Abstract
Consider a flat or open FLRW universe in general relativity. Its content is a set of separately conserved components with non-negative densities. For such a universe we derive the exact identity
q′ = (3/2) ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ wᵢ′ − (9/2) Var_Ω(w).
Here a prime denotes d/d ln a, and Var_Ω is the variance of the equations of state weighted by the density fractions.
It follows that the deceleration parameter can grow with time (q′ > 0, "slowing acceleration") only in two cases. Either some component has an equation of state that increases with time (thawing-type), or one of the assumptions fails (no energy exchange, non-negative densities, GR).
For mixtures of constant-w fluids, phantom ones included, H² is a positive Laplace mixture in N = ln a. Then q′ = −½ Var(λ) with λ = 3(1 + w), and equally spaced samples of H² must form positive-semidefinite Hankel matrices of Stieltjes type. These conditions are invariant under rescaling of H², so they apply directly to D_H/r_d, independently of r_d and H₀.
DESI DR2 line-of-sight BAO data satisfy the three-point form of the test. Their present precision, however, cannot resolve the curvature expected even in ΛCDM.
In w₀w_a fits, q′₀ > 0 at the best fit for DESI+CMB+DESY5 and DESI+CMB+Union3, but not for DESI+CMB+Pantheon+. For DESY5 the violation is confined to z ≲ 0.10. A linearized propagation of the published uncertainties gives q′₀ = 0.33 ± 0.30, about 1.1σ. The strong preference for w₀w_a over ΛCDM therefore does not translate into strong evidence for slowing acceleration.
1. Introduction
DESI DR2 BAO combined with CMB and supernovae prefers dynamical dark energy over ΛCDM at 2.8–4.2σ, depending on the supernova sample. The favored solution lies in the quadrant w₀ > −1, w_a < 0.
A recurrent interpretation is that cosmic acceleration has peaked and is now declining. For example, Wu, Wang and Yu report j(0) < 0 at more than 1σ for several DESI combinations within w₀w_aCDM.
These analyses are parametric. Here we ask a structural question instead: which classes of cosmic content can produce slowing acceleration at all? The answer is an exact sum rule. It yields a no-go theorem and a test that can be applied directly to distance ratios.
2. An exact sum rule
Let N = ln a and write H² = ∑ᵢ ρᵢ(N) in units 8πG/3 = 1. Each component is separately conserved, with ρᵢ′ = −3(1 + wᵢ)ρᵢ and ρᵢ ≥ 0. An open curvature term (Ω_k ≥ 0) is included as a component with w = −1/3.
Define the density fractions Ωᵢ = ρᵢ/H². From q = −1 − ½ (ln H²)′ we obtain:
Proposition 1.
(ln H²)″ = −3 ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ wᵢ′ + 9 Var_Ω(w),
and therefore
q′ = (3/2) ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ wᵢ′ − (9/2) Var_Ω(w),
where Var_Ω(w) = ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ wᵢ² − (∑ᵢ Ωᵢ wᵢ)².
Proof. Write Z = ∑ᵢ ρᵢ. Then:
Z′/Z = ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ (ln ρᵢ)′
Z″/Z = ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ [(ln ρᵢ)″ + ((ln ρᵢ)′)²]
Hence (ln Z)″ = ∑ᵢ Ωᵢ (ln ρᵢ)″ + Var_Ω((ln ρᵢ)′). Substitute (ln ρᵢ)′ = −3(1 + wᵢ) and (ln ρᵢ)″ = −3wᵢ′. ∎
Corollary 1 (no-go). Suppose Ωᵢ ≥ 0 and wᵢ′ ≤ 0 for every component. Then q′ ≤ 0, with equality only if a single component dominates and has constant w.
This covers:
matter, radiation and Λ;
constant-w phantom fluids;
massive neutrinos, whose w falls from 1/3 to 0;
freezing quintessence (dw/dN ≤ 0).
So q′ > 0 requires one of the following:
a thawing-type component (wᵢ′ > 0);
a negative-density term, such as closed curvature;
non-gravitational energy exchange;
a departure from GR.
Corollary 2 (jerk). Using j = q(1 + 2q) − q′ [Visser 2004], Corollary 1 is equivalent to j ≥ q(1 + 2q).
Check (w₀w_a). For matter plus CPL dark energy,
q′ = (3/2) Ω_DE [w′ − 3w²(1 − Ω_DE)], with w′ = −w_a a.
At a = 1 this reduces to
q′₀ = −(3/2)(1 − Ω_m)[w_a + 3w₀² Ω_m].
Hence q′₀ > 0 ⟺ −w_a > 3w₀² Ω_m.
3. Constant-w mixtures: Laplace structure and Hankel tests
If every component has constant w, then
H²(N) = ∫ e^(−λN) dν(λ),
where ν ≥ 0 and λ = 3(1 + w) ∈ ℝ (λ < 0 for phantom components). With the tilted weights p_N(λ) ∝ e^(−λN) dν:
(ln H²)″ = Var_{p_N}(λ), and therefore q′ = −½ Var_{p_N}(λ) ≤ 0.
H² is then exponentially convex in the sense of Bernstein and Widder.
Now sample at equally spaced nodes N_k = N₀ + kΔ and write Z_k = H²(N_k). Then Z_k = ∫ x^k dμ(x), with x = e^(−λΔ) ∈ (0, ∞). So (Z_k) is a Stieltjes moment sequence, which implies, for every r:
H_r = [Z_{i+j}]{i,j=0}^r ⪰ 0 and H_r^(1) = [Z{i+j+1}]_{i,j=0}^r ⪰ 0.
The 2×2 minors reduce to discrete log-convexity, Z_k Z_{k+2} ≥ Z_{k+1}². For arbitrary nodes N₁ < N₂ < N₃, log-convexity reads
H²(N₂) ≤ H²(N₁)^θ H²(N₃)^(1−θ), with θ = (N₃ − N₂)/(N₃ − N₁).
This form also follows from Corollary 1 in its general setting.
All these conditions are invariant under Z → cZ with c > 0. Since H ∝ (D_H/r_d)⁻¹, they can be applied to D_H/r_d with no knowledge of r_d or H₀. Equivalently, ln(D_H/r_d) must be a concave function of ln(1 + z).
4. Test with DESI DR2 line-of-sight BAO
Take three bins with xⱼ = ln(1 + zⱼ) and yⱼ = ln(D_H/r_d)ⱼ. Define the statistic
T = y₂ − θy₁ − (1 − θ)y₃.
Positive mixtures require T ≥ 0. The uncertainty is
σ_T² = σ₂² + θ²σ₁² + (1 − θ)²σ₃², with σⱼ = σ(D_H)/D_H.
We use the published D_H/r_d values and errors for LRG1, LRG2, LRG3+ELG1, ELG2, QSO and Lyα (DESI DR2 Table IV, e.g. D_H/r_d = 21.863 ± 0.425 at z = 0.510 and 8.632 ± 0.101 at z = 2.330). We treat the bins as independent.
Triple (z) T σ_T T/σ_T ΛCDM expectation
0.51, 0.71, 0.93 −0.011 0.020 −0.5 +0.008
0.71, 0.93, 1.32 +0.031 0.016 +1.9 +0.010
0.93, 1.32, 1.48 +0.014 0.033 +0.4 +0.004
1.32, 1.48, 2.33 −0.008 0.042 −0.2 +0.005
The ΛCDM column is computed at Ω_m = 0.2975, from T ≈ −½ f″ Δx₁ Δx₂ with f″ = −(9/2) Ω_m(z)[1 − Ω_m(z)].
No triple violates the bound by more than 0.5σ. The expected signal, however, is itself below 1σ per triple. At z > 0.5, current BAO precision cannot resolve the curvature of ln D_H, so this test is passed but uninformative there. Adjacent triples share data points, so the rows are not independent.
5. The w₀w_a fits
Central values. The DESI+CMB+DESY5 values are Ω_m = 0.3191 ± 0.0056, w₀ = −0.752 ± 0.057 and w_a = −0.86 (+0.23/−0.20). They give q′₀ = 0.326.
Uncertainty. The same analysis reports a pivot redshift z_p = 0.31 with w_p = −0.954 ± 0.024. Because w_p is uncorrelated with w_a, it implies corr(w₀, w_a) ≈ −0.90. Propagating linearly in (w_p, w_a, Ω_m) gives:
q′₀ = 0.33 ± 0.30 (DESI+CMB+DESY5),
about 1.1σ, or P(q′₀ > 0) ≈ 0.86 under a Gaussian approximation. The other samples give:
DESI+CMB+Union3: q′₀ ≈ 0.66 ± 0.40
DESI+CMB+Pantheon+: q′₀ ≈ −0.04 ± 0.29
Both of these error bars assume the same correlation, so they are indicative only. The Pantheon+ best fit satisfies the bound.
Redshift window. For the DESY5 best fit, q′(z) changes sign at z ≈ 0.105. At the pivot redshift, q′(0.31) ≈ −0.52, so the bound holds where the data are most constraining.
Two interpretations follow:
By Corollary 1, the region q′ > 0 requires a thawing-type component, since w′ = −w_a a > 0.
The violation lives entirely where supernovae dominate the constraint. The DESY5 sample includes 194 SNe at z < 0.1 drawn from historical sources. Efstathiou reported a ~0.04 mag offset between low- and high-redshift SNe common to DES5Y and Pantheon+, and argued that correcting it brings DES5Y into agreement with Planck ΛCDM. The DES collaboration attributes most of that offset to modelling improvements and differing selection functions, and confirms its published results.
The sum rule thus sharpens the question. Slowing acceleration today is not implied by the w₀w_a preference itself. It is tied to the lowest-redshift bin and to the choice of supernova sample.
6. Discussion
The identity in Proposition 1 is elementary, but its consequences are not usually stated:
a no-go theorem for slowing acceleration that covers phantom fluids;
a test written directly on D_H/r_d, independent of r_d and H₀;
a Hankel/Stieltjes hierarchy for constant-w mixtures.
Three extensions are needed for a definitive statement:
evaluating q′(z) and the Hankel minors on the public MCMC chains, replacing the linearized estimates of §5;
low-redshift H(z) information (z < 0.3), which current BAO lacks;
treating closed curvature and interacting dark sectors explicitly, since both evade Corollary 1.
References
DESI Collaboration, M. Abdul Karim et al., DESI DR2 Results II, Phys. Rev. D (2025), arXiv:2503.14738.
DES Collaboration, T. M. C. Abbott et al., ApJL 973, L14 (2024), arXiv:2401.02929.
G. Efstathiou, Evolving dark energy or supernovae systematics?, arXiv:2408.07175.
M. Vincenzi et al., MNRAS (2025), doi:10.1093/mnras/staf943, arXiv:2501.06664.
P. Wu, J. Wang, H. Yu, EPJC 85 (2025), arXiv:2507.22575.
A. Shafieloo, V. Sahni, A. A. Starobinsky, Phys. Rev. D 80, 101301 (2009).
M. Chevallier, D. Polarski, IJMPD 10, 213 (2001); E. V. Linder, PRL 90, 091301 (2003).
R. R. Caldwell, E. V. Linder, PRL 95, 141301 (2005).
M. Visser, Class. Quantum Grav. 21, 2603 (2004).
D. V. Widder, The Laplace Transform, Princeton (1941).
J. A. Shohat, J. D. Tamarkin, The Problem of Moments, AMS (1943).