r/MechanicalEngineering • • 13h ago

Process engineer resigned, and now I have to prepare PFMEA and Control Plan for a new prototype with no prior experience. Need advice.

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m currently working as a Product Engineer in the automotive manufacturing industry.
Recently, our Process Engineer resigned. He was mainly responsible for preparing documents such as PFMEA, Control Plan, Process Flow and other process-related documentation.
I have around 3 years of experience in manufacturing and a decent understanding of our production processes, but I’ve never prepared a PFMEA or Control Plan from scratch before.
Now, I’ve suddenly been assigned to prepare these documents for a new prototype involving around 10 manufacturing processes.
I do have the PFMEA and Control Plan from an older prototype for reference, and most of the machines and processes are similar. However, I’m not sure where to start, what information I need to collect, or how to properly prepare these documents according to automotive industry requirements.
I’m willing to learn, but I’m feeling a bit overwhelmed because I don’t have anyone experienced to guide me through the process.
For those working in manufacturing, quality or process engineering:
How difficult is it to prepare a PFMEA and Control Plan for the first time?
Can I use the existing prototype documents as a reference and modify them for the new product?
What is the best way to learn PFMEA and Control Plan quickly, especially the AIAG-VDA approach?
Is it realistic for someone with no prior experience to prepare these documents for around 10 processes within 2 weeks?
Are there any courses, YouTube channels or practical examples you would recommend?
I’d really appreciate advice from engineers who have been in a similar situation.
Thanks in advance!


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 4h ago

Will I ever find a job?

5 Upvotes

I have applied to hundreds of places. All rejections. My GPA is 3.3, I have a few decent projects, and I'm on a design team as of this year. I'm a junior. I went to career fairs and no responses, even though I connected through LinkedIn and stuff. Any advice or am I just cooked. I also tried contacting professors in my department for research opportunities. No responses.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 19h ago

I need help with a modeling

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I don't know where to asked a help with this kind of stuff and this is my first time posting anything in reddit.

For context: Im currently a High School student from Indonesia, we had a pretty tight budget or none at all and i need a help with a project that im working at.

For the project i want to create a Machine that can reduce organic waste and making it into a composter, something like Reencle Electric waste composter.

Now I already got some of the stuff figure out, like how it work and what it needed to make this.

- Bucket/Drum, heating pad, an motor, control, sensor.

Currently my teacher asked me to make a 3d/2d animation for how it worked and i don't know how to do that stuff. And the presentation is on friday.

So i asked here if anyone can help me with it? And what it can improve. Oh and here some rough sketch and a AI rendetion of it.

The animation something like this. https://youtu.be/_85hMSlIf6s?si=-DAzGjNPpaWIvzgR


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 14h ago

Where do the washers go in relation to spacers 23 ("pulley bushing") - worth reading just for the names

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

It is a heavy load bearing pulley for a squat rack.

The instructions must be wrong. It suggests one side of the pulley wheel housing ( "double wheel skateboard" ) should asymmetrical to the other.

It suggests it goes

[ bolt #24 > spacers? "pulley bushing" #23 > washer ("gasket") #27 > Pulley wheel #22 > pulley bushing #23 > washer #27 > nut #28 ]

This seems stupid.

In the photos you can see I've put a washer between the bolt/nut and the "pulley bushing" on both sides. Good idea?

What do I actually want?

There isn't any friction reduction on the inside of the cartridge pulley wheel housing , between the pulley wheel and the spacers. I can't tell if it's using bearings or not. If it's using bearings the spacers should be flush with the wheel right, but if not then maybe I should add a washer on the inside between the wheel and the spacers?

Is this a correct analysis?


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 20h ago

Manufacturing/quality engineer needing to plan my next move.

3 Upvotes

I'm at a crossroads. I've been with my company for 4 years and need to make a jump to higher pay. I've got a couple of ideas, and I hope someone who has done this can chime in with their experience and give me ideas I've never thought of yet.

I'm in a small company of 20 people doing quality, manufacturing, design, and maintenance work. When I was hired the company was a toxic mess of tribal knowledge, and poor processes. I've created a useful QMS system, drove down non-conformances to nearly nothing, created inspection programs, trained technicians, designed products (including regulated pressure vessels), and maintained ISO 9001 and ABSA (pressure vessel regulator) certification. My responsibilities have increased but my pay has not. I think I'm doing senior level stuff with a junior title (hopefully somebody can check this). Maybe I can ask for a raise to match my responsibilities.

I've thought of getting my Peng. But I don't know if it's valuable in a manufacturing company. I also thought of getting my certified quality engineer cert. I have six Sigma Green belt and lead ISO auditor certifications. Is there anything else I should consider?

I've got 8 years experience in manufacturing.

Any thoughts on how to bridge my jack of all trades master of none experience to something relevant at another company. Especially a bigger company with more resources and software (i do time and motion studies with a clipboard and old cell phone when better software exists.)

Salary is 86k and total comp including bonus and RRSP matching brings me to 100k. I've applied to a few jobs and had a few interviews but haven't found anyplace that matches my compensation.

Any thoughts on potential paths or 5 year plans?


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 13h ago

My 3D-printed Outer Wilds orrery keeps jamming. How can I diagnose the gear train?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m building a 3D-printed mechanical orrery based on the solar system from Outer Wilds. I started with Mechanical Planetarium – Tuned by HackerJack42 and used AI to help adapt the gear ratios to match the orbital periods in the game.
After assembling the orrery and adding a motor, I ran into a problem: the gear train binds and eventually jams. I haven’t figured out where the binding starts.
One thing I’ve noticed is that several gears can slide along their short D-shaped shafts or twist slightly relative to them. Some of the shafts also seem to have sideways play in their supports. I tried paper shims and then electrical tape to tighten the fit. That helped temporarily, but the gears shifted again and the mechanism jammed.
How would you troubleshoot a gear train like this, stage by stage? I’d like to figure out whether the binding starts when the gears shift or tilt, or whether some parts interfere even when the shafts are seated properly. If you spot something in the assembly, I’d especially appreciate knowing which parts to inspect and what to measure. I’d like to keep as many of the parts I’ve already printed as possible.
The project archive includes the full Blender assembly, OpenSCAD files, and STLs. In Blender, the 05_WITHOUT_PLANETS scene gives a clear view of the whole gear train.
The parts were printed in black PETG. I had them printed by a 3D printing service, so I don’t know the exact print settings.
I’ve put a lot of work into this build and would really appreciate a second pair of eyes. Thanks!


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 21h ago

Tesla Internship Interview Prep Tips

0 Upvotes

Hi guys, I have an upcoming interview with Tesla and have been prepping for it through technical questions and reviewing my own resume to be able to explain everything.

Wondering if you guys had any tips on how to stand out during the interview process, would greatly appreciate it!


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 3h ago

Cost and feasability analysis of using AI for CAD work for industrial CNC parts.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

I recently analyzed the feasability of using AI tools to drive Inventor 2027. The conclusion is that it could succesfully perform actual production cad work and did it at a price point and speed that beat humans. However it's not perfect for all situations and did best with a verifiable result rather than open ended "design me a hinge".

It can also do a lot of PDM and librarian work and organized hundreds of files as well as translate from one cad package to another or between different versions.

My conclusion is that AI is going to become bigger and bigger in CAD workflows and that mechanical engineering is having the same conversation software engineers had one or two years ago "This is interesting but it couldn't do my job".

I'm not paid by anyone or promoting anything. This was our own internal analysis.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 6h ago

What’s it like to work at P&G?

1 Upvotes

Hey there, I recently got hired as a manufacturing manager (process engineer) at a P&G plant. Does anyone know what the work environment is like? What the responsibilities are, what a typical work day looks like? What are some general tasks that I will be performing?

I start in 2 months, and from the interviews and the people I met there, I’ve been told it’s a very hands on, problem solving, management and efficient focused job. That being said, I just want to know how that all translates into the actual kinds of work I will be doing.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 7h ago

Application Engineer is a good stepping stones?

1 Upvotes

Hi guys,

i just want to tell that i got offered for associate application engineer for ABB company. TBH? i actually from background Computer Science and through out my journey after fresh grad. i was only know about IT. which is we handle server, network, security, peripherals and business IT department.

previously i was working for (Network Operation Center) NOC engineer for telecom. TBH, for 1 year i working there.. its not what i like, nothing can be learn as alrdy tried to approach, project-based that just support from side HAHA

Then after i got lay off from them, i apply thousands of application and somehow i apply for application engineer too without knowing what is it. As it related with my background from their JD. Since its a fresh grad roles, so i prepare night before interview with their JD and i just learned about PLC, HMI, SCADA, protocol and more. Its seems it give interviewer interested with me even tho i had no knowledge about engineer or industry but eager to learn.

So after i get offered. For non stop i been search for online about AE and there alot of meaning AE in a lot of industry. The one that i originally know was in IT where its a bit similar with software engineer but turns out no. HAHA.

So my question is, WHAT YOU THINK SHOULD I BE PREPARE BEFORE START WORK NEXT MONTH??!!!!! even intefviewer told me that there will be document and training to know more. BUT ATLEAST I NEED TO KNOW SMOTHING BEFORE START THIS NEW CAREER PATH!! and yeah what this path career ladders could move to in 3-5 years and 10 years of experience???

notes that i take:-
- they will use autocad
- they use protocol MODBUS and OPC
- they will use on FAT and CAT/SAT
- i just learned about commisioning?
- they know i got less knowledge
- they want someone fast learner


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 2h ago

Northrop Grumman vs Clarios

1 Upvotes

I have two offers for internships this summer, one being at Clarios for battery simulation and modeling, and the other being at northrop grumman's space systems for electromechanical. Clarios I believe would give me much more experience in hard engineering and really interesting thermal modeling, is closer to me, and will allow me to work over the school year easier, but northrop is northrop, right? I do want to go into defense for my career. I really want some advice.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 5h ago

How would you manufacture a part with these features?

0 Upvotes

I'm curious how others in the engineering and manufacturing community would approach this design.

The part is a nylon housing, approximately 100 × 52 × 38 mm, with a few challenging features:

  • A 7 mm S-shaped internal channel
  • A side port that connects to the internal channel
  • A captive ring around a post that cannot be removed
  • A thin lattice flange
  • An integrated snap hook

The initial requirement is around 50 units, with the possibility of reaching 500 per year if the design works out.

I'm interested in hearing different perspectives:

  • Would you use MJF, SLS, injection molding, CNC, or another process?
  • What orientation would you recommend?
  • How would you approach the internal channel?
  • What post-processing would you consider?
  • Are there any design changes you'd make before production?

I'd be interested in hearing from machinists, mechanical engineers, molders, and additive manufacturing professionals.

I can share the STL for anyone interested in taking a closer look at the geometry.

What would be your preferred approach, and why?


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 18h ago

Qui est réellement responsable de la coordination des inspections et de l'intégrité dans les projets EPC industriels ?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/MechanicalEngineering • • 2h ago

Graduate Jobs

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am a second year of mechanical engineering right now, and I am seriously struggling with the coursework and assignments and literally everything. I just want to ask is the job gonna be this hard or much more breathable because if I gotta work a job as hard as what I am going through right now for the next 30 years of my life then Im cooked. My hairline is declining right now. I want to know to see whether I should drop out or nah.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 8h ago

Refferal

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/MechanicalEngineering • • 16h ago

Mechanical engineers – what’s the earning potential like working self-employed or as a contractor in the UK?

4 Upvotes

I’m looking for some advice from people working in mechanical engineering, particularly those who are self-employed or work as contractors.
A bit about my situation: I’m in my mid-20s and currently earning around £44k a year working full-time on the books. My employer is putting me through a Level 3 Mechatronics Engineering apprenticeship, which I’m currently working towards.
Before this job, I was self-employed as a welder. I was charging £25 an hour and regularly working 10-hour days, so I was earning a decent amount when the work was there.
I’ve since moved into permanent employment, but one thing I’m finding frustrating is that there’s no overtime available. I’m quite happy working long hours, weekends and taking on extra work, particularly while I’m young and want to maximise my earnings.
It’s got me thinking about potentially going back into self-employment once I’ve completed my apprenticeship, but this time using my engineering qualification and existing welding/fabrication experience.
I’d be interested to hear from people who have taken this route:
What sort of hourly or day rates can you realistically charge as a self-employed mechanical engineer or mechatronics engineer in the UK?
Is there much demand for self-employed mechanical engineers, maintenance engineers or engineering contractors?
What sort of work do you typically end up doing?
Is contracting generally more lucrative than permanent employment once you factor in tax, holidays, pension, insurance and periods without work?
How easy is it to find regular work, rather than constantly chasing individual jobs?
Do companies tend to take on self-employed engineers for breakdowns, installations, maintenance and shutdown work?
Would a Level 3 Mechatronics qualification open many doors for contracting, or would I need further qualifications and experience?
Are there particular industries where contractors can earn considerably more?
If you’ve gone from permanent employment to self-employment, would you do it again?

I’d rather put the work in and earn more than be limited to a fixed salary with no opportunity for overtime.
Any advice or personal experiences would be appreciated.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 5h ago

Google Hardware/ Data Center Eng. internship interview

3 Upvotes

So I have been in the process of trying to get into Google this school year I am currently a sophomore ME and have an internal advocate, I just received an email that I am getting two 45 minute interviews one technical and one about experience related to the Data Center engineering role.

Has anyone gone through the process of interviewing for internships on the hardware side with Google? I know it’s much less common than something like cs.

I am wondering what the interviews will be like and what to prepare for. Thanks!


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 7h ago

Shaper3d as the standard?

0 Upvotes

Would you consider Shapr3D to be true industry-standard CAD software? I've found Fusion unstable due to frequent crashes, and SolidWorks has a steep learning curve. Shapr3D is much more intuitive, aside from the monthly subscription model. Could you recommend an industry-standard alternative with a similar ease of use? My goal is to commit to a single platform and build deep proficiency in it


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 6h ago

Help please! I'm in my second year of IT engineering and the first project they assigned is about communication They don’t want a simple or repeated project. I have my own idea, but it costs $250. So any recommendations?(I have only one month😞)

0 Upvotes

r/MechanicalEngineering • • 5h ago

How many people here have covered quantum mechanics to a reasonable amount for their bacholers?

0 Upvotes

I started a module for intro to quantum mechanics at my university, and I'm thinking what other engineers thought of it.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 18h ago

Is mechanical branch a gone case in engineering!!??😭😭

0 Upvotes

just the same as the title, but also is there any possibility that the mech has good, and better job opportunities overseas, if yes which of 'em??, if no, why??


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 3h ago

2-axis gimbal. Solo engineered. Master's thesis.

25 Upvotes

r/MechanicalEngineering • • 23h ago

Phone screen for an AWS data center mechanical engineer role, coming from oil and gas equipment with no HVAC background. What should I expect?

7 Upvotes

I've got a phone screen coming up for a mechanical engineer role on an AWS data center cooling team. It's with the engineering manager, who has a deep HVAC and thermal background.

My background is about 5 years designing high-pressure downhole tools in oil and gas: mostly structural design, testing and root cause work. No HVAC or data center experience.

If you've interviewed for or worked on these teams:
What was the phone screen like?

How do they view people coming from other industries?

How would you prepare to cover the HVAC and thermal gap in about a week?
Appreciate any experiences, good or bad.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 2h ago

What are some good certifications I can go and try to get as a 1st year mech e student?

2 Upvotes

I'm looking for certs I can do to add to my portfolio while im getting my degree but I'm not sure which hold weight and which are just filler and skipped over by recruiters.


r/MechanicalEngineering • • 8h ago

How to pivot to a new sector?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I have working in MEP design for about 7 years now and I want to pivot to new sector that will be less stressful.

Anyone willing to share their experience successfully moving between sectors? Any tips for how to make my resume more transferable between sectors?

Im not sure where I want to end up yet, I just know I want to leave the HVAC and construction industry altogether.