r/networking • u/andrewboring • 1h ago
Design Small, Non-Profit Network Recommendations
Hi all
I was laid-off a few months ago, and a professional colleague has given me an opportunity to build a proposal to install a network for a non-profit development project.
It's a 33,000 sq ft facility to provide temporary and transitional housing for homeless, especially those who need follow-up medical care (eg, you're homeless, you go to the ER and get stitches or a surgery and shouldn't be out on the streets while trying to heal and get follow-up care). There are approx 30 users/devices (across staff and residents) on the network, plus some visitors using guest WiFi.
My biggest challenge is that I haven't done this kind of work in a while. My career focus moved from Corp IT to IaaS, before transitioning into Product Management, so I'm not up-to-date with current hardware. Similarly, I don't have the current vendor/reseller relationships to lean on for hardware specs and use case support for producing an initial proposal.
Ultimately, I need some guidance to use as a starting point for research as I build out the initial design and BOM for their RFP; then I can get vendors/VARs/etc involved with the actual site validation, design review, and pricing exercises.
Budget allowance is around $50k USD for all the hardware, software, cabling, any subcontractors, and for me to manage and/or do the work.
The RFP covers three major domain areas:
- core network infrastructure - cabling, router/security appliance, WiFI, VoIP phones, and any supporting services (eg, URL content filtering, WiFi authentication and captive portals)
- client access devices - "thin client" PCs, tablets and other mobile devices, endpoint security, printers
- physical security - IP cameras, doorway access controls, IP cameras and video monitoring/retention, and panic/call buttons, but no burglar alarm/third-party emergency monitoring.
They're renovating an existing building, so a lot of infrastructure already exists, though I'll be expected to not assume reuse until testing and validation. They already have a network closet with two-post rack and existing CAT-5e, for example.
They have two ISPs (gigabit fiber, I think) intended to be configured for active/failover configuration.
There are around 25 wireless devices for staff and residents (mixture of thin client PCs, tablets, and laptops), accessing Internet for general browsing and telehealth appointments (residents) and business applications (o365 + SaaS apps for the staff). The RFP specifies 6 wireless access points, though I'll be validating this before a final design is presented. Also, the RFP specifies "thin clients running cloud-based applications", so I'm guessing some sort of mini PC or similar device running o365 and SaaS app, in addition to limited web browsing and one Telehealth machine.).
There are about 50 wired devices, like security cameras, wall-mounted panic/call buttons, and physical access controls (keycard entry systems), plus four thin client PCs for staff. They have existing wiring for some of this (they're converting an old retirement home), though I'll have to verify the wiring.
The existing network cabling is CAT-5e (needs testing and validation), and would work for their wired devices, though I would consider pulling new CAT-6/6e for wifi access points if recommended. I know a commercial electrician that does a lot of low-voltage side work for me, so I have access to cabling resources to help if anything new needs to be pulled (eg, CAT-6 for AP, two-wire panic buttons, etc).
Since I didn't have to design corporate WiFi access back in my day, I've been reviewing Cisco's WiFi content to get some starting points (eg, docs like this one) to get a better understanding around AP sizing based on the use case and assess density areas. Unfortunately, this content is a few years old now. Any pointers to useful (and free) sizing guides or tools are welcome.
The RFP included some high-level building design layouts with markups to show locations of doorway access, required field-of-view for cameras, and the placement of fixed-location PCs in a common area (no individual PCs are expected in resident rooms). There's a higher density of WiFi devices in a central area that I need to account for, while the edges of the building would likely only have a few devices at any given time (eg, a staff nurse with a tablet visiting a resident's room). If there's already cabling in the locations for the common areas, I'd likely recommend using those existing ports to reduce WiFi burden, as the current intent is to only use six data drops for staff PCs and printers.
--
Ultimately, this project isn't out of reach for me, but I just don't have current hardware experience and knowledge to make a confident recommendation, and will need to involve some local subcontractors and vendors to help with validating the proposal. I'd like to have an idea of what gear to consider before getting new vendors/subcontractors involved. Feel free to disregard anything out of scope for this sub, eg, endpoint security software recommendations probably belong in another sub.
VoIP phones and details come from their service provider. No PBX to manage that I'm aware of. Easy enough. Only need 7 ports for this.
My preference is for the network gear to have a central management system/control plane, so that probably means a single vendor for WiFI access points and PoE switches, and possibly the router appliance.
My general searching (in this sub, and elsewhere) seems to indicate the Cisco Meraki line would work for the network and cameras, and I've worked with Catalyst switches in the distant past. But, this is a non-profit and they're already over budget with construction. I'd rather avoid higher-priced gear and recurring per-device software license fees, wherever possible. But, if the general recommendation is to go this route for reliable small business and network/security management, I'll price it out for them.
My biggest consideration is around wireless access points, as I haven't deployed this in a corp environment. What's the general preference for low-cost gear that supports business use cases, eg, AP roaming, WPA2/3 Enterprise Auth, etc.
For a router/security appliance, I don't have hands-on experience with Cisco PIX (or ASA, or FTD, or whatever it's called now). Any alternative recommendations for router/security appliances? I'm leaning toward Netgate, as I know pfSense pretty well and it would meet a lot of their needs (eg, multiple ISP gateways, URL content filtering and proxy services, VLAN segmentation). What's the general recommendation for something a small business would use to connect to an ISP?
How is Ubiquiti in an environment like this? General consensus seems to indicate it's not really that usable for serious business networking use cases, though that mostly seems to be the opinion of enterprise guys working in datacenters. Ubiquiti is attractive to me because they sell a lot of the physical security devices, too (doorway access systems, IP cameras, push-to-exit buttons, etc, and gives me a nice, unified (and local) management interface. Having a unified management plane for both of these domain areas would be quite helpful to me or whomever has to maintain this, but not at the expense of actual usability, like client networking throughput or WiFi service availability.
If Ubiquiti isn't a viable option, I'll work with a local security vendor separately for the doorway entry, cameras, and panic buttons, though I'm open to system recommendations.
I'm not convinced that Netgear small business stuff would work well enough for switches and access points, but might be the direction if I have to get really creative with meeting their budget.
What else is worth looking into? A lot of the hardware I would consider for an IaaS datacenter environment would be well over-spec and over-budget for something like this. I just need some general recommendations to use as a starting point, and I can work it out from there.
(It's probably out-of-scope for this sub, but any recommendations on physical access security systems and/or endpoint management software are welcome, too.)