r/LLMPhysics • u/belegstrong • 1h ago
Personal Theory Physics Hypothesis
I came up with an efficiency metric called "Progress" (Pr) to measure actual goal-oriented advancement over a finite path. What do you think of this concept?
Hi everyone,
While thinking about classical mechanics and how we measure efficiency, I realized that standard work (W) doesn't always capture whether a system is making meaningful advancement toward a concrete goal. You can exert force and do mechanical work, yet if the effort isn't measured against a defined boundary, it is hard to evaluate true efficiency.
To capture this, I formulated a conceptual metric/index I call Progress (Pr) to evaluate the effectiveness of work done over a specific, finite path and time.
Here is the formula:
Pr = W / ((f)L * t)
Where:
* W = Mechanical work done (in Joules, J)
* (f)L = Finite length of the path toward the goal (in meters, m)
* t = Time taken (in seconds, s)
Why the (f) notation matters (Finite vs. Infinite):
In this notation, (f) stands for finite, distinguishing it from (i), which stands for infinite. The core principle here is that Progress (Pr) only exists and makes sense along a finite, bounded path ((f)L) with a clear goal. This finite path can either be physically bounded by nature (a strict start-to-finish distance) or it can even be sectioned off on an otherwise infinite (i) line by boundaries that you artificially define and add yourself. Without these bounds, advancement would dilute into infinity and lose measurable meaning.
SI Unit of Progress (Pr):
Derived from the formula, the unit is Joules per meter-second (J / (m * s)), which simplifies to Newtons per second (N/s) or kg m s^-3.
A Thought Experiment: Concrete Work, Zero Progress
To prove that standard mechanical work (W) and Progress (Pr) are fundamentally different, imagine performing the exact same physical action in two different environments:
The Physical Action (Performed in both cases):
* You apply a force of F = 20 N
* You move the object over a distance of L = 5 m
* Time taken is t = 10 s
The resulting mechanical work done is W = F L = 100 J
Case 1: On a Finite Path ((f)L)
Here, those 5 meters represent a bounded, finite path from start to finish ((f)L = 5 m).
Pr = 100 J / (5 m * 10 s) = 2 N/s
Result: You get concrete force (20 N), concrete distance (5 m), concrete work (100 J), and measurable Progress (Pr = 2 N/s).
Case 2: On an Infinite Line ((i))
Now, you perform the exact same action—you still exert F = 20 N, you still cover 5 m in 10 s, and you still produce W = 100 J of real mechanical work. However, you are doing this on an unbounded infinite line (i) with no defined start/finish boundaries ((i)L approaches infinity).
Because Progress (Pr) is measured relative to the total bounded goal-path (which here is infinite), the equation becomes:
Pr = 100 J / (infinity * 10 s) = 0 N/s
Result: Even though you successfully generated force (20 N), moved a real distance (5 m), and completed real mechanical work (100 J), your Progress (Pr) equals 0.
This proves that without finite boundaries, real physical effort and work still happen, yet true goal-oriented Progress does not exist.
The Core Idea:
Standard power (P = W/t) tells us how fast energy is transferred, but it doesn't account for spatial boundaries. By dividing by the finite path length (f)L, Pr acts as a heuristic to measure how cleanly work translates into actual advancement over time within a defined space.
I know this isn't a fundamental law of nature—more like an engineering/optimization index or a game-physics metric. How does this compare to existing efficiency metrics in mechanics or robotics? Would love to hear your thoughts!