Realistically the extra lanes were needed. If it takes you an extra hour to get anywhere, that’s also decreasing quality of life. They should make some designated parks and green areas. But this was out of necessity.
Ok I know this street and I wasted quite a huge amount of time passing through this bottleneck in the past. Same at Safeer square, Mahkama square and many other ones. I remember taking almost 40 mins or more only to get from a side to the other side at Safeer square. Maybe this is better than before but we're surprised because things weren't changing at this pace in the past?
I'm passing through this same street multiple times per month now and I'm quite surprised how fast I can go from some place like Abasseya square to Hegaz square compared to before.
P.S. green landscapes are important but maybe they need to re-planned again? I'm not defending anyone here but I'm just measuring the impact considering all factors.
This is a false choice. You can have low traffic while having lots of greenery and narrow roads. The main determinant of traffic is excess parking supply and free parking. If they had cracked down on the curbside parking, double parking, and sidewalk parking, they could have fixed the traffic without destroying the are.
Then at least we would have spent less time passing through these streets during these years better than nothing at all using the old scheme. We would have lost the landscapes in all cases tough unfortunately.
Well, the solution then is not to lose the landscape at all and instead of patching traffic for a year, actually providing a long-term solution. Unfortunately, almost all urban "planning" in Egypt is super near-sighted and only looks for short term gains regardless of their longer term consequences.
Take for example the HSR line being constructed from Sokhna to Alamein. This is awesome, this solves big problems, it's a long-term bet, and I can't wait for it to actually start operating. But if you look down a level, Cairo is being turned into an urban hell and Alexandria is being stripped of everything that gives it its character, just to build more car-centric infrastructure.
This didn't seem to work during the last 40 years here in Egypt. At least someone thought about a solution rather than keeping the situation as is for more years ahead. Again I'm not against green landscapes but many other countries implemented other methods for this like roof-planting for example. Maybe the old method we had suits new cites with larger areas but currently I don't think that Cairo can hold anymore with the old scheme. Resolving parking issues requires way more time in my opinion than this unfortunately.
انا مبقتش عارفه الشوارع من المنظر ده وزعلت جدا ان ده الوضع اما كنت بتضايق كنت بروح اتمشي هناك دلوقتي صعب القي حته جمبي فيها خضره من اصله والجو يخنق وكبعا الشكل بقي بشع وليه بيعملوا كل ده ليه اصلا
هو انا مش بقول ان اللي اتعمل ده صح 100% كان اكيد ممكن يتعمل احسن من كدا. بس المكان ده فعلا كان زحمة فشخ وكان ممكن تقعد فيه 30 دقيقة بتحاول تعدي بس انما دلوقتي مبتكملش دقيقة بالعربية تعدي فيها الكوبري. اظن هو بعد ما الناس كلها اشتكت من الحوار ده بداوا يزرعوا شوية لما يجددوا طريق او يعملوا كوبري فمكان معين.
For anyone wondering car reliant urban sprawl is the absolute worst way to develop a city. This results in dirty air, High maintenance costs, danger streets, and unwalkable communities. Not to mention traffic galore.
And how come the cars are parked nice and neatly in the new scenario? Not arguing, genuinely curious if you have a point of view on why people are not parked illegally on a wider road, it shouldn’t matter, no?
That's really just the picture. The cars will be parked in whatever way is allowed by police enforcement. It has nothing to do with the fact that the road is wider. You can find plenty of giant roads with people double parked; and sidewalk parking is crazy common in heliopolis.
As soon as you let driver commit crimes, they will do so.
اعتقد هي الفكرة في التخطيط ممكن يوسعوا الطريق ويحافظوا علي جزء من المساحة الخضراء كحل وسط لانك بتواجه مشكلتين زحام وعدم وجود مساحات خضراء فأتمني يخصصوا مكان للشجر في الطريق حتي لو بشكل ابسط
You can't please people. We complained that these roads were too small for the traffic that it was getting and now we are complaining that the roads do not look nice and there will be more pollution. It's a lose-lose situation but IMO this was the better option. Pollution is bad but Cairo has been fucked for a while now thanks to our wonderful birth rates and our love for the Nile River.
dah share3 el 7egaz. gedetty allah yer7amha kanet 3aysha henak. bahdelo el share3 bahdala. kan medan we ba2a 2 U-turn. ba2et el 7eta di zebala lel sewa2a
And pretty much the only green area in the street removed and it won't stay empty for long the same problem will happen again this is just a temporary fix. Also carbon emissions increased and the trees that helped suck out some of those emotions gone, also my personal opinion nothing more
Yeah and I'm pretty sure the people who are supposed to regulate traffic won't be there or not do anything and traffic signs are almost broken all the time showing yellow always
1- how can he say unusable space when it will be used by cars and busses private and public? 2-why the hell would u need to walk, it's no the country side and its not the club. 3-how does all of this count together seriously how does not walking increase crime rate ? 4-its called upkeep and it is a known factor in all countries budgets. (However there truly is other building methods that have proven cheaper and way more efficient roads wise) 5-well they either do that having to also pay extra money for our petrol or provide the proper transportation to and from their premises, which is actually how it goes nowadays. 6-as per my understanding this is how cities expand, especially for a pretty old one like cairo.
That being said. The new administrative capital covers all the above points though. However, I don't think that i for one would ever be able to buy there. So good luck with that.
Wanna walk go to Mamsha ahl masr, any place on el korneish or any park just like kids park or the national park.
Not as an actual way to commute, it isn't a small town.
Even for someone who literally works 10 mins away from his home, I won't ever walk, like really why would I arrive all sweaty and smelling terrible to any place, all be it my work place.
Please explain, I really wanna hear ur point of view.
Dude, I come from a huge city abroad. My commute to school took me an hour when I was 9. I loved every second of it. It kept me fit. When I went out with my friends we would just walk to places together.
When I moved to Egypt at age 11 I would terribly miss those opportunities but still managed to go outside and just.. walk?
I’m 25. I live in Rehab now. I’m blessed to have the opportunity to just walk to supermarkets and and places around to stay fit and healthy.
Don’t you just sometimes want to get out of your house, have an ice cream or a drink in your hand, listen to some music and just walk? Have a friend by your side? Or a dog? Or just your thoughts? Without having to search for parking, pay an entry fee to a park that you may or may not visit once every 3 months, having to cram yourself into metros on Thursday nights?
Walking is wonderful for you, your body and soul.
Edit: I have a, almost, one year old child who feels so much better after spending time outside and sleeps better that way. You don’t need a fancy club that costs 200k for a family of 4 to just walk and use your built up energy.
Vehicle capacity doesn't matter. passenger capacity matters. They removed the tramway to put in freeways, which have much lower capacity for the same area.
Monorails have been found to be a failed project worldwide. Trams are great for short trips. Cost much less to build and maintain. Are a great transport means for the elderly and people with disabilities who want to make quick errands in their neighbourhoods.
Honestly I don’t think it will affect anything climate related, egypt is mainly a desert after all so a tree or two will not be significant. It is just for aesthetics.
Honestly that's the the logical choice, we're trying to cope up with the world we don't have the luxury to do a lot of things because of the multiplicity of basic priorities.
Catching up with the world would actually mean doing the opposite of this. It would mean making the city more and more carless, more green spaces, more trees, more pedestrianised public spaces, narrower streets, wider sidewalks, cycle lanes, less parking spaces, higher parking charges, better urban planning and zoning to reduce travel distances, expanding public transport and mass transit, making cities more accomodating and safer for children, the elderly, people with disabilities and mobility issues and women.
First of all that's a street not a nuclear reactor, Second we miss alot actually, The train system that kills people, Majority of the population are poor, maybe touch some grass.
Buddy, constantly replacing trees for more roads will cause more pollution in that area. More cars coming through those roads will result in more C02 emissions. You obviously are anti-environment, which is truly crazy to me.
I mean like when we're a first world country (trillions of years away) & the government is able to support itself like a first world government then it should worry about grass, right now we barely has passable infrastructure.
I love how they didn't even clean after them in the second photo and I'm pretty sure there's other solutions that removing grass and trees they're pretty much the only thing that give the street a bit of life
I would mind if they'd replaced the trees with terrible uneven tarmac and potholes but these are very good roads. Do we remember the traffic jams, stuck in 40 degree heat in a taxi without takeef, it was impossible! So Im happy with the new road improvements. Can always use the space on top of buildings and make roof gardens, clean up the areas around and make them usable.
Or we can make the city more walkable and make more comfortable, air conditioned, affordable, efficient, convenient and fast public transport available. That's the future. Making the city better for cars is literally going back to the 1950s
Masr Elgedida wasn't designed to hold the number of people it currently does. sadly, this had to be done to mitigate the reportedly hellish taffic. the only other solution was removing the residents to another place.
من غير الحزق ده مفيش دولة متقدمة أو متخلفة بتعمل طرق وسط المدينة ٥ حارات رايح و زيهم راجع .. توسيع المداخل و المخارج و منع الركنات في الشوارع الأساسية كان هيوفر سيولة و فلوس و يحافظ ع الموجود
لا موجود في المدن الي كثافة السكان عالية فيها .. و برضوا علشان تمنع الركنه في الشوارع محتاج تقدم جراجات بديله في نفس المنطقة اصل سكان المنطقة هيركنوا فين
كويس انك ذكرت موضوع المطافي .. ما لفتش نظرك أن الناس راكنة صف ع الشمال اساسا ؟ ما خدتش بالك ان الصورتين ف اوقات مختلفة ؟ مش عارف ان تنظيم المرور اللي ماسكه مين عشان كدة الدنيا بايظة ؟ ما سمعتش عن حوادث السير طيب عشان مفيش بني ادم طبيعي يقدر يعدي كل يوم عشر حارات عشان يعدي الشارع ؟
There will always be bottlenecks in 6 lane roads, the urban system needs to change not the roads, in 10 years 6 lanes also won't be enough because there will be more and more cars and people. 1- they should tax the shit out of private cars, use the tax money for improving public transportations and road infrastructure (no middle class family should have 4+ cars) 2-re-evaluate drivers license for everyone to make sure everyone understands traffic rules and signs. 3-force tower and building owners to have a parking beneath the buildings and allow all the tenants to park there. 4-stop using military short sighted vision in such matters, practicality doesn't come on the expense of aesthetics and health. 5- there needs to be surveillance in every corner whether it be digital (cameras) or using traffic soldiers, to avoid bottlenecks and jamming points. me personally i see all of the new roads as obsolete as long as they don't apply the things that i mentioned earlier.
I disagree with this. I am an American who lives in the state of Illinois. Chicago is the 3rd largest city in the nation with 8mil people. One thing the city did to decrease traffic was to create huge, city-wide parking garages and a highway system underneath the city. That way, people can park underground, rely on public transportation above ground for their stay, and then go back to their car when they leave. The traffic is still bad, but it has lessened the traffic so significantly.
American cities aren't really well known for good urban planning. But at least some stuff is happening there in bigger cities to make them more walkable and pedestrian friendly, exactly the opposite of what's happening here.
If you look into Amsterdam, Paris, or heck even London, you'll find that those cities decrease car traffic by building parking lots on the outskirts of the city, combining them with a park-and-ride. Highways and stroads never ever go through the city, instead other viable options are provided. You can't tackle urban hell without a proper public transport network, and that's simply non-existent in (most of) Cairo or Alexandria.
Exactly, Americans often criticize the urban planning of their cities and how it revolves around the car. I live in Boston, a city of a mere 600,000 population and ranked worst in traffic. The best urban planning in the US is Manhattan, and that is because of zoning laws and killer subway network. Vancouver, Canada is considered the best in North America in terms of urban planning.
Yeah. America is built very spread out, and is very reliant on cars because of that. It’s not very urban friendly. Our states are the size of European nations, and there’s 1, maybe 2 urban cities per state. The rest are isolated and suburban.
Even in urban and suburban areas, everything is built around cars. I don't think tbh that the US is more reliant on cars because of being spread out. Rail was the backbone of the American state and the biggest motivator for spreading west at the turn of the century. So it not being widespread anymore is a choice to build everything geared towards cars, not a necessity.
I highly recommend a YouTube channel called Not Just Bikes that compares a bunch of European cities to their North American counterparts and discusses a few issues like urban sprawl and zoning in the US.
I am an American who lives in the state of Illinois. Chicago is the 3rd largest city in the nation with 8mil people. One thing the city did to decrease traffic was to create huge, city-wide parking garages and a highway system underneath the city.
Why would it matter to me what Chicago did or didn't do? Chicago isn't a city we should be emulating, and i don't want to take bad ideas from a poorly run city. Transportation in Paris and Tokyo is miles better than in Chicago, and those are the places Cairo should be copying.
just because a city is poorly planned doesn’t mean that all ideas from that city are bad. The underground parking garages helped significantly with traffic and that should be noted
you do realize that Paris has huge underground parking garages for the same reason, right?
We are talking about Cairo, a city in a poor country, which is why we should choose cheap options which actually work (reducing supply and increasing price of parking) and not expensive options which make traffic worse (creating more parking spaces underground)
Thanks for bringing up this convo, I dont live in Cairo - my mother does. Growing up in the states we have paved everything and it doesnt work. More lanes merely means more traffic. A good strategy is thinking through more of an urban lens of reducing the need for people to leave regions. Cairo could be reshaped as a city of a thousand villages & minarets
36
u/The-Egyptian_king Cairo Oct 08 '21
Originally found on r/urbanhell
5
u/goodnightshuttles Oct 08 '21
Realistically the extra lanes were needed. If it takes you an extra hour to get anywhere, that’s also decreasing quality of life. They should make some designated parks and green areas. But this was out of necessity.
21
u/aothelal Oct 08 '21 edited Oct 08 '21
Ok I know this street and I wasted quite a huge amount of time passing through this bottleneck in the past. Same at Safeer square, Mahkama square and many other ones. I remember taking almost 40 mins or more only to get from a side to the other side at Safeer square. Maybe this is better than before but we're surprised because things weren't changing at this pace in the past?
I'm passing through this same street multiple times per month now and I'm quite surprised how fast I can go from some place like Abasseya square to Hegaz square compared to before.
P.S. green landscapes are important but maybe they need to re-planned again? I'm not defending anyone here but I'm just measuring the impact considering all factors.
16
u/ivacrystal Oct 08 '21
انا مبقتش عارفه الشوارع من المنظر ده وزعلت جدا ان ده الوضع اما كنت بتضايق كنت بروح اتمشي هناك دلوقتي صعب القي حته جمبي فيها خضره من اصله والجو يخنق وكبعا الشكل بقي بشع وليه بيعملوا كل ده ليه اصلا
6
u/Toshiro_37 Cairo Oct 08 '21
tbh. the green area's are rarely kept clean cuz trashy people just throw away their garbage.
soooo unless there's a way to enforce not throwing trash in the street's. pro road till then
6
u/Silent8Hunter1 Oct 08 '21
هو انا مش بقول ان اللي اتعمل ده صح 100% كان اكيد ممكن يتعمل احسن من كدا. بس المكان ده فعلا كان زحمة فشخ وكان ممكن تقعد فيه 30 دقيقة بتحاول تعدي بس انما دلوقتي مبتكملش دقيقة بالعربية تعدي فيها الكوبري. اظن هو بعد ما الناس كلها اشتكت من الحوار ده بداوا يزرعوا شوية لما يجددوا طريق او يعملوا كوبري فمكان معين.
6
u/Georgesoliman Oct 08 '21
For anyone wondering car reliant urban sprawl is the absolute worst way to develop a city. This results in dirty air, High maintenance costs, danger streets, and unwalkable communities. Not to mention traffic galore.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '21
Your original picture literally has a fire truck stuck in traffic.
Yes let’s go back to when emergency vehicles are getting stuck in traffic because it had a few extra sqm of grass! /s
2
u/Hunting_down_anxiety Oct 08 '21
اعتقد هي الفكرة في التخطيط ممكن يوسعوا الطريق ويحافظوا علي جزء من المساحة الخضراء كحل وسط لانك بتواجه مشكلتين زحام وعدم وجود مساحات خضراء فأتمني يخصصوا مكان للشجر في الطريق حتي لو بشكل ابسط
4
u/ZedArabianX13 Cairo Oct 08 '21
You can't please people. We complained that these roads were too small for the traffic that it was getting and now we are complaining that the roads do not look nice and there will be more pollution. It's a lose-lose situation but IMO this was the better option. Pollution is bad but Cairo has been fucked for a while now thanks to our wonderful birth rates and our love for the Nile River.
2
u/B4dr003 Egypt Oct 08 '21
The old dilemma of more trees with narrow streets and horrible traffic or sacrificing trees for better roads and smoother traffic
Ican only hope they built another garden to compensate for the loss of this one
1
u/Glum_Adagio_541 Oct 08 '21
Alright, Alright.
1
u/manbel13 Oct 09 '21
Stop making kids like rabbits. Your kids are literally eating the planet.
1
u/endlessthinker2020 Oct 09 '21
Wider topic: Will Egypt ever take a step towards sustainability?!
1
u/xSenpaiHentaix Alexandria Oct 09 '21
تحيا ماسر 3 مرات
1
u/KindredSpirit__ Oct 09 '21
:(((
1
u/BoddaDsk Oct 13 '21
dah share3 el 7egaz. gedetty allah yer7amha kanet 3aysha henak. bahdelo el share3 bahdala. kan medan we ba2a 2 U-turn. ba2et el 7eta di zebala lel sewa2a
1
u/Hyper669 Alexandria Oct 16 '21
ك و ب ر ي
-1
u/Disastrous_Badger_28 Oct 08 '21
I see no problem here, on the contrary. Travel time decreased, vehicle capacity increased.
Alot of sultions in 1 picture, just removing a large unused section of the land to use it correctly.
As infrastructure in place doesn't allow for the number of residents, thus new measures and priorities had to be taken and applied.
1
u/Scroll-000 Oct 08 '21
Honestly I don’t think it will affect anything climate related, egypt is mainly a desert after all so a tree or two will not be significant. It is just for aesthetics.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '21
Honestly that's the the logical choice, we're trying to cope up with the world we don't have the luxury to do a lot of things because of the multiplicity of basic priorities.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '21
والله الواحد هنا بيشوف عقليات و عاهات بنت متناكة .. كسم التعليم اللي بيدي شهادات و يفهم الناس أنهم كدة اتعلموا خلاص
0
u/endlessthinker2020 Oct 08 '21
Seems like what all it needed is a Kobry 🤣🤣🤣
0
u/madmadaa Oct 08 '21
Greenery is cool and all but roads have a purpose, so it's better to widen it, save people time and find a suitable place to plant trees.
0
u/Jager_21 Egypt Oct 09 '21
الخضرة حلوة بس الزحمة وحشة اوى.
-11
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '21
Reddit angry that 5 trees were removed to make room for more practical, necessary road
-1
u/keko1105 Oct 08 '21
I love how they didn't even clean after them in the second photo and I'm pretty sure there's other solutions that removing grass and trees they're pretty much the only thing that give the street a bit of life
0
u/MysteryDivers Oct 08 '21
I would mind if they'd replaced the trees with terrible uneven tarmac and potholes but these are very good roads. Do we remember the traffic jams, stuck in 40 degree heat in a taxi without takeef, it was impossible! So Im happy with the new road improvements. Can always use the space on top of buildings and make roof gardens, clean up the areas around and make them usable.
-1
u/RandomAverageUser Oct 09 '21
I see no problem here
-1
u/madara707 Egypt Oct 09 '21
Masr Elgedida wasn't designed to hold the number of people it currently does. sadly, this had to be done to mitigate the reportedly hellish taffic. the only other solution was removing the residents to another place.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '21
[removed] — view removed comment