r/Monash • u/kakyoin_3rd • 14h ago
Support Accidental ai use
Hi guys i had an in person, open access exam today, where basically the only rule was no ai. When doing google searched i consistently used "-ai", however, one of the times i used "-ai" the ai explanation came up although i immediately clicked off it. This exact thing happened twice, immediately clicked off both times i didnt even get a chance to see, will i be fine given my screen was being shared?
r/Monash • u/ADecentUsername1 • 13h ago
Misc What do they actually do with the exam papers
Like the ones you clip and put in the box at the end. Do they ever check them?
r/Monash • u/KitchenEmu650 • 15h ago
Discussion PHY2032 feedback is exceptionally frustrating.
While I do have a high HD in this unit, everyone i have spoken to have had complaints about the unit. Feedback was always very vague, as well as copy-pasted with only changes in wording across many students. Feedback was clearly AI generated, and only given out weeks after deadlines. From the A2 onwards, they stopped providing feedback rubrics apparently because of time constraints.
At the start of the semester, they informed us that they would be experimenting with new assessment structures, but that no one would be excessively penalised due to the new assessment structure. Additionally, the assessments themselves did not cover any actual physiology content, with weekly content only being covered during the corresponding weekly IFATs then never again, which was great for WAM but terrible for learning the content long term.
A1: prior to this assessment, we were told that 'there wouldnt be any right or wrong answers' and that they would be assessing reasoning rather than the answer itself, however that turned out to be a blatant lie, as any student that didn't choose to escalate exactly when they decided was the right time to do so was penalised, often with consequential marks lost as a result. Completely goes against the 'no right or wrong answers' claim
A2: Feedback was incredibly vague, and no rubric was provided because of 'time constraints'. After cross referencing across numerous other students, we found that the written feedback was blatantly copy and pasted, only with very minor changes in wording. the feedback itself consisted of things like 'you did well on x y and z, but x could have been described in more detail', or 'certain dot points could have been grouped better'
A3: Feedback for this assessment was the worst out of them all, we found that across like 8 different students (with different wording for each of us), every single one of us got told that our timestamps lacked accuracy, which was just both blatantly incorrect and lazily reworded. I highly doubt that they would have gone through the effort of rewording feedback hundreds of times for every student manually, and just how unclear and/or incorrect the feedback was made me think it was just entirely AI generated. I don't completely disagree with the use of AI for marking numerous assessments, but the feedback quality was just so shit it was completely unacceptable. Students with grade differences of 20%+ were given near-identical feedback. Again no rubric was provided either. This assessment was also by far the largest out of them all in terms of workload, and the most unclear in terms of feedback
The lecturers themselves are lovely and very enthusiastic about their work, and clearly trying their best. The assessment designs and lectures were creative and it was clear that they put in a ton of effort into the cinematography of their videos, but what is the point of putting in all of this effort if the quality of marking and feedback is gonna be garbage?
i understand that they were testing new assessment structures, but they did claim that students wouldnt be penalised because of that (which they obviously didnt fulfil) and the marking itself was just extremely shitty. 80% of the unit's marks were in these highly subjective and poorly marked assessments.
TLDR: phy2032 has extremely vague, obviously AI-generated, inaccurate and lazily copy-pasted feedback
r/Monash • u/ThatBookkeeper9684 • 17h ago
Advice Failing 3 units out of 4, one of which being a core unit because of undiagnosed ADHD. What now?
Edit: Failed 2/4 units which is still bad but less bad
Second year, second semester student in Bachelor of Arts (Please don't give me shit for messing up an "easy degree")
I have struggled so much with uni because of the lack of structure. I recently became unemployed halfway through the sem. Yes I had more time, but my executive dysfunction has impeded me from prioritising tasks and completing assignments on time. Uni has become way more difficult for me to handle because of these factors.
First year was fine. I had a job and was able to balance stuff. Semester 1 of second year was good too. I finished that sem with a wam of 68 or 69. This semester has been terrible. I have not been handing in assignments. My sense of urgency is so messed up. I have too much time and never know what to do with it. I did well in primary and high school because of the structure. University has fucked up everything for me.
I'm not diagnosed with these either but I'm certain I have anxiety and depression. I have always struggled with low self esteem, comparison culture and social situations. I am in a household that does not value mental health and I am not in a financial situation to be diagnosed. I guess I have to save up or else I will fail the next few semesters too.
Does anyone know the process of what it's like to fail? Would I be level 2 of academic progress review? What does that process look like? Would my hecs place be gone? Serious answers only please.
r/Monash • u/Subject_Gas433 • 16h ago
Discussion ECC2010 Final
Should I be crashing out about the final exam of ECC2010? I could expect it's not 100% like the mock exam, but that was so far off what I thought. Emphasis of marks on content from sem 1 was crazy. I was learning the content all over again when I was in the room, and I was so lucky to answer some of those Sem 1 questions to gain back some marks. But the incumbent and entrant questions were hopeless for me.
I know I should have studied much more of Sem 1 cuz CE did say that the final covered both Sems. But the content being far-off has been an issue since MidSem Test. I'm taking more ECC units next year, and hopefully this doesn't happen again for the sake of my grades.
r/Monash • u/Holiday-Pay43 • 23h ago
Advice Easier Law electives
Hey, I’m going into my third year of law/biomed and that means I need to choose 2 law electives (one must be summer/winter or overload).
What do you guys recommend. I know some units are easier to complete after completing others even though there aren’t any prerequisites aside from core units.
Thanks
r/Monash • u/Local_Ad8381 • 23h ago
Advice Where are all the books in Monash 😟
I want to read the exorcist cuz it’s scary and want to see how jump scares work but is the library even open now ? And where are all the books ?
r/Monash • u/thebigsleep241 • 3h ago
Discussion Is NUT1011 still the WAM boost king ?
If you search WAM booster in this sub you almost always get NUT1011 (lowkey thought it was a joke at first) is it still the best option ? What were marks like ? Also at a first glance the subjective mark assignments like the poster and reflection throw me off a bit idk is there anything else better ? I high key need to WAM max
r/Monash • u/James_1317 • 17h ago
Advice Report of Uploading Finals Exam to AI
Some person on the team came to me and asked me to delete any pics I took it was an open book exam but I didn't upload to AI. And then she asked to see my gallery but there was nothing help. Am i cooked im a first year.
r/Monash • u/Turbulent_Lemon7676 • 18h ago
Grades and Academics monash uni australia
does anyone know the minimum ib score one would need to get into monash australia for a PPE degree as an international student?
r/Monash • u/Foreign_Piccolo_9789 • 19h ago
Discussion FIT3158 exam
how did everybody find the exam 😭
r/Monash • u/levi2314_ • 5h ago
Support monash malaysia 28th nov 3pm grad ticket
hi everyone i have a monash malaysia 3pm grad ticket if anyone’s interested!
r/Monash • u/Veeibes • 16h ago
Advice Clayton or caufield for an elective unit
Im tryna pick a location for my elective unit ATS 1835 intro to philosophy
I mainly have classes at clayton but i kindof want to atleast have one class in caufield just for fun and lowk wanna meet ppl there
So i iust wanted to ask the ppl of reddit if thats a good idea, wdyt? Lmk!
r/Monash • u/urL0cal_habibi • 16h ago
Advice Tips to excel in ENG1005
First year taking ENG1005 and I feel that I’’ not good enough for this. Where do you find practice questions, how did you improve in Math if you were bad at it b4? Any tips appreciated 🙏
r/Monash • u/albion2huntingdale • 23h ago
Discussion What do you get in the free snacks bag
Anything good in those bags MSA hands out during exam season?
r/Monash • u/Objective_Thing1524 • 33m ago
Grades and Academics Early Start on Study (BTC1110, CIV2206, CIV2282, ETC1000)
Was wondering if anyone had materials from the following subjects so i could start study early.
(BTC1110, CIV2206, CIV2282, ETC1000)
This can be absolutely anything lecture slides, questions, notes etc. I'm especially worried about BTC1110 as I heard it can take up a lot of time in the semester so anything is appreciated.
r/Monash • u/Eastern-While-9108 • 55m ago
New Student Monash on campus accom
Heya! I’m looking to live in the residential village or urban community next year. I’m coming in at postgrad and was just wondering whether there’s other postgrads living in RV or whether it’s mostly people coming straight from school? Would love to know more about the vibes of the flats and peoples experiences :)
r/Monash • u/fartdawgs • 2h ago
Advice (counsellor) support and diagnosis for mental health disorder?
hi all! sorry if this is a silly question but i need some help.
TLDR: i might have depression but i don't know where to go for it. asking how the entire diagnosis, therapy, and medication process works + how much it would cost and what my OSHC would cover.
i'm a year 2, semester 2, international student. i've been struggling with depression for a couple of years now, but its gotten worse over the last 2 years. i'm not diagnosed and i've never gotten medical aid for this, nor do i have experience with a counsellor/therapist.
it was manageable back then but i've since lost that support and have been spiralling ever since, especially since moving to a new country and struggling with the new elements that come with it. having major doubts about my degree and major also certainly don't help.
i suspect i have high-functioning depression since i can still somewhat keep up with assignments and follow a morning schedule (but even that's starting to lose its drive). being high-functioning makes me worry if counsellors or GPs will just think i'm being too dramatic or overexaggerating my issues.
i guess what i'm trying to ask is:
- what are the most helpful mental health services available? i have OSHC under Allianz but i'm not sure how much it covers, e.g. counselling, therapy, medication. i heard looking for GPs with bulk-billing is better but i'm unsure on how that works and if there are things i need to do beforehand to get diagnosed, book a counsellor/therapist, and get medication.
- just to note: i'm probably unable to afford regular sessions and don't have a car but live near the caulfield campus.
- are the monash counsellors any good, and could they help with getting external aid? i've seen mixed reviews on monash's counsellors so i'm unsure if they're worth going to or not. i'm on the caulfield campus.
- SIDE NOTE off topic but i've had crazy tibialis pain for 6 months. can a GP help me with that or do i have to go to a physiologist?
sorry this is a long post my thoughts are kind of all over the place. any help or input with this would be massively appreciated. thank you!
r/Monash • u/thebigsleep241 • 3h ago
Advice Help me choose please (Stats)
Has anyone done either ETX3500 (high dimensional data analysis) or ETF 3600 ( Quantitative analysis of limited dependent variables) pls help me pick i have no clue 😭🙏 (no coding on the final would help)
r/Monash • u/Rich-Collection2837 • 13h ago
Advice should I pick both phy2032 and 2042?
hi everyone, should I pick both lvl 2 physiology sem 2 units next year? what’s the workload like if you do both? I was contemplating whether the science internship should be picked instead (I only have one science elective space left) thanks
r/Monash • u/VariationInternal817 • 14h ago
Support 2nd year electives for Biomedical Science student
Hey guys, I js finished 1st year biomed and I am currently searching for electives for next year. i am also doing gig but have heard that its better to leave electives free for third year rather than 2nd year. So does anyone have any electives that are easy to do, preferably no exams.
r/Monash • u/GreedyStomach7107 • 17h ago
Advice Masters in Electrical/Electronics and a job after that in UNSW?
Just replace UNSW with Monash for this sub...
r/Monash • u/Conscious-Tomato-661 • 21h ago
Advice Level 2 WAM boosters for a BSc student?
Hey everyone, I’m going into Year 2 of my BSc next year and looking for an easy/manageable elective to help boost my WAM. Any recommendations?
r/Monash • u/Simple-Day-5429 • 21h ago
Advice Has anyone already done a Diploma of IT at Monash College, or is doing it now?
I have a lot of questions and am seeking advice because I'm in my first trimester at uni.
Thanks in advance.