r/Egypt • Cairo • Oct 08 '21

Rant متعصب We Need to do Better than this…

Post image
370 Upvotes

127 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/UrbanismInEgypt Egypt Oct 08 '21

I agree with most of what was posted here except for this:

3-force tower and building owners to have a parking beneath the buildings and allow all the tenants to park there.

This is a bad policy. The biggest cause of excess car usage is plentiful parking. We should be decreasing parking, not increasing it.

12

u/djwikki Oct 08 '21

I disagree with this. I am an American who lives in the state of Illinois. Chicago is the 3rd largest city in the nation with 8mil people. One thing the city did to decrease traffic was to create huge, city-wide parking garages and a highway system underneath the city. That way, people can park underground, rely on public transportation above ground for their stay, and then go back to their car when they leave. The traffic is still bad, but it has lessened the traffic so significantly.

10

u/hader92 Alexandria Oct 08 '21

American cities aren't really well known for good urban planning. But at least some stuff is happening there in bigger cities to make them more walkable and pedestrian friendly, exactly the opposite of what's happening here.

If you look into Amsterdam, Paris, or heck even London, you'll find that those cities decrease car traffic by building parking lots on the outskirts of the city, combining them with a park-and-ride. Highways and stroads never ever go through the city, instead other viable options are provided. You can't tackle urban hell without a proper public transport network, and that's simply non-existent in (most of) Cairo or Alexandria.

5

u/El-Fofes Alexandria Oct 08 '21

Exactly, Americans often criticize the urban planning of their cities and how it revolves around the car. I live in Boston, a city of a mere 600,000 population and ranked worst in traffic. The best urban planning in the US is Manhattan, and that is because of zoning laws and killer subway network. Vancouver, Canada is considered the best in North America in terms of urban planning.

1

u/djwikki Oct 08 '21

Yeah. America is built very spread out, and is very reliant on cars because of that. It’s not very urban friendly. Our states are the size of European nations, and there’s 1, maybe 2 urban cities per state. The rest are isolated and suburban.

2

u/hader92 Alexandria Oct 08 '21

Even in urban and suburban areas, everything is built around cars. I don't think tbh that the US is more reliant on cars because of being spread out. Rail was the backbone of the American state and the biggest motivator for spreading west at the turn of the century. So it not being widespread anymore is a choice to build everything geared towards cars, not a necessity.

I highly recommend a YouTube channel called Not Just Bikes that compares a bunch of European cities to their North American counterparts and discusses a few issues like urban sprawl and zoning in the US.

1

u/djwikki Oct 08 '21

Thanks, I will check it out

0

u/UrbanismInEgypt Egypt Oct 08 '21

I am an American who lives in the state of Illinois. Chicago is the 3rd largest city in the nation with 8mil people. One thing the city did to decrease traffic was to create huge, city-wide parking garages and a highway system underneath the city.

Why would it matter to me what Chicago did or didn't do? Chicago isn't a city we should be emulating, and i don't want to take bad ideas from a poorly run city. Transportation in Paris and Tokyo is miles better than in Chicago, and those are the places Cairo should be copying.

11

u/djwikki Oct 08 '21
  1. just because a city is poorly planned doesn’t mean that all ideas from that city are bad. The underground parking garages helped significantly with traffic and that should be noted
  2. you do realize that Paris has huge underground parking garages for the same reason, right?

5

u/UrbanismInEgypt Egypt Oct 09 '21

2) you do realize that Paris has huge underground parking garages for the same reason, right?

The total parking capacity in Paris is much much lower than in Chicago and they have been removing them one by one.

just because a city is poorly planned doesn’t mean that all ideas from that city are bad

Chicago is planned pretty well actually (wrt it's urban grid). Its parking management is a failure

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/UrbanismInEgypt Egypt Oct 10 '21

We are talking about Cairo, a city in a poor country, which is why we should choose cheap options which actually work (reducing supply and increasing price of parking) and not expensive options which make traffic worse (creating more parking spaces underground)

2

u/The-Egyptian_king Cairo Oct 08 '21

Or charge for parking