regardless of their longer term consequences.

Take for example the HSR line being constructed from Sokhna to Alamein. This is awesome, this solves big problems, it's a long-term bet, and I can't wait for it to actually start operating. But if you look down a level, Cairo is being turned into an urban hell and Alexandria is being stripped of everything that gives it its character, just to build more car-centric infrastructure.

0

u/aothelal Oct 08 '21

This didn't seem to work during the last 40 years here in Egypt. At least someone thought about a solution rather than keeping the situation as is for more years ahead. Again I'm not against green landscapes but many other countries implemented other methods for this like roof-planting for example. Maybe the old method we had suits new cites with larger areas but currently I don't think that Cairo can hold anymore with the old scheme. Resolving parking issues requires way more time in my opinion than this unfortunately.

7

u/UrbanismInEgypt Egypt Oct 08 '21

This didn't seem to work during the last 40 years here in Egypt

There has literally never been a time in which street parking has been properly restricted in Cairo history. What are you talking about.