Context: I’m someone who’s politically minded, who’s been thinking a lot about society since childhood, and who has a strong sense of justice (even if, like everyone else, I’m a hypocrite and don’t always live up to it myself).
For several years now (and increasingly so), I’ve found myself having the same thought over and over again: Nothing has any greater meaning. Actually, nothing matters if the world is going to hell, and even if we lived in a perfect world, the sun would eventually expand and swallow up the Earth along with all its memories.
I know this thought is very far-fetched and surreal for some people. Not for me. During tough times, it weighs on me every day because I think to myself: it really doesn’t matter at all whether I’m a good or bad person, whether I get up or stay in bed—if, in the end, nothing matters anyway.
All the news and bleak prospects of the current political situation (extreme inequality globally and within nations; an unstoppable climate catastrophe caused by us—the wealthy West—which is doing far too little to combat it; children bombed to death; selfishness; species extinction; the degrading treatment of animals; war; dictators running amok (and those who would like to be); right-wing extremism, etc.)—to be honest, none of that helps at all, because I lost my faith in humanity a long time ago as a result.
It’s just too nihilistic to say, “People should do their own thing; I just can’t live selfishly and happily for myself without considering others”—I can never completely stop thinking about humanity and getting annoyed with it.
Just to provide some context: I’ve been in therapy for over 1.5 years now, where these issues are also addressed, but so far they’ve never really helped. The thought that I find everything in the world (including every person I know and myself) “meaningless”—I have that thought every single day, without exception. It’s more that on good days, I don’t care about this thought, but on bad days, it wears me down.
Is there anyone else with similar thoughts or problems, and what methods have you found to deal with them? In short: how do you manage to be happy in a world you don’t understand, that you don’t like at all right now, and that you also find meaningless?
We humans are seriously mistaken concerning our idea that criminal law is determinative of, is originative of, and controls human action and inaction.
Law is a given language, while, all the while, givens are not, cannot be, determinative of human action; that is, Spinoza's dictum remains absolute, i.e.,, “determinatio negatio est”, and , is the central human ontological precept employed in this writing ; and, the dictum describes the primal ontological structure of human freedom.
Human action originates via negation, via nothing/nothingnesses, i.e., via lack, absence, need, and not via given states of affairs.
Nothing/nothingness upsurges within human consciousness as an idea, as an intention, to act in future.
That the ontological originative source of human action is always a nothing, an absence, a lack, an imagination, an intention, constitutes the checkmate of law.
The Practice and Enforcement of Law, Which Self-Righteously Purports to be Absolutely Determinative and Corrective of Everyone's Conduct, is Pre-eminently Mistaken and Unethical on the Human Ontological Plane Regarding the Actual Mode of Origin of Both Personal and Jurisprudential/Legal Action.
Law is not in fact determinative of personal or jurisprudential action.
Law is dishonest sub-human activity per the employment, incorrectly, of a claim to be determining actions for or against persons on the basis of given language of legislation/precedent; while, all the while, no human act actually originates on the basis of a prior given state of affairs, i.e., "determinatio negatio est" ("determination is negation"), (Spinoza , 1632-1677); meaning that human determination to originate an act is, ontologically, a process always solely predicated upon the lack/absence/need/nothing/non-being/desideratum of an intended/projected future state.
The magistrate, policeman, or any other jurisprudentially oriented person, claiming to act against others by given law and/or by given rule of law, is, unintentionally, radically mistaken on the human ontological level, where: "All determination is negation." (Hegel , 1770-1831 ).
J. P. Sartre (1901-1980), explains the nihilative origination of a human act, thus:
"No factual state whatever it may be (the political and economic structure of society, the psychological "state", etc.) Is capable by itself of motivating any act whatsoever. For an act is a projection of the for-itself toward what is not, and what is can in no way determine by itself what is not." And, further: "But if human reality is action, this means evidently that it's determination to action is itself action. If we reject this principle, and if we admit that human reality can be determined to action by a prior state of the world or itself, this amounts to putting a given at the beginning of the series. Then, these acts disappear as acts in order to give place to a series of movements...The existence of the act implies it's autonomy. Furthermore, if the act is not pure motion, it must be defined by an intention. No matter how this intention is considered, it can only be the surpassing of the given toward a result to be attained. This given, in fact, since it is pure presence, can not get out of itself. Precisely because it is, it is fully and solely what it is. Therefore it cannot provide the reason for a phenomenon which derives all it's meaning from a result to be attained; that is, from a non-existent. This intention which is the fundamental structure of human reality, can in no way be explained by a given..." Thus, Sartre begins his extensive description the what and how of human ontological Freedom.
"Law", whereby police, magistrates, and legislators purport to originate their legalist conduct toward other human beings, and, to originate the conduct of others, is an ontologically illegitimate/dishonest/dishonorable, and defeasible theoretical construct.
Extant rule of law/jurisprudence is not authentically ontologically human, for the reason that law wrongfully/mistakenly freely asserts it's published givens to be determinative of the human act, which act actually upsurges only nihilatively via what is intended and not yet.
As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly capable of performing tasks that once gave people a sense of accomplishment or purpose, how might this challenge our understanding of individual identity and meaning? Do you believe purpose is something we create through our choices, regardless of our circumstances, or can external factors fundamentally shape our sense of purpose?
Existentialist connection: Jean-Paul Sartre's concept of radical freedom and the idea that existence precedes essence. It raises the question of whether our purpose comes from what we do or whether we are responsible for creating it ourselves.
2. Is meaningful work necessary for an individual to experience a purposeful existence, or does the meaning we assign to our lives exist independently of our careers and productivity? If technological advancements eliminated the need for much of our labor, would we become freer to define our own existence, or would we struggle with the absence of something that traditionally gives our lives structure?
Existentialist connection: This connects to existential freedom, absurdism, and the responsibility of creating meaning in a world that does not necessarily provide us with an inherent purpose.
I gotta say, the Gym is a fairly good reaction to the Human Condition being intolerable, relentless, a bleak and meaningless desert of pain, and all that.
I wish I'd figured this out sooner.
Whereas most respites involve an element of delusion or resorting to toxic belief systems or compounds, the Gym offers a path of sublimation without self-deception.
Right now, I am on a treadmill (see Camus' Myth of Sisyphus.)
Feels familiar: I am walking at various speeds and inclines, but not getting anywhere. It is hard, and at some settings painful. I have concretized my fate in microcosm.
Yet...
I chose to come here and chose this machine, so there is a feeling of agency.
I still feel compelled to stare into the abyss, but I can imagine shapes there, in the shadows and mist. I can see that there are different forms of emptiness - from my vantage point here, sweating, on a treadmill, going nowhere.
Here, there is both continuity and permanence. ;)
Existentianism is essentially optimistic: The liberation of form from a predefined function in favor of picking or creating a new form or function.
Today I'm on a treadmill.
Don't get me wrong, I'm still committed to Schopenhauer and the idea that the most reliable compass for orienting oneself in the world is to think of it as a place of atonement.
I have headphones, however...
There are a large number of symphonies and books on tape to explore while going nowhere, losing calories, building endurance.
The restlessless is going away, and when I get home I can better focus on a clearer, higher form of lostness, alienation, and despair...
Or something new that leverages the optimism and possibilities of life without a template.
Or something new and unimagineable, just not Hip Hop or related to AI or Nationism in any way...
I hate to sound hopeful, but this is where I am.
There are Aerobics and other fitness classes offered here based on Pilates, Yoga, Salsa...
I am an advocate of Sartre's argument that existentialism is a form of humanism, and I agree that it is one of the greatest forms of freedom and also of anxiety. But this freedom, I can't feel it, I feel so trapped in my brain. What's the correlation of this with psychology?
Sup gang, i have something to vent in the last 6 days. I know that mental health related posts are not allowed, but don't care about that post's fate. If it get deleted i'll reupload it somewhere else.
As said above, right now i'm going through some shitty period in my live. Existential dread ain't something new for me, first time i encountered this almost eleven years ago, at age of 8. Since then, after every few years i have to experience this absolute horror and despair, it can last for weeks and usually appear with symptoms like insomnia and nervous nausea. That's tolerable since not too long compared to normal and calm years, but now i feel like i'm fucked. Since November 5 i hadn't a single calm night, everyday my thoughts are about time, life, death, conscience, universe and other themes this kind. I'm trying to stay tuned with real world and do my regular tasks, but it doesn't really help i guess. I know it is about to be deleted by mods, but if not - could anyone who had the same experience tell about it in comments and (if not prohibited!) give some advices? I appreciate any help
UPD 13.11: i don't know what to say. When i was writing it i thought "ok, it most probably gonna be deleted by mods, at least i'll write my soul out", but i've never expected to see so many unfamiliar people kind to me. Thanks you all guys, you're the probably the best people i've met on Reddit. So u know, i slept nice last night and i got much better yesterday. Fight ain't over, i'm not giving up, appreciate your support and kindness folks 💖
I just finished 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep' by Philip K Dick and realized how many books I enjoy are ones that explore philosophical journeys through imagined worlds. To examine what is real, the mind, and meaning in the meaningless world.
I'm currently finishing up The Expanse books. While not as heavy in the philosophical themes, since learning more about existentialism and absurdism, they become very apparent in the writing and characters.
Are there any other works of fiction that deal in existential themes that you enjoy?
*other than Camus, I still have The Stranger and The Rebel on my reading list.
I've been thinking a lot about Erich Fromm lately.
His ideas about love, freedom, responsibility and human nature seem so simple, yet so difficult to actually live by.
What really interests me is his idea that people can be afraid of their own freedom. We want to be free, but often prefer to conform, follow others or avoid taking responsibility for our choices.
Isn't that also one of the central questions of existentialism? Whether we're truly living our own lives or just following what society expects from us?
Sometimes I genuinely think that if more people understood Fromm, our society and the way we treat each other could be completely different.
If you’re actively scrolling through reddit to calm your existential dread this post is for you. I AM NOT A LISCENCED PROFESSIONAL. THESE ARE JUST THE THINGS THAT HELPED ME. IF YOU ARE EXPERIENCING SUICIDAL IDEATION PLEASE CALL A HOTLINE OR VISIT A MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL.
Tip 1: Thought release:
When we allow our thoughts to be trapped in our head they usually get worse. Talk to someone even if they don’t understand. If you have no one take out a journal or piece of paper and write it down. It sounds cliche but trust me it helps.
Tip 2: Letting go the need for external validation:
Especially for those who are actively deconstructing religion we often forget to deconstruct the systems that keep you co dependent on it. “ WERE ALL GONNA DIE SOMEDAY“ “NONE OF THIS WILL MATTER IN A BILLION YEARS” why does it have to? If you break your leg will your first instinct to say it won’t matter in a billion years? Of course not. Instead of larping on the potential future why not focus on where you are in the present. Don’t let your brain wonder off in fairytales. You‘re here now in the present for however many more years so why not make the most of it.
Tip 3: Let thoughts go:
If you feel yourself overwhelmed by nihilistic thoughts always remember that they are in fact just thoughts and can be let go. Humans have been trying to awnser the same questions your dwelling on since the beginning. Hence why it’s the plot of the oldest human story ever written. Trust me it’s futile trying to awnser them now. Just live your life.
If enough people like this i’ll do one about fear of death and fear of an existing or non existing afterlife. This post is just a way to help don’t expect it to work miracles right away.
I spent most of my life finding purpose and self-acceptance and then existentialism hit - nothing matters. We all cease to exist. And so, paradoxically, everything matters more than anything.
I cry every day at this thought. I cry in gratitude. I cry in sadness. I cry in joy. I cry in grief. I cry knowing that everything I love, including myself, will no longer be itself and so to cherish every second that it exists in the way I know it.
I have found solace in Daoism and stop every day to sense the oneness, or the Tao. Everything changes and everything exists as itself but simultaneously exists as one.
Long story short, I cannot do anything in my life without thinking about the bigger picture.
How lucky am I to experience a hot plate of food.
How lucky am I to experience intimacy with a loved one.
How lucky am I to have two feet to walk on.
How lucky am I to hear the birds sing.
And yet, it will end.
I think, in a way, community and other people to discuss this, would help. I tried sharing these feelings and thoughts with close friends, but I am a 27 year old woman living in the UK, and I seem to push people away by sharing these thoughts or feelings. And I understand why, but I would still love to find people to share them with.
What did you do?
Have you found a community to discuss existentialism?
Interesting take. There are some interesting points here.
I think even Nietzsche himself did not simply consider it a denial of the Divine. It was more of an observation of how Western civilisation was built on Christian values and how it was distancing itself further and further from those principles and values with the advent of science and rational enquiry.
Though I think both Nietzsche's own outlook and this one share the core idea of "self-overcoming", what they mean by it is vastly different, in my eyes.
Nietzsche's self-overcoming was, I think, about having one's own values rather than borrowed ones.
But here, I feel that self-overcoming does involve creating one's own values, but there's something more. It touches upon the soteriological aspect of Eastern philosophical traditions, but I can't quite put my finger on it.
I’ve been thinking about free will lately, and there’s something I can’t quite figure out. We believe that we make our own decisions. We choose what to eat, what to believe, who to love, and what kind of person we want to become. But think about it for a moment. We don’t choose our genetics, our childhood, our environment, our upbringing, or the experiences that shape our personalities. All of these things influence how we think and how we make decisions. So how much of our choices actually belong to us? For example, if someone makes a decision, that decision is influenced by everything that happened to them before that moment. Could we ever have genuinely chosen differently, or was that choice already determined by the person we had become? I’m not saying free will definitely doesn’t exist. I’m genuinely curious about where the boundary lies between our own decisions and the things that shaped us. Do we really choose our lives, or do we simply experience the feeling of choosing?
Here he is refusing theology, As an Indian here God's definition is : someone who is outside of you controlling you and the world , you can put all your responsibilities and problems on that imagined entity . People here behave like cultish if you ask any sensible question 😂 about God . They believe,they don't enquire.
Was camus talking about the same ? What was the famous definition of God at that time in France , he must be negating that definition of God .
I'm a member of a few philosophy reading groups online, but haven't seen anything involving existentialism. Would you all have any idea where to find them?
The following are the core figures of existentialism:
Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855): The Danish son of a wealthy merchant, Kierkegaard never held an academic post, but he wrote voluminously. Seen by many as the founder of existentialism, particularly Christian existentialism. . Key contributions: His analysis of religious experience, and the first developed analysis of many key existential concepts, including absurdity, anguish, authenticity, the weight of responsibility you bear for your choices, and the importance of the irrational to human life . Key works: Either/Or(1843), Fear and Trembling (1843), Concluding Unscientific Postscript (1846), The Sickness Unto Death (1849)
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900): The devout son of a Lutheran minister in Prussia, Nietzsche eventually broke with the church to become one of its staunchest critics and another founding father of existentialism. . Key contributions: Announcing the death of God; changing the human project from that of finding value and meaning to creating value and meaning; returning philosophy to its Greek roots and the concern for the health of the soul . Key works: Human, All Too Human (1878-1880), The Gay Science (1882-1887), Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1883-1891), Beyond Good and Evil (1886), The Genealogy of Morals (1887), Ecce Homo (1888)
Martin Heidegger (1889-1976): The most thoroughly academic of the existentialists. His involvement with the Nazi party couldn't stop his magnum opus from being one of the most influential books of the 20th century. . Key contributions: Turning existentialism into the systematic study of existence, particularly of Dasein; developing the concepts of being thrown and the situated subject . Key work: Being and Time (1927)
Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980): Heidegger's most celebrated pupil and the leading French existentialist. Philosopher, novelist, playwright, and political activist, Sartre lived the existential mantra of engagement in the world. . Key contributions: Popularizing existentialism; summarizing the existential perspective in the phrase existence precedes essence; developing existentialism as a philosophy of freedom
. Key works: Nausea (1938), Being and Nothingness (1943), No Exit (1943), Existentialism is a Humanism (1947), Anti-Semite and Jew (1947)
Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986): Seen by some as a mere mouthpiece of Sartre, de Beauvoir was a brilliant thinker in her own right, and she made significant contributions to literature, feminism, and existentialism. . Key contributions: Addressing the problem of other people; the development of a sophisticated existential ethics; grounding much of modern feminism in a largely existential framework
. Key works: The Blood of Others (1945), The Ethics of Ambiguity (1947), The Second Sex (1949), The Mandarins (1954)
Albert Camus (1913-1960): In many respects, Camus is the conscience of existentialism. A deeply compassionate man, his philosophy was centered on what he considered the universe's greatest injustice - death. Ironically, he died at a relatively young age. . Key contributions: Writing the greatest and most accessible of all existential novels, The Stranger; developing existentialism as a philosophy of absurdity; infusing existential philosophy with compassion and genuine humanity
. Key works: "The Myth of Sisyphus"(1942), The Stranger (1942), The Plague (1947), The Rebel (1951)
Key Existential Concepts What's existentialism all about? The following should give you some idea:
Absurdity: What human beings encounter when they come into contact with the world. Absurdity is brought about because the human instinct to seek order and meaning is frustrated by the refusal of the world to be orderly or meaningful.
Anxiety: Kierkegaard says, "Anxiety is the dizziness of freedom." You feel anxiety because you recognize that you and you alone are responsible for your actions. This produces the two-sided feeling of simultaneous dread and exhilaration.
Alienation: The sense that you're a stranger in the world, or a stranger to yourself. Many aspects of existence can be alienating. One of the primary sources is absurdity. Ironically, the stories and systems developed by philosophy and religion to address that absurdity can be just as alienating.
Existence precedes essence: Sartre's phrase to describe the existential situation humans find them- selves in. It refers to the fact that when you're born, you have no meaning, no purpose, no definition. Human beings exist first, and only later define themselves.
The Ubermensch: The word Nietzsche uses to refer to his ideal human being. Literally "overman," the word reflects the importance in his philosophy of overcoming - overcoming traditional values, over- coming the herd mentality, and, most importantly, overcoming yourself. You overcome these things so that you might attain something greater. Nietzsche's Übermensch is an unconventional creator of values, a joyous free spirit, and one who embraces the earth instead of pining away for heaven.
The death of God: The death of the notion that belief in God alone, or belief in any religious or philosophical system, is sufficient to provide human beings with the meaning, purpose, and definition they crave. It's the recognition that, because no external system can provide you with the answers, you must take responsibility for providing them yourself.
Subjectivity: Your first-person perspective on the world, including the needs, desires, and emotions that accompany that perspective. The existentialists take this as a valid and important starting point for genuinely human endeavors. This can be contrasted with the scientific mindset, which always starts with objectivity - seeing people in impersonal, objective terms without emotion or appreciation for their individual point of view.
By explaining that consciousness does not end at death but pauses psychologically, the scientific theory of a natural eternal consciousness (NEC) reveals a timeless immortality. Our NEC makes nonexistence impossible, a natural afterlife real, and a heaven of utmost joy as well as accountability possible. Note, however, that if any supernatural afterlife occurs, it will override one’s NEC. Philosophically, in revealing a timeless immortality, the NEC theory challenges existentialism's general presumption of the finality of death. However, it retains the urgency to live a meaningful life while intensifying the urgency to live a moral one.
Keywords: immortality, afterlife, natural eternal consciousness, natural afterlife, consciousness, NDE
If you never wake up from a dream, how will you ever know it’s over? —asked of myself, 2012
You need to know about the theory of a natural eternal consciousness (NEC). It asserts that we will be unaware that our final human experience is over, given that death is imperceptible. Thus, unless we experience a supernatural afterlife, we are left believing*, timelessly and eternally,* that this experience will continue. This undeniably startling NEC theory is based on psychology—specifically, observations on ordinary human experiences and the cognitive science principles that explain them. It reveals a newfound psychological reality about death: a timeless immortality that has profound significance for humanity. Developed pre-AI, it is now supported by AI.
In this brief overview, I state the NEC theory, explain it, describe the kinds of post-life experiences it reveals, and point out how it can make the world a better place. I also provide references for more detail. I close by explaining why I think the theory is hard for some to accept, then pose two questions that challenge the unpersuaded.
Theory Statement and Explanation
Theory of a Natural Eternal Consciousness: Unless a supernatural afterlife begins after death, from your perspective, you are eternally and imperceptibly paused in the last discrete conscious moment of your final experience. This moment is your natural eternal consciousness (NEC) and may be perceived as a natural afterlife.
Your final experience can be an awake one (perhaps a hallucination), a dream, or a near-death experience (NDE). Your self-awareness of it and unawareness of the moment of death guarantee you will never lose your sense of self and soul within this experience. Instead, from your perspective, the experience becomes imperceptibly timeless (paused, never to be continued) and deceptively eternal. The NEC is an end-of-life illusion of immortality, but to you, it is as real as a rainbow.
Others will know your final experience is over, but not you. In fact, you will be forever anticipating it will continue. Metaphorically, there is no OFF button for human consciousness. With death, it is simply Paused (▐ ▌) on your final discrete (never changing) conscious moment, and the Restart button (►) no longer works. This final moment is the present one of many such past-streaming moments (about 20 to 25 per second) that solely form your consciousness and thus awareness. It is paused on this moment, like an image on a TV screen or a selfie, because, unlike all other countless moments in your lifetime, no moment will ever replace it as the present in your self-awareness.
There is no OFF button for human consciousness. At death, it is Paused (▐ ▌), and the Restart button (►) is disabled. Sunset photo by Frank McKenna on Unsplash.com
That is, unless it is replaced at some point by the first conscious moment of a supernatural, faith-based afterlife. A Heaven, reincarnation, or something else? Science, as of now, cannot say.
Unlike all other afterlife theories, the NEC theory is scientific—possible only because the NEC begins before and is unaffected by death. Barring some new supernatural conscious moment, it just lingers timelessly as an unforgettable, non-biodegradable fragment of one’s self-awareness. Human experiences repeatedly verify the theory, and specified testing could falsify it. Moreover, if the NEC is a paused experience that one perceives as an afterlife, then it is a natural afterlife.
Thought Experiments and an Analogy
Thought experiments supporting the theory and an analogy can help to grasp it. First, the analogy.
Like humans, computers have experiences—e.g., answering a query about teenage suicides. Call this consciousness if you will. But, unlike humans, computers, even with AI, lack self-awareness. They have no concept of self, no soul. That is, they have no awareness of, and thus belief in, what they, as self, are experiencing. Thus, they have no aroused feelings or emotions—like pain, love, or sadness from finding stories of tragic loss of life. So, turn them off. They will have no NEC.
Assume no supernatural afterlife occurs in the thought experiments below. Also, focus entirely on the psychological, only what you can perceive and thus believe in your mind as you are dying. Ignore what you now know, as one of the living, is materially happening. That is, the brain is deteriorating to the point it no longer produces conscious moments. If you do this, the answers to the questions should make sense. Appreciating the relativity of the NEC is crucial to accepting it.
When do you know a dream is over? When you wake up. But suppose you never do. How will you ever know it’s over? You won’t unless an awake or NDE conscious moment replaces the last dream conscious moment as your present moment. For you, a timeless period (i.e., timelessness) separates these moments. Yet, you awake from a dream with the feelings and emotions present in its last moment (frustration?), an immediate surprise at the inconsistency of the awake moment, then, after re-orienting yourself, the thought (relief?) that it was only a dream. Your instantaneous reactions come from the potentially eternal, timelessly lingering self-awareness of the dream, not from your memory. (Neuroimaging testing could refute this, which would falsify the NEC theory.)
If you have undergone general anesthesia, when do you know you are not on the operating table breathing through a mask? When you wake up in the recovery room. But suppose you never do? The moment of passing out is imperceptible, as is the moment of falling asleep and death, and any ensuing periods of timelessness. So, what will ever make you believe you are not on that operating table if an awake moment never comes and you do not have a dream or NDE? Nothing.
Hallucinations, dreams, and NDEs are mysterious phenomena that have been recorded throughout human history. Jacob's Ladder, c. 1925, illustration in an American book of Bible stories for children
Now, imagine that your final experience is an NDE and you believe you are in heaven, as have many NDE survivors. But suppose you do not survive. What will ever make you believe you are not in heaven? Nothing, since no conscious moment will ever provide a new present moment to change your self-awareness. So, you will always timelessly believe you are in heaven, anticipating more glorious moments to come. This anticipation stems from the fact that each conscious moment carries within it an expectation that more consistent moments will immediately follow.
A Natural Afterlife and Other Possibilities
In the last thought experiment, the NEC is a natural afterlife because it was, to you, an afterlife, a heaven. The cause of the NDE—neurological, physiological, or transcendental—is irrelevant.
Logically, the natural afterlife can be a heaven of ultimate, eternal joy unlike any other envisioned afterlife. Many survivors of heavenly NDEs have reported intense peace and joy. When such an NDE is paused with death, it is an eventually timeless natural afterlife (etna), and now nothing more can happen to make it less joyful. An etna resolves the philosophical paradox of free will in any heaven imagined as time-perceiving, eternal, and perfect. Free will can lead to bad, even evil decisions, but its absence over zillions of years can lead to boredom. Sooner or later, no decisions need be made in an etna. So, no paradox. It is immortality without both the need for change and the existential fatigue that philosopher Bernard Williams reflects on.
If not a dream or NDE, your last experience may be lying peacefully on your deathbed, possibly surrounded by loved ones, grateful for the life lived, content in your beliefs, and knowing you’ve treated others well. If so, Google’s AI confirms that your final “peaceful moment continues uninterrupted in the final record of the mind.” Here, AI uses different terminology than I do to describe the NEC—indicating, at the least, a deduction of the NEC theory independent of my own.
Partial screenshot displayed by Google, using Gemini AI
Your NEC could be near-nothingness, near because your self is still present. Consider the ordinary, unsensual, and emotionless moments that you often have just before falling asleep with eyes closed, wherein you see nothing, hear nothing, smell nothing, taste nothing, and may physically and consciously feel nothing. This may be your final moment and thus, your NEC.
Again, the NEC theory does not rule out the possibility that the NEC could be overridden, at or sometime after death, by some supernatural afterlife. For instance, the NEC could be an intermediate realm (a purgatory?) for the soul before being eventually united with a resurrected, glorified body or being reincarnated into a completely different one.
Significance
You may have some control over your final waking experience, though unexpected events can happen—e.g., a fatal heart attack or accident. But you cannot control the occurrence and nature of hallucinations, dreams, and NDEs. Does random chance, natural causality (karma), or providence (some divine power) control these? Will they be pleasant or unpleasant? Spending a lifetime dreading that, by random chance, you could be eternally paused in a hellish experience would be awful. Thus, the NEC theory compels one to strive to develop a self that one can be happy to live with forever, to lead a life that allows one to be content and peaceful in one’s final wakeful moment, and, most importantly, to put one’s faith and trust in karma or providence.
The uncertainty surrounding the nature of one’s NEC makes accountability a possibility, and this possibility provides a “prodding iron” for humanity that I feel will change the world for the better. Once knowledge of the NEC theory becomes widespread, people should generally behave better. One example: any incentive for committing suicide or a mass shooting will diminish when one realizes that getting rid of oneself is no longer an option. Moreover, one must now consider “what dreams may come …” [Hamlet], especially if one dies after committing a suicidal heinous act.
For More Details
For more detailed explanation, validation, and discussion of the NEC theory’s significance, see the references below. A Natural Afterlife Discovered provides the most comprehensive coverage.
Those who insist that human consciousness is mortal yet supreme, even though our science can’t explain it, are likely to reject, perhaps even condemn, the orthodox-shattering NEC theory. It takes an open mind to understand it and even more so to accept and appreciate it.
I leave skeptics with two questions. When you die, precisely what will ever make you believe your last experience is over? Before answering, know that with death, you’ll perceive no indicator from a nonfunctioning brain, like “The End” or “You’re dead.” (Even with a functioning brain, you never receive a “You’re asleep” or “You’ve passed out” signal.) Besides, if you were to experience such a death indicator, what conscious moment would ever remove it from your self-awareness?
Abraham is no tragic hero. He's either a murderer or a man of faith.
In Soren Kierkegaard's Fear and Trembling, the pseudonymous author, Johannes de Silentio, describes the tragic hero as subordinating one ethical obligation to a higher ethical obligation.
For example, Brutus, the founder of the Roman Republic, subordinated his obligation as a father to his obligation as consul. His two sons were found guilty of treason against the Republic and, as consul, it was Brutus' duty to uphold the law.
But Abraham had no higher ethical obligation while preparing to **** Isaac. The patriarch wasn't ****ing the boy to save a nation and Isaac was no criminal. Abraham's highest ethical obligation at the time was as a father to his son.
Brutus subordinated his ethical obligation as a father to a higher ethical obligation as consul, making him a tragic hero. Abraham had no higher expression of the ethical. He cannot be a tragic hero.
A common critique of pure existentialism (e.g., Sartre or Camus) is that because value and significance are entirely self-generated through choice, any pursued project—whether mastering a virtuous craft or cultivating a destructive vice—generates subjective significance on equal footing, provided the actor invests radical freedom into it.
If "significance" is purely a product of subjective willpower, how does existentialism avoid collapsing into subjective relativism? Can an existential framework meaningfully distinguish between a human life that achieves Eudaimonia (flourishing aligned with truth) and one that builds "significance" out of arbitrary or destructive pursuits, without smuggling in objective, Platonic criteria through the back door?