r/MawInstallation • • 54m ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] Given Imperial TIE starfighters do not have hyperdrives, how do Imperial capital ships that deployed TIEs pursue Rebel ships that jumped into hyperspace?

• Upvotes

Won't there be a delay while all of the TIEs return to their capital ship before the capital ship can make the jump to hyperspace in pursuit? For example, say a star destroyer deploys its TIEs to deal with a starfighter escort of an important ship and the important ship is able to jump to hyperspace. Will the star destroyer abandon all of its TIEs in deep space? Will someone else come to recover the TIEs? Is the star destroyer at risk from the escort starfighters who jumped to hyperspace with the important ship since the star destroyer doesn't have its own starfighters anymore?


r/MawInstallation • • 1d ago

[META] [Canon & Legends] Thrawn is Evil, and any attempts to show anything else than that veers dangerouslly close to condoning fascism and authoritarianism.

173 Upvotes

Now, I will preface this by saying that I think he is nuanced. He has layers to his character that will make you understand and say, "Okay, I see where he comes from." I think this part is important to Thrawn as a narrative character.

But with the new Ahsoka show, I've seen an uptick in posts and work across the fandom that Thrawn is this sort of misunderstood hero, nuanced antihero, or "ends justify the means" person. He is not Luthen (despite what some Andor fans think).

Thrawn works only as a fascist. He is a true believer in the cause, the same way Cyril Karn is, except he has legit power.

Sure, does he have nuance? Sure. He's trying to defeat the grysks, but he's willing to do this by actual genocide.

For instance, his mining project on Lothal? It would've eventually collapsed the biosphere and killed off most of the planet. If he had succeeded, it would've been a genocide of Lothal.

As part of the empire, he signs off on double-digit genocides and actively uses the products of those genocides to help him. Like, we see numerous times in canon Thrawn starving out planets and stripping people of the already limited resources they have. (Thrawn books)

And despite what people say, he's also nakedly power-hungry, just as the Emperor is. As he says, "the only thing that matters is power," and explains to Ezra that "actually, helping people is bad and using it to dominate people is good" (Paraphrasing what he says to Ezra in the Star Wars Rebels Finale).

Then there's the whole thing in Ahsoka, where he knows that the Grysks are a threat, and there are things waiting to hurt the larger galaxy, and the first thing he does is restart the galactic civil war. This is literally like the Hungarian Lords rising up against their king despite knowing that the Mongols are marching. Or like the Crusader states fighting each other for territory while Islamic powers are squeezing them.

And sometimes, I feel like Zahn himself has forgotten this.

In Rebels, there's a moment where Thrawn carbet bombs a city to lure out rebels. On the actual show, we see people die from this. But according to Zahn, this isn't true, because Thrawn only targeted abandoned buildings and killed no civilians. (I wish I were making this up.) There are almost moments where Zahn Straight-Up justifies the Empire as a sort of "the ends justify the means"

As the new Ahsoka season comes in a few months, there are a lot of fans who want to see Thrawn be right, that the suffering he inflicts is actually good. This idea is so contrary to the charecter that he is. (and imo removes his best traits)


r/MawInstallation • • 18h ago

[CANON] Human ARMY officers in the Galactic Republic-Empirs

21 Upvotes

We know the Republic Navy transitioned smoothly Into the Imperial Navy as most of their officer corps was human, rather than clone personnel. We see this with Tarkin, Ozzel, Rampart, Thrawn, and I’m sure more I’m forgetting.

But how did the Imperial Army get an experienced and professional cadre of officers? Of the top of my head the only non-clone army officer I could think of is Colonel Meebur Gascon. But he’s certainly not a human, and I’m not even sure he’s actually an Army officer.

Apparently there were planetary defense forces which actually took up the brunt of the galactic civil war, while the Clone Army was just the Regular/Federal Army. At the end of the conflict, did the new Imperial Army just consolidate all these defense forces into the new service? Or did the Empire really just stand up the Army in 19BBY from scratch and commission/mobilize a bunch of new officers.

This leads me to the crux of my question, what was General Veers doing during the Clone Wars before joining the Empire? Was he a field grade officer in some planet defense force (either republic or separatist), was he in the Grand Army of the Republic in some capacity, or did he just join the Army as a Lieutenant in 19BBY.

Thanks


r/MawInstallation • • 1d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] In the Empire for matters that do not threaten the Empire's hold on power, does the general public enjoy civil rights such as due process and fair courts?

18 Upvotes

My thoughts are that if an authoritarian government wants to prevent rebellion, they should try to keep the population happy and an actively oppressed population is not happy. Also having a fair government makes people more willing to engage in economic activity and increase the amounts of taxes the Empire can collect. For common matters such as a business dispute or being accused of theft, do the people in court have a reasonable expectation of a fair process? Or is the Empire so corrupt that everything is determined by bribes like in a low income country on Earth?


r/MawInstallation • • 11h ago

[CANON] 'The shroud of the dark side has fallen'

0 Upvotes

How can the dark side's shroud fall? The dark side is not a person. It can't be shrouded. It is therefore a metaphor.

But in this same film we have Shmi. A person. She dies and she gets wrapped in a shroud. Not a metaphor.

But are we supposed to connect these two shrouds, one literal, the other metaphorical? Maybe.

'The shroud of the dark side' is the political. Empire. Palpatine. Shmi's shroud is the personal. Anakin.

The personal became the political in the following film, and Anakin's behavior towards Padme had everything to do with Shmi. 'I won't loose you the way I lost my mother'. And Palpatine connects Shmi with revenge right at the beginning of ROTS. (This is why the Imperial March is Vader's theme, and not the emperor's as it supposedly should be, and the reason why Vader's destiny and that of the empire were connected)

And there's maybe more. Shmi is a mother. She gave birth to Anakin. Since it is possible to apply 'shroud' to 'dark side' in a metaphorical way, it would also be possible to apply 'mother' to 'dark side' in the same way. And there are hints of Lucas thinking like this in the films.

If Anakin was literally born from Shmi, and we speak of the birth of Vader in ROTS, who was Vader's 'mother', but the dark side? Here's where the word 'natural', which we repeatedly hear in ROTS, becomes relevant. Mother Nature, in the evil sense of it: 'jungle', 'kill or be killed', etc, which is the yellow-eyed, or feral-eyed Palpatine.

The idea is latent in ROTJ. Vader saying to Luke 'the emperor will show you the true nature of the force'. And this when Luke had just asked Leia about her real mother. Maybe this is the idea behind the original -1980- emperor: the voice of a man, but played by a woman old enough to be Vader's mother and by a chimp -the jungle.

Maybe this is where Lucas' decision to make Anakin fatherless came from. If he chose to become Vader, to be born as Vader, then there was no father. Just himself and this evil 'mother'. So you can make Anakin fatherless by 'divine' choice. And maybe this is also where the Chosen One idea comes from.

Shmi's fate in reverse: It's creepy to think of the dark side as an unburied woman from whom the shroud has just fallen. Not awake, not walking her imperial march. Not yet.


r/MawInstallation • • 1d ago

[META] What did everyone think happened to Vader in a pre-prequel world?

26 Upvotes

The makeup in ESB and ROTJ does indicated he was likely badly burned, but outside of that we don’t get too much. What was commonly believed to have happened to him before we saw it on screen?


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] Dissolving the Imperial Senate was the correct move and it's weird that it took the Empire 19 years to do it

117 Upvotes

The Imperial Senate was filled to the brim with full-blown Rebels who were only there in order to destroy the Empire from the inside, like Bail Organa and Mon Mothma. Frankly, it's weird that the Empire allowed it to exist for so long instead of just dissolving it as soon as possible.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] Jedi, Emotion and Stoicism

29 Upvotes

My source is mostly Legends and Lucas original 6 movies, but it applies to Star Wars overall.

Before I start my argument, I am aknowledging that most fans who delve deeper into the philosophical core of Star Wars dont have this misconception. This post is simply a response to the part of the Fandom that does have this view. And its still a big percentage sadly.

One of my biggest issues with modern interpretations of the Jedi—and a deeply persistent misunderstanding within the fandom—is the belief that the Jedi Order is all about emotional repression rather than emotional control. It certainly isn't helped by the current Disney material, which heavily leans into this flawed premise (and which I firmly reject; when I talk about canon, I mean Legends). But if you look at George Lucas's actual intent, it is abundantly clear: the Jedi do not repress their emotions, not even during the prequel era.

To really understand where fans get this wrong, you have to look at the difference between Victorian Stoicism and Greek Stoicism.

Many people mistakenly view the Jedi through the lens of Victorian Stoicism. This is the classic "stiff upper lip" mentality—the idea that you must suppress your feelings, hide your internal struggles, and never show any kind of weakness (especially as a man). But the Jedi are actually modeled much closer to classical Greek Stoicism. Greek Stoicism is about emotional control, logic, and philosophy. It’s about acknowledging your feelings but maintaining the discipline to make mindful decisions in the present moment, rather than letting past traumas or immediate, fiery emotions guide your hand. It is mastery over emotion, not the absence of it.

If you want the best examples of this, look at Matthew Stover's Revenge of the Sith novelization or his standalone novel Shatterpoint. Mace Windu is constantly held up by fans as the poster boy for cold, dogmatic Jedi repression. But Stover’s work makes it clear that Windu is simply a remarkably stoic man, not a repressed one. He cares deeply and profoundly for the Republic, and he even shows genuine care and concern for Anakin Skywalker during the events of RotS. He feels the weight of the galaxy; he just refuses to let those feelings compromise his clarity.

Now, I understand there have been iterations of the Jedi Order that have gone astray and actually did suppress emotion. The best example of this in the lore is the period following the Exar Kun era. Exar Kun essentially struck the fear of God into the Jedi Order. Because he was able to turn so many Jedi to the dark side through sheer manipulation—pretending to be a loyal Jedi right up until it was too late and his followers had already fallen—the Order was left deeply traumatized. The strict, emotionally suppressive dogmas that emerged afterward were a panicked overcorrection driven by the fear of another Exar Kun, not the true ideal of the Jedi path.

The Jedi were never meant to be emotionless robots burying their feelings until they snap. They are meant to be individuals who feel deeply but have the discipline to act on wisdom rather than impulse.

They have deep friendships, joys and compassion. Anakin put it best in AOTC when he explained it to Padme, that Jedi are encouraged to love. (Just his Motive for the explanation was naughty)


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] If the Hoth ion cannon was doing most of the work of escorting the escaping transports, why didn't most of the starfighters go with the initial few transports?

21 Upvotes

It was acknowledged that two starfighters per transport are not going to be an effective escort against multiple star destroyers so why not try to save as many starfighters by sending them with the first few transports when the ion cannon is likely to still be operational.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[META] Does anyone feel that certain Wookieepedia editors abuse their power to push their interpetations?

94 Upvotes

I recently saw an exchange in the talk page regarding Luke Skywalker and one of the biggest editors on the site basically and somewhat politely told someone to fuck off and that his interpretation was both objective and factual. I won't say which issue since it's rather... socially charged, but if you know, you know. The editor also said that their interpretation was basically above Lucasfilm and Disney's lack of confirmation.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

What if the Invisible Hand crashes and kills all aboard?

23 Upvotes

The Sith have been planning on revenge for 1,000 years. Darth Sidious has concealed his identity, manipulated Jedi into a self-destructive war, and arranged for the murder of his apprentice. As Chancellor Palpatine, he was on the verge of seizing power and killing the Jedi with Order 66. But he didn't figure on overestimating Anakin's piloting skills. As he's going down, he wonders if he can use the force to save himself. No, the Invisible Hand is too massive, even for me.

Once death is imminent, he wonders if he should he reveal himself to Obi Wan so that he knows he died for nothing? "No, I don't want to see the smug look when he says "This explains a lot." Did I remember to hide my light sabers and misdeeds where no one can find them? I probably didn't need to orchestrate the kidnapping at all. Will anyone ever discover the Sith again? Finally all of the calculated risks I have taken have caught up with me. I suppose this is bringing balance to the force. We all misinterpreted the prophecy."

The mass public knows nothing and mourns the death of the beloved Chancellor and two Jedi heroes. The war goes on, but not too much longer with General Grievous as the new leader. Grievous is a skilled military commander but there no one to politically unite the factions. No one is there to issue Order 66. The Senate holds an election for a new chancellor. Padme is devastated but raises Luke and Leia on her own. The Jedi most likely recruit them.

However, power is centralized and people have shown they are willing to sacrifice their freedom for emergencies, real and fabricated. Our own world history shows you don't need Sith lords to undo democracy and liberty! There is still a real possibility that the republic crumbles. Could this be another movie? Yes, but nothing like the Star Wars we know and love.

The Jedi may still find themselves at odds with the Senate but there are thousands left and they will not easily perish. If they find out that Palpatine was Darth Sidious, serious reforms might be undertaken. Whatever else happens, Yoda, Mace Windu, and other leaders rebuild it after being decimated after the Clone Wars.

The only one who immediately knows who Sidious was - in the legends - is Darth Maul. It would be infuriating to him that the public mourns him as a hero. He hates Sidious, but he also hates the Jedi, so I don't know if he reveals anything. I don't see him as the leader of a new Sith order; he probably continues running a criminal empire.


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

Why didn’t the X-Wings not provide air superiority for Gold Squadron making the trench run.

33 Upvotes

I know the lore of the scene is this, Gold Leader was the mission leader, with Red Leader as second in command. Gold Leader and 2 designated wingmen were to perform the trench run while Red Squadron provided air superiority. Both Red and Gold leader say this before the assault after roll call. So I’m left assuming Red Squadron was busy dealing with the tie fighters while the Y-Wings were in the trench but nothing in the movie points to or implies this. Obviously it was given the limitations of special effects at the time, but it always bothered me that ANH made it look like Red Squadron was doing nothing by the time Gold Squadron was getting picked off by Vader and his wingmen. Given the context of the movie I’m lead to believe Red Squadron was just flying around doing nothing while Dutch, Gold 2, and Gold 5 were making the trench run. Even the special additions of ANH didnt depict anything different.

Side note. While I’m rambling on about Y-Wings. I know the Y-Wing is bomber but it also always bothered me that media tends to depict them as very slow and clunky when they are only 50km/h slower than the X-Wing in atmosphere. Their maneuverability rating isn’t THAT much lower either. My head canon always clocked them as fighter bombers like the real world P47 Thunderbolt or F4U Corsair compared to the P51 or British Spitfire being the X-Wing equivalent. Planes that had that designated role, but could hold their own in a dogfight or in an air support role if pressed into one. Plus faster fighter bombers fit more into the rebels hit and run tactics better than something slower like a space equivalent of a B52 or Lancaster.


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

Is it me, or do Force users seem to have more trouble with passive abilities than telekinesis?

12 Upvotes

It's something I've observed that seems kind of backwards to me. In various media it seems like Force users have an easier time learning and using telekinesis, whereas more passive abilities - like visions/sensing the future, telepathy, remote viewing, precognition, ad more, seem to take more effort or for some reason have a steeper learning curve. I would have guessed that the opposite would be true. The most striking example would be all the stuff that Galen Marek is able to do, yet he seems to have more trouble using the Force to find the Death Star.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[META] Should the rebellion have trialed some of its soldiers after the GCW?

0 Upvotes

I read up on a WW2 event called the Biscari Masscre. Evidently, 2 dozen US troops killed 73 POWs and of the 2 dozen troops, only 2 faced indictment.

That kinda makes me curious if the Rebellion itself should’ve held its soldiers accountable for any war crimes that may have been perpetuated. If they should’ve arrested any Rebel soldiers who were suspected of killing surrendering imperial officers or their families.

Or just let them go, because they’re fighting for the good side.


r/MawInstallation • • 2d ago

[LEGENDS] I think it’s interesting that Raven was a woman by default in kotor 2.

0 Upvotes

We you meet Atton he refers to Raven as a woman with the player given the option to correct them. That might actually make Raven being male a retcon. Not that it matters.


r/MawInstallation • • 4d ago

[CANON] TIL Obi-Wan was knighted when he was 25 while Anakin was admitted onto the Jedi counsel at 22

396 Upvotes

Really drives home the theory that Anakin had BPD. Even though he was one of the most accomplished Jedi in his order, any time someone said "no" to him, he saw it as a personal attack.


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[CANON] Does Vader (not Anakin) have any moments where he questions the merits of Empire? (Before Endor)

62 Upvotes

I was just thinking about how it’s kind of absurd he destroyed a Republic for his wife and then turned around a few decades later and destroyed the empire for his son. Like, trillions of beings must suffer from my family drama.

Over simplification, sure. BUT, Anakin at least already had developing fascist tendencies prior to becoming Vader. Do we ever see cracks in Vader’s belief in the Empire in books/comics/etc? Or did he really throw that all away specifically just for Luke? I feel like it would make more sense if we had evidence of some prior regrets. Hoping some of you deep lore completists have some factoids.


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

Kyber Crystals, What are They???

15 Upvotes

Like they are thrown around as a magical object thing in canon and are used to make lightsabers and the Death Star but what do they actually do? I've read some things and they seem very confusing about how they are resonated with the force or whatever.

For example, are they energy sources, or batteries, or just a focusing lens thing (for the latter, it seems like it's a big waste isn't it). They also have something to do with the force, but how? Do they help its owner fight better with the lightsaber, do they use the force to generate energy, or what?


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] If Palpatine from Star Wars tried to somehow control both the COG and Locust from Gears of War like be did with the Republic and the CIS, would it be more disastrous for him even if he somehow convinced Prescott and Myrrah?

0 Upvotes

If Palpatine from Star Wars tried to somehow control both the COG and Locust from Gears of War like be did with the Republic and the CIS, would it be more disastrous for him even if he somehow convinced Prescott and Myrrah?

Prompt: Emperor Palpatine is dropped into the Gears of War universe with the goal of pulling off his Clone Wars 'both sides' master plan, with Chairman Prescott and Queen Myrrah somehow agreeing to play along at first. How fast does this blow up in his face?

How far would Sidious get in the Gears Of War Universe?


r/MawInstallation • • 4d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] How experienced was Mace Windu?

2 Upvotes

Dooku was Yoda's Padawan (he also had a personal passion for practicing swordsmanship).

Yoda had 800 years of experience training successive generations of Jedi.

Obi Wan spent thousands of hours training the Chosen One.

And what about Windu? On whom could he practice his swordsmanship?

Were his skills, like Sidious's, the result of talent rather than actual practice?


r/MawInstallation • • 3d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] How do Jedi defend against droids?

0 Upvotes

Jedi use the force.

The force comes from living beings.

Droids are not living beings and cannot use the force.

So how do Jedi use the force to defend against droids? My understanding when they’re using the force against other living beings is that the other being’s connection to the force allows the Jedi to anticipate what they will do. But if it’s all just circuits and gears, how does the force help them anticipate what droids will do?


r/MawInstallation • • 5d ago

[ALLCONTINUITY] How often did Yoda directly take a Padawan?

14 Upvotes

We know he’s trained, in some part or another, every Temple Jedi when they’re Younglings. We also know of a few, namely Dooku, Oppo Rancisis, Ki Adi Mundi, and Cin Drallig. Oppo, Ki Adi and Dooku had to have taken place within, what, a hundred years of each other? Does he take a student every time he ages a century?


r/MawInstallation • • 4d ago

Peut on limiter un utilisateur de la force seulement avec les étiquettes JEDI ou SITH

0 Upvotes

Depuis que je regarde Star Wars, j'ai toujours distinguer les gentils (Jedi) et les méchant (Sith), mais après réflexion et après avoir vu la série Ahsoka avec le personnage de Baylan Skool je me suis rendu compte qu'on pouvait en réalité pas classé un utilisateur de la force dans ces deux catégories car Baylan Skool ne se revendique ni comme un Jedi (où il a abandonné ce poste depuis l'Ordre 66) mais sans non plus adhérer au côté obscur alors pour l'instant mon hypothèse est qu'il se situerait comme un "Grey Jedi", ou tout simplement que peut-être il représente une autre "étiquette"/Idéologie de la force, alors si vous en savez éclairez-moi car je suis un petit peu perdu sur ce sujet.


r/MawInstallation • • 5d ago

Quels sont les différents parti politique qu'il y a au Sénat Galactique ?

4 Upvotes

Je trouve que le Sénat Galactique a une place importante dans toute la galaxie (pendant l'ère de la République/New Republic), parce que le sénat représente le pouvoir central de la galaxie avec pour chaque planète un sénateur la représentant,

Et je me demande quelles sont les différentes orientation politique des sénateurs car je ne pense pas que tout les sénateurs soient tous de la même idéologie ou tendance politique, c'est comme cela dans tous les régimes, je ne voit pas les gens riche du noyau voter pour les même personnes/parti que les paysant de la bordure extérieure, et donc je suppose que logiquement qu'il devrait y avoir au moins deux parti politique dominant (gauche/droite ou Républicain/Democrate mais version Star Wars),

Alors je vous demande ceci, car moi même je m'étais fortement intéressé au Sénat et a la politique Galactique qui n'était pas assez précisé dans le canon, donc je suis assez confus sur ce sujet intéressant.


r/MawInstallation • • 5d ago

[CANON] The Rebel Y-wing (BTL-A4) isn’t a separate ship from the Clone Wars Y-wing (BTL-B), The Rebel Y-wing (BTL-A4) is a stripped down, repurposed, and modified/refitted version of the Clone Wars Y-wing (BTL-B), so both of them are the same ship/model, just different versions of the same ship/model.

0 Upvotes

According to the BTL Y-wing model graphic in Star Wars Rebel Star-fighter Owner Workshop Manual page 13, you can see how both BTL-B and BTL-A4 are the same exact ship/model due to how the graph shows how the remaining BTL-B’s became the BTL-A4/S3’s.