While I do have a high HD in this unit, everyone i have spoken to have had complaints about the unit. Feedback was always very vague, as well as copy-pasted with only changes in wording across many students. Feedback was clearly AI generated, and only given out weeks after deadlines. From the A2 onwards, they stopped providing feedback rubrics apparently because of time constraints.
At the start of the semester, they informed us that they would be experimenting with new assessment structures, but that no one would be excessively penalised due to the new assessment structure. Additionally, the assessments themselves did not cover any actual physiology content, with weekly content only being covered during the corresponding weekly IFATs then never again, which was great for WAM but terrible for learning the content long term.
A1: prior to this assessment, we were told that 'there wouldnt be any right or wrong answers' and that they would be assessing reasoning rather than the answer itself, however that turned out to be a blatant lie, as any student that didn't choose to escalate exactly when they decided was the right time to do so was penalised, often with consequential marks lost as a result. Completely goes against the 'no right or wrong answers' claim
A2: Feedback was incredibly vague, and no rubric was provided because of 'time constraints'. After cross referencing across numerous other students, we found that the written feedback was blatantly copy and pasted, only with very minor changes in wording. the feedback itself consisted of things like 'you did well on x y and z, but x could have been described in more detail', or 'certain dot points could have been grouped better'
A3: Feedback for this assessment was the worst out of them all, we found that across like 8 different students (with different wording for each of us), every single one of us got told that our timestamps lacked accuracy, which was just both blatantly incorrect and lazily reworded. I highly doubt that they would have gone through the effort of rewording feedback hundreds of times for every student manually, and just how unclear and/or incorrect the feedback was made me think it was just entirely AI generated. I don't completely disagree with the use of AI for marking numerous assessments, but the feedback quality was just so shit it was completely unacceptable. Students with grade differences of 20%+ were given near-identical feedback. Again no rubric was provided either. This assessment was also by far the largest out of them all in terms of workload, and the most unclear in terms of feedback
The lecturers themselves are lovely and very enthusiastic about their work, and clearly trying their best. The assessment designs and lectures were creative and it was clear that they put in a ton of effort into the cinematography of their videos, but what is the point of putting in all of this effort if the quality of marking and feedback is gonna be garbage?
i understand that they were testing new assessment structures, but they did claim that students wouldnt be penalised because of that (which they obviously didnt fulfil) and the marking itself was just extremely shitty. 80% of the unit's marks were in these highly subjective and poorly marked assessments.
TLDR: phy2032 has extremely vague, obviously AI-generated, inaccurate and lazily copy-pasted feedback