r/OpenChristian • u/ave_gratia_plena • 5h ago
r/OpenChristian • u/babe1981 • 8d ago
An update to the rules, and a question for you about crossposts
Hello, Open Christians and friends! It’s time for a new rules update. We’ve noticed that nearly all of the posts recently have been crossposts. While we don’t have a problem with the occasional crosspost, these days it seems like the sub is becoming a link aggregator for the rest of Christian Reddit.
So, we’ve decided to put a pause on crossposting for two weeks to see if that helps spur some more high-effort posts and better discussions. This includes crossposting from your own profile. Alongside this moratorium, we are asking you to weigh in. If you would like to end crossposting permanently, please vote in the poll. If you want to see crossposting continue, please vote as well.
Now, the elephant in the sub is that many of these crossposts come from one sub that is unaffirming and extremely conservative. While we want to help as many people as possible, the mod team has agreed that continuing to allow r/TrueChristian to be linked with our sub sends the wrong message about our intentions and our values. Going forward, all crossposts with r/TrueChristian will be removed, no matter what the rules are for general crossposts. We cannot, in good conscience, continue to allow their content on our sub for the same reason that we remove posts that link to Ben Shapiro and other conservatives who preach hate and fear.
The mod team hopes that this change will help bring back better discussions and more participation from OPs. Thank you for your time, and God bless.
r/OpenChristian • u/LuklaAdvocate • May 16 '26
Discussion - General New AI Policy
Hello all,
We wanted to make a quick announcement regarding the use of AI-generated content in our community. Many of our users have reached out voicing concern over the increase in “AI slop” posts, so hopefully this clarifies how things will work moving forward.
We have updated Rule 7 (Spam and Proselytizing) to include AI content. Specifically, AI-generated images and videos. These are officially no longer allowed. Any post which consists entirely of an AI image or AI video will be removed, so please report them as you see them.
Please note that we are not implementing a blanket ban on AI. Some people use AI to organize their thoughts, proofread their posts/comments, and help explain their viewpoint. Our goal is to judge the content of a post, not prohibit any form of AI used to help create it.
Obviously, there is going to be some moderator discretion involved here. If you feel like a post is spreading AI slop, feel free to report. If a post is generating good discussion but looks like some AI was involved in creating it, please keep in mind that this does not break the rules.
If anyone has any questions, feel free to comment and the mods will answer as we are available. God bless!
r/OpenChristian • u/Available-Ninja3400 • 2h ago
Support Thread Christian men who would date a trans woman and not be a creep about it or best of both worlds, do you exist?
Hi, i am a christian and im pretty traditional other than being trans. im really lonely and trying to find a boyfriend. what sort of spaces do guys like that frequent? how do i attract them? do they exist?
r/OpenChristian • u/grungefolker • 1h ago
Is anyone else here bloody sick of hearing how Russell brand is soooo innocent, and the simps like Megan Kelly who defend his grimy behind??
Personally this is the final nail in the coffin for evangelicalism for me, I hate that CULT and NO I will NOT TAKE THAT BACK EVER!! Honestly Christianity itself seems like a crock right now too and I’m
Becoming agnostic more and more
r/OpenChristian • u/oranange • 2h ago
Discussion - General Can I be a Christian if I don’t necessarily care if God is “real” or not?
For some context—I was raised Catholic, stepped away from religion, and now, seemingly out of the blue, I feel like I am being called back to God.
However, I feel as if my views on Christianity are different than most, and I’m not sure if they prevent me from becoming a “real Christian.”
The thing is, I don’t care much about whether God or Jesus is “real”, in the sense that, when I read the Bible (which I have slowly been starting to do), I feel like even if they don’t “exist” in the literal sense, choosing to believe in them is what makes them real. I still feel their presence regardless of whether the things that are written in the bible are “real” or not, and that, to me, is faith. The written word can be interpreted in so many different ways. Which makes one interpretation more true than another?
Like, I believe in science. I believe in evolution. I don’t believe the world was created in seven days, but I believe that when I read that story, literal or not, I still hold the core belief that God, in whatever way, created the world. And isn’t that enough?
Does that make sense at all? I don’t know. My relationship with religion is so complicated, and I’m not sure how to explore it or if it is even worth trying to find a church to attend if my views are, like, heretical. The most accurate depiction of how I am beginning to understand religion is closest to how John Green talks about his faith in his video “My Religion.”
Thoughts? Where do I go from here?
r/OpenChristian • u/JohnHammond94 • 13h ago
‘I know I sound crazy’: the creep of demons into American evangelical churches
theguardian.comr/OpenChristian • u/appearlo13 • 3h ago
Medical Prayer Request Pt 2
I posted a prayer request about a week ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenChristian/s/ozDQEifT8d
Just got back from getting a sonogram and they found an ovarian cyst and a uterine polyp. They did a biopsy and bloodwork and I’m waiting on results.
I had a cyst in ‘11 and a polyp in ‘14 that were benign. Please pray all current growths are benign as well. Thank you.
r/OpenChristian • u/Modest_Slinky • 15h ago
Vent Anyone else annoyed by the argument that heaven is worse than hell?
A lot of this comes from Athiests who are scared of eternity, which I can understand. But it feels like their understanding of the afterlife is very shallow: “when you die you can do anything forever.” The natural response to this is, “what do you do when you’ve done everything?”
I consider myself a universalist and personally believe that the purpose of the afterlife is not to retain your human wants and grudges. But when you argue that, or something similar, you get met with “so you’re just gonna get turned into a lobotomized version of yourself?”
Granted, I understand that this is kind of the version of heaven that is sold to people by evangelical Christians. I also know that a lot of media depicts this view of the afterlife which may serve as their primary reference for how it operates. I also want to clarify that it’s not all Athiests, mainly just the toxic ones. And of course, the internet is gonna be the internet. But I don’t know, I’m just kinda tired of seeing the same old argument
r/OpenChristian • u/TheAvio • 9m ago
Discussion - Church & Spiritual Practices Going through OCIA and having to defend an impermissible prompt, is this normal?
I’m a college student looking at trying to enter the faith through the OCIA process, and as part of that class, I was instructed to write a short essay about 5 questions. Most of them are asking to answer basic questions about theology and clergy, and those I had no issue with, but then this prompt came up:
Question #4: Explain in no less than 100 words each the following:
- Why sex before and outside the confines of marriage is immoral.
- Why divorce is immoral.
- Why Marriage can only be between one man and one woman.
- Why contraception is immoral.
- Why trying to change your gender using science is wrong.
- Each response to the following five questions must be persuasive to a non-Christian
- audience. This means that all arguments from authority must be avoided. In this section,
- you need to be able to demonstrate the goodness of God’s moral law. For example, whenresponding to the question on divorce, you should not say: “Divorce is bad because God
- said it is bad.” Instead, you should say something like “divorce is bad because it has
- numerous negative consequences such as _______________________________.”
Bigotry aside these are just culture war points being asked here, and having to defend these disgusting viewpoints secularly is a fundamentally defunct idea. Especially as an ace Christian, I do not want to defend these points as they are blatantly harmful to countless individuals. To anyone who’s been in my shoes before, is this normal, and if so, how do I handle this?
Edit to rant: I’ve known quite a few people who went through the process at this parish, which means they had to answer these too. None of them know I’m queer, and I have reason to suspect that they wouldn’t be all that welcoming to anyone not cishet. I don’t think I’ll be able to stay at this parish for long, as it’s incredibly likely that I’ll be scorned the moment someone finds out.
r/OpenChristian • u/autisticgarnet • 15m ago
Support Thread I don't feel a connection to Christianity. Is something wrong with me?
I was raised Christian, but I never felt a connection to God or Jesus. I'm also autistic and a lesbian, so I often feel excluded in Christian circles. I read the Bible, but it doesn't make any sense to me. I pray for a relationship with God, but I haven't felt it yet. Am I just not meant to be a Christian?
r/OpenChristian • u/RBEOX360 • 16h ago
Alternative ways to approach faith for neuro-divergent people
I live with ADHD. The dopamine rush of discovering the faith has long worn off and I'm bored. I'll straight up say it - I'm bored. Bored of the scripture, bored of the hymns, bored of the worship, bored of the debates. This has led me to look at other spiritual paths, despite my more logical, rational, and moral sides being loyal to Jesus Christ. I believe, I'm just bored.
If I jump ship to, say, paganism, I'll get bored of that too. Then who knows what's next. I want out of this cycle.
Can anyone relate?
r/OpenChristian • u/GeollandFraser • 17h ago
Discussion - Sex & Relationships How did you find your partners?
Blessings,
I have never dated before, and I am very new to the faith -- I am a Jew and very proud to be so, but have fallen in love with Anglicanism and am quite devoted to both traditions. I have no idea how to date, or even begin to date, especially because I'm quite progressive but very theologically conservative (in the sense that I believe very strongly in little-o orthodoxy, biblical inerrancy/infallibility, the creeds, the value of tradition, etc). To be clear, this doesn't mean that I'm anti-LGBT, just very serious about my theology.
For those of you who are partnered, and especially those of you with my theological inclinations, how did you find your partners? I'm not really sure how to even make friends in church (I've always been socially awkward) so finding a partner is even more daunting. Obviously I'm praying about it and entrusting it to the Lord, but I would also like some advice from others.
Thank you so much in advance!
r/OpenChristian • u/godisinthischilli • 16h ago
What would you call my theology? Progressive Christian, religious pluralist, or something else?
I’ve been thinking a lot about my beliefs lately, especially after some interesting discussions at my church. I’m baptized and still feel connected to Christianity, but I realize that a lot of my beliefs don’t necessarily fit traditional Christian theology.
Here’s where I stand:
My understanding of God:
I believe there is one universal God or divine reality.
I don’t necessarily see God as a separate being outside of creation. I see divinity as something present throughout humanity, nature, consciousness, and existence.
I believe different religions are interpreting and experiencing this same divine reality in different ways.
My understanding of Jesus and other religions:
I believe Jesus is the Son of God and an important spiritual teacher, but I don’t believe he is the exclusive expression of divinity.
I believe other spiritual teachers, such as Buddha and the Sikh Gurus, can also reveal divine truths.
I struggle with the Christian belief that someone must accept Jesus to be saved or enter heaven.
I don’t believe a good Jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, Sikh, or nonreligious person should be excluded from heaven simply because they aren’t Christian.
My understanding of heaven, hell, and sin:
I don’t necessarily believe heaven and hell are literal places we go after death. I see them more as metaphors for the human experience.
To me, hell is the suffering humanity creates through war, greed, hatred, oppression, exploitation, and cruelty.
I see sin as the ways we hurt one another and perpetuate unnecessary suffering, rather than simply breaking a set of divine rules.
Heaven represents compassion, peace, justice, and a world where people genuinely care for one another.
I think our focus should be on making Earth a better place rather than spending our lives worrying about getting into heaven after we die.
My understanding of suffering and the afterlife:
I recognize that not all suffering is within human control. Death, disease, aging, and grief are still part of existence, and I honestly don’t have answers for why.
I believe the soul or consciousness may continue after physical death, and I’m open to possibilities like reincarnation.
I don’t claim to know what happens after we die. I think it’s one of the great mysteries of existence.
Ultimately:
I believe in one God, many spiritual paths, and the interconnectedness of humanity. I think our purpose should be to love one another, reduce suffering, challenge injustice, and make this lifetime meaningful.
I realize some of this probably falls outside traditional Christian orthodoxy, but I still appreciate Jesus, Christian teachings, and being part of a church community.
What would you call this? Religious pluralism? Perennial philosophy? Pantheism? Progressive Christianity? Some combination of all of the above? I’m curious if anyone else has similar beliefs, particularly people who still identify with Christianity.
r/OpenChristian • u/jrpilotkerr00 • 23h ago
Discussion - LGBTQ+ Issues What was your experience growing up transgender?
This is long winded, but I'll do my best. I wouldn't say this is an "issue", but it's LGBT related. I'm trans mtf (25), and I came out to my worship leader of my membered church, who is one of my best friends. I'm a very avid worship volunteer, and have been at this church for probably close to 15 years. The church is relatively conservative in the south, though we don't often talk about politics. Since I came out to her a couple months ago, we've put me being on stage on pause, and we regularly meet and talk about it.
She is trying to understand where I'm coming from, and we're trying to engage in theological conversation. Where we've kind of left off is her asking, "Do you think this is really a belief that you have had since you were born? Or could it have been something you thought about once or twice and it's kind of 'spiraled' from there?" Along with that, "Do you think things would be different if you had a mentor growing up (such as parents) leading you in the direction of 'here's what the Bible says about male/female/sexuality?"
As far as I know, from the earliest I can remember (4-5 years old) I was felt like I wasn't in the right body, but I have NEVER seen that as a mistake that God has made. But I honestly don't know if it's always been a true belief that I've had, or if it was a thought that just grew. And I guess I'm asking... what was your experience? Was it always a belief for you? Did you have a mentor at a young age to have those sexuality/gender conversations with you? Did you just have a desire to wear clothes/makeup/whatever of the opposite sex?
Her other concern/question is how do I fit in to the reproduction purpose that God gave us? I personally do believe that He gave us that purpose to have kids and gave families and raise god-fearing children, and I don't plan on altering that, for more reasons than just that, too. I'll probably never get on hormones or have anything "permanent". I'm happily married to my wife, and we want to/plan to have kids together.
Be gentle on my worship leader friend. She's still one of my best friends, and she's asking all the right questions so she can understand where I'm coming from, because with her being cis female, it's all she's ever known.
TLDR: Did you always know that something was different? What was that thing that made you feel different? Did you have a mentor that potentially could have pointed you to the bible? Did that change anything?
r/OpenChristian • u/MelodicDataScientist • 20h ago
Discussion - General Has anyone else had to leave a church community that hurt them? How did you find your way back to God?
I won't go into details, partly because some of it still isn't easy to talk about, and I don't want to blame anyone. About a year ago I stepped away from a church community I had served for many years, and it left a hurt I didn't know what to do with. I've since found a new church and I'm doing okay, but it took this whole year before I could even talk about it.
What helped me was writing a song about it. Not to point fingers, just to be honest before God. Somehow putting it into words and melody became a kind of painkiller.
I'm curious whether others have been through something similar. If you've been hurt in a church, or you're still looking for a spiritual home, what helped you heal? Did it change how you know God? You don't have to share anything you're not ready to. I just think it might help to have a place where we can listen to each other.
r/OpenChristian • u/Physical-Ninja4872 • 1d ago
Support Thread I think my church is dying
Using an alt account for reasons.
I don't know that I have a question or really want anything out of this post other than to just rant and process a bit. This sub has been great in terms of support so I guess that led me to want to post here.
A while back our minister left. He had been with us for a decade and a half or so and played a large role in shaping our church by really challenging us and pushing back on harmful dogma and tradition. As life circumstances changed with aging parents and kids going to college, it made sense for him to move when an opportunity came up that would put his family in a better spot geographically. The hard part for me is that he was probably my closest friend nearby. We still talk and text each other stupid stuff we find online but it's still a loss to not be able to just go grab lunch or something together when I have a day off during the week.
Still, I saw this as an opportunity for growth and change. We, as a church, had this time to reexamine things and think about what to do with this new chapter.
To back up a bit we've lost members over the years. This area has a bit of churn due to Military families and other federal jobs in the area. The problem is that as we became a more progressive congregation fewer people tended to stay. It seemed for a while that if we had two families visit, one would usually decide we weren't for them. With COVID we lost a few people because we stopped meeting in person for a while. And while there was never any political endorsement from the pulpit or church leadership, calls for being Christian first led to some people leaving because they saw those as attacks on their preferred political position.
So here we were with a small church where one family could be the difference between our budget being in the black. Not having a full time employee made things better but we still needed money coming in if we're going to consider offering someone a position in the future. Then we have someone announce they're leaving for some reason. Well, not an immediate problem. Then back to back two other families are moving away.
Last Sunday maybe a dozen people showed up. Even if we had someone we wanted to hire as a new minister it wouldn't be sustainable. I know the church isn't a place and we could easily shut down the building and become a home church but I don't think that is for everyone. There is something about going to the place and coming together as a group. What's frustrating is the mega-church literally across the street that uses our parking lot as overflow. They've added on to their buildings and seen explosive growth while we've been dwindling. We'll just say that one would feel more comfortable wearing a red hat over there.
I guess the TL;DR is that our church has been on the decline for a while but I think we're at a real tangible point right now where we have to face the reality of closing our doors.
r/OpenChristian • u/RecordAccording333 • 23h ago
"We may not control how easily faith comes to us, but we can choose to seek God...this is more of a struggle for some of us than others."
UPLIFT: Easier for Some
I received some nice feedback about the last Uplift message—about the practice of praying not for what we want but for what God wants.
But here’s what I didn’t mention: living this way requires a good deal of faith and trust.
This is one of the most familiar passages of Scripture in the Bible:
“Faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.” (Hebrews 11:1)
One way to understand faith is as trusting beyond what we can prove or see.
This is more of a struggle for some of us than others.
I’ve been thinking about that.
Some people, like me, seem more naturally inclined toward faith, comfortable believing in a God we cannot see or fully understand.
I wasn’t particularly interested in God for many years, mind you. But once the spark of childhood faith was reignited, the path began to open up.
Others wrestle with the very idea of God, even when they might wish they could believe.
Perhaps it’s a little like maintaining a healthy weight. For some people, it seems almost effortless. For others, it’s a lifelong struggle, influenced in part by their genetic makeup.
And perhaps faith is a little like that. We’re not all made the same way. Our experiences, training, and natural predispositions shape how we approach the world, what we can believe, and how easily we trust.
But whatever our starting point, we can choose to seek God.
And even when it’s difficult, seeking a loving, trusting relationship with Him is worth the effort.
It’s why we’re here.
The good news is that God wants a relationship with us. Jesus invites us to seek Him. In Matthew 7, Jesus says:
“Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.”
And even if it takes time, the effort is not wasted. Seeking God can strengthen our faith. It can even awaken it.
This is what I suggest: spend time with God’s Word, the Bible, and with others who are walking the same path, perhaps in a church community. And ask God for his presence.
The more we do, the more the puzzle pieces begin to fit together and the more complete the picture becomes.
We begin to recognize things we couldn’t see before, and view familiar things in a new light.
As Paul writes in 2 Corinthians 3:16:
“But whenever anyone turns to the Lord, the veil is taken away.”
Until next time, keep walking toward the light.
r/OpenChristian • u/Budget_Antelope • 13h ago
Vent I want to get married and possibly have children but I’m scared
I have long contemplated getting married and possibly having children, and more recently I have thought about becoming a Catholic Deacon. However, I have also just straight up considered joining the priesthood because I doubt I will find love and I have had enough with all of this yet another wave of discourse about mixed heritage couples and dating in general, especially in progressive circles. On top of that, if I did and started a family, I’d be a shit father because I have very little of any valuable qualities or skills that a parent should have.
Im particularly worried about the topic of race when I contemplate finding a partner because I am bombarded by fears of being accused of being a racist, or an interrupter of poc progress or some other crap.
If I marry a catholic woman of European descent like myself, I’m scared I’ll be married to someone who was hiding their ignorance, complacency, or at worst gleeful bigotry from me until we tie the knot. I’m scared that my children will just continue to perpetuate whiteness and create yet another person who takes up space and oppresses non-whites just by being alive.
If I marry a non-white catholic woman, I’m scared I’ll never truly understand her and can’t be there for her when a spouse of her own culture would be a better fit for her. If we have children, Im scared I’ll have brought someone into the world that will be seen as an outcast by both white people and whatever ethnic group their mother belongs to. Worse still, they may lord their proximity to whiteness over their fellow people of color while also hating themselves.
I’m especially worried about having children because I am autistic, prone to mood swings, and has had a manic episode. All of these are at least somewhat inheritable, autism most strongly, which is what worries me the most.
As the son of an undiagnosed neurodivergent father, it was common for us to butt heads a lot, and I’m scared that I won’t be able to truly connect with my children if our brains are wired too differently or too similarly. I feel energetically drained whenever I hang out with even my closest friends that are also autistic. I don’t know if I’ll be able to handle my own children if they’re going to be as insufferable as I or my peers are.
As pollution gets worse, I also fear that, not only would I bring a family into a shittier world, but also be born with a slew of health complications and deformities both physical and mental. There is also a correlation between autism and pollution, with multiple studies linking exposure to air pollutants to increased chances of being born with autism. What kind of father would I be to not only pass down a trait that makes things harder, but also increase their chances of having it by bringing them into a world filled with pollution that would make it worse, and tell them to be proud of it? I am also aware that people on the autism spectrum are 3 to 6 times more likely to be transgender, and I am worried that I will not be able to care for them properly. I’d still love my child unconditionally, but I’d always feel guilty for giving them a body that they’d hate even if it were completely healthy and functional.
Im losing hope. Im 21 and I haven’t had a date. I can cook, clean, I have good hygiene, I have good muscles, and I’m only a little overweight but I’m starting to think I’m the problem. I feel like my standards are too high, because I have only seen a few people irl that I really crushed on.
I might just throw in the towel and join the preisthood, and let higher quality men and women who are less likely to give the next generation more issues find love where I can’t.
r/OpenChristian • u/JehovahLover • 1d ago
Why I think Christian Persecution Complex isn't just a delusion. It's a plague.
So, I'm sure many of you are familiar with the term "Christian Persecution Complex." If you aren't it's basically this: the belief among American Christians that we are, in some way, persecuted in the USA for our faith. Normally, the people who have the complex look to media, politics, and social justice issues to make their case.
Now, if it isn't already obvious, I think CPC is absolute nonsense. There is basically 0% in terms of rules, laws, and normal American standards that keep us from practicing our beloved faith. Sure, occasionally a show/movie presents Christians as stupid and/or bigoted, but (news flash) That's not Persecution! That stuff is unfortunate (but not always untrue) and we can just ignore it. Are there occasional moments of violence towards Christians? Sure, but there's violence towards plenty of people of many backgrounds. It's not like someone can shoot up a church and the government/force will just be like: "Eh. No big deal."
But I'm probably preaching to the choir so far. This is the point I'd really like to make: While many atheists and more sensible Christians probably laugh off people with CPC, I think that it is actually something rather sinister.
I'm sure you all know that in order to help others, you first have to help yourself. As Christians, humanitarian causes a a BIG part of our faith and lifestyle, but if you're in trouble in some way, you first have to solve that before you can help the needy/marginalized/actual persecuted. That's why CPC is terrible. People who have it basically think that they can just ignore the plights of minorities and other ACTUAL persecuted groups because, well: WE'RE under attack, and we've got to fight and become martyrs of the faith or whatever. Why do you think so many Christians reject CRT and call it BAD? They throw out this nonsense of it being racist when the ACTUAL racists are the ones that are turning a blind eye to systemic racism and basically saying: "America isn't the problem. Sin is! But of course... Gene Roddenberry made fun of us once so THAT us what we're focused on instead of loving our neighbors and following the Golden Rule.
Now, a few disclaimers: I hate it when Christianity is mocked too, but that isn't persecution. That is people exercising freedom of artistic expression. And half the time, they make good points if you are willing to pay attention (e.g. I'm a huge fan of the original "Planet Of The Apes" because, while it does lampoon Christianity, much of it's satire on corrupt religious and political leaders is scarily accurate as well as like, 50 other correct uses of social-political commentary in that franchise.)
Also, I get one kinda understandable reason this might happen. Jesus said: "Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness sake, for theirs is the kingdom of Heaven." Jesus doesn't lie, so we MUST be persecuted! But it's important to remember that context matters and not everything in scripture applies to every aspect of our lives 24/7.
I also know that terrible, horrific Christian persecution does exist...in other countries. We should fight that, not whine because an atheist hurt our feelings or because someone had the audacity to fight for LGBT+ rights (because I guess God forbid we let others have the same rights we have.)
TLDR: CPC is terrible because it gives many Christians an excuse to put themselves first at all times and to ignore the truly marginalized in America, as well as elsewhere.
Thank you for reading, and may Christ bless you. 😊
r/OpenChristian • u/Similar_Shame_8352 • 1d ago
God is truly impassible, and this is the surest guarantee of His love.
I find modern critiques of divine impassibility quite unconvincing. First of all, the fact that God is impassible does not mean He is devoid of love, joy, and life; rather, as the Absolute, His inner life is not subject to influence from creatures, since creatures receive everything from Him. His love and compassion are universal and unconditional, unmoored from the fluctuating, creaturely emotions of a fickle empathy. True love entails the capacity to make oneself vulnerable solely on behalf of creatures who possess no love inherently. In short, there is a recurring attempt to turn God into a cosmic figure driven by suffering and passions, as though the Incarnation—through which the Son of God truly suffered—were not enough. Indeed, it is only in Jesus that God has truly suffered with humanity and all creation, not within His divine nature as such. It was only through Jesus's earthly life that God truly and fully experienced human suffering in the flesh He freely took on.
Yet this does not mean God, as God, is indifferent to our sufferings and struggles; He does not need to suffer alongside us in order to come to our aid. While remaining wholly transcendent, He is also radically immanent, dwelling within us and within our freedom, sustaining and upholding us with a mighty arm. His love is indestructible and unshakable, precisely because it is not a helpless, reactive response to the world's suffering, but rather the creative and omnipotent will that sustains the world and drives it toward its perfection. He does all this not as a distant master or lord ruling over reality from the heights of the skies, but as a spirit of life that intimately permeates the cosmos while remaining transcendent, participating in the joys and sorrows of creatures without being altered or affected by them.
Furthermore, a God who is an unchanging, impassible rock—untouched by the shifting tides of history—serves as the guarantee of our salvation. Upon this rock, we can build and reform our ecclesial home. Even when we grow weary of fighting our battles, He presses forward relentlessly and without wavering. His immutability and impassibility are the very foundation of our dynamism and boldness. Precisely because He alone is Absolute, everything created is relative and can neither be sacralized nor adored.
Finally, conceiving of a God who undergoes passions and alterations, besides no longer describing a true "God" (since God is intrinsically absolute), risks confusing the Christian God with the fickle and wrathful gods of paganism, who had already been ridiculed by Greek philosophers.
In short, God is neither wrathful nor pathetically sentimental; rather, He is pure, eternal, immutable, and absolute love for every single creature. Because only divine love is absolute, no human reality can claim such a status, and each can—and must—be subject to criticism.
Edit:
P.S. I realize that 'impassible' is a misleading term and that it might be better not to use it. God has unchanging emotions (love, joy, and life) that are compatible with His nature, but He is not subject to passions—meaning He is not emotionally changed by anything outside of Himself.
r/OpenChristian • u/PaintingSpirited3716 • 1d ago
Getting back into faith
Hello everyone!
I am 21 and I have recently in the last few years started to get back into my faith. I was raised Protestant Christian but over my teen years I kind of fell out of the faith and became more agnostic for a while it was due to a few reasons but mainly the way I saw a lot of people use it to justify hate. A few years back I sort of felt compelled to come back actually, it feels like looking back there are things that have happened that I really do believe can only be because of Jesus. I am thinking about joining a Christian club at my uni or even just going to a local church.
The only thing is I’m a very socially anxious person, I don’t tend to reach social queues very well I can fake it but it gets a bit exhausting not being myself. I just thought it may be a good idea also because I’ve been feeling extremely lost and lonely lately, I don’t have many friends, nor family to confide in and I had a breakup earlier this year that I’m still feeling the feelings but I want to put myself out there more not to date at all just to make friends and meet like minded people. I am just worried because I know there can be some judgemental people in church but I suppose that is anywhere so I shouldn’t just assume without stepping out. I’d also like to go back to fully connect with the lord, I have been reading the bible more alone but I want to share that love of the lord with others.
Is there any advice from people who have been in similar situations? What would be the best way to push myself out of my comfort zone (I.e going to church, meeting new people)
r/OpenChristian • u/Symaf • 1d ago
Support Thread Mom for a minute.
I’m 28F and going through a really rough time romantically. My mom and aunt passed away a few years ago so I don’t have women to turn to. If anyone would be be open to chatting and helping me tonight it would be greatly appreciated. I’m feeling overwhelmed and a bit sad.
r/OpenChristian • u/ScallionLittle290 • 2d ago
Defrocked
sojo.netHave you all been following along with the controversy surrounding Defrocked? I read the book and was really shocked that progressive Christians I admire were promoting it. I'm impressed by this review as it makes me feel less alone in my concern!
Essentially the author, a UCC pastor, had an affair with her student intern, who she was supervising. She also had a multi-year affair with another famous UCC pastor, Martin Copenhaver. She then wrote this book dismissing the severity of her boundary violations and painting herself as the true victim because she had to have some very minor accountability for her actions (which didn't seem to last long, as she's since been promoted to a Conference Minister). The survivor of her abuse and the church she traumatized requested this not to be published as it was painful to them, and the publisher pulled the book. She then ignored their concerns entirely and pushed forward to self publish.
It seems the UCC is ignoring the situation because of her status, even though there seem to be growing calls for her fitness to once again be reviewed. As a survivor myself, it makes me so frustrated to see so little regard for the people who were actually harmed!