I’m a mid-career marketing professional with roughly 20 years of experience. I spent the first half of my career in market research and the second half informally building out the marketing and communications function of a small nonprofit, largely as a one-person effort within the development department.
I’m now trying to transition back into the for-profit sector and into a formal marketing role. That’s proving somewhat challenging because, despite my experience, my job titles and career path don’t necessarily reflect the marketing work I’ve actually done.
Part of my motivation for pursuing an MBA is to address gaps in my business and marketing knowledge, broaden my business education, and strengthen my credentials.
I applied to Boston University’s Online MBA and the University of Illinois Gies iMBA for Spring 2027.
How I ended up in this situation
I deliberately tried to coordinate my applications so I could compare both programs and any scholarship opportunities. BU admitted me in late August and required a decision by September 16, including a $1,500 nonrefundable deposit.
I had also applied to Gies during its first application round because that was necessary to be considered for scholarships. Unfortunately, after applying, I learned that scholarship decisions wouldn’t be announced until November. I couldn’t wait that long to make my BU decision. If I declined BU, I couldn’t count on being able to accept later, and I considered my chances of receiving a scholarship from Gies fairly remote.
After considerable thought, I accepted BU and paid the deposit. I was comfortable with that decision and had already started preparing for the program.
Then, unexpectedly, last week Gies awarded me its 70% iMBA & Coursera Scholarship.
Suddenly, I’m comparing approximately $25,000 in BU tuition with roughly $8,200 at Gies, based on current tuition.
I’m entirely self-funding my MBA. I don’t earn a particularly high salary, especially compared with what I imagine many of my prospective classmates earn, so cost is not an insignificant consideration. I had carefully worked out a plan to pay for BU largely as I went, taking advantage of the university’s payment plans and potentially borrowing a relatively small amount during the first year. Even assuming I remain in my current job and don’t transition to a higher-paying position, I expected to have most, if not all, of the degree paid for by graduation.
With the Gies scholarship, I could likely complete the degree without borrowing and at a substantially lower total cost.
Why I originally preferred BU
One of the biggest reasons was the program structure. BU has six integrated modules, and completing one module each semester puts you on a straightforward two-year graduation schedule. I’m at a point in my career where I want to earn the degree and move forward. I was concerned that although Gies says it can be completed in two years, students might more commonly take longer.
Cost was another factor. BU guarantees $25,000 in tuition for five years, while Gies currently costs approximately $27,300 and, as far as I know, doesn’t offer a similar tuition guarantee. When I first learned about the Gies program a few years ago, it cost around $24,000. Given those increases, I thought there was a reasonable possibility that Gies could end up costing considerably more than BU by the time I graduated. I appreciated that BU was both less expensive and offered certainty about the total cost.
I also liked BU’s integrated curriculum and its cohort/POD structure, which seemed designed to encourage ongoing relationships with a smaller group of classmates. I appreciated that BU also has a traditional residential MBA program, even though I understand that the online program is separate and doesn’t offer access to all the same resources. I live in the Northeast, where BU is a familiar name, and Boston is close enough for me to visit. I also have friends there.
Why Gies appealed to me
Previously, the biggest advantage of Gies was the opportunity to earn a Digital Marketing specialization. Although I’ve worked in marketing for years, much of that work has been done independently, without other marketers around me. I feel there are areas where my marketing knowledge could be stronger.
The specialization appeals to me as an opportunity to address some of those gaps while earning an additional credential that could complement my experience. BU’s integrated curriculum includes a module with a substantial marketing component, but I’m not sure how that compares with Gies’s three-course specialization in terms of depth and practical knowledge. BU also doesn’t offer a formal specialization that I could list alongside my MBA.
My current concerns
Now that I’m looking more closely at Gies’s course offerings, I have a few concerns.
First, I’m trying to understand how realistic a two-year schedule would be. I work full-time and would strongly prefer not to extend the degree beyond two years if possible, but I also don’t want to overload myself to the point that completing the program becomes miserable.
Second, I have a humanities and social sciences background rather than a quantitative one. I understand that finance, accounting, economics, and statistics are part of an MBA, but some of those subjects will require more work from me. I had actually been planning to enroll in MBA Math within the next week to prepare for BU.
At BU, I knew that Module 2 had a reputation for being particularly quantitative and challenging. Looking at Gies’s required courses, I’m wondering how many of them are similarly demanding and whether I could arrange my schedule to avoid taking two especially difficult quantitative courses simultaneously.
Third, I’ve now looked more closely at the live-session schedules. BU’s evening classes, generally 8–10 p.m., work well for me. Although only some sessions require attendance, I was planning to attend most of them because I liked the idea of having a regular class at a predictable time each week to help me stay current with the material.
Gies offers more live-session options, but there’s also greater variability in when those sessions are scheduled. For some courses, the available times would be difficult or impossible for me to attend, meaning I might have to rely entirely on recordings and review the material independently. I’m concerned that losing the structure of a regularly scheduled class could make it harder to stay on pace.
Finally, the scholarship acceptance agreement includes some conditions I hadn’t anticipated. Recipients must maintain a 3.0 GPA, remain continuously enrolled or document a leave of absence, and serve as Gies Online Ambassadors. The academic requirements seem reasonable, and I’m not necessarily opposed to being an ambassador. I just hadn’t realized it was part of the scholarship and don’t know how much time or involvement it requires.
What I’m hoping to learn
I’d particularly appreciate hearing from people who considered both BU and Gies, or who chose one over the other.
For Gies students and alumni, how manageable was completing the program in two years? Were there particular courses you found significantly harder than others? Did you find it helpful to pair quantitative courses with less demanding subjects?
Did you find that the flexibility of the Gies program made it easier to complete, or did having to manage your own schedule make it harder to maintain momentum?
For those who completed the Gies Digital Marketing specialization, or who have taken BU’s integrated marketing coursework, what did you think of the depth and practical value of the material?
I’m also curious about the student populations in both programs. I’ve seen some comments suggesting that Gies attracts a particularly large number of students from engineering, finance, and other quantitative fields. Did you find that to be true, or were your classmates drawn from a broader range of industries and professional backgrounds? I’d be interested in hearing about the mix of students at BU as well.
And if anyone received the Gies Coursera Scholarship, I’d be interested in hearing about your experience with the scholarship conditions, especially the ambassador requirement.
I was genuinely happy with my BU decision before the scholarship arrived. Now I find myself having to revisit a decision I’d already made after considerable thought.
Part of what I’m struggling with is whether choosing BU despite the scholarship would be financially irresponsible. I still see genuine advantages to BU, but it’s difficult to ignore a difference of nearly $17,000 when I’m paying for the degree myself.
I’d really appreciate any firsthand perspectives.